Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about Rainbows

234 replies

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 08:57

As a guide leader and as a mother I find this worrying:

girlguiding.foleon.com/guiding-magazine/guiding-summer-2022/rainbow-girl

OP posts:
SpiderVersed · 21/07/2022 13:16

It's the old Vegan Cat scenario with poor Rainbow - such homophobic parents can't imagine having an effeminate little boy so declare him a girl.

So many professionals have left the Tavistock because they were seeing parents "transing the gay away" and not able to speak out about it. They also confirmed trans childern were no more at risk of suicide than any other teen with mental or emotional difficulties. The "dead son/living daughter" is emotional blackmail from charlatans like Mermaids.

Guiding was about showing girls the endless possibilities open to them, broadening their horizons. It sure as hell wasn't about enforcing gender stereotypes. I'm glad our local leaders are GC.

Beamur · 21/07/2022 12:41

Leaders don't share sleeping areas with children and no Leader should provide personal care like showering without another adult present.
There are rules around ratios and if you have a sole Leader, how that has to approached to safeguard children and adults.
I'm not happy with the direction GG have taken on this but these statements around sleeping and showering aren't quite true.
They have recently updated their information on their website about their stance on trans inclusion and policies around sleeping are also on their website. They are more transparent than they were prior to the court case with Dr Alcock.

pinkandyellowmarshmallow · 21/07/2022 12:24

I’m really surprised at this. I recently added both my DDs to the waiting list for Rainbows/Brownies, I’m thinking twice about it now.

How can this be seen as progressive? It’s just reinforcing stereotypes. My DD had a playdate recently with a boy, they both dressed up as Elsa, it’s no big deal.

MrsOwainGlyndŵr · 21/07/2022 12:04

And when that little Rainbow, starts going through puberty and is still sleeping in the same space as other little girls, that's ok too?

As when one of the leaders is a trans woman, they can share sleeping and shower facilities with your daughters and you're not told, that's ok too?

Not only is it not ok, Leaders who organise residential events are not allowed to call out on a risk assessment that there is a penis in the camp. Of any age. So that a penis-haver might, in extremist, help your daughter to wash or toilet herself.
Nor are they allowed to inform parents that there is a penis at camp and that that person might help the girls with intimate activities

DontAskIDontKnow · 21/07/2022 11:59

I am doing my small bit in the pushback against Gender Ideology, but I have kept my girls in Girlguiding because I trust my local leaders and I really don’t want to lose such a valuable organisation.

it’s reassuring to hear from leaders that they are concerned about this and would like to push back. Unfortunately, I don’t know how they can push back. I’ve corresponded with Girlguiding on this subject and they are completely captured and unreasonable.

if they do start pushing this nonsense during sessions then I will have no choice but to remove my youngest, as she is very gender non-conforming in appearance, and I am really worried that someone will implant these stupid, regressive ideas into her head.

NotAGirl · 21/07/2022 11:44

Awesome GG pushing sexist stereotypes that have constrained girls and womens lives for millennia. Can’t have those uppity women thinking they could read ‘boys’ books and ‘boys’ toys when everyone knows it is what books you read, what toys you play with and what you wear that makes you a girl

FFS GG you are supporting ideology that is damaging the life opportunities open to women

underneaththeash · 21/07/2022 10:54

The issue is that they’re a charity and they can’t afford to hire anyone who isn’t just out of uni. Therefore they gets lots of idealistic early 20s you don’t adults, whose brains haven’t matured properly yet!

its ridiculous. A 7 year old doesn’t have the capacity to make decisions like that, it’s his parents pushing theirs onto him.

i’s be interested in knowing nationally how many kids in Girlguiding actually are boys. I suspect it’s very few.

as a leader, I just ignore it. I don’t believe it’s possible or preferable for anyone to change sex. would not admit a boy, I’d just close the unit (it wouldn’t run without me).

Onlyforcake · 21/07/2022 10:48

I think you are being ridiculously hateful, prejudice and not a little bit overly dramatic.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 21/07/2022 10:46

I acccept that I have a sample of three, personally known to me… So then I’m wondering what else they get wrong. Because I know that some of it IS wrong. The ‘anti-trans’ stuff people come out with has such a hysterical, bigoted tone

More than 20. I don't have special insight. I have seen the dynamics play out in a number of families. Yes, some of them have detransitioned and that was made easier by it being social detransitioning rather than after more substantial medical or surgical interventions. Others are intending to pursue these interventions with the support of their families.

You classify the concerns of others as anti-, hysteria, bigotry etc even when it's grounded in a review of clinical evidence. Setting that aside, would you ever challenge your friends/whomever with what they got wrong or how they were mislead by others (eg, the suicide risk)?

