Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Summer holidays - outdated

634 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:05

So I was just scrolling through Facebook and I saw some pictures after school club/breakfast club to my sons school put up and it just got me thinking how crazy it is that schools just completely shut down for like 6-7 weeks.
They have all these facilities during term time to support working families because there is obviously a need to for it, but in the holidays... ahh f*ck it!
Obviously o know there's summer schemes but at a massive expense and also different hours and locations.
My sons school isn't offering one so he's attending some random school for 3 days over the summer mainly just so he's socialising!
I'm extremely lucky as my mum is a great help to me during the holidays. And obviously I'm very much looking forward to spending more time with my boys and no school run... hurry!!!
But I just find it crazy that schools close for such a significant period of time.
Obviously I know school isn't childcare but it school itself enables parents to work so it kind of is 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
SoHereBesMe · 21/07/2022 21:19

We get 2 months 😁 it seems like a long time at the start of July, but it flies, and I'm a working parent. But I do like the more relaxed routine and nearly morning banshee acts from me required to get everyone out the door, in uniform, lunch packed and spellings, reading and homework all done.
Hard to believe we're already nearly half way through it.

IndiaRose22 · 21/07/2022 21:18

For the PP who said about teachers wouldn't be happy having their 3.5 months holiday eroded...

School staff need to spend time with their own families, as they can't just take random days off here and there like anyone else (teachers/TA's/librarians can't anyway). And how much work gets done in those 'holidays'. Plenty. 3.5 months is nowhere near accurate with all the work done outside of school hours/term times.

Fairislefandango · 21/07/2022 21:18

I don't feel the current 6 weeks holidays suits my lifestyle and I don't think it suits the lifestyle of most people I know.

The point of the education system is not to facilitate your lifestyle. It's to educate your child. Do you have any evidence that a 6 week summer holiday is detrimental to children's education (given that most countries have longer ones, including countries whose children do better in their system than ours do)?

You keep not answering that question.

Phineyj · 21/07/2022 21:14

Because full time teachers have a choice between dental appointments in school holidays or not seeing a dentist at all? No school will give teaching staff time off for routine dental treatment!

Although actually my dentist works some Saturdays as does the physio I sometimes see, and my hairdresser. They both have 2 x DC under 5, so they work when their husbands are available to do childcare and have 3-5 weekdays with their DC each week. I personally think it would be better if subsidised good quality childcare was available, but that's what they do.

Regarding the SAHMs of the past, even in the 70s when I was primary school age, there was a much lower expectation of supervision. My DSis and I would spend half the day in a wood, a stream or messing about with other neighbourhood children.

Like it or not, this isn't acceptable nowadays outside some exceptional communities (I do have one friend in rural Scotland whose DC still spend holidays that way).

JustLyra · 21/07/2022 21:12

alnawire · 21/07/2022 10:14

So many children don't need the break from school, they need it from their parents. The forgotten children. Left in shitty families because there is no one to help them. Just in my street we have a family who do nothing but shout at their kids. Their idea of parenting is to ignore then shout when something goes wrong. These kids are desperately in need of intervention. The summer holidays gives them 6 weeks of hell with absolutely no let up. It's horrific. The teenagers in the family are, predictably, going off the rails. The youngers are not far behind. These children need the safety and relief that school (or something else for holidays) offers. They need the proper meal provided. They need the contact with ordinary humans. They need not to be left at home being miserable for weeks at a time.

This thread has highlighted that people don't see far past their own situation. For some children being in school, or a group/club during the summer holidays would be massively beneficial.

And before anyone naively suggests 'reporting them to SS' - they have social work involvement. It's a meeting everyone now and then to ensure the children are not being physically harmed and have a place to sleep and meals provided. The emotional damage isn't on SS radar.

These children NEED less holidays.

Abused and neglected children need properly funded intervention services that work for them, and with less plain focus on keeping families together at all costs.

My parents were abusive and neglectful. One of my lovely, lovely school teachers rigged a raffle so I won a hamper of non-perishable food and snacks when I was 6. She helped my brother hide the stuff for me from our father. It was wonderful of her.
however, what we really needed was social services to listen to them, and us, and not put a zillion “plans” in place with my father that failed repeatedly.
It took my grandparents basically taking us and daring my parents to go to the police to get us out.

Children do not need more school. They need proper services and help.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 21:11

@afuckinggoat were not mates so yeah just stop thank you!

OP posts:
Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 21:10

JMR185 · 21/07/2022 21:08

I think it's naive to think teachers have such an easy time of it. I helped at a primary school on a voluntary basis and they work long days, far longer than when their pupils attend and over the weekends too. They also work during holiday periods. They manage classes of 30, with different abilities and needs. Some children also have complex behaviour issues that they're expected to control, at times without help. (Budget constraints) Teachers often run after school clubs, unpaid. One teacher told me that in the USA and other countries he worked, teachers are appeciated and thanked for their work while in the UK parents are more likely to complain. From my experience, those more likely to complain have problems managing their own children let alone a class of 30!

But who has said teachers have an easy time?!

OP posts:
JMR185 · 21/07/2022 21:08

I think it's naive to think teachers have such an easy time of it. I helped at a primary school on a voluntary basis and they work long days, far longer than when their pupils attend and over the weekends too. They also work during holiday periods. They manage classes of 30, with different abilities and needs. Some children also have complex behaviour issues that they're expected to control, at times without help. (Budget constraints) Teachers often run after school clubs, unpaid. One teacher told me that in the USA and other countries he worked, teachers are appeciated and thanked for their work while in the UK parents are more likely to complain. From my experience, those more likely to complain have problems managing their own children let alone a class of 30!

afuckinggoat · 21/07/2022 21:08

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 21:07

@afuckinggoat see my last post also.
I'm not scavagiving for free childcare. I'm a single parent and I pay for my son on my own.
I don't feel the current 6 weeks holidays suits my lifestyle and I don't think it suits the lifestyle of most people I know. So I go back to my point of what is the benifit to my son For 6 weeks? I don't see why it has to be 6 weeks. If there's a reason then fine, tell me, but nobody has.

I would be more then happy for my son to spend some extra time being creative or socialising or learning, but there are no options around me other then sports.
So again.... where is the options for a boy like him? He's signed up to a sports scheme which he will no doubt hate... but hey if nothing changes that's just the way it is!

Mate, you're not listening so I'm going to stop engaging.

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 21/07/2022 21:07

Just to say op, I teachinically have the qualifications to set up a non sport summer provision.
However, even if I magically got enough money from the government to set it up so I could employ qualified safe people for a fair wage in a suitable.enviroment. well the thought of having to deal with attitudes like yours puts me right off.
Maybe if people appreciated people who look after their children more there wouldn't be a dearth of wiling childcare providers.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 21:07

@afuckinggoat see my last post also.
I'm not scavagiving for free childcare. I'm a single parent and I pay for my son on my own.
I don't feel the current 6 weeks holidays suits my lifestyle and I don't think it suits the lifestyle of most people I know. So I go back to my point of what is the benifit to my son For 6 weeks? I don't see why it has to be 6 weeks. If there's a reason then fine, tell me, but nobody has.

I would be more then happy for my son to spend some extra time being creative or socialising or learning, but there are no options around me other then sports.
So again.... where is the options for a boy like him? He's signed up to a sports scheme which he will no doubt hate... but hey if nothing changes that's just the way it is!

OP posts:
celticprincess · 21/07/2022 21:04

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 08:20

I think I'm not necessarily thinking that schools should completely ditch the summer break. Like I've said a few times I'm looking forward to spending extra time with them. I'll make it as special as I can. I loved the holidays when I was younger too, although I do remember feeling at about week 5 it was abit long. I missed my friends that I hadn't met up with.

But there should be something. My point really is, how can schools so strictly enforce attendance and breakfast and after school clubs etc for all the different reasons they explain and then just nothing!

I just think it's leaving a lot of vulnerable children, and families who are having to struggle affording childcare or saying no to extra work etc etc in an even more vulnerable position.

6 weeks is such a long time for families to struggle and I think really schools should have a more modern approach tk this. If they don't I just don't think their values of looking after children and families Are that valid.

Just my opinion. I know all won't agree. But you'll see a theme of those disagreeing is the parents that can stay at home or the majority (not all) of teachers.

But what you are saying doesn’t make sense. The schools don’t make the rules. The government makes the rules about the attendance expectations and then make the schools enforce this otherwise ofsted then potentially fail the school based on attendance. The schools values have nothing to do with the government rules. Schools provide the breakfast and after school clubs partly by choice as they want to support their families with reasonably priced familiar childcare.

On another note, as a childless teacher in my younger days I loved the 6 weeks break and the flexibility it gave me to have a holiday (at a higher price than those who can go on holiday during term time). I also found it a bit lonely as most of my teacher friends had families so I didn’t see them during the 6 weeks. Most of my non teacher friends would be working. So I’d have quite a lot of time on my hands. Since having children I find the 6 weeks flies by but is also the most exhausting part of my year!! As the teacher parent the childcare for the summer does fall on me. Their dad may have them for a few days here or there depending on his work. One of my children is autistic and struggles with the lack of routines so likes activities to be planned and carried out and can’t cope with many days of just doing nothing at home. They’re not at the age where they would go out to play with friends and disappear for hours. Autistic child doesn’t like ‘playing out’ and the other child would need taking to and from her friends’ houses. We don’t have kids living on our street to play onto with.

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 21:03

@Wednesdayafternoon

I agree that childcare in the holidays needs to be better. I think there should be clubs for vulnerable children and parents who need it. There may be school staff who would appreciate extra money to run them.

CountessVimes · 21/07/2022 21:03

coolernow · 20/07/2022 21:46

I think they should have more camps like in the US

They have camps in the US because the children are off school for 12 weeks from mid May to mid August!

afuckinggoat · 21/07/2022 21:03

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 20:55

@afuckinggoat In my opinion think they are outdated because in previous generations there would typically be a stay at home parent who would be able to spend the holidays with them. To enable the children to be able to do all the things that you and many others have rightly pointed out that children need - a break, fun with family etc etc. For a lot, date I even suggest the majority, this is absolutely not the case and I think to support parents the school year should be adapted OR the goivermenr or whoever makes these decisions should come up with a way or a scheme to support both children and parents who still need that routine.
I don't agree that it's sustainable or healthy to have children passed between family members or random play schemes or families going into poverty to support this. I think that if schools or goouverments can advertise before and after school clubs then there should be some support during the holidays img they stay this way.
Why 6 weeks? Where has the concept of SIX weeks actually come from and what's the science behind it? It seems like a really random number. Why not 4 weeks? Still a long break and less pressure on families and children. But if someone can sit here and tell me the exact reason and science and NEED for 6 whole weeks, nearly 2 months of no school or routine for children then I am MORE then happy to listen and try to understand it.
I am not a teacher. I don't work in education. I am not a member of gouvernment. I don't have the solution to the problem I see. But I really strongly believe that 6 weeks off in the summer is something. We have done for generations and I just don't understand why. I think there's alot of people who are very lucky to be able to enjoy it, there's a hell of alot more people o clueing children who don't.
I have no problem with teachers. I don't want them to work for free and I have never once implied or said so. I've just spent half an hour writing a card for my sons teacher for her last day tomorrow to say how great full I am for her. This is not a teacher blasting argument. It's more a post about questioning the norm.
Families and lives are different now then what they were 50 years ago.

So it isn't more learning you want? It's more free childcare. Schools are for education. Can you agree that, in accordance with many global pedagogical studies, that our children will not benefit from more educational time than they already receive, and that it is more free childcare that you want?

You're not alone. And you're right. This model was more easy to manage in the past when there were more households with a parent who did not work. Today, far more parents are raising children alone, the 'village' cannot help us, both parents in the household must work to achieve the same levels of economic comfort experienced by previous generations. You are right. It is so much harder today. I'm with you there.

But the answer isn't more school. School is for education and we don't need more education. Other things can change before we rob children of desperately needed time off.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 21:03

Also just to add to my last lengthy post 🙈 the only summer schemes I've seen advertised in my area are sport ones. I have not seen one arts and crafts or reading or gaming or anything like that scheme local to me at all.
My son is going to a play scheme for 3 days mid the holidays just to give my mum a break and to give him the chance to have some independent socialising... but he hates sports. I'm expecting him to not enjoy it at all.
Imagine if I had to put him in this for all of my shifts all summer? He would be SO miserable.
So if nothing changes and everything stays the same but I fall into the category of having no childcare and have to use the play schemes there's nothing available for my son locally.

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 21/07/2022 21:03

OP - once again... how do you explain that the schools which seem to have the best educational outcomes and happiest children (e.g. in Scandinavia) have longer holidays?

You're asking what 'science' a 6 week holiday is based on? Well, where is your science that proves that children should have less holiday?

Bunnycat101 · 21/07/2022 21:02

I’d be in favour of a slight redistribution to have an extra week in the May half term but I also think this last week has really been dragging and the kids could have done with finishing last week which would mean extending. A long break gives people a better chance of getting annual leave over the summer. Dropping it to 4 weeks would create a mad scramble.

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 21/07/2022 21:02

It's rich because you are not actually responding to points. Just banging out your opinion.

But at least we've finally got you to admit the actual government have a role to sorting it. Not schools. So maybe some of it is going in.

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 21:01

simonthedog · 21/07/2022 20:59

I totally agree there needs to be more childcare in the holidays for the full working day. Most holiday clubs are 10am-3pm ish. This is totally impractical for many. I am a dentist and get about 6 weeks a year off, can't cover all the school holidays. Dh is also in healthcare, we have no nearby family. What really winds me up is the fuss that many teacher patients make about having their dental appointments in the school holidays. Whilst I do acknowledge that this may be necessary there is absolutely no thought from them about when I get to see/ look after my children.

So you expect teachers to consider when you see your children when you say they are 'fussing' by wanting appointments that suit them?

Consideration works both ways.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 21:00

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 20:37

Op, the main thing I'm extracting from your posts is that you seem jealous of school staff having long holidays and because you don't have them you feel school staff shouldn't either.

I think you need to re read my posts then!
Although now you've mentioned it I would love to have the summer holidays off with my son. I really wish I could have that time but I don't and it wasn't the incentive behind my post whatsoever!

OP posts:
simonthedog · 21/07/2022 20:59

I totally agree there needs to be more childcare in the holidays for the full working day. Most holiday clubs are 10am-3pm ish. This is totally impractical for many. I am a dentist and get about 6 weeks a year off, can't cover all the school holidays. Dh is also in healthcare, we have no nearby family. What really winds me up is the fuss that many teacher patients make about having their dental appointments in the school holidays. Whilst I do acknowledge that this may be necessary there is absolutely no thought from them about when I get to see/ look after my children.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 20:58

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 21/07/2022 20:51

I think it's a bit rich to accuse posters of not engaging with your points when you haven't actually engaged with any of the well laid out reasons why your solution is flawed.

Sadly, if you had made this thread less of a teacher bash exercise and engaged properly, you would have found that many people's views align with some of yours for good reasons.
For example, I do think childcare needs to be better provisioned. However, as I know about child development I realise the ideal combination is good quality parental time and qualified enriching childcare. Neither of these are solutions schools can offer and are something that could be achieved through sure start style provision and reviewing the British attitude to working hours and taking a more healthy approach to flexibility and work life balance. None of which is the school remit but would require government intervention and plenty of money.

I have said a few times I don't have the answer to the problem. So how am I being rich? I didn't say it should be my way, I've literally said I don't know! So how exactly am I being rich?

OP posts:
BustopherPonsonbyJones · 21/07/2022 20:57

alnawire · 21/07/2022 10:14

So many children don't need the break from school, they need it from their parents. The forgotten children. Left in shitty families because there is no one to help them. Just in my street we have a family who do nothing but shout at their kids. Their idea of parenting is to ignore then shout when something goes wrong. These kids are desperately in need of intervention. The summer holidays gives them 6 weeks of hell with absolutely no let up. It's horrific. The teenagers in the family are, predictably, going off the rails. The youngers are not far behind. These children need the safety and relief that school (or something else for holidays) offers. They need the proper meal provided. They need the contact with ordinary humans. They need not to be left at home being miserable for weeks at a time.

This thread has highlighted that people don't see far past their own situation. For some children being in school, or a group/club during the summer holidays would be massively beneficial.

And before anyone naively suggests 'reporting them to SS' - they have social work involvement. It's a meeting everyone now and then to ensure the children are not being physically harmed and have a place to sleep and meals provided. The emotional damage isn't on SS radar.

These children NEED less holidays.

So what you actually want isn’t shorter holidays, you want social services to do their job properly and actually look after children at risk. Schools are for TEACHING. Social workers should protect vulnerable children. Good grief - is there anything teachers aren’t responsible for in this country?

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 20:55

@afuckinggoat In my opinion think they are outdated because in previous generations there would typically be a stay at home parent who would be able to spend the holidays with them. To enable the children to be able to do all the things that you and many others have rightly pointed out that children need - a break, fun with family etc etc. For a lot, date I even suggest the majority, this is absolutely not the case and I think to support parents the school year should be adapted OR the goivermenr or whoever makes these decisions should come up with a way or a scheme to support both children and parents who still need that routine.
I don't agree that it's sustainable or healthy to have children passed between family members or random play schemes or families going into poverty to support this. I think that if schools or goouverments can advertise before and after school clubs then there should be some support during the holidays img they stay this way.
Why 6 weeks? Where has the concept of SIX weeks actually come from and what's the science behind it? It seems like a really random number. Why not 4 weeks? Still a long break and less pressure on families and children. But if someone can sit here and tell me the exact reason and science and NEED for 6 whole weeks, nearly 2 months of no school or routine for children then I am MORE then happy to listen and try to understand it.
I am not a teacher. I don't work in education. I am not a member of gouvernment. I don't have the solution to the problem I see. But I really strongly believe that 6 weeks off in the summer is something. We have done for generations and I just don't understand why. I think there's alot of people who are very lucky to be able to enjoy it, there's a hell of alot more people o clueing children who don't.
I have no problem with teachers. I don't want them to work for free and I have never once implied or said so. I've just spent half an hour writing a card for my sons teacher for her last day tomorrow to say how great full I am for her. This is not a teacher blasting argument. It's more a post about questioning the norm.
Families and lives are different now then what they were 50 years ago.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread