Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The civil service is a great place to work

31 replies

DogDaysNeverEnd · 21/07/2022 07:47

I'm looking for a job and the world's my oyster in theory but in practice it's obviously not (read that as I have no clue what I want to do with my remaining 30 year til retirement).

I had a civil service interview last week for an SEO role but it was so short I didn't get to ask much (at DEFRA). I didn't get the job, and I know there's a hiring freeze of sorts so wondering if I want to keep pursuing any opportunities I see.

I'm hoping to get some insight here. If you work for the civil service, and especially DEFRA what do you wish you'd known when/before you started? Is the pension still good? If departments are shrinking does that mean everyone is stressing? Is the work interesting?

Aibu - the civil service is a great place to work

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BeyondMyWits · 21/07/2022 15:07

I worked in IT in the CS for 15 years, pay was crap, pension ok (took mine early for only 19% loss)

The job itself was bloody awful. Trying to run real cutting edge tech alongside 2500 legacy systems that can't possibly be changed because it cost too much to change anything and the users can't possibly learn anything new yadayadayada... brought me to tears many times.

But the flexi was good.

turkeyboots · 21/07/2022 14:52

Defra is going through some major upheaval as 90% of its work hung off EU rules, so it's all changing now. If you are interested in the subject area it could be interesting but frustrating. Also Defra does loads of emergency work from animal diseases to floods to nuclear incidents which is exciting but means v v long days.
I enjoyed my time there, but won't go back.

Dotjones · 21/07/2022 14:39

It's still a bit of a gravy train compared to the private sector so it's a good option. Pay/conditions/pension/job security are much better than in the private sector.

supertedlasso · 21/07/2022 14:37

I think it really depends where you end up.

I always suggest it when someone is disabled as they'll be able to get all the equipment and other adjustments they'll need and it's reliable.

I both love and hate my current department, love the flexibility they offer but hate the work itself. I'm planning to move to a different workstream soon.

DogDaysNeverEnd · 21/07/2022 14:30

Thanks for all your replies, it's interesting to get a range of view points and I do appreciate every team/dept can be different. I'm currently in academia so there are parallels with interesting work with flexible hours and pay that isn't as high as industry! The comments about excessive bureaucracy sound painfully familiar too. What I'm not currently enjoying is being pulled in several directions at once, it would be nice to do something very focused and applied.

It might be a case of the grass not always being greener, but as change is a a good as a rest I will keep looking for something suitable. At 40 am painfully aware of how long I have left to work and I'd like to think I could enjoy at least some of that time.

OP posts:
HappinesDependsOnYou · 21/07/2022 12:43

I think it depends on what your background is and what job you are applying for.

Lots of long term CS staff I've worked with don't speak highly of it as pay has been in effect reduced over the decades and pensions etc aren't what they used to be however coming from private sector I love working for them. My work life balance is better, my work load is high but my department recognise that and are very supportive and I feel more jib security and less stress. Private sector was all money driven my experience of CS is that it isn't (although I'm sure in the higher ranks or other departments that changes) they seem to offer a lot of support for wellbeing as well and the managers in my department are very present and approachable. The last department I worked for was a bit more target driven and pressured but again compared to a management in the private sector it was much nicer!

NatMoz · 21/07/2022 12:43

Pay is 'ok' but i love the pension, the flexibility (want to work a 7-3?no problem), wfh, the annual leave and for me low stress (don't manage staff).

I've been on maternity leave and even that is very generous.

Gwenhwyfar · 21/07/2022 12:37

"I'm micro managed massively."

This was what I saw in my very short time temping at the civil service. Instead of having 4 to 10 people in a unit/department and a line manager as a head of department, it was almost like every person had their own personal manager. That person, just one level up from you, has less normal work to do because they're a 'manager' so they actually spend time supervising you closely. We also had appraisals every month whereas I'd reached the age of 40 never having any before that!
Very hierarchical and people quite high up doing things that people at the bottom could do.
Where I worked was also not understaffed like the places mentioned on MN. It was actually overstaffed and people didn't have enough to do. We worked less efficiently as well to have enough work for everyone.

pinkandyellowmarshmallow · 21/07/2022 12:37

The CS is huge so it will depend a lot on the department/team/specialism.

With that caveat in mind, I’d say the pay compares unfavourably to other sectors but the pension is better.

Maternity/paternity leave and sick pay are generally very good. As is annual leave.

If you’re recruited on a permanent contract it’s very hard to get rid of you. This has pros and cons, obviously the pro for you is a very secure role and the con is that you may find yourself working with a lot of people who don’t really do very much work because they can get away with it (not always the case of course - there are some very hardworking teams).

Better flexible working options than I’ve seen elsewhere, if you request to go part time they will usually try to find a way to support it in my experience.

Some people find the work genuinely fascinating and love working for the public good. Others find it frustrating if they’re asked to implement something they don’t believe in just because the government wants to do it.

There are mostly no bonuses (or tiny amounts which are taxed) no matter how well you perform. Absolutely no freebies like tea/coffee/milk or lunch if you’re at an internal event/training course. Sounds small but a lot of people are surprised at this!

So in summary I’d say it depends a lot on the area you work in and what you’re looking to get out of it.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 21/07/2022 12:28

I went on a course with lots of people from the civil servie. It certainly sounded very good to me. I do think you experience frustrations related to process and bureaucracy that can be very frustrating. Also, sounds like it's virtually impossible to sack people - good for you from a job security perspective, but does lumber you with some sometimes challenging coworkers.

TiredInPerpetuity · 21/07/2022 12:25

I've been with the CS for 3 years now and as soon as I'm back off Mat leave I'm getting out.

It depends on how you like to work but coming from private sector into CS has been terrible for me. The salary is poor, but the pension is excellent so you have to weigh up whether it's enough to cover the shortfall in salary that you could get doing comparable jobs in private sector.
There is flexible working which is great but to be honest, I've always had flexi in the roles I've done before due to the type of work I do so it's not a selling point for me.
I'm micro managed massively. Every decision needs about seven million meetings and then needs to go up through loads of different levels if people before anything can be implemented. This is my biggest frustration, how much time (and therefore public money!) are we wasting just hashing over the same info again and again and again. Needs more decisive and dynamic people.

There are also a lot, and I mean a LOT, of people who are terrible at their jobs. I don't know if it's the same in every department, but performance management is just not carried out in my dept. So many inept and ineffective people it's actually baffling

LikeADogWithABone · 21/07/2022 08:31

The people I know who work for the CS only work their contracted hours so much more manageable than a lot of other jobs.

YorkshireTeaCup · 21/07/2022 08:28

I've been a CS for nearly 10 years in a small technical central government department. I've progressed from HEO to Grade 6 in that time. I've been able to travel to loads of different places, met some amazing people and work on issues that make a big difference to the prosperity of our country. I have great job satisfaction and am very driven by the idea of public service.

Personally, i am very happy with my projected pension - I'd be intrigued to learn more about which schemes are better. Pay is frustrating and i only get around 60% of what someone doing my job in the private sector would get, but i really value the work life balance - especially since having my baby last year.

My workload is heavy and fast paced which can be stressful. This is where good managers are critical. I have been lucky to have some excellent managers who have dealt with performance management issues robustly for the benefit of the whole team. But i have seen teams with high levels of stress, bullying and ineffective management, which are not positive places to work. Ultimately the CS employs 400,000 people so there is going to be a very great range in experiences.

Shgytfgtf111 · 21/07/2022 08:23

I agree with the previous comment about HMRC. I am in a different department now and i love it. The pay isnt great and hasnt really increased in 10 years and the pension is OK. I wouldnt necessarily put the CS on a pedestal even I do love it.

DogDaysNeverEnd · 21/07/2022 08:23

@Testina if I rephrased and said asked if the CS has been eroded to the point other pensions have caught up? Tbh, it's not my main concern that I'm going to read up speculatively as it's not going to sway my decision, just good to get a sense.

OP posts:
TragicMuse · 21/07/2022 08:18

Depends on the department. From what I know from family and friends that work in different bits of the CS, HMRC is AWFUL to work for.

Iamanunsafebuilding · 21/07/2022 08:16

" Some colleagues are deadweight protected by being hard to fire. Ugh. "

This is my experience as well, is really frustrating when you have a decent work ethic. Read the same for 'people who know how to play the system'

woolwinder · 21/07/2022 08:15

DogDaysNeverEnd · 21/07/2022 07:58

It's "Am I being unreasonable"? So, it's a question.

I've been led to believe it's a great place to work, good pension, nice people, interesting and varied work etc. Wanting to see if any civil servants recognise that description...

Just retired from the Ministry of Justice. I made some lifelong friends there. Also they really look after you and the pension is good. Salaries could be higher.

DogDaysNeverEnd · 21/07/2022 08:13

@overitall1 sorry to hear that, but also good to know. I hope you find something less stressful soon.

OP posts:
Iamanunsafebuilding · 21/07/2022 08:13

I'm a public servant rather than a civil servant, I work for a non-departmental government body. The workload is heavy but it's really interesting work, the pay isn't terrible but I know I could earn more in the private sector. Our annual leave is fabulous and the pension is good. I really enjoy my work and like that I play a part in making a difference to the UK economy.

MrsToothyBitch · 21/07/2022 08:12

Ime, daily doing the job: Pension is ok. Holidays are good. I personally have found it quite flexible in terms of hours, leave, workplace adaptions. That's the good stuff. Interview process is what it is, but there are techniques to help and the CPD framework, though tiresome, is good for progress tracking. Supposedly we're hard to fire, lol.

My workload has mostly been ok although I did have a break down when someone more senior kept demanding updates on a SNAFU partly created by her that got dumped on me, and would respond to my emails outlining my efforts & asking for next steps/her guidance on specific issues with "thaaaaaaanks- you're a rockstar! 🤩" but no advice or actions. For months.

The tougher stuff: the figure for people who say they've felt bullied at work is high, workload can be time pressured. They also seem to hate you talking to actual people; I've found it incredibly hard to get put through to a person when I've had to call different help desks before- especially post covid. You MUST stay on top of your personal HR stuff and be assertive with stuff you want/need. Some colleagues are deadweight protected by being hard to fire. Ugh.

As long as you're in a position with progression and with decent management, it is pretty good, but be aware you're a cog in a huge machine- and be prepared to look after yourself and your interests and self advocate/be your own cheerleader. I'd recommend being unionised, too.

Testina · 21/07/2022 08:11

DogDaysNeverEnd · 21/07/2022 08:04

I get the point about reading the info about the CS pension but I guess I'm asking more in context of all the other pension schemes available. I thought CS used to be the gold standard but maybe others have caught up now?

😆 yeah - cos that’s been the general industry wide movement pt pension schemes over the last 10 years…
So you don’t want to research the CS scheme, and you don’t want to research other schemes as a comparison yourself either?

DogDaysNeverEnd · 21/07/2022 08:10

@latetothefisting I did torture the format for traffic, yes. I've asked questions in the work forum before and tumbleweed.

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 21/07/2022 08:06

I work for a CS department that is constantly recruiting. It is very very stressful, and the pay is a bit rubbish, but I can honestly say it's the most interesting job I've ever done in my life. There are a lot of staff who are just time-servers, and who don't really care about their jobs, but if you've got a bit of nous about you, its easy to just go round them and do what you want. I work flexi-hours which suits me perfectly, my team are great, and there are lots of opportunities to shine.

I don't know anything about DEFRA I'm afraid, but CS experiences are quite universal.

latetothefisting · 21/07/2022 08:05

I'm assuming op worded it that way because she posted in aibu for traffic but tried to avoid people would tell her she's using aibu "wrong" without an actual aibu.

Anyway I work in an arms- length CS body and would personally say yes the description is broadly accurate and I enjoy the work and the conditions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread