Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That accessing a medical appointment shouldn't involve so many barriers and that there should be more recognition of the need for privacy?

66 replies

HarrysRedPants · 20/07/2022 13:34

It's AIBU, I'm expecting a flaming, and I'm not posting for anything other than a rant but here goes.

I need to make an appointment to go to the GUM clinic. I won't go into details but have had some ongoing issues but due to the amount of stress I've been under and having felt unable to face my fear of going (I've been several times in the past but I'm anxious this time) I have put it off. I really, really struggle with medical stuff, particularly anything intimate. It takes a lot for me to even build up to making the call.

I found the courage to phone the clinic this morning. The last time I phoned around a year ago I was able to speak to a receptionist when I called, give a few details and then get booked in to see a female doctor. This time, it's answerphone only, leave a message, they will phone back, then a telephone consultation with a dr will be arranged in the first instance. So I left the voicemail, hoping they would phone back whilst I have privacy and an empty house. I have been browsing on my phone all morning and no call has come through- has gone straight to voicemail. I checked my settings and no reason why the call shouldn't have come through. So I've had to call back, leave another voicemail and am waiting again for a call that will hopefully come through this time.

Except I now no longer have an empty house, I live in a relatively new build with paper-thin walls and have no privacy. I don't want to have a conversation about intimate, personal medical problems when my family might hear. I totally get why they need to ask for a few details but when it was possible to speak to someone initially before, and not have to leave a message, it made it much easier for people who struggle for privacy or are working etc to choose a better time to phone. At the least, why can't there be an option to give details over email? There is absolutely nothing that allows this. Plus there is now the faff of having to have left two voicemails , I still haven't spoken to anyone and no idea when I will actually be able to have a physical appointment.

I just don't think it should be this difficult or that there should be so little regard in this day and age for the fact that it can be really difficult to pick up the phone in the first place and this feels like extra barriers. And so little regard for privacy. I've been thinking maybe I won't bother as a result.

I know there are people really struggling with far worse experiences within the NHS at the moment and that it seems trivial in comparison. I just don't understand why the appointments system for this bit has to be soo much worse than just under a year ago.

Rant over.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
riesenrad · 21/07/2022 08:57

Our surgery you have two options - either it's urgent and you need same-day appointment and you have to call at 8.30am - or if it's for a routine appointment then you can get an appointment about 2-3 weeks hence. There is nothing in between

that actually isn't bad though - a lot of people would settle for being able to book for 3 weeks time. But we can't get a face to face at all at our surgery anymore, you have to be called back. Or you do the e-consult and they will either telephone you, or call you in. To be fair, the e-consult works really well, but it's a convoluted form and has lots of irrelevant questions. I have filled them in for both my mum (who got a face to face in the end) and my DH (who just wanted a referral, so doctor phoned him back and discussed and then made referral).

Dreamingor · 20/07/2022 18:35

YANBU at all.
I routinely avoid calling for help with issues I need to for months on end due to the complexity of getting through to the point of speaking to the people you actually need to and then justifying yourself repeatedly. I just don't have the energy for all of it.

(I'm not lazy, I have genuine health conditions that leave me so drained I often struggle to even speak.)

Last time I forced myself to go thorough it all, the doctor then told me I needed to call again to book another appointment for it as they couldn't deal with it. That was around 18 months ago and I still haven't called back.

I'm a former health care professional and acutely aware of how overstretched and underfunded the NHS is, but that can't be blamed for poor management which seems to be the case at many points throughout the service.

99victoria · 20/07/2022 17:56

I had a similar situation recently. I actually got through to my GP surgery and they said they would get a doctor to ring me back. I asked if they could give me an idea of the time and they said no but it would definitely be after 12 noon. I work in a school so it's difficult to just pick up the phone. As it turned out they rang back at 10.30am! I had to stand out in the corridor giving all my private details while staff and students walked by. Then it turned out I was talking to a trainee doctor and she was concerned about something I said so she said she needed to talk to one of the other doctors and she would ring me back in the next half hour. I explained that I simply couldn't come out of the room again in half an hour as I was delivering a training session and had already walked out to take the initial call. The whole systems sucks 😡

Hamster1111 · 20/07/2022 17:15

I completely agree OP. The call back system means you have to talk when called, no matter where you are. I had to talk about my unusual discharge in the school car park the other day, because the GP called back whilst i was on the school run. If I didn't answer I would have had to call again at 8am, wait 40 mins etc etc for another call back the next day and so it goes on. I overheard another poor mum discussing her HRT on the phone to the doctors the other day too. You're absolutely correct that this system of calling back has no regard for privacy at all.

justagirlstandinginfrontofcake · 20/07/2022 16:52

It could be that their receptionist is off sick or on holiday which is why you have to leave a message. Unfortunately there is no money in the NHS to pay for cover on these occasions like they would have done previously.

When they call back, say "I think I may have BV, could I email you the details please".

FictionalCharacter · 20/07/2022 16:33

@dreamingbohemian That’s how it used to be in the UK.They switched to “telephone triage” and it all went to hell. And the shortage of GPs has made it far worse.

FictionalCharacter · 20/07/2022 16:28

SpindleInTheWind · 20/07/2022 15:04

It's awful and completely user-unfriendly and if you are hard of hearing/deaf/autistic/have other barriers to phone communication I don't know what happens.

To be brutally honest, mass exclusion.

My last GP phone call, I couldn't hear what she was saying for most of the phone call. My voice-to-text tech couldn't make sense of it either - the text just turned to gobbledegook.

A relative who has ASD won't talk on the phone but would possibly go in for an appointment with his usual GP with support in place; but he can't get an appointment in the surgery without first talking on the phone, which he won't do because of his autism.

Mass exclusion is absolutely correct. I am hearing impaired too and phone consultations with the GP are a nightmare. That’s after entering the 8AM telephone lottery to get a phone appointment in the first place, which means usually 45 mins on hold then a conversation with the receptionist that I can’t hear properly. Then I have to wait potentially all day for the call back from the GP, which I can’t hear properly. If they say the GP will call in the morning or before 1PM, the call can sometimes come in the late afternoon instead.

I usually take a leave day from work because I can’t risk the call coming when I’m at work or on public transport. Like a pp I’ve waited all day for the call and been told by the surgery that they did call and I missed it, which is impossible because there were no missed calls on my phone which I was in any case watching like a hawk all day.

I have all the technology available to help me hear but it isn’t enough for me to hear most phone calls when I can’t see the person speaking. GP surgeries can’t or won’t understand this, or don’t care. The result is that I put off this whole ordeal until I’m completely desperate. It’s a horrible system for some patients and those who run the surgeries have no empathy with people who have difficulty with it.

NoHaudinMaWheest · 20/07/2022 16:01

GP phone appointments are a real difficulty for us. Dd is autistic and can't process what people say on the phone - she even avoids phoning me. This means that she needs my support whenever she has a phone appointment. So we have to schedule them at times when we are both able to block out a whole morning or afternoon. As Dd is a student and I am a carer for her and her brother, it isn't impossibly difficult for us but can still be tricky. If I wasn't available I am not sure how she would access health services and as she has a number of medical conditions this is necessary fairly regularly.
As she has very few face to face appointments it means she doesn't get the chance to become comfortable with a familiar GP. Which in turn reduces the likelihood of her being able to manage appointments independently.

dreamingbohemian · 20/07/2022 15:27

That sucks @maranella
Who started this 8.30 am malarkey and why is it allowed? It's crazy.

I can't fault my current GP, they're pretty good, but I've needed some referrals lately and it just seems crazy to me, waiting for a letter and then having to call 50 times to reschedule.

Nat6999 · 20/07/2022 15:22

If it's BV I used an online pharmacy after doing a home test, cost £22 for antibiotics which were delivered next day by post.

maranella · 20/07/2022 15:17

It's a total mess @dreamingbohemian and it seems that every GP surgery operates slightly differently. Ask your friends what happens at theirs and you'll be amazed at the variety of awful systems out there.

Our surgery you have two options - either it's urgent and you need same-day appointment and you have to call at 8.30am - or if it's for a routine appointment then you can get an appointment about 2-3 weeks hence. There is nothing in between!

dreamingbohemian · 20/07/2022 15:10

I mean this is what happens in the other countries I've lived in:

If I need a GP appointment, I call the office, someone answers the phone, I ask for an appointment, and she finds something for me in the next few days.

If I need a referral, the GP sends it by email to the specialist, I call them a day or two later, and make an appointment.

It is not bloody rocket science and I do not understand why it keeps getting more and more complicated in the UK despite all the new technologies.

dreamingbohemian · 20/07/2022 15:05

YANBU

I genuinely don't understand why the whole appointments infrastructure in this country is so messed up

Appointments made by post, I mean it's ludicrous. So you never get the letter, or you need to change the time but no one ever picks up the phone, then they have the gall to complain that so many patients don't attend their appointments.

Endless rounds of callbacks, needing to call in a 5-minute window at 8.30 am, doctors expecting you to be able to take calls all day.

Think of how much time and money is wasted when you could just do what others countries do and hire a proper number of receptionists with a good scheduling software

SpindleInTheWind · 20/07/2022 15:04

It's awful and completely user-unfriendly and if you are hard of hearing/deaf/autistic/have other barriers to phone communication I don't know what happens.

To be brutally honest, mass exclusion.

My last GP phone call, I couldn't hear what she was saying for most of the phone call. My voice-to-text tech couldn't make sense of it either - the text just turned to gobbledegook.

A relative who has ASD won't talk on the phone but would possibly go in for an appointment with his usual GP with support in place; but he can't get an appointment in the surgery without first talking on the phone, which he won't do because of his autism.

HarrysRedPants · 20/07/2022 15:01

@Madamecastafiore as @AtomicBlondeRose said I don't think you're reading my posts properly. There is no expectation for them to ring me at a convenient time. I'm happy to phone them and wait for it to be convenient for them to answer the phone and if that means calling a few times then that's fine by me- I've no complaints over that whatsoever.

You say I could say to the admin staff it's not a convenient time to speak- well how is that helpful to them either? And how on earth will the appointment ever get made? I actually try to avoid having to not speak when they call as I'm aware they're busy etc.

As it goes, they called me back, luckily at that moment I had privacy and was able to explain to the receptionist the problem- she was great as I have always found them to be- and I was surprised that they could actually offer me an appointment tomorrow afternoon. So from that perspective, that's a brilliant service and I'm grateful for it.

OP posts:
riesenrad · 20/07/2022 14:56

So what, you either wait for the holidays or take a day off if you can do that just to wait for a call

and if you do do this, you are criticised on MN for being a Gen Z snowflake www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4593371-overly-sensitive-employeesapprentices?page=9&reply=118667276

riesenrad · 20/07/2022 14:54

Madamecastafiore · 20/07/2022 14:30

girlmom21 because it is ludicrous to expect someone to be available to call you when your neighbours aren't at home. And sometimes it's cost effective and therefore a better use of nhs money to be able to just listen to voicemails and ring people back than having to have a 20 minute call where someone explains stuff to you that they have to be quick and succinct about on a voicemail.

Ha ha. Voicemails are totally inefficient. People ramble on and don't get to the point (and only say their phone number once, I always say it twice in case the person doesn't get it the first time). Online booking is much more efficient. E-consult is good except that they ask lots of irrelevant questions and it takes longer than it should to fill the form in.

MarmiteCoriander · 20/07/2022 14:53

OP, I would ask the actual GUM clinic why they don't have an email option, have to leave a message etc etc and if they have a better system for booking? Live chat for example?

  • Could you attend another GUM clinic that has a walk in service?
  • Could you see your GP or practice nurse? My GP has an online form I can complete, with as much or little detail as I choose, and they will call back
  • Speak to a pharmacist in their private room and buy a BV kit
SpindleInTheWind · 20/07/2022 14:51

Ponderingwindow · 20/07/2022 13:54

The call backs never work. I am inevitably in a meeting or driving or otherwise unable to answer the phone.

its impossible to sit by the phone for 8 hours or even multiple days doing nothing but waiting.

I've had texts at 6.05pm to say that the GP tried to call twice during the day but I didn't answer ... but there's nothing at all showing on my phone as a missed call or a voicemail.

Only ever happens with my GP surgery, no-one else. Bewildering.

It's not a good or effective system and I think the NHS generally needs to start accepting more communication outside of phone calls within 10-hour windows, using secure systems.

HarrysRedPants · 20/07/2022 14:47

AtomicBlondeRose · 20/07/2022 14:42

Systems where they call you at some random time of their choosing are an absolute nightmare for so many people. I’m a teacher so I know it is from our point of view (can hardly take a call and have a conversation about medical issues in front of the class! And even if you could step out for five minutes finding some where private while you’re on the phone and worrying about your class is just super super stressful) but I can also imagine hundreds of other jobs that would make it very hard to do as well. So what, you either wait for the holidays or take a day off if you can do that just to wait for a call? It effectively shuts a huge swathe of people out of medical care or forces them to pay for some sort of private treatment. I’ve been buying my contraceptive pills privately (legitimately!) for years since I realised that way I can click and get them delivered to my house rather than wait around. A GP was once gobsmacked that I’d pay rather than get them free but avoiding the pissing around every 6 months was worth £15 to me.

Agree with all of this.

I also don't see how it can be efficient for the NHS and admin staff either when they end up unable to get hold of people- who's phone signal has dropped out, who have had to take their kids to school, who work in jobs where they can't take a call easily, who were desperate for a wee and miss the call cos of that!

OP posts:
AtomicBlondeRose · 20/07/2022 14:47

Everyone is misunderstanding the OP. She doesn’t expect them to call at a time that is convenient to her, she’s expecting to be able to call them and get it sorted out there and then rather than this backwards and forwards. I’m sure she’d be prepared to call a few times if she knew someone who could help would pick up eventually. Not too much to ask as for years this exact system has been in place.

Madamecastafiore · 20/07/2022 14:43

Sorry miss understood thought the fact that you were concerned about the thiness of your walls meant the neighbours could hear but regardless of whether it is the neighbours, your parents or kids, it's simply not feasible for the clinic to only be able to call people when it's convenient for them.

Step outside, go into the bathroom, ask for some privacy maybe??

Could you really not say you're not in a private place and can't go into details at the moment?

You may have one person doing all these call backs and if everyone has an issue why they can't walk into another room or the garden it makes a process that could take an hour, phoning back everyone who has left a message, take all day and when you've 50 phone calls to make, 30 lots of patient notes to update and samples to send off it means things don't get done and it impacts other areas of practice.

AtomicBlondeRose · 20/07/2022 14:42

Systems where they call you at some random time of their choosing are an absolute nightmare for so many people. I’m a teacher so I know it is from our point of view (can hardly take a call and have a conversation about medical issues in front of the class! And even if you could step out for five minutes finding some where private while you’re on the phone and worrying about your class is just super super stressful) but I can also imagine hundreds of other jobs that would make it very hard to do as well. So what, you either wait for the holidays or take a day off if you can do that just to wait for a call? It effectively shuts a huge swathe of people out of medical care or forces them to pay for some sort of private treatment. I’ve been buying my contraceptive pills privately (legitimately!) for years since I realised that way I can click and get them delivered to my house rather than wait around. A GP was once gobsmacked that I’d pay rather than get them free but avoiding the pissing around every 6 months was worth £15 to me.

LuckyLil · 20/07/2022 14:42

I agree. Aside from the voicemail problem which is just bad luck, they should instinctively know exactly what time your house is going to be empty and only call you back at that time. It's just not good enough.

Ilikecheesycrackers · 20/07/2022 14:38

My GP surgery has a thing where you fill in an online form to request a routine appointment. It works really well- they've always got back to me quickly. Frees up the phone too for those who can't manage other technology.

Would be good if this system could be applied elsewhere in the NHS.