Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about Rainbows

234 replies

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 08:57

As a guide leader and as a mother I find this worrying:

girlguiding.foleon.com/guiding-magazine/guiding-summer-2022/rainbow-girl

OP posts:
OrangeIsTheNewBlah · 20/07/2022 16:11

YANBU

I would never have anything to do with any organisation that is so captured by this horrific ideological c*lt.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 16:08

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:44

I don’t know how anyone could be any more mature about it.

Well, they could have been more mature by being literally older. I hope and pray this was the right decision for this child, but the stories and the sheer numbers of detransitioners do not fill me with confidence. Have you looked at any of the detransition websites or interviews? Absolutely heartbreaking.

The parents should have put a stop to it. They did enable the child, sorry. It's their job to protect and defend their kid, they should have said no, no drugs, no hormones until you're an adult and free to make your own decisions. I know it's easy to say that and there's a lot of pressure on parents, but still. That's your job as a parent, to protect your kid.

I know they considered this. In the end, after agonising about it, they decided that to support the child emotionally was a better choice. That the suicide rate amongst young transgender people was so high, and so much reduced by having supportive adults, that they would rather face having a mis-gendered child, even if ‘disabled’ (for want of a better term) by the transition process, than a dead child, and that of the unthinkable should happen they would know they had done what they could for child. I know they bitterly wished they had a ‘normal’ child and I do not envy them
this process one little bit. It was heartbreaking to watch, let alone live through.

In the end, I think I would have made the same choice. It’s all very easy to say ‘they should’ It’s a lot harder when it’s YOUR child’s potential suicide your discussing, rather than ‘40 percent of transgender children’ or whatever the stats are.

Again, it’s early days for this child and the two others I know. But they don’t seem to be conforming to any of the things people say. So I’m still wondering why what ‘everyone says’ isn’t what I see.

FOJN · 20/07/2022 16:06

mamamelons · 20/07/2022 12:50

The comments in this post have left me so angry. For those that read the full article, why are you so hateful? A little girl that knows who she is and parents who support her. God forbid! Unfortunately until you go through something like this with your own child you will never understand, that's why people are being educated on the subject. It's hard enough for young people transitioning so why not try understanding instead of spreading hate and fear.

Perhaps you could try understanding the concerns rather than throwing around accusations.

All children are entitled to safeguarding. It is incredibly short sighted to think that an issue which may affect you personally means that all usual safeguarding measures can be dispensed with. Girls have a right to spaces which exclude males, it is not hateful to say so. It may not matter quite as much at 7 years of age but it will within the next few years. No male leader should be sharing washing and sleeping facilities with female children under any circumstances. Any adult who thinks someone's internal, unverifiable identity trump's the reality of biological sex is a threat to appropriate safeguarding.

Those of us who are concerned about this are concerned because we have educated ourselves about the realities of self ID, which is what this policy is. Try not to be so patronising.

Absolutely none of what I have written denies gender questioning children support or understanding.

AppleKatie · 20/07/2022 16:00

Slightly off topic, but you’ve reminded me of when one of my DCs was 5 they had a non binary football coach.

after a session one day they said ‘x says she’s not a girl, she is though I can tell’.

out of the mouths of babes…. I just went for polite nonchalance ‘oh ok, now what sandwich would you like for lunch’ type thing.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 15:57

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:48

Couple of ways I think that's messed up:

  1. The child is immature enough to identify as a comic book character, but is somehow considered mature enough to be allowed to make decisions that put them at risk of severe, lifelong harm in service.
  2. The parents are wise enough to put a stop to their child identifying as a comic book character, but not wise enough to stop them from going along a medical pathway which is quite likely to end in their child being alone, disabled, in pain and under medical supervision for the rest of their life.

Could it be that they think they’re is a significant difference between the two? Kiddo didn’t do a ton of work and get a job to facilitate becoming a comic book character, for example.

Teen maturity is not uniform. Even adults make poor decisions sometimes. It doesn’t mean they stop bring able to make ALL decisions from them on, does it?

It also appears to be very, very rare that people regret transitioning (of course it happens, just not often) which suggests that something is working to make sure these kids really do want to transition, no?

ehb102 · 20/07/2022 15:55

Totally fair to be worried. I was a brownie/girl guide, my girls was on the list for rainbows from birth. I didn't send her. My bestie sent her kids to Rainbows and volunteered too despite the non-binary leader. There came a day when the non-binary leader felt it appropriate to explain to the six year olds that she was neither a boy nor a girl. This is a lie. She stood up and lied to children. No amount of trauma you have been through is an excuse for this.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:48

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 15:26

Can you elaborate?

Couple of ways I think that's messed up:

  1. The child is immature enough to identify as a comic book character, but is somehow considered mature enough to be allowed to make decisions that put them at risk of severe, lifelong harm in service.
  2. The parents are wise enough to put a stop to their child identifying as a comic book character, but not wise enough to stop them from going along a medical pathway which is quite likely to end in their child being alone, disabled, in pain and under medical supervision for the rest of their life.
beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:44

I don’t know how anyone could be any more mature about it.

Well, they could have been more mature by being literally older. I hope and pray this was the right decision for this child, but the stories and the sheer numbers of detransitioners do not fill me with confidence. Have you looked at any of the detransition websites or interviews? Absolutely heartbreaking.

The parents should have put a stop to it. They did enable the child, sorry. It's their job to protect and defend their kid, they should have said no, no drugs, no hormones until you're an adult and free to make your own decisions. I know it's easy to say that and there's a lot of pressure on parents, but still. That's your job as a parent, to protect your kid.

drawacircleroundit · 20/07/2022 15:39

"If you see them as a girl, then using the right pronouns should happen naturally," chirps the article, merrily.
Oh, if only it was that simple. Re-learning pronouns and then trying to execute this flawlessly can completely derail my train of thought, fluency and lead to an embarrassed, blushing, fumbled battle of excess compensatory nonsense as I attempt to extricate myself from my mistake.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 15:26

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:08

The child in question also decided to identify as a comic book character at about 14 and requested to be called by that name from now on. Their parents told them not to be so fucking stupid.

But they were okay with the child going on puberty blockers? That's messed up.

Can you elaborate?

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 15:23

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:02

See, this isn’t my experience at all. The transgender child I know has fought, struggled, jumped through hoops and battled some more to get puberty blockers. They had to go private in the end, but it was still a bloody performance. Whether or not I think it’s the right thing for her, she was cautioned, delayed, assessed, reassessed and counselled at every turn. She was not by any stretch of the imagination, pushed. She had to work so hard for it, I can’t imagine anyone going it on a whim. I really can’t.

But @Eeksteek this was surely the parent's doing? A child can't 'go private'. It's good that people were trying to stop the child going on puberty blockers - they should be completely banned for this usage. They are not reversible, as is so often claimed. They are dangerous drugs and put children on an almost-inevitable lifelong medical pathway. Presuming the child in question is a biological male, they are likely to go on cross-sex hormones and almost certainly this will cause infertility. If the child later wants to have 'sex change surgery' there won't be enough 'material' to create a neo-vagina. This surgery has an extremely high risk of complications and is likely to cause a lifetime of chronic pain.

So it's good that this family were put off, but bad that they decided to push for this to happen to their child. It may be that there are more safeguards in place on the NHS since the Keira Bell case and the Cass review and so on. I truly hope so. These are serious decisions that turn healthy children into disabled adults.

I'm not saying it's 'on a whim' by the way. I don't think that's the case at all. But there's a lot of pressure on children and parents now. You're told that if you don't 'affirm' your child you're a bigot and they'll kill themselves, for example.

No, they were deliberately not facilitated. The parents did as little as possible to ensure they were ‘sure’ and that the process was driven by them and meant a lot to them. They were almost practically obstructive, whilst being openly supportive, but clear the kid would need to be fully responsible for the process. I suppose you could say they ‘enabled’ in that they drove her around. I’m willing to bet she’d have got herself to appointments, then though. They didn’t even pay for all of it. Kid had to get a part time job and is aware it’s partially funded from savings for other things, and doesn’t have funding for other things (extra curricular and FE savings) that their siblings have.

I’ve been truly impressed with their dedication and mature attitude. Especially given that they can be a proper teenage little madam about other things. I don’t know how anyone could be any more mature about it. And that’s why I’m wondering where this ‘babies are being pushed into changing sex’ attitude comes from. Because it’s totally, completely the opposite to what I’ve personally seen.

crabcakesalad · 20/07/2022 15:22

Rainbow leader here and also horrified.
What on earth goes through the heads of those at HQ?!! 🤯😡🤯😡

goldfinchonthelawn · 20/07/2022 15:16

Smileyaxolotl1 · 20/07/2022 10:15

Most likely homophobic parents who are wedded to stereotypes.
utterly vile.
and shame on girlguiding for encouraging This and letting boys into an all girls organisation.

That's an interesting take on it which had genuinely never occurred to me.

DS1 wore rainbow dresses when he was little, with pink glittery wings. And glittery nail varnish. And bought fairy doll magazines. I just let him.No big deal. People at church told me I would 'turn him gay' if I carried on letting him Grin. Then eventually he just lost interest and became a soldier instead. Glitter was swapped for camo make up and wings for fatigues. And he is gay. And a cadet not a fairy princess. Though either would be fine.

I just didn't have any concerns about gender stereotypes. But if I had, if I had worried that these things were feminine, do you think that might have led him to believe his taste indicated he was a girl? I had to tell him some people would laugh at him because they thought his doll and dress were for girls but if he didn't care, nor did I and he didn't.

Mommabear20 · 20/07/2022 15:11

My DD and DS can play with whatever toys they wish, I don't agree with gender stereotypes, BUT at 5, that is far too young to make such a huge, life decision! I would not be comfortable with my DD going on a sleep away trip with girl guiding if there was a boy going too, if I wanted them to be mixed, I'd send them to scouts!

RebOrHon · 20/07/2022 15:10

Wow. So incredibly one-sided that they can’t even bring themselves to mention SEX based rights in their legal blurb. As a mother of girls there’s no way is allow them to join the GG and I say that as a third generation QG with several aunties who were devoted Owls of varying experience!

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:08

The child in question also decided to identify as a comic book character at about 14 and requested to be called by that name from now on. Their parents told them not to be so fucking stupid.

But they were okay with the child going on puberty blockers? That's messed up.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:07

The child in question was 12/13/14 during this process. Are you familiar with Gillick competency? It’s the process used by a clinician assesses an under 18’s understanding of the decision they are making, and it’s impact. If children of this age are judged to be Gillick competent, they are allowed to make the decision. Just as they are listened to about other medical decisions where they live in divorce cases and so on. It’s not new for them to be treated like this in medical settings. They aren’t 5. No one can consent on behalf of another person. Not even a child. You can only make a decision in their best interests.

I was talking about the child in the Rainbows case. But okay. At age 12, would you have understood what it meant to never be able to have a sexual relationship or an orgasm? Would you have been competent to decide that you didn't want to have children? Would you have been willing to become a lifelong medical patient, to live in pain, to be incontinent, to be dependent on medication? Would you have understood what these things really meant and what it really meant to lose them?

I wouldn't have. And I don't think most 12/13/14 year olds would, either. In fact, there are more and more detransitioners now telling us they were too young to understand the consequences - and many of these were even older than 14 when they began their transition.

No child should be able to make a decision of this magnitude. They do not have the capacity to understand what they are giving up.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:02

See, this isn’t my experience at all. The transgender child I know has fought, struggled, jumped through hoops and battled some more to get puberty blockers. They had to go private in the end, but it was still a bloody performance. Whether or not I think it’s the right thing for her, she was cautioned, delayed, assessed, reassessed and counselled at every turn. She was not by any stretch of the imagination, pushed. She had to work so hard for it, I can’t imagine anyone going it on a whim. I really can’t.

But @Eeksteek this was surely the parent's doing? A child can't 'go private'. It's good that people were trying to stop the child going on puberty blockers - they should be completely banned for this usage. They are not reversible, as is so often claimed. They are dangerous drugs and put children on an almost-inevitable lifelong medical pathway. Presuming the child in question is a biological male, they are likely to go on cross-sex hormones and almost certainly this will cause infertility. If the child later wants to have 'sex change surgery' there won't be enough 'material' to create a neo-vagina. This surgery has an extremely high risk of complications and is likely to cause a lifetime of chronic pain.

So it's good that this family were put off, but bad that they decided to push for this to happen to their child. It may be that there are more safeguards in place on the NHS since the Keira Bell case and the Cass review and so on. I truly hope so. These are serious decisions that turn healthy children into disabled adults.

I'm not saying it's 'on a whim' by the way. I don't think that's the case at all. But there's a lot of pressure on children and parents now. You're told that if you don't 'affirm' your child you're a bigot and they'll kill themselves, for example.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 14:58

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 14:43

Children (not 'children') are pushed into this because if left to their own devices they will desist. They insist they're a girl, boy, horse, dog, tractor, Superman for a bit, then they move to the next stage of development and it's forgotten. But when a parent gets involved, they encourage the child to stay fixed in that pretence longer than they naturally would. They reward and ask leading questions (like the ones in the article). They give lots of attention. The child comes to learn the 'script'. It's like Munchausen's by proxy, essentially.

Or as the saying goes, a trans child is like a vegan cat - we all know who's making the decisions.

Some children - an extremely tiny number - do have persistent gender dysphoria. But the advice is still the same - wait it out. It will likely go away of its own accord, and many of these kids turn out to be happily gay or lesbian. If dysphoria persists into adulthood and no psychological interventions have helped, an adult might decide on some degree of medical or surgical transition. But this is a decision only an adult can make.

The child in question was 12/13/14 during this process. Are you familiar with Gillick competency? It’s the process used by a clinician assesses an under 18’s understanding of the decision they are making, and it’s impact. If children of this age are judged to be Gillick competent, they are allowed to make the decision. Just as they are listened to about other medical decisions where they live in divorce cases and so on. It’s not new for them to be treated like this in medical settings. They aren’t 5. No one can consent on behalf of another person. Not even a child. You can only make a decision in their best interests.

The child in question also decided to identify as a comic book character at about 14 and requested to be called by that name from now on. Their parents told them not to be so fucking stupid. Again, I’m not seeing what people are saying. I’m not saying their wrong, but the evidence suggests it. So I’m confused.

VillanellesCoat · 20/07/2022 14:56

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 14:41

See, this isn’t my experience at all. The transgender child I know has fought, struggled, jumped through hoops and battled some more to get puberty blockers. They had to go private in the end, but it was still a bloody performance. Whether or not I think it’s the right thing for her, she was cautioned, delayed, assessed, reassessed and counselled at every turn. She was not by any stretch of the imagination, pushed. She had to work so hard for it, I can’t imagine anyone going it on a whim. I really can’t.

So I’m struggling to reconcile what I know with what people say. It’s totally possible she’s an outlier of some sort. But not all that likely really.

This is my experience too. And the parents in the vast majority want their child to be anything but transgender.
There are, of course, a minority of parents who are so entrenched in societal gender expectations that they think their young children are the opposite gender because of basic likes and dislikes. And I hope they do go to Tavistock because then they (the parents) would also ge subject to scrutiny on motivation.

Catinabeanbag · 20/07/2022 14:53

'There are some boys who like all the things that society thinks are for girls but know themselves to be boys, and there are some who feel like they are girls inside'

What does it even mean to 'feel like a girl inside'? It sounds like an odd statement to make - as if there's some universal 'girl' feeling which all females have...and I would highly doubt that to be the case.

Perple · 20/07/2022 14:50

@Eeksteek a prepubescent child has absolutely no capacity to make an informed decision about the implications of not going through the appropriate puberty for their body.

a child may well push extraordinarily for that to happen and not be pushed be parents. They are likely to have been subject to the many social pressure and fads. Or indeed they may be one of the very small proportion of people who ultimately turn out in adulthood to be genuinely dysphoric. Most dysphoric adult men choose to keep their bits and sexual function. So even for that tiny group puberty blockers would have very likely been i appropriate.

just because a pre pubescent child pushes something very much does not make it the right thing.

Schmz · 20/07/2022 14:47

Ikeepbuyinganimals · 20/07/2022 12:49

I'm a leader, I disagree with our policies but I can't say that under my real name as the opinion will have me removed and for 10+ years I have loved my team, the girls and all the opportunities. So far I haven't come across this situation so I am still remaining true to myself however when it arises, I will leave. And I'll be gutted.

I’m the same - leader with many years experience and was horrified to read this in the latest newsletter -
especially due to the v young age of the case they have showcased’
just awful
it looks like a safeguarding issue to me, not something to be shown as a good example 😩

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 14:43

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 13:24

I’m not sure why you feel ‘children’ are ‘pushed’ into this. Can you elaborate? Who pushes them? ‘Why’? I’m not goading and it’s a common attitude, but it puzzles me. I’m not trans and don’t have trans children. I’ve no skin in this game and no agenda. I just want to understand better where people are coming from.

Children (not 'children') are pushed into this because if left to their own devices they will desist. They insist they're a girl, boy, horse, dog, tractor, Superman for a bit, then they move to the next stage of development and it's forgotten. But when a parent gets involved, they encourage the child to stay fixed in that pretence longer than they naturally would. They reward and ask leading questions (like the ones in the article). They give lots of attention. The child comes to learn the 'script'. It's like Munchausen's by proxy, essentially.

Or as the saying goes, a trans child is like a vegan cat - we all know who's making the decisions.

Some children - an extremely tiny number - do have persistent gender dysphoria. But the advice is still the same - wait it out. It will likely go away of its own accord, and many of these kids turn out to be happily gay or lesbian. If dysphoria persists into adulthood and no psychological interventions have helped, an adult might decide on some degree of medical or surgical transition. But this is a decision only an adult can make.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 14:41

Clymene · 20/07/2022 13:29

@Eeksteek - 80% of children who think they may be the wrong sex desist ie they grow out of it. Unless their parents take them to a gender identity clinic which is a one way street to lifelong medication for most.

See, this isn’t my experience at all. The transgender child I know has fought, struggled, jumped through hoops and battled some more to get puberty blockers. They had to go private in the end, but it was still a bloody performance. Whether or not I think it’s the right thing for her, she was cautioned, delayed, assessed, reassessed and counselled at every turn. She was not by any stretch of the imagination, pushed. She had to work so hard for it, I can’t imagine anyone going it on a whim. I really can’t.

So I’m struggling to reconcile what I know with what people say. It’s totally possible she’s an outlier of some sort. But not all that likely really.