Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about Rainbows

234 replies

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 08:57

As a guide leader and as a mother I find this worrying:

girlguiding.foleon.com/guiding-magazine/guiding-summer-2022/rainbow-girl

OP posts:
CallingOnAvengingAngels · 20/07/2022 14:15

I think the other issue which would mean we wouldn't get mass resignations is that there is another group of volunteers who would also roll their eyes at this and say they don't believe in it - but they are also the volunteers who see most stuff that comes from HQ as "Woke Nonsense" or "Policital correctness gone mad", they tend to ignore most of what comes out at National level and carry on exactly as they've done for years. Eg, they would say they don't agree with this - but they also don't agree with the majority of changes in Girlguiding over the past 30 years, and they get around that by ignoring them. So they wouldn't quit over this as they haven't quit over all the other things they don't agree with, like the programme updates, changing the Promises, Brownies Camping, etc.

( in my opion only, I know there is a huge variety of leaders, volunteers and units, etc etc)

RebeccaCloud9 · 20/07/2022 14:11

It is ridiculous and I totally disagree with the ideology.

But in reality, it just isn't an issue. It's all just made up bollocks trying to show how woke they are. But how many of you have actually come across this in real life? I certainly haven't (as a teacher or a parent).

And if the situation ever arises where one poor little boy who likes dressing up gets forced by a bonkers parent allowed into Rainbows, it's the boy I'd feel sorry for.

Now, boys allowed in girls' rooms on Guide camp is another issue, but for Rainbows? Meh.

DisappearingGirl · 20/07/2022 14:01

There are some boys who like all the things that society thinks are for girls but know themselves to be boys, and there are some who feel like they are girls inside

This is one of the things that worries me about this whole debate. I don't think there is a definite line between these two concepts and I don't think it's something a child can decide.

There will be many boys who feel feminine and like "girly" things (and girls who feel masculine and like "boyish" things). Some will change their likes and dislikes as they grow up. Others will accept themselves as a feminine man (or masculine woman), of which some will turn out to be gay. And a (historically) very small percentage may decide as adults that they want to transition, which I have no problem with as long as they have enough life experience to fully understand the downsides.

But current thinking is pushing any feminine boy, or masculine girl, down the trans path.

BlueWhat · 20/07/2022 13:54

Thank you applekate and other leaders expanding why you don't want to leave.

It must be heartbreaking to volunteer for an organisation that you love so much and know you will probably have to leave.

But there is 2 of you on here that say if you leave your unit will close. And I get that is awful, but if 10 of you or 100 of you or 1,000 of you leaders all leave at the same time, surely it would make an impact and cause them to reassess their safeguarding issues.

I do see you are between a rock and a hard place letting your guises down and being worried about the safety.

So awful it's come to this, I have so many happy memories of the Brownies and guides.

womaninatightspot · 20/07/2022 13:47

DockOTheBay · 20/07/2022 12:18

I also find out baffling that it's socially unacceptable for a boy to wear a dress but it's suddenly socially acceptable to do so if he changes his name and grows long hair.

This. I think we should work on breaking down "gender based norms" it's fine for children to want to wear a dress etc. Rigid sterotypes are confusing for children, let them play/ dress up/ have a childhood without needing to conform.

Butchyrestingface · 20/07/2022 13:47

The stereotyping in that article. 🤯

Like reading something from the 50s. The 1850s.

Hadalifeonce · 20/07/2022 13:43

It used to make me so frustrated when DS was little , as people would comment on the fact he had a doll, and liked pink. Many times I had to say that boys can play with any toy or wear any colour they like, it's adults who have the problem. Now this madness is rearing it's ugly head again, I see many father's caring for their children. Lots of men wear pink shirts/shorts, nobody is telling them they are women; what on earth possesses parents to think they should start 'supporting' their children to live any other way, than the way they are, whether that's a cat, dog, princess or train driver, at that moment in time.

CallingOnAvengingAngels · 20/07/2022 13:42

I haven't left because my unit would close, and then those girls would be missing out totally - similar to other posters I have been involved since I was a Brownie myself, I genuinely believe that the worldwide Guiding / Girl Scouting movement is a force for good and I want to stay part of it.

I did sign the letter in The Times ages ago, I believe if I were to raise it again with HQ directly I'd be asked to change my thinking or have my membership removed, as has happened to others.

I have considered moving to Scouting but I think the girl only space is really important, so while I can maintain that at my local group level, I will.

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 13:39

BlackForestCake · 20/07/2022 13:35

Is Gg a democratically structured organisation? Is there any way for leaders to get rid of the sex-denial fanatics?

No it isn't.
Believe me HQ know how leaders feel- and have made it clear we will be kicked out if we say anything.

OP posts:
justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 13:35

I'm glad I'm not the only one horrified by this.
I've been in guiding for over 50 years, a leader in all sections except Rainbows. I know no guiders in our area who are in favour of this policy.
Most cannot speak out in real life because we would be forced to leave and have repercussions in careers etc.

It's not because we hate trans people- like most I hope they can be free to live their best lives - but not at the expense of the right of women and girls to do the same.

That poor child- of course Rainbow should have been allowed to play with dolls and wear the pretty sparkly dress- my grandson spent months happily prancing about in an Elsa dress with flashing sparkly shoes. It didn't mean he was really a girl. Now he likes other stuff (dinosaurs) but he's still not keen on cars and trains. Still a boy.

OP posts:
BlackForestCake · 20/07/2022 13:35

Is Gg a democratically structured organisation? Is there any way for leaders to get rid of the sex-denial fanatics?

AppleKatie · 20/07/2022 13:32

@BlueWhat i ask myself that most days.

