Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this about Cereal & Toast?

33 replies

Bbq1 · 21/07/2022 10:28

Only a lighthearted aibu so please don't flame me!

My ds is almost 17, very slim and healthy. He enjoys the occasional bowl of cereal and even more occasional slice of toast. That is his choice, I on the other hand love toast. There are often threads on here with parents complaining about the amount of food their teens consume. They usually state something along the lines of 'Fruit, vegetables, toast and cereal are unlimited ". The first two I understand but cereal and toast are actually unlimited?? How can it be any healthier or better if a teen consumes a box of cereal or most of a loaf (as many would) in one sitting as opposed to one bag of crisps? Add on butter/toppings and/or milk how can that be healthy?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ducksurprise · 21/07/2022 12:53

It annoys me in reverse maddie

Clearing cupboards and not leaving anything for everyone else is greedy and unfair.

Having unlimited milk, wetabix, toast so that if they are hungry they have something to eat isn't greedy. Like a pp my elder children have realised they can't eat like they did as growing teens. Their cereal habit as a teen has not led to obesity or diabetes.
Interestingly the one friend that has a weight problem had parents that were very restrictive.

maddiemookins16mum · 21/07/2022 12:49

It’s the ‘unlimited’ that annoys me. You hear it on here a lot, some greedy teen clearing the cupboard of stuff leaving nowt for his siblings etc. People coming on saying ‘oh well, he’s a growing teen’ or even worse ‘you don’t have teenagers yet do you?’. It’s greed, pure and simple. They really don’t need it to be unlimited, they won’t starve if they have to wait an hour for their next meal.
And don’t get me started on the ‘fruit, yoghurt, cereal’ after tea (when they’ve not even touched their mea.

But what annoys me the most is…..I’m annoyed and cross at myself forceveing caring that bleedin much 😳😳

VioletInsolence · 21/07/2022 12:44

I agree. I think that cereal in particular can be very addictive and both contain very few nutrients. I think it’s a very bad habit to get into….they get away with it as teens but what about ten years on when they’re obese and have pre diabetes?

Dilbertian · 21/07/2022 12:28

Teenage boys need far more calories than their adult mothers.

One of my adult dc is an average height, lightly-built man. He recognises that his calorie requirements are less now than 5-10y ago, and that he has to balance input and output or he puts on weight. As a teen, however, he would inhale cheese sandwiches and peanut butter sandwiches between meals and last thing at night. And remained skinny. Because at that age teen boys' bodies are growing almost as fast as when they were toddlers, laying down muscle and bone, and they are very active both physically and mentally.

Elevenerifebruv · 21/07/2022 12:13

I don't think people do it because it's optimum nutrition though it's because these are cheap and easy

Ducksurprise · 21/07/2022 12:12

There is a difference between an eating disorder (and over eating is as much as a disorder as under eating) and teens who are hungry.

Elevenerifebruv · 21/07/2022 12:10

Cereal and toast are things that older kids and teens can make for themselves. They are cheap and you don't have to have unhealthy white processed or sugary options. A bowl of weetabix and milk or a couple of slices of wholegrain toast with peanut butter is going to fill them up a lot better than fruit or vegetable sticks, even better if they have both

CantaloupeMelon · 21/07/2022 12:05

I think maybe it's just the word 'unlimited' that is causing confusion here? My teens can have unlimited bread and cereal in that it's freely available and I don't stop them helping themselves. That doesn't mean they'd ever eat a whole loaf of bread in one go! They also eat healthy meals and they're all really skinny and active.

ApolloandDaphne · 21/07/2022 12:03

I think by unlimited it is meant that this is the food they can eat without having to ask so that food for actual meals isn't eaten. So if they are hungry a few hours after dinner they can make themselves a bowl of cereal of a few slices of toast to fill them up. My DH is 58 and sill sometimes has some toast later in the evening if we have had a lighter dinner. He has a big appetite yet remains slim.

DysmalRadius · 21/07/2022 11:58

It's just the unlimited caveat that I wonder at. I have visions of teens chomping through a block of butter and a loaf because there are no limitations.

If a child would eat a whole loaf of bread simply because it's there and nobody is imposing restrictions on them, then the issue isn't what they're eating, surely?

I don't think posters are suggesting that there isn't a point at which toast consumption is a problem, more that there are some foods that are relatively easy to provide, cheap, filling and can be provided with little hassle and toast is one of them.

Ifailed · 21/07/2022 11:51

most bread sold in the UK is hardly healthy, rammed full of additives to hasten the proving process and then more to extend the shelf life, likewise cereals, full of sugar.

If someone is eating a healthy balanced diet there is no need for snacks between meals, they just need to learn to wait until the next meal time.

Exiledone · 21/07/2022 11:49

I give my kids bread and cereal over crisps. They're generally full/don't come asking for more after two slices of toast or a bowl of cereal. They could probably eat an entire six pack of crisps and come asking for more ten minutes later.

If you look at the calories, you can have two weetabix and a milk for under 200 calories.

