Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Summer holidays - outdated

634 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:05

So I was just scrolling through Facebook and I saw some pictures after school club/breakfast club to my sons school put up and it just got me thinking how crazy it is that schools just completely shut down for like 6-7 weeks.
They have all these facilities during term time to support working families because there is obviously a need to for it, but in the holidays... ahh f*ck it!
Obviously o know there's summer schemes but at a massive expense and also different hours and locations.
My sons school isn't offering one so he's attending some random school for 3 days over the summer mainly just so he's socialising!
I'm extremely lucky as my mum is a great help to me during the holidays. And obviously I'm very much looking forward to spending more time with my boys and no school run... hurry!!!
But I just find it crazy that schools close for such a significant period of time.
Obviously I know school isn't childcare but it school itself enables parents to work so it kind of is 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 22/07/2022 08:39

It's called budget for the summer break. Spreading holidays into colder months just means kids in the house rather than out.
Easier to get cheap days out in summer than in the winter.

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:38

riesenrad · 22/07/2022 08:36

I do not know why you're claiming that teachers would disagree, because I'm a teacher and have literally made the same suggestion just upthread

OK I should have said "some" but most teachers I know like the six weeks and would be horrified at having it reduced!

Suggestion also doesn't work for Scotland as they don't have the same holidays as England and Wales and it may be that the structure in Scotland works better (it definitely makes more sense to break up at the end of June as the weather is better than in late August).

No, we were all agreeing at work yesterday that we'd like the summer holidays shorter, and build in extra time elsewhere. No-one "horrified" by the suggestion, and many sympathetic with working parents with childcare problems.
Anyway. I can't see it happening because this government won't invest in such provision or flexibility.

riesenrad · 22/07/2022 08:36

I do not know why you're claiming that teachers would disagree, because I'm a teacher and have literally made the same suggestion just upthread

OK I should have said "some" but most teachers I know like the six weeks and would be horrified at having it reduced!

Suggestion also doesn't work for Scotland as they don't have the same holidays as England and Wales and it may be that the structure in Scotland works better (it definitely makes more sense to break up at the end of June as the weather is better than in late August).

waitingpatientlyforspring · 22/07/2022 08:34

So no 2 weeks in May because 1 year group out of 10/11 year groups will study through one holidays for one year of their life?! Very week argument.

The summer break is not the only time to go on holiday. May/June the weather is often better than July and august. Having a two week break then gives more flexibly for parents to go on holiday then than they have at the moment.

All school holidays periods are an extortionate price. Reducing the summer break by two weeks will not make those holidays cheaper.

October, yes the weather isn't great then, but again, for those who like to go abroad, there are still short hall countries where the weather is still warm enough.

For those who can't afford holidays, also struggle to afford childcare for such a long period. I know when mine were young we found it really hard - and we were incredibly lucky to have support from family and some friends to help spread the care. 4 weeks would have been so much easier to cope with, while not feeling we were putting on family.

riesenrad · 22/07/2022 08:33

I also think it's silly that school facilities shut down. Some are used for holiday clubs but some just sit there empty for six weeks (I know sometimes they have work done while they have the time). State school facilities are a taxpayer-funded resource and should be open to the public out of term-time. It would allow schools to make money on rentals, too.

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:33

riesenrad · 22/07/2022 08:31

Teachers and school staff probably disagree but I think the summer holidays are too long. I think it would be better to have a two week May half term, a month in the summer and two weeks in October half term (bring it forward a bit so it's while the weather is still nice and the clocks haven't gone back).

People always say you can't have a two week May half term because of exams, but some areas of England (and maybe Wales) already do.

I do not know why you're claiming that teachers would disagree, because I'm a teacher and have literally made the same suggestion just upthread.

howshouldibehave · 22/07/2022 08:32

badg3r · 22/07/2022 00:15

I live in a Scandinavian country. We have almost ten weeks of summer holiday but school are open for most of that time for childcare. It costs about £80 a month. They do things like going to the park, the zoo, yoga classes, sports days etc. All food is included. Most people take at least a month of holiday in the summer so it is only around a third of the class there at one time, and you are only allowed to use the service if you have to work. It isn't the teachers who take care of the kids but the after school teachers, they all work a few weeks in the summer and everyone gets a good holiday. The problem in the UK is government policy, there are plenty of ways to address allowing everyone to have a break with family over summer whilst providing a nice and affordable childcare option for kids.

Interesting reply, thank you. Lots of questions now-I hood you don’t mind!

I presume the government subsidises that heavily? How do parents prove they are working? If eg they work Monday/Tuesday would they only be entitled to childcare on those days?

Who are the ‘after school’ teachers? Are they actual teachers?

Are there fines for parents taking their children out for holidays at other times? Does this happen much? Is there any sort of teacher retention crisis? When do the buildings get repaired-are many falling down?

riesenrad · 22/07/2022 08:31

Teachers and school staff probably disagree but I think the summer holidays are too long. I think it would be better to have a two week May half term, a month in the summer and two weeks in October half term (bring it forward a bit so it's while the weather is still nice and the clocks haven't gone back).

People always say you can't have a two week May half term because of exams, but some areas of England (and maybe Wales) already do.

Dinoteeth · 22/07/2022 08:30

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:26

So we may as well stick with what we've got

Agreed!

Or lengthen summer, see if it makes any difference to attainment level if other countries do better and have longer holidays.

But the key to it has to be plenty childcare availability, and activity camps for secondary aged kids. It seems nuts at secondary age kids are expected to entertain themselves for weeks with minimal adult supervision. And not get into trouble.

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:26

basilmint · 22/07/2022 08:25

4 weeks would be unworkable for working parents trying to all take leave at the same time. Many workplaces wouldn't allow it so you would get people who couldn't take any time off with their kids. Not to mention the extortionate cost of travel if you try to compress it into 4 weeks.

So we may as well stick with what we've got

basilmint · 22/07/2022 08:25

4 weeks would be unworkable for working parents trying to all take leave at the same time. Many workplaces wouldn't allow it so you would get people who couldn't take any time off with their kids. Not to mention the extortionate cost of travel if you try to compress it into 4 weeks.

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:22

waitingpatientlyforspring · 22/07/2022 08:19

I agree. 6-7 weeks is too long, for kids and parents.

I would prefer we had 4 weeks and then 2 weeks in May and either two weeks in Oct or three at Christmas.

That would be my preference. I say that as a teacher and mum of adult DC!

Dinoteeth · 22/07/2022 08:22

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:00

To break it up for the students. They get very tired, it gets very intense. Rather than 6 weeks in the summer, do 4 then have 2 weeks in October and May. Just a suggestion.

The issue with two weeks in October (which some parts of Scotland do) is it can be cold. Its great for those wanting a cheap florida holiday but not great for those at home.

4 weeks in summer is too short for the majority of people to get time off with kids. And for areas which rely on uk tourism.

May is also right before the secondary school exams. So older kids will end up studying through it.

waitingpatientlyforspring · 22/07/2022 08:19

I agree. 6-7 weeks is too long, for kids and parents.

I would prefer we had 4 weeks and then 2 weeks in May and either two weeks in Oct or three at Christmas.

basilmint · 22/07/2022 08:17

I hope the poster who commented about other places having much longer school holidays ... I had a feeling the prices would be hugely different to UK, £80 a month. I pay £200 a month. My friend has an aunt in Italy again longer hols but cheaper childcare in the school hols.

Well then the answer is cheaper childcare,not shorter holidays for kids.

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 22/07/2022 08:15

And I think I should point out that those in education are overwhelmingly female with parenting responsibilities.

Olderkids · 22/07/2022 08:14

Here we go again!
Teachers do not just work on school days - it goes on all through ‘holidays’ too.
Why don’t you all train to be teachers - there seem to be plenty of vacancies out there.

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 22/07/2022 08:13

civil servants have more flexibility in this regard?
Cival.servents may, teachers and school staff don't.
Unless medical emergency, you are not allowed to make medical appointments in term time.
You can't take.holiday in term time and have to commit to your core hours, no exceptions.
Part time is possible, but the reality is the hours of a part time.teaching job roughly equate to a regular job. The only freedom you gain is on your official days off and most schools expect you to be contactable.to.your partner teacher on your days off.
Then there's the fact part timers are not popular with parents so schools.actively try and avoid it where they can and parents often make life so difficult it's easier to leave or revert back to full time hours.

BustopherPonsonbyJones · 22/07/2022 08:12

lawandgin · 22/07/2022 07:05

@Itisasecret no thanks, I actually quite like my job, despite the impact it will have on me spending time with my LG (which obviously I weighed up before deciding to have children).

I personally don't think it's teacher bashing to point out that teachers do get longer holidays, while also recognising they do a lot of unpaid hours, just like I do - and anyone else who earns a salary. I also don't think it's teacher bashing to discuss the fact that a lot of children struggle with 6 weeks holiday whether that be due to anxiety regarding returning (like I suffered) or because of problems at home. This doesn't necessarily mean children should spend more time in school. Clearly this is a government/childcare problem.

I have 5 teachers in my family so I see firsthand how hard they work and how much they care about their jobs and the children. But I also see that they get to enjoy long summers with their own children, while a lot of other parents really struggle - financially and emotionally. That's not to belittle any aspect of their role, in all honesty, it's a little bit of jealousy that I too work hard, worry about my clients, work long hours including evenings and weekends and I am going to miss out on so much while paying through the nose for my LG to be sent off to various holiday clubs for several years. I don't have a problem admitting that. Would I swap? Possibly, if I could turn the clock back. Would I swap now? Not a chance, mainly because I couldn't afford to retrain as I'm already paying off £30k of educational debt and couldn't afford to not be earning. It's overly simplistic to say "well go and become a teacher" and you know it.

These threads always go the same way, but for some reason teachers cannot fathom that the rest of the population don't hate and disrespect them. Holidays are a touchy subject, a bit like solicitors salaries!

Teachers don’t have an issue with the long holidays, just with the jealousy and vitriol it causes in other people.

To be fair, I’m bloody jealous of those who get to WFH. That’s a nice little number, isn’t it 🙂? Swings and roundabouts…swings and roundabouts.

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:06

I think it falls to women to compromise their work because of school holidays, and it's not easy without flexible employers. Someone may correct me, but don't civil servants have more flexibility in this regard?
Children need breaks and they need family time. As a society we need to think how this can happen to support the majority of families.

BustopherPonsonbyJones · 22/07/2022 08:03

We have a cost of living crisis. If schools did open up for holiday clubs or activities 8:30 -5:00, teachers will not cover them unless they are paid for doing so (and many still wouldn’t) and any specially appointed staff would need paying a decent rate, Lighting and building maintenance will cost money. Equipment (toys, pens, paper) will cost money: many schools have used up all their supplies weeks ago. As previous posters explained, the long holiday is a time for maintenance work to be done which can’t be done when children are around anyway. Our summer holidays are some of the shortest in the world and children do need a break and benefit from time to rest, play and enjoy activities - paid or simply reading and drawing.

The government won’t give money to fund additional childcare as the coffers seem to be empty - furlough, Covid, Brexit or the situation in Ukraine can be blamed. Most taxpayers can’t afford tax rises and many would be reluctant to fund something that for most isn’t an essential, especially if they had to suck it up themselves - which is how human nature works. Therefore, you are perfectly reasonable asking for better provision but you have to expect to pay for your childcare yourself. The American model of ‘camps’ offered at different prices seems fair. If a child is very shy and they can’t take crowds of new people, you need to develop a support network so that maybe five families share holiday childcare, especially if you WFH and have KS2 children who need minimal supervision.

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 22/07/2022 08:01

Also are people forgetting we live in bloody England.
Enrichment in summer: visit to beaches, parks, woods. All free minus travel.

Enrichment in summer: indoor activities like softplay, swimming pools, craft clubs. Cost money.

Small breaks would mean bored children indoors on their holidays and sweltering in hot classrooms in August.

Long summer breaks mean children outdoors, families can enjoy the weather and coordinate holidays.

Surely you don't need to be a child expert to understand nice weather means there's is more to do with kids?
Or is common sense for parents something teachers have to do now too?

Maireas · 22/07/2022 08:00

Dinoteeth · 22/07/2022 07:56

Why would you want short breaks during the rest of the year?

To break it up for the students. They get very tired, it gets very intense. Rather than 6 weeks in the summer, do 4 then have 2 weeks in October and May. Just a suggestion.

Dinoteeth · 22/07/2022 07:56

Maireas · 22/07/2022 07:33

You don't know that.
I personally think a long summer break is a bad idea. Shorter breaks through the year would be better.

Why would you want short breaks during the rest of the year?

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 22/07/2022 07:42

But thanks for being a walking reminder why so many teachers are leaving the profession. Great love demonstration.