Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about Rainbows

234 replies

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 08:57

As a guide leader and as a mother I find this worrying:

girlguiding.foleon.com/guiding-magazine/guiding-summer-2022/rainbow-girl

OP posts:
Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 20:13

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 16:20

It’s all very easy to say ‘they should’ It’s a lot harder when it’s YOUR child’s potential suicide your discussing, rather than ‘40 percent of transgender children’ or whatever the stats are.

It's a real shame they didn't get some better advice about this, because those stats have been comprehensively debunked. It's just not true that trans kids have higher suicide rates. In fact, there are some studies which suggest that suicidality is more likely to increase after transition.

They were already self harming. I saw these people agonise over the best thing to do. They did the best they could with the information they had at the time. It was at least five years ago - before most people even heard of it! I know the parents yearned for them to get it out of their system and left every possible door open. It was heartbreaking.

‘Children’ do make sexual health decisions. An under 16 taking contraception is a case in point. Childbirth can also result in pain, incontinence etc etc and is frankly utterly life changing, and similar age ‘children’ are making decisions about that. No one is saying their parents should be ‘putting a stop’ to their sex lives. That’s where Gillick competency comes in. You can’t say they can do it for childbirth only, surely?

I acccept that I have a sample of three, personally known to me. How many de-transitioners are personally known to you? (I‘m not going to accept a Reddit group as indication of anything but a hot topic). I’m absolutely NOT saying they did the right thing. I’d hate to be held to some of the decisions I made as a teen! I can see exactly why it’s controversial. But I know that they tried so hard to, and I know what a heart rending process it was. And my experience through them (and the two others I know) is nothing like what people are saying they think happens. So then I’m wondering what else they get wrong. Because I know that some of it IS wrong. The ‘anti-trans’ stuff people come out with has such a hysterical, bigoted tone, and yet this young person in particular has dealt with it with a level of fortitude, maturity, stamina and cheerful matter of factness that I’m honestly astounded they were capable of. I’m having a lot of trouble reconciling the two in both fact and attitude, and not coming down on their ‘side’.

BogRollBOGOF · 20/07/2022 19:13

hangrylady · 20/07/2022 18:03

The thing that pisses me off in that 'Rainbow' could gave joined Beaver Scouts, which is open to both boys and girls. But no, it had to be a group for girls didn't it, so the parents can tell everyone.

Turquoise isn't girly enough.

The Scouting programme is better than the updated Girl Guiding version. Girl Guiding is now navel gazing and talking about going for a walk. Scouting just goes for a walk. There is some flexibility, but when you have to spend 60% of your time doing death by activity cards so your girls can get their badges/ awards, there's a lot less time doing random adventures than there once was.

I have sons. When they were younger they tended to accompany me in accordance with the policies on Leaders' Children. Fair enough. But all it takes is the words "I am a girl" and all transparency goes out of the window along with requiring appropriate facilities.

Girl Guiding went the wrong way on Trans inclusion. It should have stayed single sex and supported female bodied "trans-boy" members to help them understand the great things that females can do when stereotypes don't hold them back.

I really hope that these policies are resolved before I ever have to face it as an issue in my unit.
One of my son's peers is identifying as the opposite gender and has changed identity. His friend's older sibling has taken physical measures to transition. It's not just hypothetical.

crabcakesalad · 20/07/2022 19:02

Luckily 99% of parents will be ignoring this nonsense

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 20/07/2022 18:36

hangrylady · 20/07/2022 18:03

The thing that pisses me off in that 'Rainbow' could gave joined Beaver Scouts, which is open to both boys and girls. But no, it had to be a group for girls didn't it, so the parents can tell everyone.

Exactly. And now 'Rainbow' has had it made harder for him to go back to identifying as male. Doing so would mean he would have to leave Rainbows/Brownies/Guides and walk away from a loved activity, from friends. If he had joined a mix sexed group like scouting or the woodcraft folk one, the door would have stayed open - he could return to identifying as male and continue to attend.

ringoutthebells · 20/07/2022 18:35

ehb102 · 20/07/2022 15:55

Totally fair to be worried. I was a brownie/girl guide, my girls was on the list for rainbows from birth. I didn't send her. My bestie sent her kids to Rainbows and volunteered too despite the non-binary leader. There came a day when the non-binary leader felt it appropriate to explain to the six year olds that she was neither a boy nor a girl. This is a lie. She stood up and lied to children. No amount of trauma you have been through is an excuse for this.

We've had this recently too. Like an 'information session' Hmm No advance warning. No other such information sessions. It's really quite disturbing.

hangrylady · 20/07/2022 18:03

The thing that pisses me off in that 'Rainbow' could gave joined Beaver Scouts, which is open to both boys and girls. But no, it had to be a group for girls didn't it, so the parents can tell everyone.

ihavenocats · 20/07/2022 17:02

I'm more worried about school since that's most of their life which is most of their influence, while Rainbows/Brownies is a couple of hours a week at maximum.

CousinKrispy · 20/07/2022 16:57

Also I think the question of whether Gillick competence applies in this situation is a very complicated one, both morally and legally.

It's an important principle and it needs to be taken into consideration. But it's nowhere near as simple as "oh, Gillick competence says that under-16s are allowed to make their own medical decisions" because it is nowhere near that simple.

It's interesting that Gillick competence arose from a question of contraception being supplied to young people without parental consent. Whatever one's feelings about young people being sexually active without informing their parents, access to contraception is quite a clear-cut example of something that is widely used, well-evidenced, is usually extremely safe, is easily and entirely reversible, and can prevent teenage pregnancy--which could itself have lifelong negative effects on a young woman, given the physical risks of pregnancy and the societal and financial hurdles that mothers (especially young and potentially single ones) face.

Aside from the emotive "better a trans child than a dead one" argument which may or may not be backed up by statistics specific to a UK contextpuberty blocking treatment and gender transition are very different in all aspects.

So, again, it's not clear-cut that Gillick competence can simply be slapped onto it.

VickyEadieofThigh · 20/07/2022 16:47

mamamelons · 20/07/2022 12:50

The comments in this post have left me so angry. For those that read the full article, why are you so hateful? A little girl that knows who she is and parents who support her. God forbid! Unfortunately until you go through something like this with your own child you will never understand, that's why people are being educated on the subject. It's hard enough for young people transitioning so why not try understanding instead of spreading hate and fear.

Children only "know" that certain clothes, hairstyles and toys are 'for girls' because their parents (and the media, etc) TELL them so.

Feminists have spent our lives trying to tell the world that the only way you're male or female is to be born so; now, however, we've got the notion that liking x makes you x, even if you're REALLY y.

That kid doesn't "know who she is" because that kid's parents think 'gender' = external associations.

FOJN · 20/07/2022 16:45

It also appears to be very, very rare that people regret transitioning (of course it happens, just not often) which suggests that something is working to make sure these kids really do want to transition, no?

We have no idea because data hasn't been gathered on detransitioners. Many are lost to follow up. Minors have not previously transitioned at the rates they do now. We are conducting a live experiment on children by allowing them to make irreversible changes to their body long before their neurological development is complete and we have no idea of the long term consequences The detrans subreddit has 36k members which suggest transition regret is more common than previously thought.

The interim Cass Report was very clear that social transition is not a neutral choice, there will be many more children put on a pathway to lifelong medical treatment before there are enough legal cases to halt the madness.

CousinKrispy · 20/07/2022 16:45

Eeksteek I'm glad you and the parents of the young person you're talking about have been so supportive, you clearly care deeply about their well-being.

However that's an example of only one.

I definitely know of other examples of much younger children being pushed into identifying as "transgender" apparently to satisfy some desire on the parents' part. Unfortunately not all parents are as sensible and loving as the ones in your example.

I also know of multiple examples of detransitioners.

The validity of all these young people's experiences is really important. Yes, that includes your example of a young person who appears to be making an informed choice with supportive parents.

But equally it includes the detransitioners who you have dismissed as "very few." They're not any fewer than your example of one, right?

ancientgran · 20/07/2022 16:43

I don't have an issue with Guiding being mixed, I was a leader at Beavers and Cubs and it was fine. I just don't understand why he had to become a girl, one of my sons loved wearing dresses and playing with dolls, we never took any notice and one day he stopped. If he hadn't stopped I suppose at some point we would have had to address it but when they are little why does it matter.

DockOTheBay · 20/07/2022 16:35

It’s so boring now compared to when I was at Brownies. Every badge seems the same. The poor volunteer leaders have to go through days and days of training, well beyond what I had every imagined

Completely depends on the leaders and their attitude. My Brownies unit is not boring. This term we have done camping, archery, kayaking, made clay sculptures, built electronic circuits, Lego models, baking, exploring the woods, firelighting, making slime... Some of it part of the programme and some not.
And I haven't done that much training - 6 hour first aid course, 4 hour safeguarding course, which are done every 3 years. Plus "on the job" training to become a leader in the first place.

Itswaytoohot · 20/07/2022 16:34

I don't get all this transgender malarkey about he liked girly toys and girly clothes and so on.

I have sons. When eldest was in nursery he was forever dressing in the princess dresses, I didn't bat an eyelid. When he was around 6 or 7 he was obsessed with a well known very girly tv show. He had all the characters, he'd brush the dolls hair, he'd save his money to buy the toys, put on shows with the character. Not once did it cross my mind that he must actually be a girl, I just accepted it and reassured him it's fine to play with whatever toys you like. He played with mostly girls at school too.

He's a teen now, a 6 foot deep voiced, muscly male human.

Why can't we just accept that makes and females don't have to fit into stereotypical ideals of what a girl or a boy should be.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 16:20

It’s all very easy to say ‘they should’ It’s a lot harder when it’s YOUR child’s potential suicide your discussing, rather than ‘40 percent of transgender children’ or whatever the stats are.

It's a real shame they didn't get some better advice about this, because those stats have been comprehensively debunked. It's just not true that trans kids have higher suicide rates. In fact, there are some studies which suggest that suicidality is more likely to increase after transition.

Yodaisawally · 20/07/2022 16:18

@SingingSands how would I know, no one has to tel me, and it's not just kids it leaders, again under no obligation to tell me.

MissDollyMix · 20/07/2022 16:17

There is so much wrong with that article I don’t know where to begin! That poor poor child. Awful parents who seem firmly wedded to old-fashioned gender stereotypes, an women’s organisation who are promoting the concept of ‘girl-think’ ….
My DD is in Brownies but hates it. It’s so boring now compared to when I was at Brownies. Every badge seems the same. The poor volunteer leaders have to go through days and days of training, well beyond what I had every imagined. It’s any wonder they have anyone left to run their packs. DD won’t be going back in September.

Sleepyquest · 20/07/2022 16:16

My DD likes playing in mud and not wearing dresses, is she actually a boy?

Give it a rest - poor kid is traumatised for life now no matter what. Shame on Rainbows for allowing such utter crap

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 16:16

Teen maturity is not uniform. Even adults make poor decisions sometimes. It doesn’t mean they stop bring able to make ALL decisions from them on, does it?

But children are children. They don't get to make adult decisions, because they're children. Adults get to make adult decisions for themselves, because they're adults. Yes, they can get things wrong and make bad decisions, but they're adults, so they knowingly take that risk. Children are not adults. They don't get to make adult decisions and take adult risks. That's not fair.

We don't accept children making decisions about many important parts of life. They can't vote, get married, get a tattoo, drive a car, have sex, drink alcohol etc. We do this to protect children. The same should apply to medical decisions that we know have a high rate of regret and serious complications and consequences, such as never being able to orgasm, being physically disabled, being dependent on drugs.

It also appears to be very, very rare that people regret transitioning (of course it happens, just not often) which suggests that something is working to make sure these kids really do want to transition, no?

The number of people who regret transitioning is HUGE and rising. We have begun to see the first lawsuits initiated - many, many more will follow. (To give you a sense of numbers, there are currently 36,000 members of r/detrans, a reddit sub for detransitioners.)

You're right, these kids do really want to transition - they think it will solve all their problems. So they transition, realise they still have problems, and now they also have a whole set of new problems to navigate, like being in constant pain, or dealing with incontinence in their 20s.

RockandRollsuicide · 20/07/2022 16:15

Miss maple dd also wanted to be a dog.

She used to want to eat from a bowl on the floor,copied dogs mannerisms...we had to call her a dog's name.

RockandRollsuicide · 20/07/2022 16:14

Children shouldn't even be aware of this , it's far too big a subject for tiny children.

What are we doing!

Can we all email them and let them know how we feel??

MissMaple82 · 20/07/2022 16:14

I too from around the age of 4/5 identified as a dog, I wanted nothing more than to be an actual dog, and I even "married" our pet terrier and he became my dog husband. Obviously this phase passed and I'm grateful my parents didn't transition me to become my true self!

OrangeIsTheNewBlah · 20/07/2022 16:14

“That the suicide rate amongst young transgender people was so high”

This has been shown to be false. The Tavistock has even said that the suicide rates are not higher than other vulnerable groups.

It’s incredibly concerning that people still quote unsubstantiated scare statistics.

grey12 · 20/07/2022 16:14

At 18 months "she" identified with female characters 🤦🏻‍♀️

DD2 identifies with a dinosaur character, what should I do? 😱

RockandRollsuicide · 20/07/2022 16:11

It's the age.

There is simply no way we can know until we are older.

7 year's old now and when younger identified with the wrong sex in books??

How does any 18.month old identify with a male or female character in a book??

This is dreadul.