Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about Rainbows

234 replies

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 08:57

As a guide leader and as a mother I find this worrying:

girlguiding.foleon.com/guiding-magazine/guiding-summer-2022/rainbow-girl

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 21:39

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:19

The autonomy over her own identity.

There is no autonomy over one's sex and which puberty one will go through, if nature is allowed to take its course.

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:36

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 18:32

Didimum, you might think that ‘A little boy who identifies as a boy is not the same as a transgender girl who identifies as a girl’ but in every scientific, biological and truthful way they are. You cannot force people to accept something is a fact when it simply isn’t true - boys are boys, girls are girls. Humans can’t change sex and you can’t be ‘born in the wrong body’ FACTS. If you believe otherwise that is akin to religious belief, like believing in ghosts or gods or that the world is flat. Absolutely your right to believe those sort of things but what you can’t do is insist that everyone else pretends that they believe them too. Any differences between a boy that is a happy to be a boy and one that thinks they are a girl are just personality and not following gender stereotypes, or sometimes a trauma response, possible with the added complication of adults going reinforcing (or even suggesting in the case of Rainbow) their ideas.

I didn’t say you can change sex, I said you can change gender. You can ‘FACT’ me all you like, but unfortunately (for you) this organisation, and plenty of others in increasing numbers, are not in agreement with you.

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 21:36

Didum - but you can’t have ‘autonomy’ over your identity when it comes to sex, it’s not something you can choose or change. You can, of course, have autonomy over your clothing, hair etc. I’d argue that 7 year olds shouldn’t have much ‘autonomy’ though as they are young, inexperienced and need guidance. Eg my children never wanted to wear sunhats, but I made them wear them because it was in their interest, wearing skirts or trousers didn’t matter unless trousers were the practical option for long, cold dog walks.

justanotherguider · 21/07/2022 21:35

I've just checked the gguk website.
It depends which bit you look at, but it does appear the law wording has been changed!

To be worried about Rainbows
To be worried about Rainbows
OP posts:
RunAlongLoser · 21/07/2022 21:21

Another leader here - relatively new.

My jaw hit the floor reading that newsletter. I agree with a lot of what's been said above by others. "We're all the same on the inside" - why are boys not accepted then?

I'm in total disagreement with GirlGuiding over this, but I'm another one keeping quiet until it directly affects my unit. I am so attached to my brilliant girls, some of whom have serious problems at home and get so much stability from their evening at Brownies. It would break my heart to walk away and let the unit close (again). But if I'm pushed any further on this, I will have to.

I've also just been told by a parent that the words of the Brownie law have changed from "herself" to "themselves" (the ones we learned don't match the website apparently)...... not sure when that happened....

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:19

HipTightOnions · 21/07/2022 18:28

A little boy who identifies as a boy is not the same as a transgender girl who identifies as a girl.

Really Didimum?

What do you think is the difference?

The autonomy over her own identity.

Apric0tjam · 21/07/2022 21:14

I'm really alarmed to see it set out on this thread how leaders are unable to express alternative views on this for fear of being kicked out. As a parent of a nearly guide (just finished Brownies where this issue didn't arise. Fairly old-school leaders there) is there anything I can do? Is there any point in parents contacting HQ/ divisional leaders?

Did the Katie Alcock case (which I only vaguely followed via MN, I don't have twitter or Facebook) not mean they had to change their policies?

Ikeepbuyinganimals · 21/07/2022 20:19

This is my biggest worry! Rangers is the next section after Guides and teens love to experiment. Imagine sending your Ranger on a camp and they came back pregnant. The penis in the tent soon becomes more of a risk, when it's not in a predator way, just a teens being teens way 😬

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 20:01

HappyAsASandboy · 20/07/2022 12:10

I have up when it started on about an 18 months old identifying more with the girl characters in stories Confused

I have a 2.5 year old. He loves reading stories (well having them read to him). How the fuck would I know which characters he identifies more with?! Absolutely mad! At 2.5 years old, a full year older than the 18 month old Rainbow, my child is pointing at pictures and saying the words for duck, bus, car, man, ball, mummy, ladder, tree etc. He is absolutely not showing any signs at all at identifying more with any of those things Biscuit

Exactly what I thought when I read this, @HappyAsASandboy. At 18 months my daughter was coming out with quite a few words but she was a long, long way from speaking fluently about anything abstract. My son didn't speak until he was 2.5. I just don't believe this poor little kid was displaying signs of gender dysphoria at 18 months old.

'Rainbow' has socially transitioned now. This article from Transgender Trend explains very clearly why this is not a bening thing to do to a child. www.transgendertrend.com/childhood-social-transition/ What happens at puberty?

YorkshireTeaCup · 21/07/2022 19:57

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 21/07/2022 19:34

I don't care. She's my mum, she's my DD's grandmother. She will tell me if there is a safeguarding risk to my daughter; that trumps everything else.

@SirSamVimesCityWatch Safeguarding risk or not, it's against policy so she will be kicked out of Guides (which maybe she doesn't care about) but also against GDPR / data protection laws, so she could be personally liable for a fine. See analogous case: ico.org.uk/about-the-ico/news-and-events/news-and-blogs/2019/03/two-birmingham-workers-fined-for-data-protection-breaches/

WaveyHair · 21/07/2022 19:55

RockandRollsuicide · 20/07/2022 16:11

It's the age.

There is simply no way we can know until we are older.

7 year's old now and when younger identified with the wrong sex in books??

How does any 18.month old identify with a male or female character in a book??

This is dreadul.

Totally agree.

An 18 month old child may just about be able to recognise their reflection, never mind ponder whether they identify as a different the gender.

I blame the parents 100%

AnotherNC22 · 21/07/2022 19:51

@Icedbannoffee

Scouts is set up for both boys and girls to join and have appropriate provision and safeguarding in place.

Scouts absolutely do not have appropriate safeguarding in place. It just seems to have bypassed everyone's notice on account of them being a mixed sex organisation.

www.scouts.org.uk/volunteers/inclusion-and-diversity/including-everyone/lgbtplus/transgender-and-gender-identity/supporting-trans-young-people/

"Trans young people should be able to use the toilets or facilities of the gender they identify as."

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 21/07/2022 19:40

PearlClutch · 21/07/2022 19:38

And should the Guides have a residential trip where one of the GirlGuides is male and a pregnancy results, I'm sure everyone will be completely fine with the fact that nobody mentioned one of the Guides sleeping in the dorm was male.

Not to worry! Guiding have planned for this eventuality by allowing leaders to hand out condoms and recommending girls wear sturdy pyjamas.

Yes, really. Really really.

HeleenaHandcart · 21/07/2022 19:40

I took my daughters out (they were fine, finding the particular group a bit dull and I didn’t encourage them to find positives). My eldest is autistic and I knew she would end up in trouble or confused/ upset with it all at some point.
whilst she’d be totally happy to use a pronoun of choice out of respect to the individual, out of kindness, she would not cope with the gaslighting. Being told factually a boy was a girl, she’d comment, get stubborn and confused. I’ve had to talk it through A LOT to navigate it with my 2 who are autistic.

PearlClutch · 21/07/2022 19:38

POTC · 21/07/2022 18:18

I find this as concerning as anything. NO leader should be sharing private, personal information with anyone even family. It breaks so many rules.

And should the Guides have a residential trip where one of the GirlGuides is male and a pregnancy results, I'm sure everyone will be completely fine with the fact that nobody mentioned one of the Guides sleeping in the dorm was male.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 21/07/2022 19:34

POTC · 21/07/2022 18:18

I find this as concerning as anything. NO leader should be sharing private, personal information with anyone even family. It breaks so many rules.

I don't care. She's my mum, she's my DD's grandmother. She will tell me if there is a safeguarding risk to my daughter; that trumps everything else.

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 18:32

Didimum, you might think that ‘A little boy who identifies as a boy is not the same as a transgender girl who identifies as a girl’ but in every scientific, biological and truthful way they are. You cannot force people to accept something is a fact when it simply isn’t true - boys are boys, girls are girls. Humans can’t change sex and you can’t be ‘born in the wrong body’ FACTS. If you believe otherwise that is akin to religious belief, like believing in ghosts or gods or that the world is flat. Absolutely your right to believe those sort of things but what you can’t do is insist that everyone else pretends that they believe them too. Any differences between a boy that is a happy to be a boy and one that thinks they are a girl are just personality and not following gender stereotypes, or sometimes a trauma response, possible with the added complication of adults going reinforcing (or even suggesting in the case of Rainbow) their ideas.

HipTightOnions · 21/07/2022 18:28

A little boy who identifies as a boy is not the same as a transgender girl who identifies as a girl.

Really Didimum?

What do you think is the difference?

Icedbannoffee · 21/07/2022 18:25

Some people suggested we just say no, encourage her to identify with the male characters, but how can you explain that to a young child? To what end? No to playing with toys she loved or characters she loved to pretend to be? It felt cruel to say no, to the say the least

I would bet zero people have said this, if anyone said anything (unlikely) I'd wager it was something reasonable and sensible like- children can play with whatever they please, it doesn't affect their biological sex. Its not like people sprout penises because they play with an action man instead of a barbie.

Simple- join scouts which is truly inclusive not bigotted guides where parents want their precious little darlings to be protected from penises. Have some empathy and get a grip. Having a trans member is not a safegaurding issue growing up in an over protective family however is.

Scouts is set up for both boys and girls to join and have appropriate provision and safeguarding in place. Rainbows are supposed to be a safe space for girls and therefore its not the same. I have empathy for the young child who should have been able to enjoy the toys, stories and clothes they wanted without being told they are a different gender when that's a social construct and they will always be a boy. These harmful gender stereotypes are harmful for everyone.

XSnoe · 21/07/2022 18:22

My daughter has preferred male characters and traditionally "boy" things from around the age of 2.

From 4, she started showing a distaste towards anything stereotypically feminine - pink clothes, dresses, "girl toys", princesses etc. She has loved blue, toys from the "boy section", clothes from the "boy section", monsters and superheros.

Her best friends at school are boys. She refuses to wear the "girl" uniform, so won't wear skirts and dresses.

She has expressed wanting to be a boy because "boys are cool" at times, and recently has said she wants her hair cut short "like the boys".

This is stereotype/gender role based, but imagine how easy it would have been to just tell her that actually, she is a boy, and give her a new name.

POTC · 21/07/2022 18:18

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 20/07/2022 10:38

I am also worried. I have a DD in Brownies and I am always thinking about pulling her out, but she loves it. I have an advantage in that my mum is a guider in her unit, so anything at unit level I know about - she knows and shares my concerns and would tell me if there was a trans male at birth now identifying as female (hoping that's clear enough and on the right side of the talk guidelines) in the unit. But most parents of Rainbows, Brownies and Guides don't have that inside info and once DD gets older and starts wanting to do district activities I will lose that level of safeguarding.

Guiding are fully captured, they fought Katie Alcock in the courts over this and defended to the death the rights of a trans male at birth now identifying as female guide leader to share photos of themselves on public social media dressed in dominatrix leathers and brandishing guns. There is no hope for them.

I find this as concerning as anything. NO leader should be sharing private, personal information with anyone even family. It breaks so many rules.

Scarletandtheblack · 21/07/2022 18:08

Yanbu - and poor Rainbow - how can they possibly make an informed choice about what being trans means at their age?

JustLyra · 21/07/2022 17:52

Our local Rainbow and Brownie leaders quit over this issue.

a couple of them have set up a girls club one evening a week. It’s not the same, and I imagine for them not being part of an organisation they were part of for a very long time must be sad, but they’ve done a brilliant job for girls locally.

CallingOnAvengingAngels · 21/07/2022 17:33

Just to clarify also, Rainbows can and do, take part in residentials, only 1 night at a time, but they absolutely can do this, and many groups do so.

IrishMumInLondon2020 · 21/07/2022 17:00

mamamelons · 20/07/2022 12:50

The comments in this post have left me so angry. For those that read the full article, why are you so hateful? A little girl that knows who she is and parents who support her. God forbid! Unfortunately until you go through something like this with your own child you will never understand, that's why people are being educated on the subject. It's hard enough for young people transitioning so why not try understanding instead of spreading hate and fear.

It’s not a ‘little girl’. It’s a boy.