Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s fine to get a dog if you both work full time?

58 replies

chatterbug22 · 21/07/2022 09:43

As above, not about our situation but about a friend. I thought it would be interesting to see what people think.

They’ve wanted a dog for ages- one is a shift worker with several days off per week and the other works a very flexible 9-5 with half the week at home. Friend is upset as they’ve been told repeatedly that a dog is a massive tie and will prevent them from going on holiday / going away. She has worked out that there is only one day every couple of weeks that they wouldn’t be at home, and her dad lives just down the road and would be happy to pop in on the dog and give it a walk on these days. AIBU to think people just find an excuse to warn people off doing things these days? I don’t see an issue in their situation, pets bring massive joy!

OP posts:
MyDogsTheBestDog · 21/07/2022 12:07

one is a shift worker with several days off per week and the other works a very flexible 9-5 with half the week at home

Saying they're 'full-time' is a bit of a wind up.

Surely someone with 'several days off per week' - given that there are only seven days in a week - is not full time!

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 21/07/2022 12:00

It's fine for some people and not for others.

I know a woman who works in the office 9-5 monday to friday and pops home at lunch to let her dog (a young beagle) out. The rest of the time it's on it's own. Thats unacceptable imo, even if the dog is technically 'fine'.

We have a dog and both work full time, but we have very flexible jobs and WFH often so there is always someone home with him. On the odd occasion we both need to go into the office he goes to my mums, who is retired and has two dogs of the same breed and land so he has a whale of a time there. He also goes to her when we go on holiday and I dont feel the slightest bit bad as I know he is with people he knows having all his needs met and then some. But we are lucky to have the flexible jobs and the support. We also have my mums dogs when she goes away so it works both ways.

It's all about the individual situation.

sparkypupp · 21/07/2022 11:41

This is my exact set up.

It's still not 'easy' to own a dog when you work shifts/work from home but we make adjustments to give the dog what she needs.
The only impact on holidays is the additional cost for boarding!

I really wouldn't give other people's opinions any headspace but I would opt for daycare over someone popping in now and then on those odd days. Our dog also goes to daycare when the shift worker is sleeping, they might want to consider this too.

Lineala · 21/07/2022 11:19

I'm sure our neighbours think their dog is fine when they leave it during the day at weekends. It isn't. It starts barking from the moment they leave to the moment they return. It's foul for the dog and foul for us.

ihavenocats · 21/07/2022 11:15

Think from the dog's perspective. You say they'll be out this/that amount of hours each week. Think how much will the dog be alone and is that okay? They're pack animals, not solitary, they like to be among their pack, sleep among their pack, rest among their pack, eat among their pack. We already deprive them of this in many ways and you're talking about also leaving them alone. Everyone I know with dogs ensures they are never alone. This is the reason I don't have one, they are too needy and it's a choice between giving them what they need or neglecting their needs and I'm not willing to do either. We have adopted three animals but we knew we could meet all their needs, not so with a dog. Definitely don't be buying them ones as animals are not things to have but living beings to care for as and when we are able to do that.

stargirl1701 · 21/07/2022 11:08

I was told this BS too.

Ddog is so not a tie. She's been so easy. She slept through the night from 5 months, she eats everything she is given, she is always happy to go for a walk, she is always delighted to play.

DC are a flipping tie.

FawnFrenchieMum · 21/07/2022 10:59

I think there is two separate parts to your OP, people are absolutely right that a dog is a huge tie and responsibility. All our UK breaks have changed since we got a dog, we have to plan around where he can stay with us, where we can eat, someone staying back with him if we wanted to do a theme park or something while we are away. We have taken one abroad holiday since having him and spent a long time building him up to his time in the kennels, starting with a day visit, then one night, then two, then a long weekend etc before the actual holiday.

The second part about their working full time / shifts I think is totally reasonable. We both work full time but I am only in the office twice a week (although we only finally agreed to get him when my previous job went full time home working, unfortunately I was made redundant a few months later!). He is perfectly happy on the days I am in the office, he gets a long walk in the morning and DS takes him when he gets home at 3.30. We have a camera to check on him any time.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 21/07/2022 10:52

VickyEadieofThigh · 21/07/2022 10:50

I'd say it depends on a wide range of factors. The small dog rescue charity I support is full to bursting and regularly has dogs that people have given up because it was too much work and/or expense for them, or the dog wasn't perfectly behaved when they were out and chewed things in the house or needed the toilet and had to go indoors, etc.

They need to know that it's expensive, takes a lot of time to train a dog (and it never ends, to be honest) and that this is a living being who - if not given the time, love and care to settle - might be damaged by its experiences if they end up relinquishing it.

This is the same for all dog owners though, regardless of work hours.

VickyEadieofThigh · 21/07/2022 10:50

I'd say it depends on a wide range of factors. The small dog rescue charity I support is full to bursting and regularly has dogs that people have given up because it was too much work and/or expense for them, or the dog wasn't perfectly behaved when they were out and chewed things in the house or needed the toilet and had to go indoors, etc.

They need to know that it's expensive, takes a lot of time to train a dog (and it never ends, to be honest) and that this is a living being who - if not given the time, love and care to settle - might be damaged by its experiences if they end up relinquishing it.

Iheartmysmart · 21/07/2022 10:47

I have to be honest and say I wfh full time and even then find having a dog a bit of a tie. Up early every morning to make sure he has a decent walk before logging in, spend most of my lunch break walking him then as soon as I finish for the day we’re out for another walk. I do live in a flat though which means we’re out more than most. I think having my dog adds an extra couple of hours ‘work’ into my day.

cottagegardenflower · 21/07/2022 10:40

No

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 21/07/2022 10:21

Yamyam13 · 21/07/2022 10:16

It's definitely doable, but it's the getting to that stage that needs considering. Our dog is 8 months old and we are only just getting to a point where we dont have to constantly watch her, and we can leave her for a good 2 hours (only ever after a long walk) etc. It's all doable, but still a huge commitment and a lot of work but if they want a dog that passionately then they will find it rewarding and be fine with putting in the hard work.

It's a good point - they'll need to consider how they manage the puppy stage where the puppy needs supervision almost constantly. Shifts is well and good, but presumably there is sleep involved etc.

But there are definitely more and less high maintenance breeds (and individual dogs). Advise your friends to choose wisely. Our dog is 9 months old, and she's been fine to leave to 6 hours at a time for a couple of months already (she sleeps, no signs of distress, no accidents). We worked hard on seperation anxiety from the beginning though and she's VERY chilled out .

Alliswells · 21/07/2022 10:21

What you have described is perfectly fine.

Tell your friend to tell those commenting to butt out.
Everyone is an armchair expert these days and are too quick to offer their unwanted opinions Hmm

hoorayandupsherises · 21/07/2022 10:19

My DH works shifts, I do two days in the office, three days at home (even before the pandemic), one of which is always DH's day off. So there's a max of one day a week where she might be on her own for four hours. We have a dog walker booked in on that day to keep our slot, so even if my DH isn't working, she comes and takes her out.

JengaCupboard · 21/07/2022 10:19

It's perfectly fine as long as you plan in advance! We both work full time, but the dog goes to day care a couple of days, to my mum and dad's a couple of days and with me to work at other times as my environment allows this.

Personally we don't leave him unattended barely ever (aside from an hour here and there for a supermarket run etc) but that's just us - and we have holidays together rather than boarding but again, totally personal choice.

He's very happy, social and no signs of anxiety at all.

I think some people don't realise the cost of responsible pet ownership, and it can well be the full time working people than can afford to care for their animals properly. Between daycare, insurance, good food and all the other fun bits, he probably costs us around £500.00 per month - paid for by working full time.

Yamyam13 · 21/07/2022 10:16

It's definitely doable, but it's the getting to that stage that needs considering. Our dog is 8 months old and we are only just getting to a point where we dont have to constantly watch her, and we can leave her for a good 2 hours (only ever after a long walk) etc. It's all doable, but still a huge commitment and a lot of work but if they want a dog that passionately then they will find it rewarding and be fine with putting in the hard work.

thereisonlyoneofme · 21/07/2022 10:11

Dont rely on professional doggy care, all the local kennels and dog sitters here are full to bursting, and it seems to be all over the country.

NewCatName · 21/07/2022 10:11

Can she not get 2 dogs?
That would be slightly better I think, to give each other company when no one's home.

Lyricallie · 21/07/2022 10:09

There's a difference between being out of the house all day and what you've just described. We both work from home and occasionally need to go on site visits. We just manage it so someone is in the house or worst comes to worst our friend can come round if it's a whole day. Then if they're not available we have a local dog care we can send him to which is where he goes if we are away for long weekends. For holidays he stays with the in laws (but we're careful not to take the piss) and we will watch their dogs when they're away. So yes it can be done you just need to be organised.

LindaEllen · 21/07/2022 10:08

If they're willing to pay for doggy daycare/dog walker on a regular basis, fine.

If they're planning on just leaving the dog alone for a large proportion of its life, not fine, and not fair.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 21/07/2022 10:07

It's completely fine.

We both work full time (well, me sligthly less), but I work from home. Once in a while I am away with work or need to go into the office and we just have a dog walker come in for our dog. She's completely fine.

I would get a low key breed in these circumstances though. You don't want one that needs hours of exercise a day, or is known to be destructive if left alone if you know that will happen on occassion.

Lovetogarden2022 · 21/07/2022 10:04

Our neighbours work full time (very stressful jobs too where they're having to go on trips away etc). They manage absolutely fine. They get up early and walk the dog before breakfast, and then walk the dog after their dinner at night. They've also got a fantastic woman who comes a couple of times a week if they're especially busy during the day to take it on a long walk.

The dog used to have awful seperation anxiety (you'd hear it whining in the daytime) but now it's absolutely fine.

My best friend and her partner work shifts and they have a dog - it's absolutely fine and on the very rare occassion they can't walk the dog for whatever reason, a friend of family member will pop in to let the dog out.

I personally wouldn't get a dog as I've got enough to think about with working and kids, but if they've got the space etc I see no issue really

Tiani4 · 21/07/2022 09:55

That's fine. She has thought through how to ensure someone is there for dog to walk him/her. They may be working FT but one is wfh and the other on shift patterns with dad round the corner to help and a back up friend who is dog sitter! Your friend has more cover than most people!!

My friend works FT and got dog pre covid - got up early to walk him, went home at lunchtimes to walk him, DCs were home 3.30pm and walk him then and they walk him again long walk in evenings. Her mother walks him if she is in training all day,

I'm jealous as she's lost so much weight! And DDog is now her favourite child 🐕🤣

It's sweet but like talking to a mum with a pfb! It's years of hearing about everything he does!! GrinGrin

She takes him with her on most U.K. holidays they have and has a friend at work who stays at hers to dog sit when she goes away.

It can be done but only by recognising DDogs needs

dontdrinkanddriveok · 21/07/2022 09:55

Why can't they dog walk to help others out?

I would love a dog but we both work full time and there is no way. My DP and DSis live close by and share the dogs between them.

It's not fair to expect a dog to sit at home all day, they are individual social creatures with personalities and needs.

womaninatightspot · 21/07/2022 09:55

A dog is a huge tie. I have one and so no holidays for me. There's a lot of planning and expense in making sure dog doesn't spend the day alone. She is lovely but a massive commitment. I think everyone in the house needs to be onboard with the idea of getting a dog otherwise it is not fair.