Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Renting when retired

84 replies

Blackbirdsinthgarden · 20/07/2022 15:24

I DO know some people have no choice whether or not to rent in retirement but would be interested to hear other peoples views. I was out at a social occasion a few nights ago with my friends, their grandmother, three adult young men, mid 30’s, their partners and 4 children. During the meal two of the young men (brothers) got into a heated discussion with their cousin (a young man of a similar age, with his partner - no children). The cousin and his partner were renting a property but were saving very hard for a deposit to buy a property. His cousins (both on decent salaries) both rent and guffawed the cousin and his partner for wanting to buy their own property. They laughed and said it “was a fools game”. Both had no intention of buying their own property and told said cousin they could rent a better house in a better location rather than buy. The cousin’s view was that, if he and his partner bought in a less desirable area, they may eventually move up the housing ladder and eventually own their own home and be mortgage free in retirement.

My own young adult children made sacrifices to buy and now have a mortgage on a property which they like, but not their dream home, so I was on the side of the cousin. The two brothers earn more than the cousin and have been offered help by their parents and grandmother for a deposit, but have refused, saying that, when they retire, the State/Government will pay for their rent through housing benefit. They told the parents/grandmother that they would still welcome the money though to go on holiday! (Which was refused, by the way!).

I was taken aback and before the discussion got too heated, the topic was soon changed and we enjoyed the rest of the evening, albeit with a bit of tension in the air.

Am I being unreasonable to think that the two brothers should have welcomed money towards a deposit and that they were being naive/arrogant to think that the State will fund their housing in retirement? They both, as reasonable earners, rent quite comfortably and prioritise expensive holidays/cars over everything else. Will the Government still be able to fund their housing in retirement? Apart from the State Pension, they said they have little private pension (a mug’s game apparently!) and that they would be entitled to pension credit.

Apologies for the rant but I feel they are quite blinkered! Who knows what benefits will be available in 30+ years time (if any). I know that some people will have no choice to rent in retirement, but at their age I would have bitten my family’s hand off!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheRealHousewife · 22/07/2022 10:01

I got on the property ladder in my 20s. Bought and sold a couple of times over the years. Not far of 60 and now mortgage free. Not assisted with any inheritance or hand outs. Going forward might consider selling and renting (rather than a formal equity release scheme) to free up equity.

Bunnycat101 · 22/07/2022 09:41

If they could have bought and are choosing not to I think they’re being very naive. Owning in later life provides a degree of security. by the sounds of it they won’t be paying much into a pension so not sure how they think they’ll fund their retirement. By then the state is unlikely to be paying to house then at the level they’ve been used to.

Also I would rather sell my home in old age to pay for decent care of my/my families choosing than be at the mercy of whatever the council choose to put me in. I’ve seen the difference with grandparents between a nice home and a more basic one.

Blossomtoes · 22/07/2022 09:22

SheeplessAndCounting · 22/07/2022 09:07

No the government will take the private pension as income and add it onto state pension so unlikely they will get any help. If the only had state pension they would get pension credit so would be no worse off than person with additional private pension

Surely that depends on the size of the private pension? Pension credit is not very much at all is it?

Maximum income from the state including pension credit is £182.60 a week.

SheeplessAndCounting · 22/07/2022 09:07

No the government will take the private pension as income and add it onto state pension so unlikely they will get any help. If the only had state pension they would get pension credit so would be no worse off than person with additional private pension

Surely that depends on the size of the private pension? Pension credit is not very much at all is it?

Adversity · 22/07/2022 08:56

It’s naive to think the system now will be the same in the future. Legislation and policies change all the time.

There is no milk and honey from any political party.

When I was a fresh faced 21 year old I thought I would get my state pension at 60, there were no tuition fees and child benefit was universal. All changed under successive Governments, the Labour Party introduced tuition fees, people always seem to forget that. There have been many other changes that affect society as a whole or just specific groups but all have a knock on effect.

When you rent you have no control whatsoever with how long you can remain in that property for.

@Babyroobs A perfect example of pensioners being asset rich cash poor was played out by my Mother and her sister. Both widows who lived till past 90. Mother sold her 4 bed house and bought a 1 bed bungalow with a small garden. Aunt remained in her 6 bed three storey house with enormous garden the size of two building plots. My Mother lived comfortably with no worries having freed up capital and with small running costs. My Aunt lived in a state of purgatory, freezing house, livedon the ground floor only towards the end, burnt herself boiling kettles as she would not put the hit water on but was deemed compus mentis so could do as she wished.

The main difference was personality, my Mother was always the practical type, Aunt was always a deeply sentimental soul. She raised her children in that home, her DH died in it and she couldn’t stand to leave.

HikingforScenery · 22/07/2022 08:52

If they could get secure tenancy with the council or a housing association, then I guess they’re right. Also it doesn’t sound like they’re going to have any children whose lives they’d like to better so why not?

The best of owning a home is the security element, to me.

Fuwari · 22/07/2022 08:47

I’m in a HA property and because of the size of the property and location (close to central London) it would cost close to 1mill to buy. I’ve seen other properties on my street on right move. There is no world in which I could afford to buy it. On my salary I’d need to move far out of London and massively downsize. I’m also lucky to have a secure tenancy. So for me personally it would make no sense to buy. I should get full HB in retirement and even if I didn’t, I can let out one room for nearly as much as the full rent cost (this is allowed, you just can’t let the entire property). As others have pointed out, I’ll have no repair costs to worry about. Being so central means I don’t need to run a car. My costs will be minimal.

Private renting is a whole different ball game. I’ve seen a relative have to move into ever smaller properties as rents have risen. They’re on minimum wage as they live rurally and not many job opportunities. They are entitled to some UC but the housing allowance is way below market rent. They also have the expense of running a car as it’s needed to get to work (dire public transport). No security at all. They are just surviving.

CallMeNutribullet · 22/07/2022 08:41

While I agree this person probably has a false idea of what their retirement will look like, there appears to be a moral value applied to home ownership.

There's nothing wrong with choosing to rent rather than making lots of sacrifices to buy a home you don't like in an area you don't like. Our obsession with buying property is what's driven property prices far out of reach for anyone on a below average salary.

Ponoka7 · 22/07/2022 08:22

@entropynow, email your Tory MP and ask him to throw in affordable housing into the leadership debates. Look upwards, not downwards when feeling resentful.

Ponoka7 · 22/07/2022 08:19

There's been a massive building of her over 55 housing in the county that I live in, so some councils are planning well for the future. We are Up North, so the thought of life in retirement for the majority isn't scary, we are used to low wages. I know a few self employed people who will have the equivalent disposable income on a state pension, with a small private pension top up, than they have now. Repossessions were up to record levels because of Covid and government policies. They are set to continue because of the cost of living crisis. The Tory's rely on the pensioner vote, hit the pensioners too hard and out they go. It's why pensioners wasn't subject to the bedroom tax. We are encouraging immigration from the commonwealth. Many of those will start paying into a pension when they get here, often in their 30/40's etc and won't get on the property ladder. There will always have to be state provision because of the structure of our immigration and welfare state model. Where we live houses start at £60k, so it makes sense to buy if possible, but not necessarily if property is silly money and your income may drop.

entropynow · 22/07/2022 07:58

@XingMing
Once and yet again I will point out that aside from NHS rare cases, the council subsidises, it does NOT provide care free. Everyone pays towards their care, from income if not capital. As a sw I got so fed up with 'they get free care, never worked, why should my relative have to spend capital' lines like this.

entropynow · 22/07/2022 07:52

XSnoe · 20/07/2022 18:16

My grandparents are retired and they live in a 2 bed housing association house with a little garden.

How nice for them. Meanwhile where I live the social housing waiting list has topped 3000.

VestaTilley · 20/07/2022 22:16

The two brothers sound rude, ignorant, ill educated and very naive.

There may be nothing but an absolute bargain basement state pension in 30 years, and it may be that people who earned well won’t qualify for pension credit (which probably won’t exist by then anyway).

If they’ve no house to sell, no private pension to live on and no big inheritance coming they are going to be screwed. To say nothing if either of them become too ill to work at a young age. Heaven help them.

Good on the cousin for having his head screwed on the right way.

Babyroobs · 20/07/2022 21:50

In my job I also see the other side of it. many pensioners who have bought their properties but can't actually afford to maintain them adequately because they only have state pension and maybe a small private pension coming in. Then they look to equity release schemes or the house falls into a state of disrepair and they really struggle. They can't afford walk in showers when they need it ( they may get a grant if they are lucky ), can't afford boiler replacements etc

Babyroobs · 20/07/2022 21:47

Ilikewinter · 20/07/2022 20:00

@Junipercrumble, I totally agree, both my aunty and MIL have social housing and want for nothing. MIL has passed now but as she had no savings when she was unfortunately ill she got all care and adjustments made to the house FOC, my aunty has recently has a new bathroom and kitchen fitted.

I dont begrudge either of them, they both worked throughout their lives and brought up families, however what happens to those that cant secure social housing, theres no way on earth you can privately rent on a state pension.

There are many many pensioners in private rented accomodation. I do know this as I deal with them every day. If they just get state pension they would likely get a significant chunk of their rent paid for by claiming housing benefit. It does depend on state pension amount of course as with any means tested benefit.

Babyroobs · 20/07/2022 21:43

SarahSissions · 20/07/2022 16:12

It’s absolutely fine to rent when retired, but you should be aware that most pension calculators assume that you will be mortgage free and have no housing costs. If you plan on renting then you need to plan to have a pension to cover your ongoing housing expenses

People with just a state pension will likely get most of their rent covered by housing benefit. Pensioners in receipt of even a pound of guaranteed pension credit get their rent and council tax covered in full. Not sure whether the local housing allowance rate still applies, I assume they can't live in a house in a very expensive area and have it all paid for.

XingMing · 20/07/2022 21:33

I really really don't want the government to be able to tell me where I can live in retirement. It's nobody's business but mine, as long as I can buy it outright or afford to rent it and pay the bills.

For the sake of the thread, I will add that I don't believe that anyone believing in a comfortable retirement funded by the public purse is anything other than a deluded donkey. My 90-y-o demented DMIL has a limited existence, for which she is paying £975 per week (over £4000 per month) for accommodation, food and care. But she is well and kindly looked after, which can't be taken for granted. But it is her money that funds her care and subsidises the residents for whom the council pays.

Cornishclio · 20/07/2022 20:47

We always wanted to own our own property to give us stability but being mortgage free in retirement is a bonus. Our children have taken the same path so I agree with you. The brothers are being naive that benefits will pick up their rental bills in retirement. It will probably be a one bed flat in an area not of their choosing. Who wants to rely on government funding in their old age with no or little say of their own as to where they put you? As for turning down their grandmothers offer I think they will regret it. People who only live for today usually regret it as they get older as I guess they don't have a private pension either

MsPincher · 20/07/2022 20:46

mumwon · 20/07/2022 17:30

@BMW6 actually pensioners do get charged bedroom tax if they are in private rentals as opposed to social housing or council housing

Pensioners aren’t “charged” anything. But they do need to pay their rent and will only get housing benefits to cover the size they need if they are in private rental.

Dreamwhisper · 20/07/2022 20:17

I don't know enough about the truths of renting vs buying in the UK housing market. I know overseas the pros of renting are more evident but that's because normal houses aren't quite the insanely expensive commodity they are here.

I hope there are some pros to renting as it will be decades be before I can even think about buying.

However they need to rethink their idea of accommodation - this could change in 30 years I suppose but as far as I know, if you are single with no dependents you don't get housing benefit for anything above a shared room, and as others have said there is a bedroom tax too. Plus a large element of HB is again, geared at people with dependents and I think the rate drops a fair bit once you don't have school aged children living in the property.

I'm hoping the system will change in future as it is quite worrying, but I simply can't afford to pay private rent and look after my kids well and save for a future different home. One of those things always has to be sacrificed and as you can imagine, it's the non tangible thing that will always go first.

MsPincher · 20/07/2022 20:07

BMW6 · 20/07/2022 15:47

Well the State will not pay the whole rental for a house of their choice now let alone in future!

Have they not heard of the "bedroom tax"?
And if they are reliant on the State where are these landlords in the private sector who are prepared to rent to them over a working person?

They sound niaeve

Pensioners dont have their housing benefits reduced for under occupancy (ie no “bedroom tax”).

DelilahBucket · 20/07/2022 20:05

They are being extremely naive if they think that renting when retired will be this amazing thing. My mum is a pensioner, and despite being mortgage free she struggles to get by. There's no way she would be able to cover any rent costs.
Our plan had always been to be mortgage free as early as possible. I do not want a retirement featuring scrimping.

MeanderingGently · 20/07/2022 20:04

It depends on choices, doesn't it.
I rent and will be doing so right through retirement. I will only have a state pension but I can live on that quite happily.

Of course, there's no saying how things will change in the future, and in 30 years' time the economy may well be very different.

However, you don't have to own your own home to have a good retirement. But I do not consider living on a state pension to be the "government paying for my rent". It isn't, I paid my national insurance all those years for it.

Ilikewinter · 20/07/2022 20:00

@Junipercrumble, I totally agree, both my aunty and MIL have social housing and want for nothing. MIL has passed now but as she had no savings when she was unfortunately ill she got all care and adjustments made to the house FOC, my aunty has recently has a new bathroom and kitchen fitted.

I dont begrudge either of them, they both worked throughout their lives and brought up families, however what happens to those that cant secure social housing, theres no way on earth you can privately rent on a state pension.

JamMakingWannaBe · 20/07/2022 19:53

Do the brothers have partners or was it just the cousin with a partner who was looking to buy?

Swipe left for the next trending thread