Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Summer holidays - outdated

634 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:05

So I was just scrolling through Facebook and I saw some pictures after school club/breakfast club to my sons school put up and it just got me thinking how crazy it is that schools just completely shut down for like 6-7 weeks.
They have all these facilities during term time to support working families because there is obviously a need to for it, but in the holidays... ahh f*ck it!
Obviously o know there's summer schemes but at a massive expense and also different hours and locations.
My sons school isn't offering one so he's attending some random school for 3 days over the summer mainly just so he's socialising!
I'm extremely lucky as my mum is a great help to me during the holidays. And obviously I'm very much looking forward to spending more time with my boys and no school run... hurry!!!
But I just find it crazy that schools close for such a significant period of time.
Obviously I know school isn't childcare but it school itself enables parents to work so it kind of is 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
HappyGa · 21/07/2022 11:11

YABU - School's are there to educate your child, not provide parents with childcare. They should have LONGER off in the summer when the weather is hotter/better not less time.
Kids need to have time to play, re-charge, relax and, yes, see their families and parents. In England the holidays are shorter, school days are longer and kids start school earlier than most of the western world but our children aren't more successful OR better educated for it.
I would rather see kids off longer, like in Northern Ireland, but with cheap play/summer schemes like they have there which are run by councils and local leisure centres. Kids can go for a week at a time for about £30 and do all sorts of activities.

Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 11:06

I’m also going to point out that teachers are also parents. According to the DFE there are nearly 1m full time employed members of staff (teaching and support staff) in the UK. Plus however many hundreds of thousands of part-time staff too. What you are asking for will have a huge knock on effect on a lot of people for possibly very little benefit.

At an average extra of £800 per staff that is almost 1billion pounds extra to fund. And that is before the extra maintenance/food/energy bills. An extra two weeks pupil premium would probably be millions too!

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 11:04

TheInteriorSilence · 21/07/2022 10:56

They don’t hold any childcare qualifications here. The teaching assistants at the local school aren’t even qualified in anything.

I guess it varies depending where you are. ☺️

How do you know the teaching assistants aren't qualified in anything? All of our support staff have relevant qualifications.

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 21/07/2022 11:03

Anyone looking after your children as a bare minimum needs an enhanced CRB, union or insurance cover, space and safe and clean facilities. That's the cost.

I wouldn't leave my own child with someone unqualified. Tas aren't allowed to take full responsibility for classes long-term because it's a legal requirement to be qualified when looking after children.
If you are wanting children to do activities like swimming then really a water safety qualification is needed

Even childminders nowadays need to be registered with the DfE. And are ofsteded.
For good reason. Unchecked and unqualified child provision on the cheap is bad news.
If parents can't afford it the government should subsidise it. It's not teachers responsibility to pick up the slack.

Fairislefandango · 21/07/2022 11:02

All this comes down to is: "I don't want to pay for childcare in the holidays". But somebody has to pay for it. Childcare workers, holiday club organisers and teachers don't work for free! So either parents pay for it or the government does. Do you think that's going to happen? No. So since you're going to have to pay for it, why does it need to be schools staying open longer, rather than the type of childcare and holiday schemes which are already available?

Macaroni1924 · 21/07/2022 10:59

blebbleb · 21/07/2022 08:55

My son is only 2 at the moment but I dread him starting school with all the holidays. My husband and I both work full time would really struggle to cover all the time off and random inset days. Not everyone has a parent at home all the time or working part time, we can't afford to pay the bills on 1 wage. Also no family nearby.

Most households these days don’t have the luxury of a stay at home parent but then before you started trying for a baby surely you discussed childcare options? What happens on snow days, sick days etc. Schools have been the same for years so it’s not like you entered into parenthood without knowing this.

Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 10:57

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 10:39

Well I'm sorry you feel that way.

I wouldn't make a post just to argue but the way you're talking to me isn't exactly nice so maybe you need to read my responses in a different way!

I also don't have to acknowledge anything, why would you expect me to do so? We don't all have to agree!

I’m not being unkind to you. Disagreement is not I kind. And we don’t have to agree but it is not a discussion when the person proposing that you work two extra weeks a year for their own convenience refuses to even recognise some of the points against their plan.

I’m sorry that you are in such a tight position with childcare over the Summer. But the solutions is not to make everyone else miserable too.

And I am very much fed up of someone having this brilliant idea every single Summer holidays and having the explain to them why it is so unworkable and silly. It is also the stick that Give used to beat us with when he thought we weren’t working hard enough (hence why their is now a massive teacher shortage). It is very much a huge trigger point for most teachers.

TheInteriorSilence · 21/07/2022 10:56

They don’t hold any childcare qualifications here. The teaching assistants at the local school aren’t even qualified in anything.

I guess it varies depending where you are. ☺️

Emarjha · 21/07/2022 10:56

I think it's disgusting people think so little of their children they want to pay those responsible rock bottom
I don’t think that’s the case. I would love to hire a super expensive private nanny to look after my kids. But I can’t because I don’t earn enough. My ability to pay a carer depends on how much I earn. Realistically I can probably afford to pay about half of my after-tax salary per hour - and that has to cover all of my kids.

TyotyaKlava · 21/07/2022 10:56

the majority of professionals got their higher education degrees abroad (including myself). The ones who got local education aren’t really professionals. Mind you there are universities that have higher standards.
although I remember when I was doing my professional accounting qualifications it took a while to remember some secondary school level maths!!!

TheInteriorSilence · 21/07/2022 10:54

@BaddityHabbityHoppingPot

what are the fully qualified in? Where I am they aren’t qualified.

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 21/07/2022 10:48

Its 'extortionate' because fully qualified staff should be paid a working wage. The extra safeguarding, insurance, space, equipment and catering adds to that.

I think it's disgusting people think so little of their children they want to pay those responsible rock bottom.

TheInteriorSilence · 21/07/2022 10:45

TyotyaKlava · 21/07/2022 10:38

The country I am from has school holidays lasting over three months from 26 may to 1 September! Three months of doing nothing, I remember going back to school with a completely blank memory of anything I learnt precious school year 🤷🏻‍♀️

It’s amazing that there’s any professionals in your country. What’s the point in schooling if everyone forgets everything they learnt 😂 what a waste of time!

TheInteriorSilence · 21/07/2022 10:43

I agree OP. Here the holiday clubs are sports only :/ my children hate sports! plus it’s extortionate.

Kids need a break, yes. But it needs to be spread evenly throughout the whole year.

After all, they aren’t required for harvest anymore. We need a modern approach

ApplesandBunions · 21/07/2022 10:43

Firstly, you'd need qualified staff. Unlikely to work seasonally so how are you going to fund it make it a viable job for a year. There's a reason seasonal jobs are traditionally filled up by teenagers and it's because they are cheap.

This is a big issue, and it's one reason why universal provision as some people are arguing for is unrealistic and unnecessary. There's no reason to think we have oodles of suitably qualified people waiting to provide summer holiday childcare, and obviously we know existing school staff aren't the solution. What resources there are need to be targeted better at those who need them.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 10:39

Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 10:33

@Wednesdayafternoon

What you’re posting doesn’t come off as ‘just here to chat’. It sounds like rabble rousing.

I’ve yet to see you accept that shorter holidays are unworkable and would disadvantage most students.

Well I'm sorry you feel that way.

I wouldn't make a post just to argue but the way you're talking to me isn't exactly nice so maybe you need to read my responses in a different way!

I also don't have to acknowledge anything, why would you expect me to do so? We don't all have to agree!

OP posts:
TyotyaKlava · 21/07/2022 10:38

The country I am from has school holidays lasting over three months from 26 may to 1 September! Three months of doing nothing, I remember going back to school with a completely blank memory of anything I learnt precious school year 🤷🏻‍♀️

BaddityHabbityHoppingPot · 21/07/2022 10:37

See I am qualified but I understand the limitations with that proposal.
Firstly, you'd need qualified staff. Unlikely to work seasonally so how are you going to fund it make it a viable job for a year. There's a reason seasonal jobs are traditionally filled up by teenagers and it's because they are cheap. I am of the opinion that only qualified staff should be responsible for children. It's a responsible job. So would parents pay the money to pay a decent and fair wage? Would the government subsidies it.
Space. Again money would be needed for a tailored space. Maintenance. Safety etc.
Insurance. You need both a union and public liability insurance to work with children outside a teaching role. Would add towards costs.
Speciality. Child development means children should be provided with many opportunities. This means specialists for sports, swimming, equipment are needed. Who's willing to pay that

What you want requires money, time and dedication. Which is why you hope you can shame teachers into doing it for free and schools into supporting it with all the cleaners, maintenance staff etc that would take.

If this is something parents think is required they need to either pay for it or start petitioning for the government to run it.
Not the schools responsibility.

turquoise1988 · 21/07/2022 10:37

The cost of living isn't the school's fault. It isn't teachers' fault. It's a government issue.

I wish that people would stop implying that it's always schools and teachers who should be giving more, more, more.

Nearly every single teacher I know who gets paid 40 hours a week works anywhere between 50 to 70. We do not work 9-3. We do not get a six week summer holiday. We don't leave our classrooms on the last day in July and return to some sort of magical transformation ready for the start of the new year. I appreciate that this isn't exclusive to teachers and that other professions are demanding, but there is still such a level of ignorance around how much teachers get paid and how much 'holiday' they have.

We have our own families, our own children to care for in the holidays too.

Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 10:33

@Wednesdayafternoon

What you’re posting doesn’t come off as ‘just here to chat’. It sounds like rabble rousing.

I’ve yet to see you accept that shorter holidays are unworkable and would disadvantage most students.

Phineyj · 21/07/2022 10:32

I think we can all agree there's a problem but I personally would prefer to discuss solutions. Mumsnet represents a lot of people - lots of higher earners too, lots of educated people. We could lobby effectively if we wanted to.

The decision makers generally aren't affected by childcare issues and don't care a great deal about child welfare. They do care about economic growth.

Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 10:31

@80sMum

Everything you list as optional is already taught as part of the curriculum. Your compulsory term sounds dreadfully dull and would put most students off coming to school.

Wednesdayafternoon · 21/07/2022 10:30

Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 10:29

Op, you’ve been given a whole long list of why this is unworkable/silly but you seem to stick like grim death to the idea.

Issue with shorter holidays:

  • would have to pay all school staff for the extra hours (most admin staff are term time only so they would also need pay increases). This would costs millions, perhaps billions.
  • It would squeeze the holiday season so it was more difficult to co-ordinate time off for holidays in most work places.
  • A shorter season would invariably make holidays more expensive and therefore make them the preserve of the wealthier.
  • Less relaxation/ social time for students- how would this affect child mental health. This is a big issue.
  • Gives students less time to experience enrichment (would could be as simple as a trip to the park with friends). School enrichment has been cut to the bone by cut backs. Many schools have sold playing fields to raise money and are slashing budgets for art, music and performing arts. When will students get to experience this if they aren’t in play schemes in the Summer?
  • Only benefits some families at the expense of others- surely targeted support is better.
  • Increases the divide between rich and poor households. One has long holidays and the other barely any at all. Why disadvantage poorer kids by grinding them down with extra work- which you have no evidence will help them get ahead. It is not as simple as more time at work/school= better results. In fact, the opposite is often true.
  • some working parents will save money on holiday clubs.
It seems pretty obvious to me that there are better solutions than taking two weeks holiday off of everyone’s kids to suit you. As others have suggested it would be far better to increase funding to social care and tackle the cost of living in this country. We have some of the shortest holidays and longest working hours in Europe yet we are not the. Most productive and don’t have the best education. Our population is also one of the least happy. Just more of the status quo is not the answer.

I'm not disagreeing with anyone's ideas other then the people who say it should stay as it is.
Also I'm just here to chat, I didn't realise that by someone adding an opinion or a solution meant the chat was over 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
woodhill · 21/07/2022 10:30

Harvest festival is at the end of September

Perhaps the terms started later like universities

Legrandsophie · 21/07/2022 10:29

Op, you’ve been given a whole long list of why this is unworkable/silly but you seem to stick like grim death to the idea.

Issue with shorter holidays:

  • would have to pay all school staff for the extra hours (most admin staff are term time only so they would also need pay increases). This would costs millions, perhaps billions.
  • It would squeeze the holiday season so it was more difficult to co-ordinate time off for holidays in most work places.
  • A shorter season would invariably make holidays more expensive and therefore make them the preserve of the wealthier.
  • Less relaxation/ social time for students- how would this affect child mental health. This is a big issue.
  • Gives students less time to experience enrichment (would could be as simple as a trip to the park with friends). School enrichment has been cut to the bone by cut backs. Many schools have sold playing fields to raise money and are slashing budgets for art, music and performing arts. When will students get to experience this if they aren’t in play schemes in the Summer?
  • Only benefits some families at the expense of others- surely targeted support is better.
  • Increases the divide between rich and poor households. One has long holidays and the other barely any at all. Why disadvantage poorer kids by grinding them down with extra work- which you have no evidence will help them get ahead. It is not as simple as more time at work/school= better results. In fact, the opposite is often true.
  • some working parents will save money on holiday clubs.
It seems pretty obvious to me that there are better solutions than taking two weeks holiday off of everyone’s kids to suit you. As others have suggested it would be far better to increase funding to social care and tackle the cost of living in this country. We have some of the shortest holidays and longest working hours in Europe yet we are not the. Most productive and don’t have the best education. Our population is also one of the least happy. Just more of the status quo is not the answer.