Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain to the board of governors?

84 replies

messicliche · 20/07/2022 18:54

Hi all, below is a post from DH.

NC as post could be outing.

A bit of background about the situation. I am a senior leader in a secondary school. As a result, I am well aware that we are not bound by the standard 'Burgundy Book' directive document etc.

Essentially, last week was asked to perform a role outside of my general remit (supporting with sports day results outside). The day before sports day itself, an email was sent around to all staff (after school hours, approx 2.5hrs after school ended) noting that all staff are expected to wear normal formal attire.

Maybe naively, I automatically ignored it as I had seen the sports day support schedule and I was scheduled to be outside. As a result, I wore what I deemed 'appropriate attire' to support with this, think, sports shirt, shorts, appropriate trainers.

Cue the next day, turn up on site, instructed to go home and change into the professional dress that was directed the day before. Moreover, I then have received a professional letter of conduct for my inappropriate dress. To add, there was another member of staff that this happened to as well.

My issue is more the way it's been dealt with rather than the being asked to go home and change, although that's annoying. At no point did the head speak to me about this, I was hauled into a room with my SLT line manager. Also, at no point did the head mention that I would receive a letter of professional conduct for my dress. It was just placed in my pigeon hole. Found it by sheer luck.

So essentially the question is

AIBU - there was a directive sent the day before, you weren't mentioned as being excluded from it, even though it was sent outside of school hours, you should have followed it even if it would have meant dying outside in the heat

YANBU - ridiculous overreaction, petty, spiteful and vindictive and need to take it further to his line manager who is the chair of governors and potentially hand my notice in

FWIW - the PE staff were all in PE attire, and continue to be even when now outdoor PE can't take place because of the heat. I think I'm so frustrated by the lack of consistency shown by the top leadership in following rules and guidelines. I would stress that throughout the year I am (in my eyes) impeccably dressed and often gaze at other people thinking, how on earth are they getting away with that (think, open toed flip-flops, short dresses that are traditionally not professional etc.)

Would love to hear all of your opinions, apologies about the rant.

Happy to add any extra info if anyone needs it

Thanks!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fairislefandango · 21/07/2022 11:11

I mean... yes it's pretty daft and unnecessary to insist on formal wear out on the field on sports day, and yes, they dealt with it very heavy-handedly afterwards. It sounds like a very unsupportive and officious SLT. But... your husband chose to ignore a clear instruction. If it had been me, I'd have tutted and been pissed off but worn the suit.

VickyEadieofThigh · 21/07/2022 11:02

messicliche · 20/07/2022 19:12

To reply:

It has crossed my mind to speak to him first, definitely the sort of person that would hold a grudge. I will speak to my Union but unfortunately they are not represented in the school.

Also, the pigeon hole isn't locked, just in the staff room. FWIW, letter was in an envelope so not readable but noticeably there.

I agree.

What would your DH hope to achieve by complaining formally to the GB? He needs to try to resolve this before resporting to what is in fact raising a grievance.

He should (a) ask his union for support and (b) follow that advice.

I'ma retired secondary HT who is now a chair of governors. The process with complaints and grievances is that the complainant should always try to resolve the issue prior to going to a formal grievance.

You say the HT probably won't take this well - this is exactly why your DH must involve the union and think carefully about what he hopes to achieve.

messicliche · 21/07/2022 10:32

MarshaMelrose · 21/07/2022 00:10

To be honest his account gets more confusing rather than enlightening.

He got permission to wear sports wear.
On the day he goes into school wearing his sportswear.
He reads an email saying he should wear formal wear.
At 7.30 he's told to go home to change.
He changes into formal wear.
What in that has he done wrong? He's followed each mandate he's been given.

And yet he doesn't disagree that he was potentially in the wrong. How is that then when he's just followed what he's been told? It suggests there's more to the situation than he's saying. And that's sort of backed up by the words he uses to describe the reprimand he's been given. "ridiculous overreaction, petty, spiteful and vindictive" An overreaction is used to describe a sanction that's too strong. You wouldn't use it for an action that deserved no sanction. So I don't know what's gone on here or what he believes he's done wrong.