Its also psychological. If they do the whole 'I'm hungry' winge, I offer basic boring bread and butter. I know if they say no to that then they're not really hungry and they're just sniffing for crap. Which is not given. If they say yes, then I know they're hungry and as above will keep them going longer than a bag of crisps.

Besides, most breads and cereals are fortified. So it is a good way of getting stuff into some kids.

Bbq1 · 21/07/2022 11:46

5128gap · 21/07/2022 11:36

If my child needed 'unlimited' cereal or toast, and was slim and healthy then I would assume that their regular meals were insufficient. I would either increase portion sizes or suggest substantial between meal snacks, such as jacket potato and beans, thick veg soup with bread or oats and yoghurt. I certainly would not be encouraging endless processed cereal. Toast is fine if its wholegrain with a decent topping such as nut butter or banana, but limitless buttered white bread, no. If a child is hungry they need nutrition as well as to be filled up.

This is exactly it. There are other affordable far more nutritioussnd filling snacks available. I also very much doubt that children eating through a loaf and cereal are eating wholegrain and muesli because it's not so affordable then.

OP posts:
KweenieBeanz · 21/07/2022 11:44

Pretty sure the OP is trying to make the point that the teenagers described probably don't actually need such vast amounts of toast /cereal, they just LIKE it, and making it unlimited means they are probably consuming far more calories than the need, and contributing to issues of obesity. I know so many people who describe their teens as slim when they really aren't, largely because they are wolfing down loads of extra food each day. Buttered toast is yummy. Of course you'd eat more of it whether you are hungry or not!!!

MintJulia · 21/07/2022 11:43

My ds can have as much wholegrain toast as he likes. He's at the hollow legged, growing-fast stage. He has as much fat on him as a stick of celery.

Wholemeal toast is excellent in terms of nutrition. Plenty of fibre, reasonably unprocessed, slow release carbs and a small amount of protein. Butter adds a bit more protein and valuable fats that make him feel full. A little marmite adds some vitamins. A very very small amount of sugar.

Knowing he can have as much as he wants, means he feels no pressure to cram, and stops when he feels full. He has a healthy relationship with food as a result.

I don't buy cereal except porridge oats (which he doesn't like).

Plumbear2 · 21/07/2022 11:41

I think you are confusing unlimited in this case. My teens know they can help themselves to fruit, bread, cereal etc so is unlimited in that sense. In reality they won't eat a box of cereal in a day or a loaf of bread, bout it is still in limited as they can help themselves if they are hungry.

Siameasy · 21/07/2022 11:40

There’s no way cereal is healthy, it may as well be a pudding. That’s the marketing guys having you over. Bread isn’t much better.
Snacking is out of control hence we are facing rising rates of obesity and T2 diabetes which will put even more strain on the NHS. Come on!!!

MissyB1 · 21/07/2022 11:38

I’m not sure unlimited anything is a good idea. My teen has a healthy appetite, but I would be a bit worried if he was eating numerous bowls of cereal, and whole loaves of bread in addition to his 3 perfectly good meals a day.

5128gap · 21/07/2022 11:36

If my child needed 'unlimited' cereal or toast, and was slim and healthy then I would assume that their regular meals were insufficient. I would either increase portion sizes or suggest substantial between meal snacks, such as jacket potato and beans, thick veg soup with bread or oats and yoghurt. I certainly would not be encouraging endless processed cereal. Toast is fine if its wholegrain with a decent topping such as nut butter or banana, but limitless buttered white bread, no. If a child is hungry they need nutrition as well as to be filled up.

iklboo · 21/07/2022 11:35

DS(16) doesn't like toast. But loves toasties & Welsh Rarebit. No, I don't get it either.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 21/07/2022 11:32

Well presumably because they have better mutritional value than crisps. Depends of course what bread/ cereal you buy. But no teen is going to eat an entire box of wheatbix as an alternative to a bag of crisps are they?

SlowingDownAndDown · 21/07/2022 11:30

i thought the latest advice was fruit should only be eaten with meals for the sake of your teeth, and all snacking is unhealthy.

Bbq1 · 21/07/2022 11:24

Of course there is nutritional value in bread and cereal but definitely some more than other. It's just the unlimited caveat that I wonder at. I have visions of teens chomping through a block of butter and a loaf because there are no limitations. I'm not arguing against anything. Just pondering. Unlimited bread and cereal is trotted out so often as a healthy option that I was just questioning if it's really that healthy. Also, are there parents out there who support their child in eating truly unlimited amounts of certain foods? Like I said, I'm not arguing against anything, I just don't know anyone irl who uses this approach to providing unlim amounts of specific foods.

OP posts:
SantanaBinLorry · 21/07/2022 11:20

'Unlimited' surly just means unlimited within reason/budget/what's actually in the house.

No one refills their fruit bowl daily.

Bread, milk, cereal all healthier more filling and cheap(er) than 15 packets of crisps.

TheInteriorSilence · 21/07/2022 10:59

Well ok then, but good cereals do exist

I don’t think I understand the logic to this thread. 😅