Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you pay £400 to add an inscription to a headstone for someone you never knew?

186 replies

OwlButter · 21/07/2022 19:21

I'll explain!

My great grandma died in 1972, I was only a baby and have no memory of her.

She was buried with my great grandad who had died a couple of years previously. However due to some sort of family fall out, her name / years of life/ any inscription was never added to the head stone. So all his details are on there but nothing for her.

As if she didn't exist.

I've recently found all of this out when I made a visit back to my birthplace and w wandered round the graveyard - I live 250 miles away.

So I've made enquiries with the local council and stone masons and yes, I can do it. Just need to fill in some paperwork etc but that bit is straightforward

The cost however is something else. It'll cost me £400+ , if not more.

So .. would you do this? I can't work out why it feels important to me. I didn't know her. But she lived, she mattered and now it's like she didn't exist. And for some reason that matters to me.

On the other hand, I didn't know her. Her own children are now dead (my grandad etc) and no one else in my family (her grandchildren who are now 70 odd) care about this.

What would you do? Money is a consideration for me of course but I could potentially consider doing it next year - it's not like I have this cash just lying about though

OP posts:
perimenofertility · 21/07/2022 20:06

I would do that, yes. I have framed photos of my great-grandparents at home. They all died before I was born yet I still feel a connection to them. They were my grandparents' parents, and I loved all of my grandparents so for that reason I'd do it. But as someone else says, I also wouldn't think it wrong not to do it. Do it if you want to, but don't feel obliged.

JamMakingWannaBe · 21/07/2022 20:06

Can you do a CrowdFunder to help pay for it? It would only take 20 people who knew her to chip in a tenner and that's half the cost. Get yourself in the local paper and I'm sure you could raise the rest. Good luck.

weaseleyes · 21/07/2022 20:04

I don't feel it's that you ought to do it, but it would be a lovely thing to do. And now you've had the idea, I suspect you won't be able to put it out of your mind until you do it. Otherwise it will always sit there as an unfinished possibility.

FWIW, I have up framed photos of long dead ancestors that I have no way of identifying now my parents and grandparents are dead. But when I came across the photos in their effects, it seemed so wrong to discard them. I like to think of keeping that thread, even though I'm not really sure what it represents. (I may well be keeping photos of complete strangers, of course!)

ReviewingTheSituation · 21/07/2022 20:04

*inherit, not inherent!

filka · 21/07/2022 20:04

I own two family graves and I view them as part of the family heritage/history that future generations can come to.

On one I must have put my aunt's name on the stone maybe 25-30 years after she died, but I felt a lot better for having done it.

In the other a young-ish adult is buried with her parents but not named. I took ownership of the grave as it's family, but I haven't felt compelled (enough) to add her name - perhaps because she died 20+ years before I was born.

So it really does comedown to personal feelings. On balance I don't feel that a flower holder really cuts it.

I like the suggestions of a contribution from other living relatives, especially any that knew her - kind of family crowd-funding.

But it's a strange thing, if you are cremated then there is no headstone to engrave, and no-one seems to worry about that. Many cemeteries have a place to engrave names of people who have been cremated, maybe your cemetery would allow that? I think it would be a smaller and less expensive format of inscription.

ReviewingTheSituation · 21/07/2022 20:03

When the grandchildren die, are likely to inherent anything in any wills? Maybe put some of that money towards it, so that it's a family contribution of sorts.

I can see why you want to do it.

I think I'd be putting aside a couple of £ here and there as a saving pot and doing it when I had enough. £5 a week would get you there in under 2 years. Or you could do it over a longer period of time - there's no hurry, once you've made the decision to do it.

MouseRoar · 21/07/2022 19:56

how about setting up a gofundme page for it?

takemetomars · 21/07/2022 19:56

OwlButter · 21/07/2022 19:31

@Floralnomad not sure where I'd put a bench! And it's not about anyone reading it. I know that no one will read it. It's about her life being marked on her headstone

I would do it. It's such a lovely thing to do. I agree that she deserves to be remembered

Saracenia · 21/07/2022 19:55

I would if I could afford it.

Perple · 21/07/2022 19:53

I would do it.

its honouring her and also honouring yourself as her descendant.

I think gestures matter. And it would be money well spent.

huuskymam · 21/07/2022 19:53

I would, it doesn't seem right to me, to leave her off it with her huabands details being there.

sallladfiingerss · 21/07/2022 19:53

What about something like this?
Surely they can't ban and dispose ofpersonal memorial items on a grave?

Would you pay £400 to add an inscription to a headstone for someone you never knew?
PandemicAtTheDisco · 21/07/2022 19:52

One of my previous partners didn't get a headstone because of a dissagreement between his parents and his on/off partner. His on/off partner had ended their relationship before he died and they weren't on speaking terms. The argument was about the inscription and who was paying.

The bitter and spiteful actions of one person meant no headstone. To my mind, finally getting a headstone would make me feel he was remembered. I really dislike the unmarked grave.

HollowTalk · 21/07/2022 19:52

What does the money mean to you? I think if it just means that you save a little less one month, then I would do it. If it means you can't feed your starving children, then I wouldn't! I would really want to though.

Hotenoughtoburnasausage · 21/07/2022 19:49

I want to be buried with my name on the headstone! I would be sad if my dgm wasn't acknowledged as having lived..
Do it op.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 21/07/2022 19:48

How lovely of you. If I could afford it, I would. It pulls on my heartstrings that someone with an entire family is not acknowledged on their own grave.

TamSamLam · 21/07/2022 19:47

If it means something to you, and you think it would mean something to her, then that's a good enough reason to do it.

But, I doubt she'd want you in any sort of financial difficulty for it. So I wouldn't until I could comfortably afford to do so. Even if that meant I left a sum and an instruction in my will for it.

925XX · 21/07/2022 19:45

Yes if i could afford it.

MiddleParking · 21/07/2022 19:45

No I’d spend it on a Dyson airwrap but it’s your money!

OwlButter · 21/07/2022 19:44

The thing is, she is irrelevant now. She has been dead for nearly 50 years. There are only about 4 people who recall her and I'm not one of them.

And that's sad 😞 Eventually we all become irrelevant I suppose

OP posts:
onelostsoulswimminginafishbowl · 21/07/2022 19:44

I would. I think it matters and it would be wonderful to acknowledge. She is a part of you.
However, only if I had the money.

Thefriendlymoth · 21/07/2022 19:41

Could you get a memorial flower holder, I’ve seen them on lots of gravesites. I think the sentiment is lovely OP but I’m absolutely certain, if you had met, she wouldn’t have wanted you to suffer any financial difficulties just for this.

Athenajm80 · 21/07/2022 19:40

I would definitely do something to ensure she is "recorded" so to speak. I think I'd also want people to know that she had been forgotten/erased but hell if I know how that would be done!

There are plenty of people who visit old cemeteries, I don't think it would only be you who would read her inscription. There's a lovely cemetery near me which was designed for Victorian people to walk in. If I go there, I try to read all the gravestones I pass, especially the less flamboyant ones, so that those people are still remembered in some tiny way.

Oh, I had an idea about the erasing thing. It might not work, but in the cemetery I mentioned they have a Friends of x cemetery and have histories of some graves. If the one where your relative is buried has similar, maybe they would record her story. If you would want it recorded obviously.

AliceMcK · 21/07/2022 19:40

Yes I would, I actually want to do something similar but waiting for certain older relatives to die because I know there will be trouble if I dared stepping on certain toes, mainly uncle who is official “owner” of the plot and my M who refused to have a my DFs name put anywhere until she dies then she wants a joint plaque. I have absolutely no intentions of paying any kind of respect to her but do want to with my DF. The plot in question is for my DGF & DU that both died before I was born, it actually needs a new headstone anyway. My DF requested some of his ashes be buried there but my M refused to do this. Another DU died when I was younger but we never knew his ashes were not collected or any kind of place for his name to be remembered so I want to add my DF & DUs names to the headstone. I can do it without my uncle’s permission but it would just cause too much hassle so I will do it when he’s gone. The expense is a lot, I have been putting a few pounds here and there away in dedicated money box for when the time comes.

OwlButter · 21/07/2022 19:40

@MsMcGonagall I don't know why I thought about it either! I strolled round and spotted it and then I wanted to know where she was and it went from there

No one else will contribute I'm afraid. It's irrelevant to them and they do not have the money anyway

So this would be me alone doing this

The process takes at least 20 weeks so it's not a quick fix

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread