Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to move to Scotland?

108 replies

kisaki333 · 20/07/2022 21:58

Hi, please help me make a decision as my heart and brain are not in the same place.
Background:
DH and I are in our 40's, we have a 6-month old and we are currently in a waaaaaay too small rented flat in SE England.
A while back, we've had an offer accepted on a house (SE England). The mortgage offer is for a 5 year fix under 2% which, by today's standards is incredible. It runs out in Sept, though, so we can only use it for this house.
The house in question is an OK house in an OK area with OK-ish schools. Nothing spectacular and it's about all we can afford in this area of the country.

While we were waiting for our sellers to get a move on with their chain (it's been months), we became convinced the sale will fall through and after viewing umpteen other properties, we realized we can't afford any other house we like around here. So we started thinking about moving to Glasgow where we lived years ago (when we were young and wild!). In Glasgow, we could afford either a superb house in an OK area or an OK house in one of the best areas with the best schools (like Bearsden or Milngavie etc). But to get there we have some bumps:


  • DH would have to ask for a transfer from his work. It would probably be granted but no idea when, it depends when there's an opening. Risk is where-ever he gets transferred might not be as nice as his current setup, it's a gamble.

  • I would also almost certainly have to change jobs as my current employer wants us 3 days in the office (although I can do my job from home without any issues) . Risk is the new job would probably not be paid as well. I am the main earner so that would be painful but not disastrous in the short term.

  • We would likely have to first move into rented accommodation in Glasgow and only after buy a house (very hard to do viewings from miles and miles away and the market is hot there at the moment). Risk is: really nasty to move twice with a small baby.


My head says to buy the SE property (bird in hand etc). My heart wants to go back to Scotland.
A third option would be to buy the house in the SE now and then move up north in a few years. But by then DH will be almost 50 and he's the social one of us two. Really hard to start fresh in your 50's...

I am so very torn. I want to do what's best for my DC and I just can't decide what that is.

So please let me know what you think!
YABU - buy the SE house, Scotland is just a dream which might easily become a nightmare!
YANBU - listen to your heart and go north

OP posts:
pippinsleftleg · 21/07/2022 08:07

Can anyone recommend places just outside Glasgow with good transport links into the city?

Pugdogmom · 21/07/2022 08:03

English person, living in Scotland most of my life.
I wouldn't live in England now if you paid me. Weather colder up here though. I live outside Glasgow and great transport links into the city. Never felt unwelcome due to being English.

There are some villages that are quite insular that don't like " incomers" , but that applies to resident Scots as well as English. Takes at least 20 years if not more to become accepted..🤣

Don't listen to the moaners complaining about the SNP running the country into the deck...🙄. No they aren't perfect, but we have the same issues here as anywhere else in the world or even RUk ,such as NHS understaffed etc.

My daughters took advantage of the free University education and one is still studying whilst other 2 have professional jobs.

There are great places to live and you would have a great welcome. I wouldn't pick Rutherglen as a place to live though.

fudfootedfannybangle · 21/07/2022 07:43

Best country in the world - and I say this as someone who spent 20 years working and living all over the globe.

choose your area carefully, educational worries are not unfounded - and you need to pick the school with the right SLT who have a long-term vision, not just a “job”.

there’s room to breathe, people are friendly and have time for you the further you travel from the cities.

my accent is like the Queen 😂 despite my Gaelic names and having been born and bred in Scotland. I’ve had no crap about my accent although I’d not loiter around Tesco at the forge on match day doing “performance parenting”!

I live very rurally and although we’re not fans of second home owners, colour and creed are not an issue and we’ve people from all over the world living here rubbing along together in harmony.

I’m always stunned driving south that it’s just so built up. Too much traffic. Too many people. You’re ok until you hit Preston! 😉

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 21/07/2022 07:33

Tellmewhyaintnothinbutaheartbreak · 20/07/2022 22:24

Come back but please be advised that the SNP has run the country into the ground.

that being said, check out Giffnock, clarkston, busby, East Kilbride, cambuslang, Rutherglen, Shawlands

This. I wouldn't come here with a young child if I actually wanted them educated. The schools here are shit and getting worse. You might be slightly better off in Glasgow as there and Edinburgh are the only places allowed money now it seems in Scotland, the rest of us are fucked. But I don't think so, my Glasgow colleagues aren't happy either.

notanothertakeaway · 21/07/2022 07:26

CoolAir · 21/07/2022 02:27

Remember Scotland has an "offers over" bidding system OP. Currently in popular areas you can expect to pay 20% over the offers over price for a house so you need to adjust the price bracket you're looking in accordingly

Yes, important to be aware that "offers over" means just that, so don't make the mistake of thinking house prices are lower than they really are

Scottish education system (7 or 8 Nat 5's aged 16, 5 Highers aged 17, 3 Advanced Highers aged 18) means children have a broader education for longer, instead of specialising after GSCE's in England

Currently no tuition fees for University

We don't seem to have the same issues with NHS eg ambulances queueing for 12 hours. I've had hospital tests in the last year 3 times. No difficulty getting GP appointment, the hospital tests all took place within a week, results almost immediately

We have various friends from England. I'm not aware of them experiencing racism

In some parts of the country, there is resentment towards people buying second homes that sit empty most of the year, but I think that's understandable and probably happens in eg Cornwall too

Mo81 · 21/07/2022 07:04

I moved to Scotland from Northern England when my youngest was a toddler and I don't regret it. There are lots of places outside of Glasgow that have good trainlinks into Glasgow for an easy commute but still have a small town feeling . The only caution I would give tou is that the scottish and English school systems are very different.so if tou are going to move it would be easier on tour child to do it before he starts. Good luck.

CoolAir · 21/07/2022 02:27

Remember Scotland has an "offers over" bidding system OP. Currently in popular areas you can expect to pay 20% over the offers over price for a house so you need to adjust the price bracket you're looking in accordingly

NC12345665 · 21/07/2022 02:21

Celia24 · 21/07/2022 00:36

Nonsense. Just completely untrue. SNP definitely have their downfalls but quality of life is fairly decent.

I live in West End OP, love it here. Southside ok too though I suppose....friends love it there too and I'm from Southside. Was a safe place to grow up.

Poverty levels rising and rising. The hospitals are disgusting. Failing education system. Drug epidemic. It's not fairly decent for everyone. Maybe decent for people in big houses in Bearsden.

kisaki333 · 21/07/2022 02:04

Vikinga · 21/07/2022 00:15

What about friends and family?

I hate built up areas and would much rather move to where I can live in a nice and bigger house but Glasgow is still expensive.

Have you thought about somewhere like Sheffield or outskirts?

Prices are affordable, plenty of jobs and people are really friendly.

@Vikinga I should have mentioned in my post... we are not British by birth. We moved to the UK 10-15 years ago and have friends in both the SE and Glasgow but no family. And no close friends in either so, from that perspective, it makes no difference. Still, I don't feel like I could start from 0 anywhere else. If I did, I doubt it would be the UK, to be honest... That's why I said either here in the SE or Glasgow as at least we know the areas a little bit and have some acquaintances there...

OP posts:
SkeletonFight · 21/07/2022 00:51

The weather is shite though!

Newestname002 · 21/07/2022 00:47

What a great thread! I've now got a small glimmer to come to Scotland myself now! 🌹

Glitterblue · 21/07/2022 00:40

@TunnelOfGoats we're quite a friendly, welcoming bunch I wouldn't like to think English people were treated with hostility but I suppose there will always be some. My ex is English and found Edinburgh very welcome when he moved up to move in with me. He still lives there, 25 years on.

Lucienandjean · 21/07/2022 00:36

We moved from England to Scotland a few years ago and it's been a good move in most ways: cheaper housing, more space and countryside, we live near the sea too.

But I hate the way the SNP is driving the country into the ground. Not even the just independence stuff - more that they are completely incompetent (and don't know what a woman is, apparently). I honestly don't think we could stay if Scotland gained independence, it would just be a disaster. I'd also be concerned about school standards if I had young children, and I'm already concerned about falling ill as the NHS here is in an even worse state than in England.

We've found Scotland to be a beautiful, generally friendly place. Despite my reservations about the Scottish government, in nearly every other way our lives here are good.

In the years we've been here we've had one serious incident of anti-English sentiment, from a Crazy Neighbour who threatened my dh with violence for speaking in an English accent(!) But the neighbour is crazy and would have found some other way to hate us I'm sure, the Englishness was just an excuse.

Celia24 · 21/07/2022 00:36

Tellmewhyaintnothinbutaheartbreak · 20/07/2022 22:24

Come back but please be advised that the SNP has run the country into the ground.

that being said, check out Giffnock, clarkston, busby, East Kilbride, cambuslang, Rutherglen, Shawlands

Nonsense. Just completely untrue. SNP definitely have their downfalls but quality of life is fairly decent.

I live in West End OP, love it here. Southside ok too though I suppose....friends love it there too and I'm from Southside. Was a safe place to grow up.

Dasher789 · 21/07/2022 00:34

@TunnelOfGoats I grew up in Scotland and moved away for uni. After ten years or so away, I came back last year with my English husband. We have not had anyone make us feel unwelcome. On my street actually there are four English families in the immediate vicinity. I am not aware of any of them having any issues. They all seem to love it up here too. I second the PP who said it can be difficult at election times however, the type of people who behave like this have an issue with any non snp/independence supporter so it's not exclusively an assault on English people.

For OP, we are very glad we made the move. We have a much better quality of life. We are in east lothian.

maidofold · 21/07/2022 00:32

I live in London. DH from Glasgow and all his family are there and he would love to move back. We could have an amazing house there. I used to love going there but for me it has changed. It used to be so friendly but when we go there now there is more and more hostility towards English accents and I don't feel welcome anymore. Not by my DH family but generally out and about. I would be worried about my kids with their English accents being bullied. Digs about being English all the time. I laugh with them but there's only so much...
Perhaps it would be different if we lived there and not just visiting. I wonder if because Nicola has made the anti English/Westminster her goal on her relentless pursuit of independence this is now how it is there. Plus the weather is so much worse! It's such a shame as it's a beautiful country and used to be so welcoming to all but I don't find that now.

Lagertha6 · 21/07/2022 00:21

kisaki333 · 20/07/2022 21:58

Hi, please help me make a decision as my heart and brain are not in the same place.
Background:
DH and I are in our 40's, we have a 6-month old and we are currently in a waaaaaay too small rented flat in SE England.
A while back, we've had an offer accepted on a house (SE England). The mortgage offer is for a 5 year fix under 2% which, by today's standards is incredible. It runs out in Sept, though, so we can only use it for this house.
The house in question is an OK house in an OK area with OK-ish schools. Nothing spectacular and it's about all we can afford in this area of the country.

While we were waiting for our sellers to get a move on with their chain (it's been months), we became convinced the sale will fall through and after viewing umpteen other properties, we realized we can't afford any other house we like around here. So we started thinking about moving to Glasgow where we lived years ago (when we were young and wild!). In Glasgow, we could afford either a superb house in an OK area or an OK house in one of the best areas with the best schools (like Bearsden or Milngavie etc). But to get there we have some bumps:


  • DH would have to ask for a transfer from his work. It would probably be granted but no idea when, it depends when there's an opening. Risk is where-ever he gets transferred might not be as nice as his current setup, it's a gamble.

  • I would also almost certainly have to change jobs as my current employer wants us 3 days in the office (although I can do my job from home without any issues) . Risk is the new job would probably not be paid as well. I am the main earner so that would be painful but not disastrous in the short term.

  • We would likely have to first move into rented accommodation in Glasgow and only after buy a house (very hard to do viewings from miles and miles away and the market is hot there at the moment). Risk is: really nasty to move twice with a small baby.


My head says to buy the SE property (bird in hand etc). My heart wants to go back to Scotland.
A third option would be to buy the house in the SE now and then move up north in a few years. But by then DH will be almost 50 and he's the social one of us two. Really hard to start fresh in your 50's...

I am so very torn. I want to do what's best for my DC and I just can't decide what that is.

So please let me know what you think!
YABU - buy the SE house, Scotland is just a dream which might easily become a nightmare!
YANBU - listen to your heart and go north

Go go go.

I'm in NW Eng and trying to convince my DP to move there in the future but he says no.

Scotland is my favourite place on earth.

Vikinga · 21/07/2022 00:15

What about friends and family?

I hate built up areas and would much rather move to where I can live in a nice and bigger house but Glasgow is still expensive.

Have you thought about somewhere like Sheffield or outskirts?

Prices are affordable, plenty of jobs and people are really friendly.

Sooverthisnow · 21/07/2022 00:15

Not with children. The education system is a race to the bottom but it’s ok because they’ll be taught gender trumps sex and they can choose what they are from a young age, and you as parents have no right to question it. 😕

BellaLab · 21/07/2022 00:11

My advice would be to be careful where you move to. We have only recently moved back to our hometown where we were born and raised but we moved due to DH’s job years ago. Many locals in the village have taken a massive dislike to newcomers who have moved here. A lot of the houses are now second homes which have been bought by people South of the border, this means that a lot of local younger house buyers are priced out of the market. People who have bought houses here to relocate aren’t welcomed at all and are almost shunned by the original villagers. We were welcomed back with open arms as both our parents lived here, however there is very much a divide of incomers and villagers.

FayeGovan · 21/07/2022 00:08

👍👍😁

SummerIsComingNowish · 21/07/2022 00:05

FayeGovan · 20/07/2022 22:53

This thread warms my heart ❤

@FayeGovan I grew up in Elderpark Street 😊

giggly · 20/07/2022 23:58

I have just been on holiday to the SE and the best bit was the weather tbh. Can’t stand the busyness of London, the queues in the motorways( and that’s from someone who regularly sits at a standstill on the M8) and the amount of people just everywhere. I’ve lived overseas and Scotland is just the best wee country ever.
Second what others are saying But house prices but there are so many good areas to choose from without paying over the odd for south Ren schools.
come on up you’ll not regrets it

Goodnewsday · 20/07/2022 23:57

As long as you’ve got your wellies and a jacket packed, come on in 🤣 sadly you have already missed our one day of sun for the year as it fell on Tuesday, nightmare!

Houses here are going for way over still although it is calming down a bit now. It’s frightening what you can get here compared to there though

drlel · 20/07/2022 23:56

If you're looking at houses in bearsden or milngavie they're currently going at 20-25% over the HR value (and the offers over price is actually usually even below the HR value). Most are going to a closing date which a couple of years ago was unusual for Scotland.

Sure it's still much more affordable than SE England but just wanted to flag

Ps this is the area I live in and love it but the weather is so much wetter and colder!