Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Summer holidays - outdated

634 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:05

So I was just scrolling through Facebook and I saw some pictures after school club/breakfast club to my sons school put up and it just got me thinking how crazy it is that schools just completely shut down for like 6-7 weeks.
They have all these facilities during term time to support working families because there is obviously a need to for it, but in the holidays... ahh f*ck it!
Obviously o know there's summer schemes but at a massive expense and also different hours and locations.
My sons school isn't offering one so he's attending some random school for 3 days over the summer mainly just so he's socialising!
I'm extremely lucky as my mum is a great help to me during the holidays. And obviously I'm very much looking forward to spending more time with my boys and no school run... hurry!!!
But I just find it crazy that schools close for such a significant period of time.
Obviously I know school isn't childcare but it school itself enables parents to work so it kind of is 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 08:00

This has moved on since I was last here. But I just wanted to make the point again that reducing maintained school/ academy school holidays is the unfair way to do this.

Private schools are not going to change their holidays. So all you’ll do is widen the gap between wealthy children who get to have long carefree holidays full of fun and state school kids who get four weeks in which to cram everything in (including I suspect holidays so pricey that no one can afford them).

The actual solution is better entitlements for working parents, tackle the cost of living so that people can survive on one or part time wages and the creation on national play schemes for holidays.

I grew up in the states and loved my long holidays. My parents worked so I spent a lot of time a drama camps/ gymnastics camps/ tennis schemes. I loved them. They are totally different to school and really bring out talents that kids didn’t know they had. But they should be subsidised.

If holidays are shorter then I’ll have to quit teaching and find any way I can (beg, borrow, steal- scholarship) to get my DC into private. I don’t want her to be disadvantaged because the working culture in the U.K. is so backwards.

NewNamePrivacyneeded · 21/07/2022 07:57

Rather than a shorter summer all at the same time, the summer could be staggered so some LA's off from mid July and gradually stagger to avoid all off at the same 4 weeks. Scotland and public schools appear to be able to manage this.

cansu · 21/07/2022 07:57

If school holidays were to change. You would need to
Pay staff more - staff are not paid for six week holidays
Accept that teachers would want to either book time off like other staff do or be paid more to reflect fact that their holidays always will be more expensive than others.
Put air con into schools so that the lessons are productive. Kids cannot work effectively in the heat.

NewNamePrivacyneeded · 21/07/2022 07:56

Teachers are contracted and paid to work 190 days a year - they won't do more. Yes it fits more with the old days when mums would often be at home when children were young so an adult there for them. Most people work a full year with just 4 or 5 weeks holiday so naturally it doesn't fit with the 190 day working year. Perhaps the contract should change to pay another 10 days and the holiday shorter?

I have lots of teachers in my family and they love the big holiday and most go away for the summer. It's a great career option with good benefits, sickness, pension and of course holiday, if you can perhaps look into it.

Youaremysunshine14 · 21/07/2022 07:54

If school summer holidays were four weeks long, how many working parents wouldn’t be able to get any time off at all during that period? Holiday prices would be through the roof, so increasing numbers of children would have no proper holiday at all.

This. A shortened holiday would mean all the parents in a workplace clamouring for the same few weeks off, and some would inevitably have to miss out. The issue isn't the length of hols but the lack of affordable childcare in the UK and so few play schemes. In the States kids can go to camp for a few weeks yet we just don't have anything like that here.

DanglingMod · 21/07/2022 07:46

It really wouldn't be feasible to open school buildings for childcare in the holidays. Our site is out of bounds to all staff on and off over the summer as there is so much maintenance work going on, it would be unsafe even for adults to be in the building, let alone kids running around. We have to book days that we want to go in with the site manager.

It also isn't really feasible to shorten the holiday. Climate change is already making the last few weeks of term utterly unbearable in schools. Children are ill, have nosebleeds, are listless and exhausted and do not learn anything. We are already just babysitting them for the last few weeks of term even though we are told to and try to teach up to the very last lesson. This issue with the weather is only going to get worse.

The govt is definitely not going to pay any more to open schools for longer. They are not even funding the proposed teacher pay increase, meaning it would have to come out of existing budgets, if schools do agree to pay it to staff. What else can be cut in school? Zero budget for books instead of a tiny amount? Heating off at 10am in winter instead of 12 noon (probably necessary anyway this winter because of fuel price hikes. Genuinely, be prepared for there to be no heating in schools this winter. Our school saw an £80,000 hike in fuel costs last Spring, with no help to pay for it)?

What we do need is better and cheaper childcare options in the summer, with longer hours (the 10-3 dance/archery/football/sailing camps only seem to benefit children whose parents are not at work that week, anyway).

Ylvamoon · 21/07/2022 07:45

With the chronic shortage of labour at the moment perhaps this sort of system could be re-introduced, but not just for harvesting, there's seems to be shortages everywhere, e.g. restaurants, airport staff (flight controllers should be restricted to the over 11s) doctors (see flight controllers) police, Prime Minister etc

🤣
I'm just seeing my DS (12) as work & pensions minister, we'd all be playing xbox until the country is bankrupt!
While DD (18) as finace minister would make the most cutting taxes and setting up offshore accounts for her hard earned cash- while living off mum & dad!

howshouldibehave · 21/07/2022 07:41

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 21/07/2022 07:23

I read on here just recently that the long summer holidays originated to allow children to help their parents bring in the harvest.

With the chronic shortage of labour at the moment perhaps this sort of system could be re-introduced, but not just for harvesting, there's seems to be shortages everywhere, e.g. restaurants, airport staff (flight controllers should be restricted to the over 11s) doctors (see flight controllers) police, Prime Minister etc.

Granted, it may require a bit more research before being implemented, I'm just making a casual observation.

My DS would love to have a go at stepping in for the PM-great idea. He doesn’t go to many important meetings, has loads of parties and is now on holiday till September!

imagine the whole country being squeezed into a shorter summer holiday and then fighting over a limited amount of holidays and accommodation to fit everybody -and the prices would increase due to the ridiculous demand people would take their children during term time.

Yep-this is exactly what would happen. Meanwhile private schools (and most other countries’ schools) would continue to have a couple of months off in the summer-enjoying the cheaper prices!

I have heard the argument about school holiday for decades. Some people want it longer, some people want it shorter, some people want more in the spring (for skiing and holidays in certain places), others want more in the Autumn. A minority of people want less because they have an obsession with teachers having such an easy ride and think teacher holidays should be cut down to 6 weeks. There is no one glaring option though that everyone wants so no obvious alternative. I also can’t see any government forcing state schools to reduce their summer holidays whilst keeping private schools the length they are.

There is no political will to increase the schools staff pay for the extra weeks (as already stated, they aren’t even funding the proposed pay rise) and the school buildings are often falling down and need chunks of time when they are not in use so they can safely be maintained.

More available, flexible and affordable childcare and flexible working sound like a sensible and achievable aim-but the childcare shouldn’t be in schools-they need time for site staff to sort maintenance and repair. I certainly don’t want my children having less time off over the summer.

I personally think it’s a crying shame that most of the Sure Start centres were closed, that would have been an ideal place to start for holding summer clubs. It might have been a good source of summer work for students who wanted it as well.

Writingquest · 21/07/2022 07:27

Can’t bare this smug attitude. Comparing to many other “professionals” who’s got all the benefits and perks, including WFH and astronomic salaries, teachers earn NOTHING to cover for the stress they experience every day. I’m not even talking about the support staff, who’s wages are laughable. So please take this attitude somewhere else and do something, if summer holidays bother you so much. You can offer your time as a volunteer for all the potential summer clubs you are describing and contribute your own time… to make a real change, you know. Maybe you can volunteer for the actual school to see what’s it like.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 21/07/2022 07:23

I read on here just recently that the long summer holidays originated to allow children to help their parents bring in the harvest.

With the chronic shortage of labour at the moment perhaps this sort of system could be re-introduced, but not just for harvesting, there's seems to be shortages everywhere, e.g. restaurants, airport staff (flight controllers should be restricted to the over 11s) doctors (see flight controllers) police, Prime Minister etc.

Granted, it may require a bit more research before being implemented, I'm just making a casual observation.

Dinoteeth · 21/07/2022 07:21

No please don't suggest shorter holidays.

Lots of families already struggle so both parents can be off at the same time.
Shortening the holidays makes getting a holiday even more expensive and shortens their season.

The answer has to be better summer holiday care. My kids go to an afterschool that was set up as a 3rd sector not for profit organisation 25 years ago.
Every school should be able to access this type of provision.

SoftSheen · 21/07/2022 07:15

I think children need the holidays and would like the Summer break to be extended to 2 months, like in most private schools. A better solution for working parents would be better provision of affordable holiday clubs/camps where children can meet with a different group of peers and have fun doing non-academic stuff.

Comedycook · 21/07/2022 07:14

Oh and those saying school isn't childcare....tell that to the job centre

Comedycook · 21/07/2022 07:13

I think the summer break is needed but could be cut down to four weeks.
Six seems ridiculous to me.
Even my kids get fed up towards the end and just want to get back to their routine.

Ylvamoon · 21/07/2022 07:09

I think the issue needs to be addressed politically.
If people insist on the amount of holidays children have, then childcare should be subsidised up to the age of 14/15.
This can be on a sliding scale as DC get older and should be in days / weeks not £££.
Yes, shool buildings and leasure centres should be used for affordable childcare.

arrogantorwhat37 · 21/07/2022 07:09

it is not the responsibility of others to be your childminders. You knew how schools work before you conceived, why should everything change because you work?

HeliosPurple · 21/07/2022 07:08

Teacher here. I work regularly 7.30 - 6.00 and then again in the evening. I work every single weekend.

Teaching is a job which is predicated on working in the evening and at the weekend (especially if you are senior leadership team alongside a teaching role). I’ll be working for at least two weeks of the holidays on planning and other leadership responsibilities/long term school development planning. Ofsted expectations are unreal and schools do a vast amount of work to keep ofsted happy. I love my job but couldn’t do it without the longer holidays as I’d be utterly burnt out.

VaccineSticker · 21/07/2022 07:05
  • school isn’t a baby sitting service. Pay for your own clubs and summer camps. Children from disadvantaged backgrounds should get help to access these clubs.
  • the uk has one of the shortest summer school holidays in the world. If you think 6 weeks is too long, I grew up with 12 weeks of summer holidays!
  • Children need a break from school and a structured routine.
  • it’s not the teachers fault here and why does the conversation always descend to teachers versus parents argument?
  • imagine the whole country being squeezed into a shorter summer holiday and then fighting over a limited amount of holidays and accommodation to fit everybody -and the prices would increase due to the ridiculous demand people would take their children during term time.
  • OP maybe you should save up and find a decent holidays camps in your area instead of blaming the system.
stuntbubbles · 21/07/2022 06:59

Confusion101 · 20/07/2022 23:15

Agree with the PP who said rather than looking at this as a "schools should be open longer" why aren't we challenging working hours and expectations? Technology has come on leaps and bounds in recent years thereby making majority of working industries easier and more efficient yet instead of employees reaping the benefits of that we are expected to work harder and longer... Work - Life balance is shite and throwing kids into more schooling so we can work more shouldn't really be the answer. We all deserve the break!

Yes yes yes. Our work has “summer hours” where we can all suddenly finish at 3pm on Friday – lovely, but how come we can’t always finish at that time? Most jobs are made-up bullshit anyway, there to keep the capitalist economy chuntering along, why not make up that we only need to do 30 hours a week?

Annual leave entitlement is also crap, and worse in companies that dictate when you can take it, or include the bank holidays instead of having them as extra.

Given that many schools closed this week for the heatwave, and future Julys will be hotter and more ferocious, I do wonder if climate change will play a part in dictating future school years and planning.

The issue isn’t the summer holiday, it’s the crap childcare provision, stagnating wages, cost of living, work/life balance and poor annual leave.

Darbs76 · 21/07/2022 06:52

It is tricky for many parents during the summer holidays. I have no family nearby and so I had to use a combination of summer clubs, and annual leave. There are some that are 8-6 and I’d try and find one near to work so I could get max use of it so drop them off and straight into work. Our work used to do a holiday club in one of the offices and that was fab. But it was cut! Too costly I guess. Thankfully my kids are almost 18 and 14 so now they just stay home and have done since 11 when they started secondary. I think kids need a break but 4wks would be plenty as it’s not easy trying to juggle it all

DameHelena · 21/07/2022 06:49

OwlinaTree · 20/07/2022 21:58

I think a lot of teachers would leave if they didn't have the long holiday! Many teachers are also working parents and appreciate time with their own children that they don't get much of in term time.

I appreciate it's hard for many working parents though.

My dad’s a retired head teacher and it wasn’t much of a holiday for him. Often he’d take the pupils on a summer trip for a week or so (once or twice my mum and I went too and that was our holiday, as money was tight. Other than that I largely remember him working at home or going in to school; he’d often have to take me in if my mum was working.

TitInATrance · 21/07/2022 06:46

If school summer holidays were four weeks long, how many working parents wouldn’t be able to get any time off at all during that period? Holiday prices would be through the roof, so increasing numbers of children would have no proper holiday at all.

My DC are grown up now and as solo parent I had to arrange care for every day I wasn’t on annual leave, but they do need a break. If I remember rightly their former nursery provided care for the first year or two, especially for older DC when younger DC was still FT.

cliffdiver · 21/07/2022 06:46

Teacher here, I'd rather a month during summer, and stick an extra week on Feb and June half terms.

Reenskar · 21/07/2022 06:44

Which 2 weeks are you proposing shortening the holidays by? Some schools had to close in the heat this week.

Our secondary had 38% attendance on Tuesday and the kids were hot, tired and grumpy. Very little meaningful learning happening. Would you suggest the kids go back in mid August or stick out the end of July- both have the potential for very hot weather?

InChocolateWeTrust · 21/07/2022 06:43

I'm fine with the length of time off for kids, what constantly annoys me is the gap between how much annual leave workers get and how much time off school kids get.

It's a nightmare to coordinate, especially if you have children different ages. Most summer provision for school aged kids is 9-3 with limited options for wraparound, which isn't long enough hours for a working day, and in many areas there arent enough childminders available.

Swipe left for the next trending thread