Having said all that, it was sports day, it was probably hot, I don't blame him for wearing his shorts.

Sorry, just to clarify, he is wrong because he wasn't given explicit permission to wear sports kit. A PE staff member told him he could, but he never checked with any higher being. So potentially he is in the wrong there for not checking. That's my stance anyway!

OP posts:
Tromboleese · 21/07/2022 00:57

I’m a Chair of Governors. It is fairly standard in any grievance policy to have gone down the route of speaking to the HT before coming to us. We have to follow policy.

Given the clarification on the email being out of hours, him not seeing it but being asked to change all good, but a disciplinary letter sounds OTT to me.

In my experience of governance across 8 schools (maintained), governors are independent and do not rubber stamp the HT’s decisions. We have overturned decisions and exclusions where the evidence presented pointed it was the right thing to do. Last week I upheld a parent’s complaint, they have had an apology and we are restoring their relationship with school. Your DH should know the CofG well enough to judge if raising a grievance is worth it. If it were at my school, I would be interested to hear about it, not least from a staff wellbeing point of view.

BrilloSolar · 21/07/2022 00:25

Can you imagine him going for another job?
Interviewer: do you have any write warnings against you?
OP's husband: yes, last year I wore shorts and t-shirt to help out at sports day all day.
Interviewer: ....

MarshaMelrose · 21/07/2022 00:10

To be honest his account gets more confusing rather than enlightening.

He got permission to wear sports wear.
On the day he goes into school wearing his sportswear.
He reads an email saying he should wear formal wear.
At 7.30 he's told to go home to change.
He changes into formal wear.
What in that has he done wrong? He's followed each mandate he's been given.

And yet he doesn't disagree that he was potentially in the wrong. How is that then when he's just followed what he's been told? It suggests there's more to the situation than he's saying. And that's sort of backed up by the words he uses to describe the reprimand he's been given. "ridiculous overreaction, petty, spiteful and vindictive" An overreaction is used to describe a sanction that's too strong. You wouldn't use it for an action that deserved no sanction. So I don't know what's gone on here or what he believes he's done wrong.

Having said all that, it was sports day, it was probably hot, I don't blame him for wearing his shorts.

BrilloSolar · 21/07/2022 00:07

Lol, that wasn't so brief once I got going! I'm angry for him!

BrilloSolar · 21/07/2022 00:06

Ugh, honestly, he wore sports kit to help with sports day- seriously, what is wrong with the leadership here?

I'd definitely write an email sent to both the head and chair of governors. I'd actually ask them to clarify their policy on emails sent out of work time. So a very simple, brief email along the lines of:

  • I've received this formal warning (or whatever it is) and request a formal response before following this up with my Union and also in considering my future position at Shit High School.
  • On 15th of July I received notification that I was to assist with sports day all day on 18th July.
  • On 17th July, an email was sent at 7pm, which I did not read until 8:30am on 18th Julybwhen I first accessed my emails on my arrival at work. Because of this, I arrived at school dressed in sports wear to assist in sports day all day, and was not aware that the email stated that I was required to wear formal wear that day to assist on the field all day for sports day [yes I'm labouring that point a lot just so the chair of governors can see how rediculously it is].
  • can you please clarify the policy on accessing emails outside of working hours and at what time in the evening I am required to be checking emails that will impact my working day the next day.
  • I will be raising the disciplinary letter with my union as I feel I acted in good faith, arriving in appropriate sporting wear to assist with sports day (and in the belief that I was being directed as cover for the sports department and so wore the same attire as all other members of the sports department did that day), unaware of the email that had been sent after working hours the evening before, only to be sent home to change and then to receive a formal warning.
50mg · 20/07/2022 22:52

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2022 22:44

And he needs to bear in mind that they also generally work fulltime - and then go on to do the Governor part, such as meetings until nearly 10pm (the ones that include approving teaching staff pay rises and progression and the ones where they try to find ways to not make people redundant despite a reduction in real terms in GAG and the hugely increased costs of utilities tend to go on the longest).

In short (or in this case, NOT in shorts) - if he's going to go down the grievance route for receiving an email he both read and ignored or didn't read and chose to ignore until he was told 'everybody' also included him and then had to get his Mum wife to bring him some clothes like they were his Geography homework, he really needs to consider his audience - and whether it's really an effective use of everybody's time to deal with a middle manager complaining that he received an email so shockingly late that it was received at the sort of time that Governors are usually having meetings after a full day at work and then got told to put some clothes on because nobody wants to see his thighs or hairy shins.

The other teaching staff (except one) managed to read the email. The support staff managed to read the email. He managed to read the email - and ignored it.

Submitting this as a grievance is going to get one reaction from the Clerk as it's read - 'Oh, you're joking' - one from the Chair - 'Is he joking?' and one from anybody else who knows of the grievance - 'Is he having a laugh? He's submitted a grievance against the Head and unioned up for this?'

I agree that's what they'd all be thinking, but they'd also have to investigate and if the story is as told here, the HT's response was disproportionate. That said it is the "senior leadership's" actual job to support the HT and be "on message". He can challenge privately, but publically heust support, so he can expect to be reprimanded as part of the outcome too.

DH needs to decide if it's a hill he wants to die on. If he wins what does he want the outcome to be? Is it worth it?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2022 22:44

50mg · 20/07/2022 21:55

He needs to get his story straight before going to governors 😆

And he needs to bear in mind that they also generally work fulltime - and then go on to do the Governor part, such as meetings until nearly 10pm (the ones that include approving teaching staff pay rises and progression and the ones where they try to find ways to not make people redundant despite a reduction in real terms in GAG and the hugely increased costs of utilities tend to go on the longest).

In short (or in this case, NOT in shorts) - if he's going to go down the grievance route for receiving an email he both read and ignored or didn't read and chose to ignore until he was told 'everybody' also included him and then had to get his Mum wife to bring him some clothes like they were his Geography homework, he really needs to consider his audience - and whether it's really an effective use of everybody's time to deal with a middle manager complaining that he received an email so shockingly late that it was received at the sort of time that Governors are usually having meetings after a full day at work and then got told to put some clothes on because nobody wants to see his thighs or hairy shins.

The other teaching staff (except one) managed to read the email. The support staff managed to read the email. He managed to read the email - and ignored it.

Submitting this as a grievance is going to get one reaction from the Clerk as it's read - 'Oh, you're joking' - one from the Chair - 'Is he joking?' and one from anybody else who knows of the grievance - 'Is he having a laugh? He's submitted a grievance against the Head and unioned up for this?'

Smokealarmwakeup · 20/07/2022 22:23

Im a teacher and I officially finish work at 3:15. I complete work at home but don’t open emails I’m not expecting unless I’m in work, this stops me forgetting to action things because I can’t deal with it straight away and it stops me staying up until 1am doing little jobs. If I’m doing unpaid overtime it’s up to me to decide what I’m doing. Him seeing the email is irrelevant because he didn’t read it.

messicliche · 20/07/2022 22:19

His version of events through this thread is kind of irrelevant. As stated, he doesn't disagree that he was potentially in the wrong. It is how they handled the situation.

For the avoidance of doubt, since I have all the messages I will clear it up.

2 days before D-Day: 'DW I get to wear PE kit on Thursday, it's sports day'
Thursday Morning; DH wears PE kit to school
Thursday 630am: 'Shit I got an email from HT about professional dress today, oh well I'm here now'
Me at 6:42am ' should I drop in spare uniform?'
Him 6:42am 'no it's fine'
Him 7:34 'just been hauled into SLT person office been sent to change'

Then he went on a wild goose chase for a brand new uniform in the retail park nearby before I had to drive to his school 25 minutes away and deliver the uniform.

The email time stamp is 18:06 from the Head the day before, he just checked. It's a weird email tbh.

Also, just to add to DH's point about the handling, he had no lessons that day - only the results - along with 1 science teacher and PE teachers (in PE kits).

OP posts:
50mg · 20/07/2022 21:55

He needs to get his story straight before going to governors 😆

MarshaMelrose · 20/07/2022 21:54

DH was unclear, he ignored it when he saw it in the morning at 630am.

I'm sorry but after you telling me off for not reading the full thread, I've got to say, your husband was definitely not unclear.
He was very clear and sequential.
The day before sports day itself, an email was sent...
Maybe naively, I automatically ignored it ...
Cue the next day....

If he'd only read it after he'd arrived, he wouldn't have worded it like that. He'd have said, "I didn't read it til I arrived at work the next morning but I was already dressed in my sports stuff so I thought it would be ok." Perfectly reasonable position but then he'd go and check if it was OK and if not go and change.

It's not that I think the head was reasonable or your husband was unreasonable but I just find it difficult to believe these revised events. Your husband didn't once mention that they're being unfair to punish him for disobeying an instruction he never received. Instead he's complaining that he should have been allowed to ignore it because it came outside school hours.

AIBU - there was a directive sent the day before, you weren't mentioned as being excluded from it, even though it was sent outside of school hours, you should have followed it even if it would have meant dying outside in the heat

If he's going to take it further he needs to get his story properly sorted out.

50mg · 20/07/2022 21:23

He specifically said he ignored it, not that he didn't see it.

I suspect there's more than one version of this story.

messicliche · 20/07/2022 21:09

PantyMcPantFace · 20/07/2022 21:02

The day before sports day itself, an email was sent around to all staff (after school hours, approx 2.5hrs after school ended) noting that all staff are expected to wear normal formal attire.. So the email arrived at about 4.40pm then? Probably still within the bounds of working hours. And as PP had said - staff would have all probably checked emails before heading out for work - just in case a last minute change of plan.

So it does sound to me as if he has been caught deliberately ignoring and explicit instruction. No quick email from him to check it meant him...no - he just decided to ignore it.

Whether or not it was a sensible instruction is irrelevant here. He didn't bother to check.

I wonder if your DH has form for doing things the way he wants - and this was just a straw on the camel's back?

Sorry DH shouldn't be allowed to tell stories - he left school at 330/4 so 2.5 hours was after the time he left. i.e. after 6pm.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 20/07/2022 21:08

RTFT. He did not see the email as it was after the curfew of emails (6pm). So he was unaware until he showed up in the morning at 630am. So no, he didn't choose to ignore it.

Um, I did read the whole thread. He wrote...

The day before sports day itself, an email was sent around to all staff (after school hours, approx 2.5hrs after school ended) noting that all staff are expected to wear normal formal attire.

Maybe naively, I automatically ignored it as I had seen the sports day support schedule and I was scheduled to be outside. As a result, I wore what I deemed 'appropriate attire' to support with this, think, sports shirt, shorts, appropriate trainers.

Cue the next day, turn up on site, instructed to go home and change into the professional dress that was directed the day before.

That reads to me that he did see the email the day it was sent, he decided to ignore it, the next day he turned up and was sent home. You're saying he didn't choose to ignore it but he actually does say that that is exactly what he did. ”Maybe naively, I automatically ignored it". I can't see anywhere that he's changed that story. Have I read it wrong somehow?

messicliche · 20/07/2022 21:06

@NeverDropYourMooncup DH was unclear, he ignored it when he saw it in the morning at 630am. The line manager spoke to him at 730am on the way to a morning meeting. It was irrelevant either way as he was at school when he read the email and home is still 25mins each way.

If any one is wondering, I had to drop off a suit and shoes for him during my working day!

OP posts:
PantyMcPantFace · 20/07/2022 21:04

And I agree with yout DH and many PP - daftness to be in formal wear. But if you have a tricky relationship with your manager/head FFS don't just unilaterally chose to ignore it. a) Check if it seems daft and b) find another job somewhere he fits better.

PantyMcPantFace · 20/07/2022 21:02

The day before sports day itself, an email was sent around to all staff (after school hours, approx 2.5hrs after school ended) noting that all staff are expected to wear normal formal attire.. So the email arrived at about 4.40pm then? Probably still within the bounds of working hours. And as PP had said - staff would have all probably checked emails before heading out for work - just in case a last minute change of plan.

So it does sound to me as if he has been caught deliberately ignoring and explicit instruction. No quick email from him to check it meant him...no - he just decided to ignore it.

Whether or not it was a sensible instruction is irrelevant here. He didn't bother to check.

I wonder if your DH has form for doing things the way he wants - and this was just a straw on the camel's back?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2022 20:56

messicliche · 20/07/2022 20:29

RTFT. He did not see the email as it was after the curfew of emails (6pm). So he was unaware until he showed up in the morning at 630am. So no, he didn't choose to ignore it.

The head does not just shrug his shoulders, he is quite notorious for this and as his wife who hears the brunt of it every day, I wasn't surprised when he told me.

I forgot to add - someone (probably the other woman who did the same thing) challenged the time the email was sent as being after the agreed hours for emails (their school day is early 750am-210pm, so 6pm is far outside of hours and this email was sent after 6pm) he then sent a passive aggressive email to the whole school stating that the 6pm curfew does not apply to him. Found that funny.

That doesn't wash with the statement that he automatically ignored it.

Maybe naively, I automatically ignored it as I had seen the sports day support schedule and I was scheduled to be outside.

Deciding that instructions for all staff don't apply to you is different to then claiming 'Oh, this came a bit late, I'll say I didn't see it'.

Bet he'd have read the email if it had been saying 'due to the Red warning for excessive heat, the school is closed to staff and students on Monday and Tuesday of this week' - even if it had come through at ten o'clock Sunday night.

RoastingMarshmallow · 20/07/2022 20:31

As a teacher (PE) and previous SLT, I'd say it's 100% time to find a new job because who on earth tells their staff on sports day to wear formal attire and then treats a staff member like that?! All of our staff and children wore PE kit for sports day this year and that has been the case in all schools I've worked, not just this one.

I'd contact my union as their job is to advise on the next steps. I would also write a letter, copied to HR, asking for clarification about why I received the letter of professional conduct so that I could respond to the points in writing to defend myself.

Absolutely do not let DH meet with the headteacher unless an outside, impartial person is present as this headteacher is clearly not rational.

messicliche · 20/07/2022 20:29

MarshaMelrose · 20/07/2022 20:18

He's a senior leader who received an email about what he should wear but he decided to ignore it. What normally happens at the school when staff are told to do something and they decide to ignore it? If the head normally just shrugs their shoulders and does nothing, then I'd definitely challenge it, with the head first.

RTFT. He did not see the email as it was after the curfew of emails (6pm). So he was unaware until he showed up in the morning at 630am. So no, he didn't choose to ignore it.

The head does not just shrug his shoulders, he is quite notorious for this and as his wife who hears the brunt of it every day, I wasn't surprised when he told me.

I forgot to add - someone (probably the other woman who did the same thing) challenged the time the email was sent as being after the agreed hours for emails (their school day is early 750am-210pm, so 6pm is far outside of hours and this email was sent after 6pm) he then sent a passive aggressive email to the whole school stating that the 6pm curfew does not apply to him. Found that funny.

OP posts:
Sunbun19 · 20/07/2022 20:26

Lolliepoppie · 20/07/2022 19:15

You knew that the dress code was formal attire and deliberately ignored it. Then were unhappy when they asked you to change into…formal attire.

Unless you were running races, you didn’t need sports gear. A light dress or blouse and tailored shorts would be just as cool?

Chalk it up to experience and move on.

It's op husband 😂

cansu · 20/07/2022 20:26

They sound barking mad. Find another normal school to work in.