Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Summer holidays - outdated

634 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:05

So I was just scrolling through Facebook and I saw some pictures after school club/breakfast club to my sons school put up and it just got me thinking how crazy it is that schools just completely shut down for like 6-7 weeks.
They have all these facilities during term time to support working families because there is obviously a need to for it, but in the holidays... ahh f*ck it!
Obviously o know there's summer schemes but at a massive expense and also different hours and locations.
My sons school isn't offering one so he's attending some random school for 3 days over the summer mainly just so he's socialising!
I'm extremely lucky as my mum is a great help to me during the holidays. And obviously I'm very much looking forward to spending more time with my boys and no school run... hurry!!!
But I just find it crazy that schools close for such a significant period of time.
Obviously I know school isn't childcare but it school itself enables parents to work so it kind of is 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 21/07/2022 20:51

I think it's a bit rich to accuse posters of not engaging with your points when you haven't actually engaged with any of the well laid out reasons why your solution is flawed.

Sadly, if you had made this thread less of a teacher bash exercise and engaged properly, you would have found that many people's views align with some of yours for good reasons.
For example, I do think childcare needs to be better provisioned. However, as I know about child development I realise the ideal combination is good quality parental time and qualified enriching childcare. Neither of these are solutions schools can offer and are something that could be achieved through sure start style provision and reviewing the British attitude to working hours and taking a more healthy approach to flexibility and work life balance. None of which is the school remit but would require government intervention and plenty of money.

celticprincess · 21/07/2022 20:47

FarmerRefuted · 20/07/2022 22:06

Teachers don't get 3.5 months holiday. They're contracted and paid to provide 190 days of teaching/directed time plus however many days training, planning, etc (exact number will vary by school, responsibility level, and so on). That pay is divided over 12 months so it seems like they're getting paid for school holidays when in reality they're not, they're just having their contracted pay. If you wanted shorter/less school holidays and more directed time then teachers would need to be paid for that additional time, the money for which would need to be raised via increased taxes. There would also need to be more investment in support staff, resources, buildings, etc.

Exactly this. I was coming on to post this exact statement myself.

as another poster also said, there is absolutely zero flexibility for teaching staff regarding their own children. Mine gets dropped at breakfast club at 7:30 (would be 7 if they opened sooner as I would prefer to get Through the traffic with time to spare on arriving at work) and picked up at 5:30 ( again this would be later if later was provided). I only work part time. One reason I can’t work full time is that our staff meeting/training evening actually finishes too late for me to get back through the traffic to collect my children before their after school club closes. The other reason I need to work part time is that one of my daughters was having a lot of medical appointments which are only ever available on weeks days during school hours. So I basically had to drop days to be able to do that. I’m now needing those days for looking after my elderly parents so can’t go back full time. But none of the flexibility of going on late for an appointment or making up hours for an appointment that other jobs give. And then finally we are paid for 1265 hours per year which equates to 195 days of 6 hour days. How many teachers do you know that only work a 6 hour day?? That would be 8:30-3:30 with an unpaid hour for lunch. Teachers are in school way more hours that those and are also then taking work home.

I do agree though that 6 weeks is a long break. They probably should make it 4 and make all the other holidays 2 weeks. But people would still complain at this. But if they shortened the total amount of holidays then teachers would require additional pay.

Itisasecret · 21/07/2022 20:46

norwichmummy123 · 21/07/2022 20:42

Last year I imagined 6 weeks would reduce post lockdown due to having to catch the kids up from missing two years.

Catch kids up from what? We are one of the most highly pressurised, tested and accountability based systems in the world. Our children start earlier than most and spend a higher % of time than most other countries in school (England). With relatively poor global results to show for it and high rates of mental health diagnoses in our youth.

Maybe, just maybe the children need to slow down and the system needs to change.

afuckinggoat · 21/07/2022 20:45

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 20:26

@Thebestwaytoscareatory when you opened this thread did you read my OP?
I have literally stayed MULTIPLE times o do not have an issue with childcare. So no I don't have the angle of what inconveniences me most.
I have listed why I think the school holiday schedule set up is outdated SEVERAL times on this thread and it is not to do with any inconvenience to me. I've emphasised a lot with those who struggle so to work, but no this is not about my own inconvenience.

I'm fine. But I know a lot who aren't.

Wouldn't it be amazing to have 6 weeks off school with your children. To get to enjoy them and make precious memories? I would absolutely LOVE that. But I'm reality I can't achieve that fully.
My OP was mainly a reflection on me feeling shocked that we still have this very historic set up of school holidays which doesn't really reflect modern lives. I also find it odd that there are school clubs ie breakfast and after school clubs which advertise their importance to children's learning and supporting work parents enough to get parents to sign up and pay for this service, yet in the holidays it's like all that importance and support they advertise is not necessary.

In what way are the holidays outdated? Are you referring to the popular myth that the summer holidays were to enable children to assist with the harvest? Our educational system was established in the 19th century when farming was so mechanised, there were complaints that there wasn't enough farm labour work for adult men, let alone there being enough work to necessitate thousands of children labouring in the fields a whole season before the autumn harvest.
Many historians state that the origins of the long summer holiday lay in the need to get the children out of the classrooms during the hottest months.
So I ask, is this need outdated? Are our summers no longer hot? Are the classrooms now air conditioned? Are our children now in need of even more time learning when there is plenty of pedagogical evidence demonstrating that more time in school does not equal higher quality learning?

Again, it is not schools or holidays that are outdated. Our working patterns are not compatible.

I'll say it again for the people in the back: Don't punish the children. It is not their fault. Ask for better lives for us all, not worse lives for our children for the sake of an inconvenience that we will only have the pleasure of experiencing for the most fleeting amount of time.

JudgeJ · 21/07/2022 20:43

coolernow · 20/07/2022 21:46

I think they should have more camps like in the US

And parents would be willing to pay for them or would they expect some more free childcare? The American camps are eye wateringly expensive.

norwichmummy123 · 21/07/2022 20:42

Last year I imagined 6 weeks would reduce post lockdown due to having to catch the kids up from missing two years.

woodhill · 21/07/2022 20:40

I think dc need time to stop and stare and the holidays allow for this.

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 20:37

Op, the main thing I'm extracting from your posts is that you seem jealous of school staff having long holidays and because you don't have them you feel school staff shouldn't either.

turquoise1988 · 21/07/2022 20:35

@Wednesdayafternoon

Out of interest, what do you think the answer is, then? What do you want?

As other posters have pointed out, holiday childcare IS available. You just have to pay for it. People know this when they choose to have children.

Are you implying that holiday childcare should be available for free?

I'm not clear what you are getting at, to be honest.

Whinge · 21/07/2022 20:34

I also find it odd that there are school clubs ie breakfast and after school clubs which advertise their importance to children's learning and supporting work parents enough to get parents to sign up and pay for this service, yet in the holidays it's like all that importance and support they advertise is not necessary.

Our breakfast and after school club weren't set up to support children's learning or to help working parents. They were set up because there's a demand for them and we need the money. Our school is desperate to plug the gaps left by years of cuts so it makes sense to offer these clubs, and if we didn't offer them parents would find another option or even another school.

Itisasecret · 21/07/2022 20:32

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 20:26

@Thebestwaytoscareatory when you opened this thread did you read my OP?
I have literally stayed MULTIPLE times o do not have an issue with childcare. So no I don't have the angle of what inconveniences me most.
I have listed why I think the school holiday schedule set up is outdated SEVERAL times on this thread and it is not to do with any inconvenience to me. I've emphasised a lot with those who struggle so to work, but no this is not about my own inconvenience.

I'm fine. But I know a lot who aren't.

Wouldn't it be amazing to have 6 weeks off school with your children. To get to enjoy them and make precious memories? I would absolutely LOVE that. But I'm reality I can't achieve that fully.
My OP was mainly a reflection on me feeling shocked that we still have this very historic set up of school holidays which doesn't really reflect modern lives. I also find it odd that there are school clubs ie breakfast and after school clubs which advertise their importance to children's learning and supporting work parents enough to get parents to sign up and pay for this service, yet in the holidays it's like all that importance and support they advertise is not necessary.

You’ve equally been told many times that our system is outdated in the respect that it has some of the shortest holidays in the world, with poor academic progress in comparison to other western countries which have longer holidays. We also have some of the highest SEMH issues in the world. This has been academically researched in some depth.

Your refusal to even acknowledge this is a clear indication of exactly what your thread is about.

turquoise1988 · 21/07/2022 20:30

@Eeksteek I take your points on board, but I think your view that longer terms will simply mean that everything gets 'spaced out' is very naive. Doubtless, the powers that be will find even more content to cram into an already packed curriculum, resulting in even greater stress, just spread out over a longer time period.

If I were to redesign the school day/year? I wouldn't even know where to start, but I would hazard a guess that a Scandinavian model would be a best bet.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 20:29

@Supergirl1958 you're very welcome 👍🏼

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 21/07/2022 20:28

Delatron · 20/07/2022 21:41

I don’t think they need to be 6 weeks. They forget lots and spend a month when they go back catching up.
A month would be plenty. Then stick an extra week on the May/Oct holidays.

There are a few schools that run on this term schedule where I live, 6 weeks half term and then 2 weeks break us 4 weeks in summer.
I think people forget that in some countries schools are off for 3 months. Just imagine it!

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 20:26

@Thebestwaytoscareatory when you opened this thread did you read my OP?
I have literally stayed MULTIPLE times o do not have an issue with childcare. So no I don't have the angle of what inconveniences me most.
I have listed why I think the school holiday schedule set up is outdated SEVERAL times on this thread and it is not to do with any inconvenience to me. I've emphasised a lot with those who struggle so to work, but no this is not about my own inconvenience.

I'm fine. But I know a lot who aren't.

Wouldn't it be amazing to have 6 weeks off school with your children. To get to enjoy them and make precious memories? I would absolutely LOVE that. But I'm reality I can't achieve that fully.
My OP was mainly a reflection on me feeling shocked that we still have this very historic set up of school holidays which doesn't really reflect modern lives. I also find it odd that there are school clubs ie breakfast and after school clubs which advertise their importance to children's learning and supporting work parents enough to get parents to sign up and pay for this service, yet in the holidays it's like all that importance and support they advertise is not necessary.

OP posts:
angela99999 · 21/07/2022 20:21

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:58

I think my point really is, how can schools or the gouverntn or who ever makes these decisions think that during term time they will offer so much support to parents for example breakfast and after school clubs to support parents and also aid extra socialising and learning etc, but the. In the holidays.. nothing.
Does none of that matter then 🤷🏼‍♀️

You're right, my daughter's school have cancelled their summer sports club because they couldn't staff it. She's having to use an expensive club in another local school. However it starts much later than her childrens' normal breakfast club and finishes at 3.30. The term time after-school club finishes at 5.45.
But even this is better than when my own children were at school when we had no breakfast or after-school clubs at all.
Our primary school did eventually set up a summer club but it only ran for two weeks. You had to have a pretty decent salary to be able to pay for proper childcare.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/07/2022 20:17

PS I’m a full time working parent so do know it’s a struggle

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/07/2022 20:17

It worries me for the vulnerable children. The disadvantaged children. The neglected children.

This I agree with.

Generally though, I do think kids need a longer break once a year. Just to process and have a break from all the friendship nonsense, an emotional as well as the physical rest.

Sweatingmytiitsoff · 21/07/2022 20:16

@Thebestwaytoscareatory has a good point. Time management is key and saying no politely.

Many companies will take advantage and you have to learn this quickly other wise it becomes the "norm". There's occasions where it can't be helped but it should not be a regular thing

Itisasecret · 21/07/2022 20:16

LovelyIssues · 21/07/2022 20:09

I work in a school and whole heartedly agree 4 weeks is long enough and to take those extra 2 weeks over Xmas and Easter. And I say this knowing I'm lucky I am off in the 6 week holidays with my children and adore that time with them

God no. For example years in primary and secondary pupils cannot afford to have an extra week at Easter. It will just be rolled into another revision camp. Working in a school - not as a teacher in a high stakes year you don’t.

stuntbubbles · 21/07/2022 20:15

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 21/07/2022 20:12

More fool you / them. I value my one and only life and if my work want me to give them any more of it they can pay for it. That's what should be normal.

A-fucking-men. This country has a really bizarre attitude to work. Overtime shouldn’t be normal! Working through lunch shouldn’t be normal! Being grateful for scraps like the shit “perks” of free bruised fruit in the staff room and statutory holiday allowance shouldn’t be normal!

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 21/07/2022 20:12

antelopevalley · 21/07/2022 19:25

Any professionals work more hours than they are paid for. Totally normal.

More fool you / them. I value my one and only life and if my work want me to give them any more of it they can pay for it. That's what should be normal.

LovelyIssues · 21/07/2022 20:09

I work in a school and whole heartedly agree 4 weeks is long enough and to take those extra 2 weeks over Xmas and Easter. And I say this knowing I'm lucky I am off in the 6 week holidays with my children and adore that time with them

KarmaComma · 21/07/2022 20:08

coolernow · 20/07/2022 22:09

Imo teachers get pretty good pay when you realise it's for 190 days.

190 days direct teaching time. Undirected time is unlimited. School residentials, plays, after school clubs, music performances, results day support, meetings, training, admin, parents evenings, marking, planning etc not included in 190 days,

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 21/07/2022 20:06

ldontWanna · 21/07/2022 18:56

Funny how neither OP or any other posters saying the summer hols are too long here have any comment on the much longer holidays that a lot of other countries have.

Probably because most of those saying they are too long are not looking at it from a "what's best for the children and their health / education" angle but from a "why should I be inconvenienced" one instead.