Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"School is just not a good fit for all children"

171 replies

Postcovid · 20/07/2022 17:14

Do you agree? My DS is finishing Year One, and although he is bright, has a good work ethic and concentrates well on his set tasks, he just resists a lot of the conforming needed and when asked to do simple things like put his coat on before going out to play, or especially when moving on from playing to a work task (his class use a carousel format, so of course some tasks/games are more fun than others). His teacher has to count down/threaten to remove gold stars, and he always eventually makes the right choice but rarely the first time.

At home he is always asking "why" when asked to do something or not to do something. When given an explanation, he usually complies. However when he asks "why" in school, of course his teacher doesn't have the capacity to answer every time. I've spoken to him about this sort of thing at length, explained it's the teacher's rules in the teacher's classroom, that he must do as she asks etc. He tells me sometimes it's when something will be boring, he says he doesn't want to.

FWIW yes we have considered neurodiversity and he has recently been referred for assessments, but we will be waiting years. And also yes, I fully understand it makes the teacher's job tricky when she has 29 other children to teach. But on the flip side, I understand not wanting to conform all the time, and not to do things without trying to find out the reason. I'm hoping it'll stand him in good stead in terms of not succumbing to peer pressure when he's older. But I feel that more and more, schools expect 30 children to act like robots and conform to everything on demand.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 20/07/2022 18:24

I’d also follow the natural consequences route of ‘well you can leave your coat here but you will get cold’ rather than ‘you need to do this because I’ve said so’.

And then what about when you’re outdoors with a class of 6 year olds and James (who complains and refuses any task he doesn’t fancy) starts whining and crying about being cold? March every other child back inside to get their coat? Have a member of staff do so, leaving one person responsible for every child? Leave him to suffer his natural consequences and let him tell his mother (who remarks that he usually ‘makes the right choice’ after some level of argument with his teacher and complains that school is forcing him to conform) that he was left outside on a cold and rainy day with no coat?

Realistically if a teacher is saying ‘get your coats please’ they aren’t doing it for a laugh. If every student didn’t want to listen and argued back constantly there would be literally no time left for learning.

eatingapie · 20/07/2022 18:22

@wordler absolutely agree with you, I lost a longer post that said the same! School is a blunt instrument really. It’s the most efficient way the state can educate a large number of children at once but is it anybody’s vision of an ideal leaning environment- I don’t think so. I did this as a opening for CPD once - imagine your utopian school- and yeah nobody came up with ‘a really big building filled with kids of different ages who all do the same stuff regardless of interests or ability’.

Peawigeon · 20/07/2022 18:21

You are being completely reasonable.

Frankly it's blindingly obvious something so rigid and broken cannot possibly suit every child. No brainer.

collieresponder88 · 20/07/2022 18:21

So you homeschool him and he eventually gets a job and his boss asks him to do something You can't ask why you just have to do it ! You would be setting him up for a fall there

NancyJoan · 20/07/2022 18:20

But I feel that more and more, schools expect 30 children to act like robots and conform to everything on demand.

Unquestioning automatons is not the alternative to 30 children who question every individual instruction or change of pace. Most NT children pick up social cues that it’s time to put on coats/line up/sit on the carpet with everyone else.

WesleyNeverDies · 20/07/2022 18:18

Of course not. Nothing is a good fit for everyone.

eatingapie · 20/07/2022 18:18

I work in SEND so I KNOW school
is not a good fit for all children.

I also think that giving a reason for an instruction is really important- otherwise why are you asking the kids to do it? Does he need his coat? Is is cold? Does he need it later? What purpose does it serve? If the teacher can’t think of a reason then that suggests to me it’s a pointless instruction. I’d also follow the natural consequences route of ‘well you can leave your coat here but you will get cold’ rather than ‘you need to do this because I’ve said so’.

I also don’t think kids who struggle with school are necessarily neurodivergent or have any specific SEN. Some just don’t like school. This always seemed like a perfectly valid viewpoint to me. This is why I work in a SEND department lol.

SherbertLemonDrop · 20/07/2022 18:17

Yanbu. I feel I made the wrong choice making my child go to school. He has never enjoyed it. I thought it was the only choice as I was a single working mum. It has been unfortunate for him that I was unable to homeschool.

pantherpie · 20/07/2022 18:16

Rayn22 · 20/07/2022 17:20

As an early years teacher I disagree! There is nothing wrong with an enquiring mind and that is good but there also has to be structure and organisation in the classroom.
Unfortunately we all don't have want to do things but that is life. I think we have gone the other way and are too quick to target a child for intervention when we just need to teach a little resilience.
We can't accommodate all children and if you feel there is a neuro diverse issue then you need to discuss that with the school teacher and senco for more support? Have school raised any issues?

I have autism and I agree with this.

The real world doesn't always make allowances. Life is a series of doing things you don't want.

He's young, but I don't think you'd be doing him any favours by expecting him to learn to do what you're supposed to at school as much as possible.

wordler · 20/07/2022 18:16

You'll get a lot of 'well it's how it is so he'll just have to comply' answers on here. And well, I guess that's true.

But I think we can also admit that if there was such a thing as an unlimited budget for education, and unlimited resources for parents, we would not choose to make children learn in big groups of 20-30 kids, with a rigid curriculum that is the same for everyone, or inside a rigid time structure M-F.

I don't think it's bad to admit that the current system is far from optimal and is also designed to churn out a compliant workforce while providing convenient childcare for the current compliant workforce.

Sherrystrull · 20/07/2022 18:16

I have taught ks1 for many years.

You may find that the increased structure in year 2 actually helps your ds.

I go through the timetable at the beginning of each day to ensure all children know what is coming and when. It helps all children to cope with the day.

A now/next board plus time countdowns should be an integral part of a ks1 classroom and it is worth asking the teacher if this is in place as you feel it would benefit your ds.

In terms of asking why. I encourage all children to question and enquire but also sometimes they just need to do as they are told and follow school rules. It is a balancing act with young children.

junebirthdaygirl · 20/07/2022 18:12

I am a Primary Teacher.
Some teachers are more dictatorial than others. And some children react to that. Other teachers seem to be able to ease into things and it doesn't invite a reaction. It's difficult to explain but l have seen both in action and how a certain child will react on both occasions. Perhaps next year he will find himself flowing easier with the Teacher.

worriedatthistime · 20/07/2022 18:11

@Mischance but those children may still want to join clubs and conformity is expected then as well , you can't run a club with kids doing what they like
Schools have a wide range if kids they don't all act the same
But simply being told coat on before going outside isn't a massive deal
Within our own homes surely most have some rules we expect our kids to follow

salmongrey · 20/07/2022 18:10

GoldenSpiral · 20/07/2022 18:04

It sounds like your precious little dumpling simply doesn't want to do the bits of school he doesn't fancy! Sometimes you have to do things you don't want to do, and your DC needs to learn that. It's part of life, including the lives of people that are successful or non-conformist as adults.

Did you read the bit about being referred for neurodiversity assessment? Nice bit of ableist narrative there.

As a SEN parent, mainstream school is very much not set up for all children. It can't be. We've has major success in an autism school where there is a huge amount of flexibility, support, child led education with a bucket load of therapy added in. My son was a bit like yours - and they have the time to answer all the whys while subtly helping him understand that these whys will carry on in many areas of his life later on.

declutteringmymind · 20/07/2022 18:10

I'm the nicest possible way, your son sounds like a bit of a whinger.

worriedatthistime · 20/07/2022 18:08

The you have the option to home educate but even if they join groups outside of school there will be rules and they will be expected to conform at times its part of life skills

UndertheCedartree · 20/07/2022 18:04

I agree school is not a good fit for all children. That is why I home educate my autistic DS.

GoldenSpiral · 20/07/2022 18:04

It sounds like your precious little dumpling simply doesn't want to do the bits of school he doesn't fancy! Sometimes you have to do things you don't want to do, and your DC needs to learn that. It's part of life, including the lives of people that are successful or non-conformist as adults.

MermaidSwimmer · 20/07/2022 18:00

The PDA society has some good resources for parenting a child like this which may help.

DDivaStar · 20/07/2022 17:58

No school won't suit all children. But the examples you give are fairly standard requests to get ready to go outside and move to a different activity. These would most likely be required in many situations in his young life, assuming he can simply refuse whenever he wants may just reduce his opportunities. Maybe enquire more on.why he is so hesitant and more opportunities, so sometimes he might find the thing he didn't want to do is actually fun.

BuffaloCauliflower · 20/07/2022 17:58

I’d recommend the book Changing Our Minds by Naomi Fisher, and Ken Robinson’s TED talk ‘do schools kill creativity’. I’m not anti school many do an amazing job, but it’s an unnatural environment that needs conformity to function and doesn’t allow children to learn naturally in the way they will when given half a chance.

We’ll be home educating

rainbowduck · 20/07/2022 17:54

Of course it doesn't.

I teach in a Montessori 6-12 classroom and we get a lot of children for whom the mainstream schooling hasn't worked out.

MargaretThursday · 20/07/2022 17:52

"Why?" isn't something that is something that it's always reasonable to ask and expect an explanation other than "because it's time to do that"-and if he's reasonably bright then he'll be able to work that out for himself.

If he's able to say:
He tells me sometimes it's when something will be boring, he says he doesn't want to.
then I don't think it's to do with "not to do things without trying to find out the reason" it's more than just he's refusing to do things he doesn't want to do.

Sometimes we all have to do things we find boring or we don't want to do. I'm sure my colleague didn't want to fill out that tax return this morning. It was boring.
He may be ND, he may not be, but sometimes you do need children to obey without long explanations. I remember one time when I had 5 children with me (2 my own-not a teacher, just friends) and I was very glad that when I said "we're going now, come on quickly" in the shop that they all came out without needing an explanation. The police came in as I exited, and I'm glad to report that none of them saw what was going on.

Kanaloa · 20/07/2022 17:52

I don’t think school is necessarily right for all children but neither is work and most of us need to do that. You aren’t compelled to send your child to school though - I’ve always told mine that it’s a great great privilege. And if you really felt it wasn’t right for him you are allowed to remove him and teach him yourself.

However, some things you’ve mentioned make me think your son needs to learn to adapt a bit too. A child leaving year 1 should be capable of hearing ‘coats on please’ and putting on his coat as asked. Learning to follow simple instructions without arguing/moaning/answering back is expected at his age. That, along with your ‘he usually complies/I don’t want him to have to conform/he eventually makes the right choice’ makes me think more than not being suited to the school environment he’s simply not used to doing as he’s told and can sometimes be rude/refuse to do things he doesn’t want to do. But in real life sometimes we have to do things we don’t want to do, don’t we? Those activities will likely be set up specifically to help him learn certain skills.

Bluevelvetsofa · 20/07/2022 17:50

One of my managers used to say that if you ask a class of 30 children to do something - to line up in the playground, for example and 29 can do it, but one can’t, you have to adjust the expectation to something they can all do.

I can see that that’s inclusive. I can also see the argument that there re things people have to do in life that isn’t necessarily their choice and that it’s a life lesson.