Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Summer holidays - outdated

634 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:05

So I was just scrolling through Facebook and I saw some pictures after school club/breakfast club to my sons school put up and it just got me thinking how crazy it is that schools just completely shut down for like 6-7 weeks.
They have all these facilities during term time to support working families because there is obviously a need to for it, but in the holidays... ahh f*ck it!
Obviously o know there's summer schemes but at a massive expense and also different hours and locations.
My sons school isn't offering one so he's attending some random school for 3 days over the summer mainly just so he's socialising!
I'm extremely lucky as my mum is a great help to me during the holidays. And obviously I'm very much looking forward to spending more time with my boys and no school run... hurry!!!
But I just find it crazy that schools close for such a significant period of time.
Obviously I know school isn't childcare but it school itself enables parents to work so it kind of is 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 21/07/2022 14:34

happinessischocolate · 21/07/2022 13:57

Or instead of changing the school holidays, how about we change back to being able to afford your mortgage and bills on one salary or 2 part time salaries so that a parents can stay at home for the kids?

Or is that too radical.

Why the race to occupy ourselves and our children in permanent work and schooling 24/7

To do that the government have to stop propping up high house prices. Which means house prices would fall. I would support that, but I think most people on MN would not.

Bobby80 · 21/07/2022 14:14

happinessischocolate · 21/07/2022 13:57

Or instead of changing the school holidays, how about we change back to being able to afford your mortgage and bills on one salary or 2 part time salaries so that a parents can stay at home for the kids?

Or is that too radical.

Why the race to occupy ourselves and our children in permanent work and schooling 24/7

This.

happinessischocolate · 21/07/2022 13:57

Or instead of changing the school holidays, how about we change back to being able to afford your mortgage and bills on one salary or 2 part time salaries so that a parents can stay at home for the kids?

Or is that too radical.

Why the race to occupy ourselves and our children in permanent work and schooling 24/7

Holly60 · 21/07/2022 13:49

coolernow · 20/07/2022 22:09

Imo teachers get pretty good pay when you realise it's for 190 days.

You'll be planning on retraining, and becoming a teacher then?? No? why ever not?

Holly60 · 21/07/2022 13:48

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 21:58

I think my point really is, how can schools or the gouverntn or who ever makes these decisions think that during term time they will offer so much support to parents for example breakfast and after school clubs to support parents and also aid extra socialising and learning etc, but the. In the holidays.. nothing.
Does none of that matter then 🤷🏼‍♀️

Isn't it about profit though, rather than some altruistic desire to help working parents? Demand and supply? After school and breakfast clubs cost money and are run by outside companies who are looking to make a profit like everyone else.

If the school was open, so would the after school clubs because they'd make a profit.

Schools themselves are not childcare and teachers are not babysitters.

Any after school clubs run by the school are about extending the provision, whether it's academic or pastoral. Again, not childcare.

And to your comments regarding teachers having 6 weeks with their own children but other working parents not having that - many teachers would have considered this when they chose teaching as a career. You could have chosen to become a teacher, but chances are you can't think of anything worse and didn't think the school holidays were worth the rest.....

teachers get told 'rather you than me!' Until it gets to the holidays, then they are blasted for having such an easy ride...

Bobby80 · 21/07/2022 13:43

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 22:01

Yes this is what I'm referring too really!

Teachers are teachers, not social workers. I agree that vulnerable children need supported but I don’t think out entire education provision should be overhauled to do this. Maybe we need to address the roof cause of the problem - and no, I’m not sure what the answer is!

CeeJay81 · 21/07/2022 13:40

They are thinking about changing it here(Wales).

www.walesonline.co.uk/news/education/school-year-changes-calendar-wales-24339971

Sometimeswinning · 21/07/2022 13:40

figmaofmyimagination · 20/07/2022 21:57

Yep, this.

Agree with the PP who said a month is plenty.

Yes, teachers choose when and how the holidays work.

Sockwomble · 21/07/2022 13:37

"The 6 week summer holiday is a big reset for children. It enables them to return in Sept able to look at the new year with fresh eyes. Regardless of what they've been doing for the holidays, they are more rested than at any other point in the year, enabling them to learn at their best that term, and adapt to the huge changes that each September brings."

That may be the case for 'mainstream' children but with my son and other children at his special school the first few weeks of term are often the most problematic of the year as they get used to being around other children and adults again, re learning school routines etc.

JustLyra · 21/07/2022 13:34

Changing school terms would involve restructuring schools, nurseries, colleges and universities - not just schools.

universities that rely a lot on overseas students would be massively reluctant to any change that takes them out of line with how other counties work imo.

antelopevalley · 21/07/2022 13:33

@JustLyra that is very sad.

JustLyra · 21/07/2022 13:30

sicknote26 · 20/07/2022 22:26

Agree, if my child's school done this it would be a life saver, my child wont go to another school during the holidays as she doesn't know anyone, throughout my childhood my primary school offered a summer play scheme, it was fantastic and allowed my parents to go to work.

Small playschemes have been pushed out of the market by funding decisions in a lot of cases.

Until covid I was chair of a volunteer run playscheme. We also ran a breakfast and after school club.

Our council has always given decent grants to playschemes. For many years it covered our insurance, one of our major costs, and a wee bit more. We also hired spaces at the same cost as charitable groups and things like the pensioners lunch clubs.

It was always a simple process where they took the number of applications and split the money equally. it was generally just groups like ours that ran playschemes.

Then a number of big childcare companies realised this and rebranded their £80 a day holiday care as a “playscheme”. They now get the exact same share of the council pot as smaller schemes. They tend to get a bigger share of the other types of funding because they have paid staff to deal with the applications.

One company even attempted to book the space that our playscheme used for one day a week in the holidays. Now they’re not going to use somewhere one day a week - it was a clear attempt at making the booking for our playscheme fail so they had less competition (by sheer coincidence according to them this happened shortly after we were in the local paper for our bloody fantastic inspection results).

alnawire · 21/07/2022 13:21

I would have been absolutely devastated when l was younger if they had shortened the summer break, l looked forward to it all year.

You realise you don't speak for all children?

Children do need some time which is not controlled by schedules and rotas. It definately shouldn' t be viewed as a waste of time.

Some thrive on it

Parents just seem to manage, as they do, its been this way for years, and teachers do deserve this time, theres no way l could do what they do, and yes l do know its not a holiday as such for them.

Some parents don't 'manage' even in term time. Some are really shit.

Who wants to live in a world where the ethos is work, work, work, twenty four seven, its bad enough now.

I would like to live in a world where the needs of children are not overlooked. Where vulnerable and disadvantaged children are more important than they are right now.

user1471505494 · 21/07/2022 13:16

Wednesdayafternoon · 20/07/2022 23:00

I get three weeks holiday a year and maybe one or two days of that is spent on myself.

Wouldn't it be nice if we all got to enjoy our work holidays!

The big difference is that you get PAID for your holidays. Teachers don’t

Eeksteek · 21/07/2022 13:14

@itispersonal

presumably because it’s a big problem for a lot of people? It needn’t affect me personally, my kid’s old enough to be left now and I took holidays off with her. I knew about it and managed it. But just because I knew about it doesn’t mean it isn’t a huge and avoidable problem desperately in need of overhaul (although now would not be a good time!)

@RockandRollsuicide What proportion of support staff need the holidays to care for their kids, though? It’s chicken and egg!

@BigBobBoots but would children need a break so badly if the strain were spread with longer terms. Do children (and teachers) need such long holidays to reset because they have such short terms? It’s cyclical.

Surely the fact that the school calendar is SO different to absolutely any other pattern of life (or work) suggests it’s being kept for no good reason. If it was good for anyone, it would develop or be proposed in other walks of life. But it doesn’t!

ErrolTheDragon · 21/07/2022 12:56

Sartre · 21/07/2022 12:44

I think 6 weeks is too long and have always thought it should be 3 or 4 instead. Maybe just giving them the whole of August off makes more sense. DH went to private school and said he had 2 months off over summer, I would be absolutely enraged if I paid 10k a year for my child to attend a school that closed for 2 months over summer personally!

Doubtless if they only had one month's holiday rather than 2 in summer they'd charge £11k.

knackeredmu · 21/07/2022 12:55

I'd like to say that for older kids - young adults that 6 weeks is a much needed break. Time to switch off unwind and do some of the stuff they enjoy with their friends - years 10 and 12 here and it is very different to primary !

Eeksteek · 21/07/2022 12:53

Sherrystrull · 21/07/2022 12:28

School staff took their job knowing how the school year works. You took your job knowing how the school year works.

If you're not happy in your job and the flexibility it provides then change.

I can’t. I didn’t go back to work because as a lone parent with no family support it was too bloody hard to find something that worked around school. My kid already has no dad, and I didn’t want her to spend anymore time in childcare than she had to.

So I work in my own business, where I make the rules. But if kids went to school say 9-1 year round, I could easily get an office job mornings. Couples could likely more easily get work where one does earlies, one lates and juggle the kids between them. It just seems like so much of a barrier.

The point of the summer holidays was so that kids could help with the potato harvest. How many kids are doing that? Almost none. So why keep it? It’s like dicking about with the bloody clocks twice a year ‘for the farmers’ when there are hardly any left and we’re all exhausted bloody office/catering/retail
workers scrambling to reset our kids’ body clocks twice a year. Why do we DO it?! It’s archaic, and yet we persist with something utterly crappy because nothing is perfect for everyone. Even though a change would be partly better for a lot more people.

Caspianberg · 21/07/2022 12:51

@Sartre - or you could ask why private schools easily top the ranks for most results, yet have almost double the weeks holidays per year? Surely that shows state schools are falling hugely behind.

BigBobBoots · 21/07/2022 12:51

The more I think about it the more I just feel like the holidays should be more evenly dispersed. Maybe a constant shorter week. Maybe long half terms or long weekends...
A shorter week or a shorter day does not solve the childcare issue - it just moves it around.
The 6 week summer holiday is a big reset for children. It enables them to return in Sept able to look at the new year with fresh eyes. Regardless of what they've been doing for the holidays, they are more rested than at any other point in the year, enabling them to learn at their best that term, and adapt to the huge changes that each September brings.
I teach deprived children. I'm sure that some of them will sit in their flats for the entire summer watching tv and gaming. So sad. But they will still be in a stronger position to learn in Sept than if they just had 2 weeks off school, as they get a chance to recover physically and emotionally from the demands of learning and conforming.
Learning all day every day is very different from doing a job, much more demanding.
I think that every child should be able to have some fun in the summer holidays, and would love for my pupils to have the same opportunities that my own children get (some activity centre, some camping, a couple of day trips, develop interests). This would help their resilience and learning beyond measure. Its not considered an entitlement in this country but if I were PM for a day I would make it happen. Interestingly in France 'Colonies de Vacances' are a big thing - with organised activities, trips and centres for the families that need it. But it should be based somewhere other than their school building as children need a break.

Sartre · 21/07/2022 12:44

I think 6 weeks is too long and have always thought it should be 3 or 4 instead. Maybe just giving them the whole of August off makes more sense. DH went to private school and said he had 2 months off over summer, I would be absolutely enraged if I paid 10k a year for my child to attend a school that closed for 2 months over summer personally!

ApplesandBunions · 21/07/2022 12:44

antelopevalley · 21/07/2022 12:39

Most people I know use a variety of childcare, including family, shift work, and a bit of paid childcare.

Yeah I suspect the cobbled together model is probably the commonest.

ErrolTheDragon · 21/07/2022 12:41

The more I think about it the more I just feel like the holidays should be more evenly dispersed. Maybe a constant shorter week. Maybe long half terms or long weekends...

One aspect of a long summer break does fit with modern expectations of a 'proper summer holiday' - a fortnight away somewhere. If the summer holiday was reduced then the bulge in demand and price rises would be huge. Schools staggering their holidays would be problematic for people with kids in different schools.

There's all sorts of reasons - many valid - why the idea of reducing the summer break would probably be very unpopular with many parents as well as teachers. It would probably create more problems than it solved for many.

antelopevalley · 21/07/2022 12:39

Most people I know use a variety of childcare, including family, shift work, and a bit of paid childcare.

ApplesandBunions · 21/07/2022 12:37

Funny because most parents where able to pay for nursery where free doesn’t exist.

Hmm I doubt that's true. Factor in how many preschool aged children are looked after by a SAHP, extended family members, parents alternating shifts/part time etc, often because it's cheaper than paying for nursery, so aren't in childcare. Then consider the number who do go to nursery but couldn't be there without the free hours or very substantial state top ups (UC can cover up to 85%) and I'm not sure the majority of parents had actually been paying the costs of nursery per se. It doesn't really surprise me that some of the cost barriers might still persist once the child starts school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread