Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to send this text message..

137 replies

Littlelollipopxo · 20/07/2022 09:45

We have two DS 7 & 1.5, Currently NC with MIL & FIL and all of partners family, happened in last 12 months and atm there is no intention of reconciliation on either side.

MIL & FIL currently live down south, we haven’t seen them since the Christmas period, which is when the NC with them happeneD, so they haven’t seen either DS since then.

however, they will randomly FaceTime DS’s iPad to speak to them (this has probably happened once a month since Christmas) they don’t text to give a heads up or ask if it’s ok for them to speak (don’t ask if we’re out or their having tea or visitors or whatever)

They did this last night, DS came running over to us with iPad (we had friends over) saying Nanny was on phone, I said ok go and sit inside so you can speak to her properly (phone call lasts about 5 mins then that’s it till next time)

would I be unreasonable to send a text asking for a heads up when they plan on FaceTiming, or do I just let them keep randomly ringing?

I get we don’t speak atm and for context I have never stopped them speaking/seeing DS’s neither has partner they have simply chosen not to and have 8 other grandchildren who they still see etc.

so yeah thoughts please:)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WinterMusings · 21/07/2022 11:08

@Littlelollipopxo

as I said previously, they have caused enough of a problem in your lives that NC seemed to be your best solution.

I get that you don't want your Dc to resent you cutting contact with them, but you have to do what's BEST for your children. When he's older but still a child he might ask & you can give him further age appropriate explanations. older than that you can be much more forthright.

the thing is, you know she thinks it's her right as a grandmother to xyz. What happens when before long she's inviting him to stay & likely bad mouthing you. Or allowing him to do stuff you wouldn't.

your DC do not need a relationship with people who have treated you & DH so badly you've gone NC, they just don't.

just block them ON DC devices,you youngest us too young to know/care and your eldest, if he even notices or cares, can simply be told they must be very busy, but as HE never asks to call them I doubt he'll be that bothered.

id put a stop to it now, before it causes real issues.

LampLighter414 · 21/07/2022 00:12

They would have been deleted as a contact/blocked/app removed from iPad as soon as it first happened for me.

Mamai90 · 20/07/2022 23:35

Veebees26 · 20/07/2022 10:03

I agree, it's crazy to me the amount of shit people get just for making different decisions to what some commenters think they should.

Ultimately if the OP believes it to be in the best interests of her children to still have contact with their GPs then that is her decision alone, she hardly deserves a load of crap for it from folk that haven't a clue about her situation or the circumstances.

This all day long.

There are some right sanctimonious twats on mumsnet.

A580Hojas · 20/07/2022 23:35

How do you propose your parents in law have a relationship with your children when they don't have one with you?

NightyKnight · 20/07/2022 23:30

Littlelollipopxo · 20/07/2022 22:25

@NightyKnight wow thankyou that was very helpful and some good scenarios! I think the second option may work best in setting healthy boundaries etc, I see your point about the NC in the future that I wouldn’t want him to think that’s the default answer to everything because it isn’t.

thanks :)

You're very welcome! You've got this!

Littlelollipopxo · 20/07/2022 22:25

@NightyKnight wow thankyou that was very helpful and some good scenarios! I think the second option may work best in setting healthy boundaries etc, I see your point about the NC in the future that I wouldn’t want him to think that’s the default answer to everything because it isn’t.

thanks :)

OP posts:
NightyKnight · 20/07/2022 21:21

So I've read most but not all of the thread and I can see both sides, though I think some people could have been gentler with how they phrased their opinions...

Basically what we're talking about here is boundaries.

And first off I'm going to point you in the direction of a brilliant book (series for every scenario), called Boundaries by Dr Henry Cloud and Dr John Thompson. I have no vested interest but I'm a coach and I have used their books as tools in my work and in my home life A LOT!

One analogy they use is that boundaries are like a fence around your property with a gate. You get to decide who comes in and out.

For some people they don't trust the fence and gate, so they build castle walls, complete with drawbridge, moat and possibly a fiery dragon to keep people out!

However, you can make something so secure and well protected that no one can get in and that can have negative consequences. I think this is what you're worried about with regard to your DS.

A couple of hypothetical scenarios for you...

A) You continue as you are, GPs randomly call up on the iPad without any agreement or concern for timings etc. Let's say this carries on going til DS is 13,14 yrs old. DS now has the idea that when GM calls he has to answer no matter how inconvenient it is, as he has never learned a clear boundary that phone calls are for the receiver's benefit and can be at their convenience. Now DS wants to share about their new love interest (assuming they still have a good rel with GM)... but this person is someone GPs don't approve of (fill in the blank...different race, background, different gender to expectation)...GM expresses shock/horror etc and says no this won't do at all. DS talks back. GM cuts him off as he isn't doing what they approve of (I think this is kind of what you alluded to that there is no room for alternative views or choices?). Regardless DS is now hurt and upset by seemingly loving GPs reacting negatively to him having an opinion and a boundary about what is okay in his life. Now...unfortunately you have to step in to protect your child, and probably have the same arguments with the GPs as you had before you went NC.

