Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH obsessively closes windows all year round. AIBU to be annoyed about it?

145 replies

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 09:52

This is non-heat wave specific. This is a year-round problem.

DH is obsessed with shutting all windows and doors. As soon as I walk through a room, he is trying to shut the door behind me and gets grumpy if I say how weird it is. Saying about conserving heat blah blah blah.

Even this morning - when we finally we got some more cool air outside, I went to open our big back doors onto the garden and he said - "Oh the air is a little cool, let's just keep them shut and the house will cool down naturally throughout the day" (The house is still 30 degrees this morning)

WHAT???

If I open a window, he closes it. It feels infuriating. He says our house is cold and I'm being weird.

I mean - it's really bloody annoying but I guess he has the same right to have it all closed as I do - but this morning was evidence I think that this is psychological rather than him being cold.

He's quite anxious and can have depression - and I think it may be related. It feels like he's trying to keep us all in somehow.

Anyone ever had this with a partner? And am I stretching it somewhat to think closing windows is about mental health??!

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 20/07/2022 13:21

If an open window person lives with a closed window person then the only fair solution is compromise.

JugglingJanuary · 20/07/2022 13:16

Allywill · 20/07/2022 11:30

i am obviously in the minority as i hate windows and doors open too - husband opens them and i shut them. i find it lets flies/moths in, and he has a terrible habit of leaving windows open and going out/going to bed which i feel is very insecure. not sure why one persons desire for open windows trumps another’s for closed ones

Because houses need fresh air!

and why should 'closed' get their way??

@SomeLikeItWhat

I couldn't live with a window & door shutter!

my bedroom windows are open 24/7 unless I'm away on holiday (I close them to narrower openings in winter, but they're still
open)

my front door is open from
when I get up until I go to bed (unless I'm home alone & I close it when
I go in the shower) it's a small open house & I can see it from everywhere except the bedrooms/bathroom. It's also on a fairly private lane)

I love having the skylight open, I usually open it when I'm in the shower (it's in the bathroom) as it's like showering outside😀. But due to the unpredictable weather, I sometimes close it after my shower.

when I renovated I opted not to have the new doors hung in most rooms, I like the open flow.

my great Aunt thinks having the windows wide open isn't 'proper' so hers are only ever open 'a crack'.

my bf thinks it's odd to have them all open, especially the door, it makes him uncomfortable, sometimes I shut the door, sometimes he just has to live with it, or piss off home where he sits in the muggy lounge, whining about it being too hot 🙄🙄

this is only one of many reasons we won't ever live together

if I were you DH. Would have to go & talk to someone until he stopped insisting on being locked up like Fort Knox or we'd need to go our own ways, I'd feel claustrophobic with him shutting everything (as well as majorly pissed off!!)

EverybodysALebowski · 20/07/2022 13:12

If he's going to listen to that Ben Shapiro shit, he needs to invest in a pair of headphones or ear buds. It's inconsiderate to have something on that one's partner doesn't want to hear. Bluetooth headphones are cheap.

My dad went through something similar when he was about 10 yrs away from retirement. Complete with long explanations of why store brands were better. I agreed with him (as did my mom) but the lecturing behaviour was very annoying, as if he'd just discovered that life is expensive and had to tell us all.

I do wonder if this is a sign of something bigger mh-wise that needs looking after. Is he worried about his job or your family income? He might have good reasons for being worried, but needs to learn healthy ways to express and act on those worries. The eating the same thing repetitively and other stuff might also hint at some anxiety or at least anxiousness.

(Obviously no one in this thread is a professional afaik and we shouldn't toss around diagnoses. But any big change in behaviour is worth examining and understanding.)

It sounds like he's being very tight about money but a few private therapy appts a month could make a huge difference. Even if he doesn't have anxiety or something similar, a temporary outlet for understanding his worries could be well worth it.

ApplesandBunions · 20/07/2022 13:09

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/07/2022 13:00

It’s not all about the twins though is it

they might not be bothered but you are

you deserve a holiday

Exactly, and there are plenty of inexpensive 3 year old friendly holidays to be had in the UK. A few days at a caravan park in term time shouldn't rush you more than a couple of hundred if that's his concern.

maddening · 20/07/2022 13:01

Mine opens them all year, perhaps we can swap?

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/07/2022 13:00

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 12:43

@ApplesandBunions - Not a 2 week holiday to the Maldives, but a week in France or something - yes. I get that taking 3 year old twins on holiday isn't a walk in the park..is is really worth the money when they don't really care...but I feel stuck at home all the time. Haven't been away since 2018. I know there are bigger problems in the world but guess all adds up to me feeling a bit trapped.

It’s not all about the twins though is it

they might not be bothered but you are

you deserve a holiday

CombatBarbie · 20/07/2022 12:59

Is the household more prone to illnesses because its not being aired? I love opening the windows to get some fresh air circulating.

Hotenoughtoburnasausage · 20/07/2022 12:57

Do you have access to your own funds op?
I would be buying my own roll of kitchen roll to make him watch me use it how I liked....
If you haven't you need to change that ASAP.

skybluee · 20/07/2022 12:55

I just wondered as he says your house is cold butthe more I read the more that sounds like a cover for something. It sounds like he feels more secure with everything shut up. I agree with you, it's more healthy for things to be open and fresh air to get in. I agree with the poster who said that maybe you could take him on a night out (or meal out) and have a few drinks and see if he relaxes and goes back to the old him. I'm sorry you're in this situation, it sounds stifling and if someone followed me around doing that it actually wouldn't be the windows that bthered me, it would be the control issue.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/07/2022 12:54

My exh was like that about kitchen roll! Maddening when you’ve got a little one.

He would say “use a sponge” or “use a mop” if it as on the floor. I’m quite happy to do that as well afterwards if it’s something sticky - and often do now I’m on my own with the kids (which is bliss btw) - but you can’t dry up liquid with more liquid!

stuntbubbles · 20/07/2022 12:52

If it weren’t for your updates I’d have asked if his initials were TC. My ex boyfriend was like this, he wouldn’t even let me have a window open if he wasn’t in the room in question, in case he wanted to be in the room in future and the air/a chill had got in. I’d be lying on the bed with a lovely breeze going and he’d come in, announce, “You don’t need that open, don’t worry, I’ll just do it”, close it, lock it, bugger off again. So miserable. Houses need air! Part of the horribleness of the heatwave was that the windows had to be closed to keep the heat out and there was no relief; the joy unconfined when it rained and the temp dropped and I could air the house!

Meraas · 20/07/2022 12:47

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 12:35

@MurderAtTheBeautyPageant Imagine...trying to fall asleep in a room with all the windows shut and listening to the whiney voice of Ben Shapiro spouting nonsense coming out of your partner's phone while you're trying to sleep

THIS IS MY LIFE.

AHHHHHHHHHHHH.

It sounds miserable. Why are you with him?

madasawethen · 20/07/2022 12:46

If he's listening to US right wing nutters, that would affect his mental health.
Increased fear, paranoia, the government and liberals are out to get him, and so on.

skybluee · 20/07/2022 12:46

If your house was 30C you'd surely want it to cool as quickly as possible so what he said doesn't actually make sense (it cooling naturally over the day/a few hours). Is he unwell and feeling the cold or is it related to saving energy and money, that has somehow gotten misconstrued or out of hand (at 30C you really don't want to be keeping heat in and surely you won't need to put any heat on for weeks - depending on where you are of course).

Spanglemum · 20/07/2022 12:43

Sounds really difficult OP. Anxiety, whatever its cause, does make people very controlling. Also the meal thing, are you short of money? Do you do it to him? I think he needs to see the GP.

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 12:43

@ApplesandBunions - Not a 2 week holiday to the Maldives, but a week in France or something - yes. I get that taking 3 year old twins on holiday isn't a walk in the park..is is really worth the money when they don't really care...but I feel stuck at home all the time. Haven't been away since 2018. I know there are bigger problems in the world but guess all adds up to me feeling a bit trapped.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/07/2022 12:43

Oh and someone else controlling the doors and windows would drive me potty - much more so than the fact of them being shut in itself

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/07/2022 12:42

I absolutely literally could not live with this. If someone kept shutting me down about a topic the way your DH is doing to you, I couldn’t live with that either.

i am very claustrophobic and even reading this makes me claustrophobic. I can’t cope with all the doors shut - I like the doors open unless there’s a reason for it - like at night or when I’m in my “office” working.

I wouldn’t want the kitchen door shut when I’m cooking or sitting room door shut when relaxing.

i love an open window. Both at night and during the day. It’s much better for the house to get some air through it too.

ApplesandBunions · 20/07/2022 12:37

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 12:25

@LuckySantangelo35 I think you're right. I need to make an effort to help him relax a little perhaps.

To be honest - I find myself daydreaming about being free of it all - I want to tile the bathroom (waste of money according to him), I want to take the kids on holiday (too much hassle and waste of money). He cooked dinner last night telling me how much he'd saved on each item by going own supermarket brand.

I mean - I get cost of living - but I feel like i'm not living at all.

Maybe I'm too lax.

I can't cause all the disruption to our DS because my DH is too careful with money or likes to keep the windows shut. But it feels stifling.

I'm pleased some people get it. He's made me feel like I'm being way OTT about it all.

Are you in a position where you could afford things like a holiday?

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 12:35

@MurderAtTheBeautyPageant Imagine...trying to fall asleep in a room with all the windows shut and listening to the whiney voice of Ben Shapiro spouting nonsense coming out of your partner's phone while you're trying to sleep

THIS IS MY LIFE.

AHHHHHHHHHHHH.

OP posts:
PuntasticUsername · 20/07/2022 12:35

Tbf, I'm an absolute dick about kitchen roll. I don't like waste in general, and I don't like using disposable kitchen roll to clean up, when most of the time you can use a cloth instead and then rinse it out or throw it in the wash if necessary. Kitchen roll is for times when you really do need to throw it away after (eg something really unhygienic) or for wiping fat out of pans so it doesn't go down the sink.

But I do recognise that this is MY issue, and I generally manage to bite my tongue at the absolutely profligate kitchen roll habits of my beloved family. I expect someone will come along to remind me about water use as well, which I hadn't actually factored in, and may now have to think about 😳

I think I WAS within my rights the other day to say "umm..."at DH, who was wetting a piece of kitchen roll to clean up some sugar spilled on the table. You can just sweep dry sugar into your hand. Why would you purposely MAKE SYRUP on the TABLE. It's upsetting me right now to think of it.

Oh OP yanbu btw, I'd find your husband's habits difficult to live with too.

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 20/07/2022 12:31

Oh God. I could not be with a man who was a Ben Shapiro fan.

Nopety nope.

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 12:28

@19Bears Ah - I've read your posts before about your DH & your challenges with him. I did see one post about you saying your DH watching Ben Shaprio videos. Sorry to sound like i'm stalking you but my DH watches Ben Shapiro so much - and therefore it stuck in my mind as never came across anyone that watches him before. Weird similarities.

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 20/07/2022 12:26

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/07/2022 12:23

@Nc830

better that than a stuffy stinky house

I realise this thread is probably going to draw disproportionate responses from those of us who like a lot of fresh air, but I think never having the windows open is pretty extreme. Most people probably do it at least sometimes.

SomeLikeItWhat · 20/07/2022 12:25

@LuckySantangelo35 I think you're right. I need to make an effort to help him relax a little perhaps.

To be honest - I find myself daydreaming about being free of it all - I want to tile the bathroom (waste of money according to him), I want to take the kids on holiday (too much hassle and waste of money). He cooked dinner last night telling me how much he'd saved on each item by going own supermarket brand.

I mean - I get cost of living - but I feel like i'm not living at all.

Maybe I'm too lax.

I can't cause all the disruption to our DS because my DH is too careful with money or likes to keep the windows shut. But it feels stifling.

I'm pleased some people get it. He's made me feel like I'm being way OTT about it all.

OP posts: