Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to move to Scotland?

108 replies

kisaki333 · 20/07/2022 21:58

Hi, please help me make a decision as my heart and brain are not in the same place.
Background:
DH and I are in our 40's, we have a 6-month old and we are currently in a waaaaaay too small rented flat in SE England.
A while back, we've had an offer accepted on a house (SE England). The mortgage offer is for a 5 year fix under 2% which, by today's standards is incredible. It runs out in Sept, though, so we can only use it for this house.
The house in question is an OK house in an OK area with OK-ish schools. Nothing spectacular and it's about all we can afford in this area of the country.

While we were waiting for our sellers to get a move on with their chain (it's been months), we became convinced the sale will fall through and after viewing umpteen other properties, we realized we can't afford any other house we like around here. So we started thinking about moving to Glasgow where we lived years ago (when we were young and wild!). In Glasgow, we could afford either a superb house in an OK area or an OK house in one of the best areas with the best schools (like Bearsden or Milngavie etc). But to get there we have some bumps:


  • DH would have to ask for a transfer from his work. It would probably be granted but no idea when, it depends when there's an opening. Risk is where-ever he gets transferred might not be as nice as his current setup, it's a gamble.

  • I would also almost certainly have to change jobs as my current employer wants us 3 days in the office (although I can do my job from home without any issues) . Risk is the new job would probably not be paid as well. I am the main earner so that would be painful but not disastrous in the short term.

  • We would likely have to first move into rented accommodation in Glasgow and only after buy a house (very hard to do viewings from miles and miles away and the market is hot there at the moment). Risk is: really nasty to move twice with a small baby.


My head says to buy the SE property (bird in hand etc). My heart wants to go back to Scotland.
A third option would be to buy the house in the SE now and then move up north in a few years. But by then DH will be almost 50 and he's the social one of us two. Really hard to start fresh in your 50's...

I am so very torn. I want to do what's best for my DC and I just can't decide what that is.

So please let me know what you think!
YABU - buy the SE house, Scotland is just a dream which might easily become a nightmare!
YANBU - listen to your heart and go north

OP posts:
QueenOfRap · 21/07/2022 10:00

MorrisZapp · 21/07/2022 09:31

YABU

Move to Edinburgh.

I was waiting for someone to say this 😂

NorthCountryBlues · 21/07/2022 09:58

Also, the weather - we are on the east coast and the weather is much much better here than on the west. But I honestly think the weather in Scotland is going to become something to envy (yes you can all laugh at me!)
We had a high of 30 this week - much more bearable than 40.

NorthCountryBlues · 21/07/2022 09:54

I’m an English transplant in Scotland. I LOVE Scotland. I would never move back to England. We go back each year to see family and my heart honestly lifts when we cross back to Scotland.

In a way I don’t know why the two places feel so different but they really, really do. The education system gets a lot wrong here but they do early years really well and the school starting age is later which I think is a brilliant thing.

And I’ve never received any hostility here - just lovely, open warmth, and a great appreciation for my love of Scotland!

Mousemat25 · 21/07/2022 09:53

I am an economist living in Scotland and find the whole independence question very stressful. It would be economically disastrous- there is absolutely no question about it - and I cannot unsee this reality but my kids are at a stage of their schooling where we can’t move so I just remember the wonderful countryside we have access to here and try to have faith that the majority of Scot’s will do a bit of research if there were another independence vote and not believe the grade A bunkum the SNP comes out with.

Educational standards are declining under the SNP too, as detailed in the OECD report published last year. The findings were that the Scottish educational system had failed to keep pace with the latest best practice and had no long term strategies or vision. This is something that could be said for so many things that SNP works on. But the hills are not so far away, as are the islands and beautiful when you get there.

Bobby80 · 21/07/2022 09:46

pippinsleftleg · 21/07/2022 08:07

Can anyone recommend places just outside Glasgow with good transport links into the city?

Depends entirely on your budget but there are some really, really good choices. Bearsden, Milngavie, Helensburgh, Kirkintilloch, Giffnock, Clarkston. An estate agent would be your best bet for other commuter towns.

Bobby80 · 21/07/2022 09:37

Sooverthisnow · 21/07/2022 00:15

Not with children. The education system is a race to the bottom but it’s ok because they’ll be taught gender trumps sex and they can choose what they are from a young age, and you as parents have no right to question it. 😕

Having taught in both systems I'd strongly disagree. Can you direct me to the E&O that you are referring to? This is the resource that is delivered by all state schools from early level to senior phase and I can't see where "gender trumps sex".
rshp.scot/

entropynow · 21/07/2022 09:34

@Indoctro
England is not 'cramped', don't be bloody ridiculous. Ten minutes walk out of my town in the southeast and there is endless countryside for miles

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 21/07/2022 09:34

The way they’re throwing up houses around here it won’t be long till we’re as cramped as England as sad as it makes me to say it. Also can’t stand the SNP and their constant need for independence, If they get it this time it might not be such a nice place to live (my opinion/concern only)

Itawapuddytat · 21/07/2022 09:33

"that being said, check out Giffnock, clarkston, busby, East Kilbride, cambuslang, Rutherglen, Shawlands"

Currently living in one of these areas and not British by birth either. DH doesn't speak with a Scottish accent either and he's happy here. We've all been made welcome here and enjoy our life a lot. The house prices can be crazy in places indeed but I think this is the situation everywhere. Schools are indeed great in Est Renfrewshire, but there are nice schools and nice areas in other places of Glasgow/nearby too, you just need to check before you decide to buy a house in the catchment. YANBU!

MorrisZapp · 21/07/2022 09:31

YABU

Move to Edinburgh.

kikisparks · 21/07/2022 09:22

Mumsnet is usually quite anti Scottish so this is nice to see. I’m an independence supporter and have no anti English sentiment (Westminster on the other hand…)

I love living in Scotland, it’s not perfect but there are a lot of advantages. That being said I live in a small house in a nice peaceful suburb of Glasgow and am well aware my experience is different to someone living in a deprived area.

FayeGovan · 21/07/2022 09:22

Ach i knew it wouldn't take long!!

lazaro · 21/07/2022 09:17

It's just the weather really OP. Could you cope with that? It does have an effect of mental snd physical health. Mind you, London / SE are frequently stifling in August now and if global warming means that 40 degrees or high 30s are going to become the new norm, a lot of people might be heading for Shetland!

The other thing is, education standards are poor in relation to the rest if the U.K. Great if they want to stay in Scotland for uni (its free as well which is another major plus), but not so great if they want to go for the top unis in England as the provision for AH is patchy and not many even take them.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 21/07/2022 09:14

FayeGovan · 21/07/2022 08:59

I had to leave mn for a while as every post on scotsnet was rubbishing Scotland and everything about it. Yes, the snp aren't perfect by all means but the way a certain group of posters took over every thread saying how awful education etc was hear really depressed me. And it was the opposite to my lived experience here with my kids. I couldn't understand these posters and i really liked some of them apart from these views, so i came off scotsnet to get a bit of distance as it was just upsetting hearing constantly how awful Scotland was, according to them. There's a lot of hatred for the snp on scotsnet and anyone who wants independence is mocked immediately. Also reference's to braveheart/wee nippy or worse. Im glad i don't see that so much now.

Yes, this! My kids are in primary school, my half siblings are in/have recently finished secondary in a different area and I just don't see the problems with the education system. My kids are happy at school and are learning well, my brother got AAAAB at Higher. There are issues with some poorer schools, but that's the same across the whole UK (my sister had to switch subjects at Higher because the Engineering teacher left and they couldn't recruit a replacement - that's a subject that didn't exist in my day and I think the pool of teachers is quite small). My two adore their school and have had some absolutely brilliant teachers and it's not a posh school - it's a perfectly average town primary.

WeeOrcadian · 21/07/2022 09:01

I'm in the NE of England and would give my right arm to be able to move to Scotland, I've even posted on here about it. I wish we'd have moved before DC were born, or started school at least.

I'd do it in a heartbeat.

maldivemoment · 21/07/2022 09:00

Mon back. Ye’ll love it.

(just remember tae bring yer wellies & midge repellent!)

FayeGovan · 21/07/2022 08:59

I had to leave mn for a while as every post on scotsnet was rubbishing Scotland and everything about it. Yes, the snp aren't perfect by all means but the way a certain group of posters took over every thread saying how awful education etc was hear really depressed me. And it was the opposite to my lived experience here with my kids. I couldn't understand these posters and i really liked some of them apart from these views, so i came off scotsnet to get a bit of distance as it was just upsetting hearing constantly how awful Scotland was, according to them. There's a lot of hatred for the snp on scotsnet and anyone who wants independence is mocked immediately. Also reference's to braveheart/wee nippy or worse. Im glad i don't see that so much now.

BellaLab · 21/07/2022 08:53

There’s a Scotsnet board on here OP that may be of help to you. These lots of information about schools, the housing market etc on there too ☺️

FayeGovan · 21/07/2022 08:53

Ive just had a think about people i know living here with English/Welsh accents. There's loads! It never occurred to me to treat them any differently. Why on earth would I? Now I'm not saying there will be arseholes about who will make a comment but personally i was called out for being Scottish when i lived in England years ago. Meaning there's arseholes everywhere!!!
Please don't let that even be a consideration for you @kisaki333

Arthursmom · 21/07/2022 08:50

I live in Scotland. I would never live in England and the opportunities for the latter have been endless with jobs etc. simply would not do it 😂 second south side of Glasgow and east Renfrewshire

florafoxtrot · 21/07/2022 08:48

Same here. There is typically so much negativity around Scotland on MN.

OP - why don't you do a bit more fact finding as such to try to answer your questions about whether you could transfer your husbands job and what job opportunities there are for you?

Topcat9876 · 21/07/2022 08:47

From Scotland have lived and worked in England.

Move to Scotland.

Particularly Glasgow.

Dae it. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 21/07/2022 08:46

There are weird misconceptions about how the English will be treated/welcomed here. My DH is English with a very posh accent and has lived here since he was 19 with no issues. He is now a councillor and his parents asked if you were allowed to stand if you were English - er, yes!

slowquickstep · 21/07/2022 08:38

Why on earth would you stay in the south. You can't afford it so think how much your child will struggle in 20 years time to buy a house.

ChilliPB · 21/07/2022 08:37

Do it @kisaki333 !

We moved to Edinburgh from London this year. We transferred with our jobs and we have a much better life in Edinburgh. It’s got loads to do (as has Glasgow if you’re looking there) and all the city amenities but we can get out into the countryside easily too. It’s more relaxed and friendly than London. House prices are better although it is still expensive in Edinburgh (think Glasgow will be a bit less).

I’ve lived here only for a few months but 100% love it and don’t regret it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread