Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to move to Scotland?

108 replies

kisaki333 · 20/07/2022 21:58

Hi, please help me make a decision as my heart and brain are not in the same place.
Background:
DH and I are in our 40's, we have a 6-month old and we are currently in a waaaaaay too small rented flat in SE England.
A while back, we've had an offer accepted on a house (SE England). The mortgage offer is for a 5 year fix under 2% which, by today's standards is incredible. It runs out in Sept, though, so we can only use it for this house.
The house in question is an OK house in an OK area with OK-ish schools. Nothing spectacular and it's about all we can afford in this area of the country.

While we were waiting for our sellers to get a move on with their chain (it's been months), we became convinced the sale will fall through and after viewing umpteen other properties, we realized we can't afford any other house we like around here. So we started thinking about moving to Glasgow where we lived years ago (when we were young and wild!). In Glasgow, we could afford either a superb house in an OK area or an OK house in one of the best areas with the best schools (like Bearsden or Milngavie etc). But to get there we have some bumps:


  • DH would have to ask for a transfer from his work. It would probably be granted but no idea when, it depends when there's an opening. Risk is where-ever he gets transferred might not be as nice as his current setup, it's a gamble.

  • I would also almost certainly have to change jobs as my current employer wants us 3 days in the office (although I can do my job from home without any issues) . Risk is the new job would probably not be paid as well. I am the main earner so that would be painful but not disastrous in the short term.

  • We would likely have to first move into rented accommodation in Glasgow and only after buy a house (very hard to do viewings from miles and miles away and the market is hot there at the moment). Risk is: really nasty to move twice with a small baby.


My head says to buy the SE property (bird in hand etc). My heart wants to go back to Scotland.
A third option would be to buy the house in the SE now and then move up north in a few years. But by then DH will be almost 50 and he's the social one of us two. Really hard to start fresh in your 50's...

I am so very torn. I want to do what's best for my DC and I just can't decide what that is.

So please let me know what you think!
YABU - buy the SE house, Scotland is just a dream which might easily become a nightmare!
YANBU - listen to your heart and go north

OP posts:
sweetkitty · 20/07/2022 23:42

We are originally from outside Glasgow, lived in the SE for 9 years had DD1 then decided to move back, we’re 20 mins from Glasgow now and have never regretted it. I gave up my career and became a SAHM (and I was the main earner at the time). Once all DC were at school I went back to uni retrained and now have a second career I love.

caoraich · 20/07/2022 23:33

I live in one of the Glasgow areas you mentioned and we are really happy. We're not from Glasgow but we like it here and DC is happy. Plenty of local friends and neighbours are English. I'd say go for it if you can get the work stuff sorted out

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/07/2022 23:27

I’d go to Glasgow - great city, and it sounds like you can sort the work thing out.

Although I don’t think it’s amy harder to move in your 50s than your 30s or 40s so I wouldn’t worry about that.

jcmd · 20/07/2022 23:23

Tellmewhyaintnothinbutaheartbreak · 20/07/2022 22:24

Come back but please be advised that the SNP has run the country into the ground.

that being said, check out Giffnock, clarkston, busby, East Kilbride, cambuslang, Rutherglen, Shawlands

I second this.

Scottishskifun · 20/07/2022 23:20

TunnelOfGoats · 20/07/2022 22:29

Genuine question, but do any of you English posters who have moved to Scotland get any hostility from the locals? We would love to move there and the lifestyle would really suit our interests, but wouldn't want to be surrounded by people who don't want us there

Yes but mostly around election times or referendum it's not pleasant when it does happen.
But I'm also pretty rural and some people where I am don't even like toonsers (the city folk) visiting or moving here. So it very much depends on where you are and it is the minority.

StoneofDestiny · 20/07/2022 23:17

I've lived in Scotland and England (various parts of both). There is good and bad bits of both - live in one, but it's easy to get to the other.

Bobby80 · 20/07/2022 23:13

Scotland in a heartbeat. A better education system, free university, wild outdoor space, fewer people, Irn Bru…….

I live in a town with a large Royal Navy community. Lots of English families and I’ve never heard of any anti English behaviour or rhetoric. Buy them a drink and the Scots love you 🥃

Icannever · 20/07/2022 23:11

I am from Scotland but my dads English, I don’t think he’s ever felt unwelcome in Scotland.
We absolutely love holidaying in England, weathers better, more to do for older kids but we are always glad to get back to Scotland where it’s just that bit quieter, traffics better, beaches are so much quieter.
I think schools are better here, perhaps less academic but more child friendly. Less emphasis on testing and more child led learning in my experience plus you will never be fined for taking your child out of school. I love that our school holidays are earlier too as it means you can get cheap holidays in England.
Also if we’re going to get lots more heatwaves like this week I’d rather be here where it is cooler (ok freezing)

MugginsOverEre · 20/07/2022 23:03

@ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor I wouldn't say there's anything in particular wrong with England if I'm honest. It's pretty much the same but with different accents! But I live in a small Scottish village and I just adore it. It's so nice. There's probably tonnes of quaint English villages I'd love as much too but this place is my home and I wouldn't go anywhere else. I don't need to go back to my English roots anymore except fleeting visits to family and popping down to Blackpool for a holiday once in a while.

Oh and there's scotch pies and red kola here. Nuff said.

Boysnme · 20/07/2022 23:00

@kisaki333 what type of jobs would you be looking for? Depending on the industry you might find the job market really good just now.

FayeGovan · 20/07/2022 22:53

This thread warms my heart ❤

MugginsOverEre · 20/07/2022 22:48

I moved from England to Scotland twenty some years ago.

I wouldn't even want to go back to visit. I'm love it here.

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 20/07/2022 22:44

I wouldn’t be so sure on being able to get a house easily here. House prices are ridiculous just now and availability is horrific. Most houses go for well over what they are worth with several bidders these days.

I need to ask though, all these posters who say they have moved here from England. What’s wrong with England? I’ve only ever holidayed there so no idea what it’s like to live there but so many English insist on moving up here.

Threeboysandadog · 20/07/2022 22:42

My parents (then mid 40’s) left Hertfordshire when I was 14 and my sister was 11 moving an hour North of Inverness. It’s only in the last few years that I’ve thought about what a huge upheaval that must have been, especially for my Mum. I don’t think they had any regrets.

I wouldn’t leave Scotland now.

TheSecretaryBird · 20/07/2022 22:42

We haven’t found any hostility towards us at all - everyone we’ve met so far is really friendly. We have made some good friends already because of our horses, and our neighbours are really friendly (but not too overbearing or interfering!!!). We had an absolutely awful neighbour when we lived down south so that has made us quite wary of neighbours.
Everyone is so chatty and friendly - in shops for example, and so helpful.

StoneofDestiny · 20/07/2022 22:38

Tunnel - nothing beyond banter, husband is English, and football, accent banter is no different from what I, a Glaswegian, get in England. All good. (Just take a sense of humour)

Indoctro · 20/07/2022 22:35

TunnelOfGoats · 20/07/2022 22:29

Genuine question, but do any of you English posters who have moved to Scotland get any hostility from the locals? We would love to move there and the lifestyle would really suit our interests, but wouldn't want to be surrounded by people who don't want us there

I'm from England , (RAF)

I speak with a very English accent. I get no hostility at all but I have lived here for 38 years but not in the same place.

Also I don't agree with the schools thing someone else mentioned. My sister had 9 schools due to forces and moving and I also had a few

Forces kids do it all the time with no affect.

clpsmum · 20/07/2022 22:34

TunnelOfGoats · 20/07/2022 22:29

Genuine question, but do any of you English posters who have moved to Scotland get any hostility from the locals? We would love to move there and the lifestyle would really suit our interests, but wouldn't want to be surrounded by people who don't want us there

None whatsoever. Always been accepted and made to feel welcome. I think Scotland is the best country in the world I really do

StoneofDestiny · 20/07/2022 22:33

Come back - west end of Glasgow will give you all the social buzz, great schools, cafes, restaurants, museums, botanic gardens, parks etc etc

clpsmum · 20/07/2022 22:32

Whostoblame · 20/07/2022 22:14

Come to Scotland, I moved here from England and don't regret it for a second

This^^ couldn't agree more

And university is free here for your child/Rens future

mistermagpie · 20/07/2022 22:31

TunnelOfGoats · 20/07/2022 22:29

Genuine question, but do any of you English posters who have moved to Scotland get any hostility from the locals? We would love to move there and the lifestyle would really suit our interests, but wouldn't want to be surrounded by people who don't want us there

I never have, despite my relatives panicking about that when I moved up here. I have an English accent and people generally just ask where I'm from. There's a bit of banter around football stuff, but I'm not into football so it goes past me.

haringthroughlife · 20/07/2022 22:31

Glasgow hands down (although I may be biased as I'm Glaswegian!)

  • even if your new job is slightly lower paid, everything is proportionate - Glasgow is significantly cheaper to live than the SE
  • it's a fantastic city with loads to do with kids
  • thinking to the future, once you've been there long enough (I think it's 5 years) your kids will be able to go to a Scottish uni without paying any tuition fees
mistermagpie · 20/07/2022 22:29

I live in one of the areas of Glasgow named above and I love it! I'm from England but I've been here for over 20 years and would never move back.

Areas like Giffnock, Netherlee, Clarkston, Bearsden are lovely. I don't really like Newton Mearns but it has good schools I suppose. Everything is easy to get to.

I work in Glasgow and it takes me about 20 minutes to drive to work.

TunnelOfGoats · 20/07/2022 22:29

Genuine question, but do any of you English posters who have moved to Scotland get any hostility from the locals? We would love to move there and the lifestyle would really suit our interests, but wouldn't want to be surrounded by people who don't want us there

Ihaveoflate · 20/07/2022 22:28

I would love to be brave enough to move to Scotland but family (and familiarity) keeps me in the north of England.

Do it now while your child is very young and will know nothing else. Speaking from experience, it can be very traumatic to move from one end of the country to another as a school aged child.