I don’t pretend I’m powerful enough to force other leaders into also leaving with me though.

And if I go, my unit will close. And then 100 years of continuous guiding in that unit will cease. And all those opportunities all that history will stop.

For what at the moment is theoretical- there aren’t any trans members in my group.

I will ask the parents though (I am working up the courage, it’s already on the list for sept) and I will feedback when it’s done. I also contributed fully and anonymously to a recent equality and diversity survey by Gg.

mamamelons · 20/07/2022 13:30

"Children don't think they can change sex unless the adults around them lie to them. There is nothing kind about lying to children."

What complete nonsense. Having been through this with my child at a young age I can assure you they are not lied to. They are told they can be who they are and we will accept them. In our case I showed my son lots of "feminine" males who wear dresses and told them that boys can like "girly" things too etc etc. It was not a quick change it happened over years of open discussion. The decision is led by the child not the parents.

Ikeepbuyinganimals · 20/07/2022 13:30

Because we currently have full units of girls getting amazing opportunities and life skills, making lots of friends, recovering from lockdown life. And until the scenario arrives on the doorstep (it undoubtedly will) I will give as much energy as i have spare to them because eventually I won't be able to and there won't be this kind of space. My unit is the same, other leaders will follow me out the door.

Clymene · 20/07/2022 13:29

@Eeksteek - 80% of children who think they may be the wrong sex desist ie they grow out of it. Unless their parents take them to a gender identity clinic which is a one way street to lifelong medication for most.

Dinnertime22 · 20/07/2022 13:27

I agree with BlueWhat. Pull them out.
I could not send her there and be comfortable anymore. Such a shame as the leaders were fantastic.
There are other groups to join.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 20/07/2022 13:26

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 13:21

That's scary. Because apart from anything else, what happens in a few years, when he starts going through puberty? Is he going to be allowed to drop all the girl stuff, or is he going to be pushed into puberty blockers and hormones? It's child abuse.

If he get anywhere near mermaids or the tavistock, odds are that it will be puberty blockers (off-label drugs not developed or tested for this purpose, let's remember) and then cross sex hormones. Then a lifetime of drug dependence and surgical intervention. All because a little boy wanted to play with dolls and wear pretty clothes.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 13:24

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 13:21

That's scary. Because apart from anything else, what happens in a few years, when he starts going through puberty? Is he going to be allowed to drop all the girl stuff, or is he going to be pushed into puberty blockers and hormones? It's child abuse.

I’m not sure why you feel ‘children’ are ‘pushed’ into this. Can you elaborate? Who pushes them? ‘Why’? I’m not goading and it’s a common attitude, but it puzzles me. I’m not trans and don’t have trans children. I’ve no skin in this game and no agenda. I just want to understand better where people are coming from.

myyellowcar · 20/07/2022 13:24

An 18 month old identifying with female toys and characters. What the actual fuck have I just read. Have these people just made this up? I had an 18 month old who identified as a Stagecoach bus most of the time. The fact that this is taken as a sign that this BABY was the wrong gender is absolute madness.

BlueWhat · 20/07/2022 13:22

@AppleKatie I promise I'm not being goady, but why don't you leave? Why don't you ALL leave?

Then they would HAVE to sit up and take notice.

By staying aren't you being an (un)willing accomplice?

Why don't you ask the parents why they won't send their daughters to camp? Send it up to HQ, if no one is complaining why would they change?

I'm genuinely interested in your views.

I was offered an interview for a very well paying job there, but I just couldn't accept the interview and told them why.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 13:21

That's scary. Because apart from anything else, what happens in a few years, when he starts going through puberty? Is he going to be allowed to drop all the girl stuff, or is he going to be pushed into puberty blockers and hormones? It's child abuse.

BugsInTheBed · 20/07/2022 13:18

Its quite telling that the parents were worried about playing withb"girls toys" at 18months.

Fgs let toys be toys and all that.

Why does guides have to be for dresses and femme stuff. Will they chuck the butch/tom boy /whatever girls out!?

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 13:16

Ducksinthebath · 20/07/2022 09:02

It really is.

At five I was convinced I was part horse. Thank goodness my mother didn't let me live in my "true" identity.

But it was totally acceptable for you to go around being part horse. Presumably you no longer do. However, the only acceptable way for a boy to wear a dress is to be a girl. So that’s what’s happening. I wonder if the treatment of small children playing with gender stereotypes were treated the same as them trying on other play identities, and not either instantly needing to be formally and permanently labelled as transgender or repressed as unacceptable. Presumably, your parents indulged you being part horse as far as practicable, and didn’t assume it would follow you into adulthood?

Maybe if we just all chilled out a bit over it, it wouldn’t be such an issue. You can’t compare it to being, say, part-horse, if you are treating it very differently. By making such a big deal out of it, we are forcing it to be more of an issue. (I’m sorry, this is very poorly put. I can’t seem to drill down what I mean properly.)

BugsInTheBed · 20/07/2022 13:16

Youre right. A smaller organisation for those that like wearing dresses and doing craft and cake decorating 😔.

It had such a unique place in society it really could have been at the forefront of things for women/girls but it wont be.

Clymene · 20/07/2022 13:16

mamamelons · 20/07/2022 12:50

The comments in this post have left me so angry. For those that read the full article, why are you so hateful? A little girl that knows who she is and parents who support her. God forbid! Unfortunately until you go through something like this with your own child you will never understand, that's why people are being educated on the subject. It's hard enough for young people transitioning so why not try understanding instead of spreading hate and fear.

Children don't think they can change sex unless the adults around them lie to them. There is nothing kind about lying to children.