PearlClutch · 21/07/2022 10:37

Yes, shame on Girlguiding. They've ruined what was a great organisation with this ridiculous support of sex stereotyping; somethign they were supposedly all about combating.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 21/07/2022 10:36

This is a psychologist's warning about the harm that adults do to young children when they "affirm" a belief that the child is the opposite sex in opposition to the reality of the child's body. The psychological damage is massive:

www.transgendertrend.com/childhood-social-transition/

bloodyunicorns · 21/07/2022 10:32

‘Treat us respectfully and just the same as any of the other girls, because on the inside we’re all the same really!'

said Rainbow, but really said no 7yo ever. The poor boy has clearly been brainwashed by his insane parents. And shame on GirlGuiding for letting this happen. Girls need girl-only spaces away from boys. It's good for them.

Beamur · 21/07/2022 10:06

waterbabys
Would completely agree. I have very close experience of a child strongly identifying as a boy (born female) for several years. Family accepted a name change, and the child desisted entirely by choice a few years later. Also 40 years ago. This is nothing new. Kids have been experiencing gender 'identity' issues for a very long time. It's part of growing up for very many people. What we didn't have in the 70's/80's was medication and mass media. Despite what activists now might think what a lot of people did have were loving and supportive families who let their kids grow up and work it out. Which is also why the desistance rate was something like 90%.. the small number of people whose dysphoria wasn't resolved by puberty and the realisation that they were gay probably would now be better supported with medication and affirmative surgery than was available then.
I have a teenage DD and can see a swathe of teenage girls mired in gender ideology and just hope they come out the other side unharmed.

waterbabys · 21/07/2022 09:50

@Eeksteek I'm genuinely not trying to be goading or anything, but it comes across that you may think that many of us GCs have no actual experience of our own with trans identifying children/teens/young adults/adults (forgive me if I'm interpreting that incorrectly!). However, many of us are friends, siblings, parents, partners to them, and/or work with them via schools, social work, extra curricular groups or charities (I personally fall under a few of these!). We haven't come to GC conclusions by reading the Daily Mail (!), and we've been talking about gender ideology and the impact on children far longer than 5 years (in my case at least).

Alluding to concerned women, with carefully considered opinions and experiences, being 'hysterical' about this issue is misogynistic.

Beamur · 21/07/2022 07:36

Sadly I think GG are being very poorly served by HQ at the moment.
They're losing members and Leaders. The push for inclusion is in theory great but in practice yet more of a burden on volunteer leaders as there's bugger all support from HQ for it. There's lots of headlines and twee graphics but then when push comes to shove and you have girls with often multiple needs in your unit and ask for help from HQ there isn't any. Meanwhile parents are being demanding and pushy.
One of my friends is a Guide leader and a teacher, she's commented that at school they have a system by which any safeguarding incidents are logged and shared with other agencies. No such system in GG. In fact until fairly recently, if a girl changed units because of issues, or moved between say Guides and Rangers and had been tricky, you weren't supposed to tell the next unit, to give the girl a clean start.
Yesterday on Facebook, GG latest ill considered post was about the cost of living crisis and telling parents to go to unit leaders for help with getting subs reduced and information about grants. Without offering any information up front to units about these grants. There were dozens of furious comments from Leaders, it's not a rich organisation at grass roots and some units barely scrape by. Plus every unit has to pay an annual subscription to GG which has had a massive hike this year due to loss of income from Covid. This has to be paid per person in the unit, including a payment for Leaders and other volunteer helpers. (Scouts don't charge their Leaders) Guide Leaders are becoming very disillusioned.

Fawnia · 20/07/2022 23:22

Girlguiding has really gone to shit in the last 5-10 years, and volunteers and staff have been treated abysmally. It’s no surprise they’ve gone this far with the sections.
Honestly Girlguiding has had its day.

Darnley · 20/07/2022 22:26

I am so angry about this, and those in the movement that support it.
no way I could stand by and allow it. It’s blatant abandonment of safeguarding and bloody dangerous.
I know many in the movement agree, but you need to stand up to this nonsense, en masse, and bring some common sense to bare.. if enough of you do, the cowards will back off and you’re lovely, safe, groups can return. I hope.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 22:20

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 22:01

@beastlyslumber I do take your points. What I can’t get past is that for child I personally know, I really think this was also the lesser of two evils, and that puberty is so central to gender development, that it makes the involvement of children unavoidable (if you accept that it is possible to be truly transgender, of course).

I’m not trying to convince anyone. I’m just finding it hard to reconcile this experience with other peoples views. (And perhaps provide a little balance)

I obviously don't know if you're right about that particular child. I am talking in terms of principles. Even happy and well adjusted TW like Blaire White are against child transition. I don't see any grounds for making exceptions- the risk of getting it wrong is too devastating. And not allowing children to go through puberty is going to have so many physical and emotional consequences that we can't even foresee.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 22:17

@CousinKrispy Indeed. The plural of anecdote is not data. I’m just trying to share that in my actual (if vicarious) experience of transitioning teens (one I know well, and followed the process quite closely with. Two are much more private) is very different from other people’s impressions of the process. I’m genuinely curious about how these impressions are formed, and whether what I’ve seen is the anomaly, or if everyone else’s experience is anything but first impressions and Daily-Mail fed hysteria. Because if I hadn’t seen it so closely, I think I’d feel similarly. I did initially. I’m hoping to pass on some of that depth, I think.

You can bet your life I’d be tearing the evidence apart if it were my Tween exploring her gender identity, though.

Eeksteek · 20/07/2022 22:01

@beastlyslumber I do take your points. What I can’t get past is that for child I personally know, I really think this was also the lesser of two evils, and that puberty is so central to gender development, that it makes the involvement of children unavoidable (if you accept that it is possible to be truly transgender, of course).

I’m not trying to convince anyone. I’m just finding it hard to reconcile this experience with other peoples views. (And perhaps provide a little balance)

tillytoodles1 · 20/07/2022 21:48

My nephew was the only boy in his mums group of friends, they all had girls. He played with pushchairs and Barbies, and all the other "girlie" stuff that their mums thought they loved.

At home he still played with his Barbies and stuff, but also cars and other things. It's what kids do, they don't have to like certain things to be girly or boyish.

It really annoyed me when my granddaughter was born that all girls toys were pink.

CousinKrispy · 20/07/2022 21:29

Eeksteek you might want to re-read my point about Gillick competence, which was that it was established for young people to have access to birth control--medical treatment which has several points that are completely different from treatment for gender dysphoric young people. You are drawing a parallel with the opposite of birth control.

And, again, your anecdotal knowledge of one or three transitioner does not carry more weight than existing detransitioners. It doesn't carry less weight, either--the young people you know in this situation are also important and need support. And maybe they have followed exactly the right path in their lives, we need to acknowledge that some will make this choice.

But it's not logically sound to throw aside one "small number" of young people with actual lived experience because it doesn't fit in with the lived experience of the one (now three) individuals you support. Both are valid.

user1487194234 · 20/07/2022 20:55

I left Guiding over this issue
I had run a Guide unit and a Rainbow unit for 20 years

I did tell my Commissioner why but I am told she did not make that public,in fact according to the minutes of the district meeting I was struggling from stress

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 20:44

This person was an adult when he transitioned. Think how much less equipped actual children are to make these kinds of decisions.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10953157/Man-suing-NHS-trans-surgery-regrets-bravely-waived-anonymity-share-ordeal.html

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 20:41

I'm not trying to tell you that your friends didn't try hard and that it wasn't a difficult process for them @Eeksteek But I do think that children should not be allowed to make these decisions.

When you say no one is trying to put a stop to children's 'sex lives', that's not the case. We have an age of consent - 16. Yes, children can decide to take contraception - but contraception is generally safe and well understood, and the lesser of two evils. A girl who gets pregnant at 13 or 14 could make the decision to have the baby, yes, and that would be risky, but at least we understand the risks and have good experience of mitigating them. In the UK at least, she would likely be encouraged to have an abortion. But with puberty blockers and hormones, we are running an experiment on children, and the early results are not looking good.

If you take a look at r/detrans, you will see post after post after post from very young people asking questions like whether their atrophied testicles will become normal again, or whether they will ever get their voice back, or how they can ever forgive themselves for what they've done to their bodies. It is heartbreaking.

I'm glad your young friend is doing so well, and hope very much that this continues to be the case. I hope that they won't regret that they can't have a sex life, or kids, and that they don't end up living in horrible pain. I hope they'll be well and happy for life. That doesn't change the fact that they should never have been allowed to go on experimental medication as a child. If an adult wants to medically or surgically transition, then that's absolutely their decision and they have every right to make it. They presumably understand the massive risks they're taking and what they have to lose. Children cannot understand this. If you don't know what it is to have an orgasm, how can you agree to never having one? If you haven't got through puberty, how do you know that you don't want your penis? At age 14, how can you decide you never want to have kids of your own? Children should not be allowed to make irreversible decisions like this.