Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what else to do with DM racist comment?

209 replies

FluffingMarvellous · 21/07/2022 21:29

I'm utterly shocked.

Sat watching the news with DM and she randomly comes out with "I hope Rishi Sunak doesn't get PM as it would be awful to have a Muslim PM".

I was so shocked I just stared at her and said "That's completely racist, you can't say that!"

She then said "No its not really. It's political. If he got it, the Muslims would take over the country".

I was completely appalled, told her never to say anything like that to me and certainly not to the children but she just didn't get it.

DM has MH issues so it's v hard to challenge her on anything or it can turn quite nasty. But I still feel like I should have done more, I just don't know what as she's still my DM but I'm so shocked. She's never said anything like that in front of me before although I know she does have some very strongly pro Brexit ideas which almost verge on being anti non British people, but never explicit and only in line with other strongly pro Brexit people (which I'm not here to start a debate about).

Haven't told DH as would literally ban her from ever coming in the house again.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 23/07/2022 16:37

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 16:26

Yes, i was agreeing with you, and further disagreeing with the poster who said otherwise.

Fair enough Grin

I mean, it's just basic humanity isn't it, to recognise that everyone's different and has different relationships with their religious beliefs (including, sometimes, a purely cultural identification). Some are very devout, some casual, some obsessive, some extremist, some pragmatic.

It's weird to assume that a Christian politician will keep their beliefs in the background, while a Muslim one will let it influence their decisions (especially when he's actually a Hindu who took his oath on the Bhagavad-Gita…).

My friend was really upset she might have eaten pork, so I tried to sympathise with her and cheer her up — it would've been a total dick move for me to start talking about how it only happened because she was drunk, and asking how come she was okay with breaking the alcohol rule but not the pork rule, and if she was really a Muslim then blah blah blah.

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 16:29

My auntie, who was a Colonel in the Salvation Army (i.e. full time career priest and staff member) once told me that Catholics were not 'real Christians'. I think and hope the SA has moved on since then (50 years ago).

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 16:26

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 23/07/2022 16:22

Erm… that was my point. People shouldn't be going round pointing at people saying "You're not a real Muslim because you drink, you're not a real Sikh cause you cut your hair, you're not a real Christian because you don't go to church, you're not a real vegetarian because you wear leather shoes, you're not a real football fan because you don't go to matches, you're not a real x because y". Muslims (and Hindus) are just like Christians insofar as the label covers people with an enormous range of beliefs and real-world behaviour, whatever some of the more well-known "rules" might be.

Yes, i was agreeing with you, and further disagreeing with the poster who said otherwise.

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 16:24

Also my Muslim friend said he will not eat ritually slaughtered meat because he thinks it's cruel, and he knows plenty of others, including his family, who feel the same way. He said something like 'It's 2022, not 1322'.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 23/07/2022 16:22

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 16:13

A Muslim who eats pork once accidentally or a hundred times deliberately, does not cease to be a Muslim. That's ridiculous. He said he has this conversation about once a week: What is your background? I’m Muslim. Oh, I had no idea! But you drink? Yes, I do. Do you fast? No, I did occasionally growing up, and my mom still does, but I don’t. (Always) Do you eat pork? I like a pepperoni pizza. He says his 'selective' application of his Muslim faith is no different from many Jews, Hindus, Christians, and Sikhs. His Imam told him that while he could not condone the rule breaking, he knew that God still loved him.

Erm… that was my point. People shouldn't be going round pointing at people saying "You're not a real Muslim because you drink, you're not a real Sikh cause you cut your hair, you're not a real Christian because you don't go to church, you're not a real vegetarian because you wear leather shoes, you're not a real football fan because you don't go to matches, you're not a real x because y". Muslims (and Hindus) are just like Christians insofar as the label covers people with an enormous range of beliefs and real-world behaviour, whatever some of the more well-known "rules" might be.

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 16:13

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 23/07/2022 13:23

Who are you to say who's not really a Muslim? A Muslim friend of mine was very upset once that she might have accidentally eaten a pork sausage roll thinking it was a veggie one. The reason she'd been careless on the sausage roll front was that she was pissed Grin Humans are inconsistent, unpredictable, and don't always follow the rules you think they should.

A Muslim who eats pork once accidentally or a hundred times deliberately, does not cease to be a Muslim. That's ridiculous. He said he has this conversation about once a week: What is your background? I’m Muslim. Oh, I had no idea! But you drink? Yes, I do. Do you fast? No, I did occasionally growing up, and my mom still does, but I don’t. (Always) Do you eat pork? I like a pepperoni pizza. He says his 'selective' application of his Muslim faith is no different from many Jews, Hindus, Christians, and Sikhs. His Imam told him that while he could not condone the rule breaking, he knew that God still loved him.

lookluv · 23/07/2022 14:18

Bloody insulting to say everyone over 50 is racist because of how they were brought up such a generalisation with no evidence.

I work in the extremely multicultural NHS and the worst discriminatory behaviour I have witnessed has come from the younger generations ( for want of a better word) They seem to think they are the arbiters of what is and isn't racism and the comments made are racist and discriminatory as much as an older person might say.

But the excuse for balatant racist sexist etc behaviour is now its cultural and we have to accept that because in their culture x is considered subhuman, inferior etc.

HolidayPleeease · 23/07/2022 13:55

Ffs HE'S HINDU PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!

EnvyEnvyEnvyEnvyEnvy

5zeds · 23/07/2022 13:41

@roarfeckingroarr I wouldn't want a Muslim PM - because I wouldn't want a PM with strong religious views of any religion.

No I think it’s non-Christian and specifically Church of England that isn’t wanted. Boris was a CofE convert, Blair a closet Catholic. There are lots Muslims who aren’t “strongly” religious. There are lots of Christian’s who are hard line, (see American religious anti abortionists). Try to fight justifying finding Muslims inherently more scary/draconian it simply isn’t true.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 23/07/2022 13:23

phishy · 23/07/2022 13:18

*he also ate pork and drank beer and wine. They aren't all the same.

Not really a Muslim then. And saying ‘they aren’t all the same’ is really fucking offensive, as if only a pork eating and alcohol drinking nominal Muslim is acceptable. Have a word with yourself.

Who are you to say who's not really a Muslim? A Muslim friend of mine was very upset once that she might have accidentally eaten a pork sausage roll thinking it was a veggie one. The reason she'd been careless on the sausage roll front was that she was pissed Grin Humans are inconsistent, unpredictable, and don't always follow the rules you think they should.

phishy · 23/07/2022 13:22

roarfeckingroarr · 23/07/2022 12:58

I wouldn't want a Muslim PM - because I wouldn't want a PM with strong religious views of any religion.

Well BoJo actively switched to Church of England, but that’s fine isn’t it?

Honestly, so much bigotry n this thread. I hope no Muslims have the misfortune to come across any of you.

Learn to integrate FFS.

phishy · 23/07/2022 13:18

*he also ate pork and drank beer and wine. They aren't all the same.

Not really a Muslim then. And saying ‘they aren’t all the same’ is really fucking offensive, as if only a pork eating and alcohol drinking nominal Muslim is acceptable. Have a word with yourself.

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 13:06

roarfeckingroarr · 23/07/2022 12:58

I wouldn't want a Muslim PM - because I wouldn't want a PM with strong religious views of any religion.

I worked for years with a Muslim who was very relaxed about religion, went to interfaith sessions at synagogues, Christian churches (all types), Hindu and Sikh temples. His philosophy, he said, was 'live and let live' and he admired the Sufis. he also ate pork and drank beer and wine. They aren't all the same. He'd make a very good Prime Minister, I feel, but as he is a Labour supporter that might not be possible for a while.

roarfeckingroarr · 23/07/2022 12:58

I wouldn't want a Muslim PM - because I wouldn't want a PM with strong religious views of any religion.

DelphiniumBlue · 23/07/2022 12:35

FluffingMarvellous · 21/07/2022 21:30

He's not even Muslim anyway, he's Hindu. But that's beside the point of what she said.

I don't think that is beside the point actually, she was stereotyping him on the basis of the colour of his skin. The fact that she got his religion wrong proves the point that trying to stereotype people based on their appearance is not only racist but stupid, and leads you to wrong conclusions.

Anothernamechangeplease · 23/07/2022 12:26

hattie43 · 21/07/2022 22:05

It's a generational thing . My parents come out with sayings that you couldn't say now .
FWIW I don't think your mother would be the only one to think that

It really isn't a generational thing.

I'm sorry if your parents are racist, but their age is no excuse.

woolwinder · 23/07/2022 12:21

I could also mention that my father (who I have been berated for cutting off) once said, to my sister, of someone very close to me, 'Is Woolwinder still seeing that Jew?'.

Coffeeenema · 23/07/2022 11:26

Petulathethird · 21/07/2022 23:30

It stops, or it should stop, when the majority of people accept that racist comments are not acceptable.

I suspect that you are white, middle aged or older and vote conservative.

Oh the irony and hypocrisy in your comment....😂

Loopyloopy · 23/07/2022 05:15

phishy · 23/07/2022 02:24

This is close to saying it’s non-racists fault for not educating racists.

Well, no. I'm just pointing out that the OP has two options . I agree that OP is not responsible for her mum's views.

Realistically, however, regardless of what is fair, the situation is:

OP can shut her mum down and walk away from the discussion. If her mum is "too far gone", this might be what OP needs. It won't change her mum's opinions, though.

If OP has the energy, she can engage her mum in the manner that @picklemewalnuts suggests. This is the approach that may actually work.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 23/07/2022 02:35

Forcibly shutting her down further won't change her views. Only open discussion will.
I hear you, depends on the person though.
Sometimes people are "too far gone" though.
Sometimes shutting down and walking away is the best option.

phishy · 23/07/2022 02:24

Loopyloopy · 23/07/2022 01:02

This is a very good point. You expressed your disappointment in her comment. Forcibly shutting her down further won't change her views. Only open discussion will.

Brenee Brown has some great stuff on this.

This is close to saying it’s non-racists fault for not educating racists.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 23/07/2022 02:14

I think it stems from ignorance and growing up in all-white villages, and eating a whole Daily Mail for breakfast each day. A white bubble
I think this is a great point .
It really is in some cases. It's what you grow up with.
I come from one of the said villages. It's what you know, and you grow up knowing no difference.
There can be a lot of ignorance
You have to actively widen your circle, work wise etc by moving to a bigger town and educate yourself on history/cultures

boymama82 · 23/07/2022 01:10

I'm more worried about the fact he's a dickhead 😉

Loopyloopy · 23/07/2022 01:02

picklemewalnuts · 21/07/2022 21:53

If you make a blanket ban on say8ng things like that, you don't actually educate or change people's minds. They still think like that, just quietly.

You could answer:
He's not Muslim, anyway.
Don't you worry the Christian politicians will try and convert everyone?
Why do you think a Muslim prime minister would make the country Muslim?
Do you think everyone that's dark skinned must be Muslim?
Why does that scare you?

Etc.

If you actually talk about it, she'll get to explain what she's really worried about and expose her irrational ideas to disinfecting sunshine.

'Shut up, that's bigoted!' Is such an unhelpful trap we've fallen into these days.

This is a very good point. You expressed your disappointment in her comment. Forcibly shutting her down further won't change her views. Only open discussion will.

Brenee Brown has some great stuff on this.

SmallSoupcon · 23/07/2022 00:49

This sounds like my PILs, and recently I was shocked to hear my SIL say something racist too.

I don't cut them off but I do react naturally - with shock that they'd say something like that - and explain why.

I think it stems from ignorance and growing up in all-white villages, and eating a whole Daily Mail for breakfast each day. A white bubble. They are fearful of the things they don't know or understand, especially other cultures and 'forriners'. They've literally never been around anyone who's challenged their views before.

For example, when the Sussexes H&M were expecting, my MIL became bizarrely obsessed over skin colour, saying the only thing everyone wanted to know was if it would 'come out a black baby'. No-one has ever questioned her saying this sort of thing before. But I bloody well did! After all, how else will people change?