Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Summer holidays - outdated

634 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:05

So I was just scrolling through Facebook and I saw some pictures after school club/breakfast club to my sons school put up and it just got me thinking how crazy it is that schools just completely shut down for like 6-7 weeks.
They have all these facilities during term time to support working families because there is obviously a need to for it, but in the holidays... ahh f*ck it!
Obviously o know there's summer schemes but at a massive expense and also different hours and locations.
My sons school isn't offering one so he's attending some random school for 3 days over the summer mainly just so he's socialising!
I'm extremely lucky as my mum is a great help to me during the holidays. And obviously I'm very much looking forward to spending more time with my boys and no school run... hurry!!!
But I just find it crazy that schools close for such a significant period of time.
Obviously I know school isn't childcare but it school itself enables parents to work so it kind of is 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 22/07/2022 07:41

Sorry, can I just clarify op. Are you comparing 'overtime' by equating the 1 hour overtime you mentioned and missing lunchbreaks with working a 70 hour week when you are paid for half that?
Or are you comparing with other professions that do a 70 hour week like lawyers, whose salary reflects that overtime and is hugely more inflated than a teachers.

The only profession I can think of as coming close to the amount of unpaid overtime to teaching are nursing (who get bashed nearly as much as teachers and have a similarly piss poor wage and public attitude to what they should do) and some.swlf employed people who choose their own hours.

People have rightly identified this as a teacher bashing thread because you keep returning to how it should be schools who sort the problem and teachers who emphathise with you, rather than conceding it's an organisational government issue.

No amount of best teacher mugs or whatever else you bit the person currently dedicated to your child is going to change the fact that you are entitled and treat teachers like slaves.

Maireas · 22/07/2022 07:33

user1487194234 · 20/07/2022 21:54

Of course you are correct OP ,but no way will teachers ever agree

You don't know that.
I personally think a long summer break is a bad idea. Shorter breaks through the year would be better.

ClaudiasWinkleMan · 22/07/2022 07:31

Sweatingmytiitsoff · 22/07/2022 07:28

@ClaudiasWinkleMan your absolutely right that schools are not childcare however your in your own bubble because you don't have to source childcare for school hols. I changed jobs from a night to day job and my God I had a very rude awakening to going to having to pay for just 2 days childcare sometimes to 4 days every holidays.

I do agree though it's a parents responsibility but it is easier said than done!

Not in a bubble at all. I have to pay for childcare. I’m not a teacher. Have worked in education before but am a regular working parent if 2 children with SEN. So often much harder to find childcare. I just don’t think it’s anyone else’s problem but mine.

Sweatingmytiitsoff · 22/07/2022 07:28

@ClaudiasWinkleMan your absolutely right that schools are not childcare however your in your own bubble because you don't have to source childcare for school hols. I changed jobs from a night to day job and my God I had a very rude awakening to going to having to pay for just 2 days childcare sometimes to 4 days every holidays.

I do agree though it's a parents responsibility but it is easier said than done!

ClaudiasWinkleMan · 22/07/2022 07:19

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 22:00

I do get thsi side of it...
but the comment about them spending time with their kids annoys me abit.
I work and know other parents who work full time and don't get X amount of weeks off and all bank holidays to spend with their kids. Likely chance if they move jobs then they wouldn't get more then 4 weeks a year off work to spend time with their children and the. Also have to work bank holidays etc!

But do you work most evenings and weekend, unpaid, marking and planning? The difference with teaching is the vast majority have to take work home. Most teachers do at least 3 hours extra work a day, start at 7 leave at 7 and still have marking or resources to make. The children of teachers that I know always say they barely see their parents at term time, there parents never get to go to assemblies and sports days as are busy teaching other peoples kids.
they don’t get paid for the extra hours of working at home. They don’t get paid for the parents evening, attending fundraiser events, residential trips, or answering emails at 11.30 at night, the list of unpaid work is endless. They also are paid on a pro rata bases so not paid for the holidays.
We have a huge teacher recruitment and retention issue in this country. Massive problem actually and numbers of empty places in teacher training is growing. It’s shit like this thread where parents view school as free childcare and don’t place value on education and whinge about the holidays teachers get that help make many in education go fuck this I’m getting a nice office job instead.
Your childcare needs are yours to sort. Why should the government pay hundreds of thousands more to keep schools open all year? Having children is a choice. When would schools carry out maintenance work? When would vital training take place? Sorting classes out takes weeks. Last year my childrens primary had to have their whole heating system replaced, took all summer and carried over to half term. This summer it’s vital work being done to the hall and kitchens. Can’t be done when children are there.
Schools are not childcare and the sooner a lot of parents realise this the better.

Sweatingmytiitsoff · 22/07/2022 07:14

Sweatingmytiitsoff · 22/07/2022 06:31

I hope the poster who commented about other places having much longer school holidays ... I had a feeling the prices would be hugely different to UK, £80 a month. I pay £200 a month. My friend has an aunt in Italy again longer hols but cheaper childcare in the school hols.

£200 a WEEK! Sorry got mixed up.

lawandgin · 22/07/2022 07:05

@Itisasecret no thanks, I actually quite like my job, despite the impact it will have on me spending time with my LG (which obviously I weighed up before deciding to have children).

I personally don't think it's teacher bashing to point out that teachers do get longer holidays, while also recognising they do a lot of unpaid hours, just like I do - and anyone else who earns a salary. I also don't think it's teacher bashing to discuss the fact that a lot of children struggle with 6 weeks holiday whether that be due to anxiety regarding returning (like I suffered) or because of problems at home. This doesn't necessarily mean children should spend more time in school. Clearly this is a government/childcare problem.

I have 5 teachers in my family so I see firsthand how hard they work and how much they care about their jobs and the children. But I also see that they get to enjoy long summers with their own children, while a lot of other parents really struggle - financially and emotionally. That's not to belittle any aspect of their role, in all honesty, it's a little bit of jealousy that I too work hard, worry about my clients, work long hours including evenings and weekends and I am going to miss out on so much while paying through the nose for my LG to be sent off to various holiday clubs for several years. I don't have a problem admitting that. Would I swap? Possibly, if I could turn the clock back. Would I swap now? Not a chance, mainly because I couldn't afford to retrain as I'm already paying off £30k of educational debt and couldn't afford to not be earning. It's overly simplistic to say "well go and become a teacher" and you know it.

These threads always go the same way, but for some reason teachers cannot fathom that the rest of the population don't hate and disrespect them. Holidays are a touchy subject, a bit like solicitors salaries!

Dinoteeth · 22/07/2022 06:46

£80 per month for child care is so cheap. Thats £20 a week, £4 per day.

I'm £30 per day. With a not for profit committee run organisation. OK the hours at 8.30-5.30.

So that must be getting subsidised from somewhere. So effectively paid via taxation as we all know nothing is free.

Your probably right that the UK holidays being so short make it difficult to recruit and set summer schemes up.

Sweatingmytiitsoff · 22/07/2022 06:31

badg3r · 22/07/2022 00:15

I live in a Scandinavian country. We have almost ten weeks of summer holiday but school are open for most of that time for childcare. It costs about £80 a month. They do things like going to the park, the zoo, yoga classes, sports days etc. All food is included. Most people take at least a month of holiday in the summer so it is only around a third of the class there at one time, and you are only allowed to use the service if you have to work. It isn't the teachers who take care of the kids but the after school teachers, they all work a few weeks in the summer and everyone gets a good holiday. The problem in the UK is government policy, there are plenty of ways to address allowing everyone to have a break with family over summer whilst providing a nice and affordable childcare option for kids.

I hope the poster who commented about other places having much longer school holidays ... I had a feeling the prices would be hugely different to UK, £80 a month. I pay £200 a month. My friend has an aunt in Italy again longer hols but cheaper childcare in the school hols.

Isaidno22 · 22/07/2022 01:07

There is a recruitment crisis in teaching and what you’re actually complaining about is childcare. Smack bang in front of you is an obvious solution. Get yourself signed up to a teacher training course and enjoy your unpaid summer holidays with your own kids! You get paid to train now. Go for it! It’s so rewarding.

Ponderingwindow · 22/07/2022 00:45

Part of the problem may indeed be that 6 weeks is too short. Children in countries with longer breaks have many more enrichment opportunities available. The programs are easier to run because they operate for a decent portion of time. Staffing often comes from university and late year students, particularly those studying teaching and childhood development who are also on their summer holiday time. The program directors are generally qualified teachers interested in earning additional income during the break. Many localities use the empty schools to run subsidized programs so there are affordable options.

Macaroni1924 · 22/07/2022 00:33

Think I know the answer to this given the tone of the teachers responses on here!

Comments like this from OP are exactly why this is a teacher bashing thread.

badg3r · 22/07/2022 00:15

I live in a Scandinavian country. We have almost ten weeks of summer holiday but school are open for most of that time for childcare. It costs about £80 a month. They do things like going to the park, the zoo, yoga classes, sports days etc. All food is included. Most people take at least a month of holiday in the summer so it is only around a third of the class there at one time, and you are only allowed to use the service if you have to work. It isn't the teachers who take care of the kids but the after school teachers, they all work a few weeks in the summer and everyone gets a good holiday. The problem in the UK is government policy, there are plenty of ways to address allowing everyone to have a break with family over summer whilst providing a nice and affordable childcare option for kids.

Mamanyt · 21/07/2022 23:59

Many schools here in the US are going year-round now. They go 6-9 weeks, get a 2-4 week break, and a 6-week break in the summer. Most of the parents, and the kids, seem to really like it. Easier to schedule a family trip when everyone doesn't want off at the same time. and the kids aren't off for so long a time that they lose good study habits.

watingroom2 · 21/07/2022 23:45

Holidays are for deep cleaning and repairs.

If you have low funds it takes the few staff a while to complete the job.

Metrette · 21/07/2022 23:37

Dinoteeth · 21/07/2022 22:48

Children haven't missed two years. They had two terms when they learned at home.
Which was torture.
They need to have a normal summer, seeing friends, having fun. So many Children have suffered horrendously from social distancing, worries about a virus, worries about killing granny, missed that time developing socially and emotionally.

I agree with this so much! They have so much fun to catch up on.

Metrette · 21/07/2022 23:33

They’re children. They need this break and most other countries have at least two months off. French and Italy for example were off at the start of July and that means this heat wasn’t an issue there.

Your tune would be better spent campaigning for better holiday childcare places and funding for holiday and after school clubs all year round.

that would benefit you and your children rather then just you.

GymGecko · 21/07/2022 23:27

I'd quite like a model where you teach 5 weeks then have a week off (or two depending on the occasion) since it's the long 8 week half terms where children tend to struggle, they get tired etc. It also gives staff some time to catch up and update planning more frequently which can only benefit the pupils and quality of teaching.

I'd also hope that there may be the added benefit of fewer 'peak' prices for holidays meaning I could actually have an affordable break away, as could families with school age children.

echt · 21/07/2022 23:20

Long, not ling.

echt · 21/07/2022 23:19

In Australia the general model is 5 1/2 weeks summer break and 3 fortnight breaks in the rest of year. This means terms are 9/10 weeks long, but it's doable.
The fortnight breaks are fab. You get time to decompress and have a good amount of time to holiday and/or be at home.

I should add that term-time holidays for students and families are entirely normal and unpunished. Teachers can take term-time holidays out of accrued ling service leave, and they do. They have to be applied for and approved in good time, but I never hear of anyone being knocked back

Happiness all round.

riceuten · 21/07/2022 23:04

I do remember a post here from a mum who said that 13 weeks holidays a year was "outrageous" and that "4 weeks was probably more appropriate" - mainly because of the issues arranging childcare. "Good luck getting teachers to work 9 more weeks", I thought.

I don't think there's necessarily anything bad with looking at the allocation of holidays during the year, but reducing it overall? No.

MsJuniper · 21/07/2022 22:59

I changed career to be a teacher a few years ago so I do understand what it's like to have a more usual work pattern as a parent. Industries vary but I knew very few people who couldn't vary their hours enough to be there for a special assembly or exam. When it came to school holidays, however, DH and I split our AL so we could cover them and never took time off together. There was lots of ferrying and timetables.

When I trained as a teacher, I explained to the DC that I would be there for the holidays, but that I wouldn't be able to do the events and special days. During term time, they know I need to work most evenings and at least half a day every weekend. It's the first day of the summer holidays today and I've spent half a day in school sorting out my classroom. I'll go in at least one more day. That really is the baseline just to provide the level of teaching needed.

So 190 days of teaching, plus 5 days of Inset, plus around 5 days during school holiday time. I know lots of jobs require working outside of normal hours, but if I only count the Saturdays, that adds up to another 20 days or 4 weeks. So it works out around 8 weeks' holiday. I absolutely, truly, honestly appreciate and value that holiday and understand that it is a perk of being a teacher.

Here's the other thing: I see your children exhausted by this point in the year. Yes, there is some slippage during the summer which we account for in our planning. But they also come back refreshed and ready to learn (whatever they've been doing in the holidays).

In terms of when the holidays are taken, I think the summer break needs to start earlier, and this may necessitate reorganising the weeks. My suggestion would be to start at the beginning of July and return in mid-August - but that leaves a long autumn term. The May half term week could perhaps be redeployed to the October half term? There would still be a long weekend in May and the one in August, so those short breaks would ease the change.

It's interesting that as pp have said, many countries with good outcomes start school later and have longer holidays. I think they are also set up better for affordable childcare so perhaps there is less resistance. Additionally, you would expect private schools to have shorter holidays if there were such a danger of knowledge loss, but their holidays are longer too.

howshouldibehave · 21/07/2022 22:55

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 22:53

Would you like your holidays taken away to suit someone else's lifestyle?

I made my choices when I became a teacher. You made your career choices.

You can't now complain that they don't suit you and want others to bend over backwards to accommodate, making their own lives harder.

That is pretty much the crux of it!

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 22:53

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 22:43

Honestly guys I can't tell you how boring I'm finding this "conversation".
I have spent so much time repeating myself through my responses to the same repeated questions of people coming on here demanding a solution from me when I'm made it extremelyyy clear I don't have a solution or demanding I explain why I don't think the current situation works when I've explained it sooooo many times or teachers accusing me of "bashing" them when I literally haven't said anything negative about teachers.

This is just my opinion which is based on mine and my family and friends and mums in the play grounds experiences. You don't have to agree with me and that's fine but it's so tiring to keep reading the same responses from people who don't care to read the post. It's ok to not agree. I very much doubt if I came up with an amazing idea anything would change anyway.

So I'm out because I literally don't have the energy anymore! It's just so boring.

If I've learnt anything it's to absolutely not make a post about teaching or schools because wow... it's clearly a touchy subject!

Would you like your holidays taken away to suit someone else's lifestyle?

I made my choices when I became a teacher. You made your career choices.

You can't now complain that they don't suit you and want others to bend over backwards to accommodate, making their own lives harder.

converseandjeans · 21/07/2022 22:50

OP have you considered a career change? Teaching might tick all the boxes for you 😉