B) You take this opportunity to sit your DS down and explain that phone/video calls have to convenient for the family as a whole, so now you're going to ask GPs to schedule calls. You also let GPs know you will be present, if out of sight.

Here you start, very simply and gently to set up the idea of healthy boundaries. As DS gets older you can start to talk about what they need to do if someone says something that makes them feel ick or sad inside...come talk to mum and dad, and let's work out what your needs are here, let's work out what kind of a boundary is going to help you feel better, safer, more confident in future, and let's find a way to do this in a respectfully assertive way.

C) You choose to do what some PPs have suggested and go fully NC.

Initially DS may be confused, wonder why GM doesn't care any more, but not enough to ask, so it leaves a slight nagging doubt that maybe they did something wrong. Maybe you explain that the GPs upset you and you have chosen this route. Just check in with yourself, what message does that send? If you upset your child later, is that their first reaction, to go NC because that is what was modelled and they don't know any other way of setting a healthy boundary? I think you are also concerned that down the line they may be upset with you for not giving them the chance to have that relationship with them.

I am NC with my brother for about 5 yrs now, so don't think for a moment that I am questioning that aspect. I just think this could be a good ongoing opportunity to teach your DS and eventually both your DCs about setting and enforcing healthy boundaries little and often. I understand what people have said about them being toxic, but your LO is too young to understand that, and at the moment their ability to introduce that toxicity into DS's life is very limited indeed so I don't think you are doing anything wrong by allowing it. It is your choice ultimately.

You are also entitled to change your mind one way or another down the line, in order to work out what is healthy, what you are willing to allow, and what is safe.

I have had to work extremely hard with my parents, especially my mother, on what are acceptable boundaries, both with me and my son (14 yrs). Unfortunately for her now, her constant overstepping, not listening, subtle guilting, shaming etc means that my son is unwilling to spend more than the briefest time with her. We go to lunch with them, have a pleasant, fairly superficial, but safe time, and then we leave when my son has had enough and wants to go. I still gate-keep a fair amount as my son has some SEN, predominantly anxiety.

Someone did suggest I went NC with both my parents, to see if that helped my son. I considered it, but my dad is 76, and for me I couldn't live with cutting him off in order to distance my mum. I did set stricter boundaries with her, I do sometimes threaten to hang up on her when she won't let something go (but I do know it is only because she cares and is desperate to help...but her controlling nature makes it hard and A LOT!), and we have upped and left when she wouldn't calm down or let something go (dog with bone), but I try to do it calmly and firmly, and then explain to my son why we needed to do that. My hope is that my son will have a much much better understanding of how to keep himself safe as he grows up than I did, and also know that I am there for him and will protect him, even from my own parents if necessary. It's harder, but I think it is worthwhile. Over time she has got better at self-policing, and she knows much more clearly what I will and won't tolerate, and the same with my son. I don't think she will change her underlying beliefs that drive some of the unhealthy behaviours, but that's not surprising as she is 70, and has no interest in therapy or improving her emotional intelligence.

Sorry, that's long and I didn't even say if you are BU or not! I think it's more complicated and nuanced than that, and you and your son deserve better than a simple yes or no.

As for sending the text, you could simply write, you are busy with activities and holiday plans and whilst you accept the GPs calling, you would like them to schedule a regular time so you can build it in at a convenient time. You would suggest xy day and time. If this is not acceptable then you will be removing the GM's email from those which will be accepted by the tablet for incoming calls.

HTH x

5128gap · 20/07/2022 20:44

My mum didn't speak to her mum either. They had an argument, and neither wanted the relationship to continue, so they never made it up. As adults they simply didn't like each other and (perhaps sensibly) didn't think their blood relationship required them to suffer each other's company. Today they would no doubt be described as 'NC'.
I had an excellent relationship with both. Neither was perfect and as I got older I could see how their characters were simply not compatible. On one hand a very sensitive woman who got easily upset, on the other an overly blunt one who didn't see the need to mince words. But both good women with considerable strengths.
No doubt had the expression been so popular then, they would have described each other as 'toxic'. But in truth, they weren't, it was their dynamic and relationship that was.
Few rifts are entirely the fault of one person's 'toxicity' (and yes, of course there are exceptions, like abuse) but often behaviour that is intolerable to one person won't necessarily pose problems for everyone they encounter.

Horological · 20/07/2022 16:58

I know it's a difficult thought to imagine, but It is highly likely that some people on this thread will eventually be on the receiving end of NC by their adult children at some point in the future. Instead of vengeful fuming I think people should think more about what NC actually is.

Being able to go NC is one of the good things about the modern world that people (especially women) understand that they are allowed to have boundaries, that they have the right to call out bad behaviour, toxicity and abuse. Going NC is a brave and necessary thing to do if anybody in your life has not treated you well. The thing is though, going NC is about asserting your own boundaries. It is to protect yourself and make your life as you need it and want it. But, it's not a punishment to the other person. The other person almost never 'learns' anything from being ostracised, in fact they often redouble their toxic behaviour as a way of retaliating. There is therefore little to be gained by insisting that everyone you associate with is also NC unless (of course) the toxic behaviour involves eg. child abuse or other illegal behaviour.

My grandparents were very poor parents to my mother and so she was NC with them, but I did have some contact. As I child I learned from my mother that people have the right to go NC, and that was a very important life lesson. I understood that my grandmother had a very unpleasant side to her her which was a combination of trauma she had suffered as a child and a total ignorance what children needed to thrive. So, I learned that many (if not most) adults are capable of good and bad depending on circumstances. My grandmother was awful to my mother (no doubt) but as she grew older and learned how to behave better when under less pressure she proved to be harmless ocassional company for me with the added bonus of keeping me connected our family heritage (language, food, history etc). This is absolutely not to minimise how she behaved at all but to acknowledge that many people behave unforgiveably with some people and at some point in their lives, but not always and forever.

I think that is a really important thing to know because it applies to every one of us. We are going around thinking we are decent people but at some point it is quite likely that somebody in our family will tell us what we have done wrong. Humans are complicated.

Nursemumma92 · 20/07/2022 15:24

@KettrickenSmiled haha ill happily be called a self appointed prefect if that means I'll call out people launching attacks at others. Life is not black and white and whilst I don't necessarily agree that I would allow contact with relatives we are NC with, I have a very difficult MIL and know that these situations are not clear cut. Just think you need to back off and choose your words nicely rather than make allegations and assumptions when you haven't read what the OP has actually put.

LittleOwl153 · 20/07/2022 15:10

I think the big question is where this goes in the future. Would there be an expectation that your youngest gets involved? At which point you or dh would have no choice but to be more involved...

Also what do you envisage this contact with the 7yr old being when they are 10, 12 and at secondary, 15 and u0set about something at home? What happens when he says granny says she wants to see him so is coming to pick him up and he can stay a few days? You need to really consider what this looks like in the long run. I can see why it happened as you probably didn't intend for the NC with you and your husband to be long term but it is getting that way now so if there is no resolving you need to consider what happens with the dc contact.

To answer your question, no I don't think granny should be able to rule when contact is and certainly don't let it be a pattern but I don't think your solution works. Just say no to dc. Cut granny off if necessary, put the ipad away and do something else when a call is expected that you don't want....

KettrickenSmiled · 20/07/2022 14:48

Nursemumma92 · 20/07/2022 13:52

You cannot possibly judge whether someone is a 'poor parent' from a MN post. At no point is he unsupervised and you'd see that if you read the OP's post. He also doesn't have a device that anyone can call him on- just his parents and GP's.
Family situations can be extremely complex, and whilst it can be difficult to understand why you would let your DCs have contact with toxic relations, it can also be harmful to a child's wellbeing if the relationship is cut and they don't understand, in situations where the GPs pose no risk and have conversations once a month that are listened to.

Really no need to be rude and provocative with your words.

So nice to meet a self-appointed Prefect @Nursemumma92

Why keep cheerleading for a mother who allows her 7 year old facetime calls on his ipad, because it's "only" his grandmother, who is so abusive to his parents that they've cut her out of their own lives?

If someone was so abusive to you that you had to go NC with them, why on earth would you allow them contact with your child?

HannahSternDefoe · 20/07/2022 14:15

Littlelollipopxo · 20/07/2022 09:55

@fuzzkin only me , dad and MIL have his email to do this

Change his email address, keep it private (you and DH) and block them.

If they don't want to speak to their SON then why should they have any access to their Grandson?

Itsbackagain · 20/07/2022 14:15

Given it's a rare call I would think you were looking for an argument to do send that text. If it's not a suitable time to accept a call then I assume your child wouldn't have their ipad? On another note why on earth do you permit contact with people who you believe are toxic? Eventually they will be toxic to your son and/or in a couple of years you won't be beside him all the time to hear what's going on. We are NC with MIL and that would include my DC until they were old enough to make their own decisions

Littlelollipopxo · 20/07/2022 14:12

@Nursemumma92 thankyou

OP posts:
IWentAwayIStayedAway · 20/07/2022 14:09

you block them, they don't get to speak to your children

Nursemumma92 · 20/07/2022 13:52

KettrickenSmiled · 20/07/2022 11:53

There's nothing wrong with pointing out inconsistency & poor parenting.

OP describes her inlaws as toxic & damaging - but she not only allows them to facetime her 7 year old, she is considering breaking her NC in order to communicate when that contact is convenient.

It's insanity.
If the inlaws are too toxic for 2 adults to handle, why is OP exposing her child to them? And unsupervised?

You cannot possibly judge whether someone is a 'poor parent' from a MN post. At no point is he unsupervised and you'd see that if you read the OP's post. He also doesn't have a device that anyone can call him on- just his parents and GP's.
Family situations can be extremely complex, and whilst it can be difficult to understand why you would let your DCs have contact with toxic relations, it can also be harmful to a child's wellbeing if the relationship is cut and they don't understand, in situations where the GPs pose no risk and have conversations once a month that are listened to.

Really no need to be rude and provocative with your words.

essex42 · 20/07/2022 13:31

I/we have some experience of this. My FIL is an EXTREMELY difficult man and my DH and his brother often had big fallings out with him when they lived at home. MIL, now dead, was lovely. We had a huge argument with him when we were staying there when our sons were small about 30 years ago. They live in the south. We live in the north. We left immediately and DH didn't speak to his father for a couple of years because of what he had said. We never visited again until about many later and then it was only to stay a night pre a Heathrow flight. FIL wasn't the sort to keep in touch with our boys but MIL was and she continued a good relationship via phone calls and letters. Way before the days of video calls. Our sons are now grown up and have a much better relationship with their grandfather than DH and his brother ever did. He has mellowed somewhat at 90! It would be my advice to allow your son to continue his contact with his grandparents as long as it is positive. I wouldn't have wanted our sons to have missed out on the relationship they have now. They go and stay with him when they are working nearby and, although they also have occasional big rows, they very much value and appreciate their grandad even though we all know he is an awkward old git! 😉

DisforDarkChocolate · 20/07/2022 13:14

You describe these people as toxic, you know at some point it you son disappoints them he'll be cut off.

Why are you letting them have contact with your son?

Also, I think its just another way to control you.

HouseInTheHills · 20/07/2022 13:11

Horological · 20/07/2022 12:51

This is such an odd thread.

I don't understand why people posting are so confidently asserting that it HAS to be the case that it would be harmful for your in-laws to have contact with your DCs. OP, nobody on here knows your in-laws, only you know them and only you can judge.

It is perfectly possible for adults to behave badly to some people but not others. My grandparents were very poor parents to my mum ('toxic' in todays' language) but were really kind and lovely to me. My mum was NC with them but I had separate contact. I was able to understand from quite a young age that people were complicated. And that's the truth about people. Real life is not an episode of East Enders with goodies and baddies in constant battle with each other.

OP you didn't post for advice about whether you should allow contact with your DCs, you have already decided that you do allow it. And that's fine because only you can judge the situation, not strangers on MN. The dilemma you really wanted an answer to was how the contact is managed. I think you should carry on as you have been. Tell your DCs that they need to tell you every time they get in touch and that you will decide at that time whether to answer, delay or ignore.

But can you not see how messed up that is. They treated your mother poorly, but were lovely to you? That’s not the behaviour of lovely people.

If someone treats me badly, they don’t have access to my children. They have the potential to treat my children badly or they may be doing it do manipulate.. It’s not normal. Why be toxic to your children but kind to grandchildren. That in itself is toxic. It very, very fucked up.

Obviously, there’s a world of difference between not getting on with your parents and them being toxic.

madasawethen · 20/07/2022 13:10

It's hard to know what to say if you don't say what the falling out was about?
You said toxic, but what does that mean?

SizzlingInTheBakingHeat · 20/07/2022 13:08

I don't understand why you'd let them have a relationship with your children if you aren't speaking? We fell out with my husband's family a while ago, they don't get to have a relationship with our children, absolutely not, our eldest is 6. Why would you allow that? You aren't NC if they are ringing your child anyway. If you are NC block them.

villamariavintrapp · 20/07/2022 13:04

But what if they called when you weren't in the room? By allowing them to speak to your children you're teaching them that these are safe and good people. How will your children know that that's not the case if they call one day when you're out? Or if they bump into them in the street? Your children will not know that the relationship they've built up with their grandparents is only 'safe' because it's been supervised under strict conditions, because you haven't told them that.

Littlelollipopxo · 20/07/2022 12:59

@villamariavintrapp they only speak to them when I’m in the room, I wouldn’t allow them to go off and talk to them

OP posts:
villamariavintrapp · 20/07/2022 12:57

Like most other posters I can't understand why you're letting them have contact with your children. Your children are trusting you to protect them, and teach them how to judge people, and behaviour, and how to manage relationships. It's very confusing that you have cut contact (presumably due to much more than a 'fallout') but consider them good people to have in your children's lives. Have you told your children that they must only speak to their grandparents in front of you?