Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about Rainbows

234 replies

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 08:57

As a guide leader and as a mother I find this worrying:

girlguiding.foleon.com/guiding-magazine/guiding-summer-2022/rainbow-girl

OP posts:
Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:30

So you are suggesting parents subjecting their healthy child to years of medical intervention and therapy for their own benefit/nefarious reasons is not child abuse. Ok. Would you say that if the parents took their child for any other unnecessary medical treatment fit their own satisfaction? What if the child expressed a wish to have a leg cut off as he wanted to be a pirate? Would that be ok for you?

Didimum · 21/07/2022 22:26

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:19

@Didimum why? Why is a child able to make one of those decisions and not the others?

One of the reasons is that the other decisions don’t include the years-long inclusion of dedicated medical professionals and therapists.

Now, I’ve made it abundantly clear that you are not required to agree with me. You can think what you like.

I’m off now, it’s getting late. Byeeee.

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:25

SunnySideDeepDown · 21/07/2022 22:20

There's so much hatred and bigotry in some of these comments.

Trans people do exist. I have a friend who's been a trans man for decades. He's not weird, confused, messed up. He's an intelligent, caring, social, very normal guy.

Stop with the stereotypes and hate

No ones saying transpeople don’t exist. We are discussing the child abuse involved in convincing a toddler they are not the sex they are.

SunnySideDeepDown · 21/07/2022 22:20

There's so much hatred and bigotry in some of these comments.

Trans people do exist. I have a friend who's been a trans man for decades. He's not weird, confused, messed up. He's an intelligent, caring, social, very normal guy.

Stop with the stereotypes and hate

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:20

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 22:17

The Rainbow story is nonsense - it’s so obviously untrue, at least in parts. Children of 18 months don’t ‘identify with’ characters in books, what does that even mean? Most characters in toddlers books are animals or toys anyway. What does a toddler identifying with someone in a book look like? Does it just mean they like them? Or role play the part? Or want the merchandise? I have met lots of very small firemen and super heroes, should their parents let them play with fire and jump off roofs?

according to @didimum yes, toddlers are capable of making all kinds of decisions about their lives

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:19

@Didimum why? Why is a child able to make one of those decisions and not the others?

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 22:17

The Rainbow story is nonsense - it’s so obviously untrue, at least in parts. Children of 18 months don’t ‘identify with’ characters in books, what does that even mean? Most characters in toddlers books are animals or toys anyway. What does a toddler identifying with someone in a book look like? Does it just mean they like them? Or role play the part? Or want the merchandise? I have met lots of very small firemen and super heroes, should their parents let them play with fire and jump off roofs?

RunAlongLoser · 21/07/2022 22:12

justanotherguider · 21/07/2022 21:49

Last time there was a major change (to the promise) there was a full consultation with the membership- we discussed it with the guides & rangers- this has just appeared.....

Oh dear. It would be interesting to know when it changed.

Didimum · 21/07/2022 22:11

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:07

@didimum if the parents starved their child because they said their 18 month old had expressed the idea that they were fat, would that be child abuse or would you condone that? If the child was convinced it was a dog and the parents fed it dog food and walked it on a leash would that be child abuse or would you condone that? If the child said it wanted to get married and the parents allowed it, would you condone that? Why would a child that age, who does not reliably know what it wants to be when it grows up, decide with such certainty it is the opposite sex unless the parents influenced the child. If you can’t see this is child abuse I feel very sorry for your children

I don’t equate those things to the transgender experience. But if you do, fine - once again, we don’t have to agree with each other. And my kids are a-ok, thanks for the concern.

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:07

@didimum if the parents starved their child because they said their 18 month old had expressed the idea that they were fat, would that be child abuse or would you condone that? If the child was convinced it was a dog and the parents fed it dog food and walked it on a leash would that be child abuse or would you condone that? If the child said it wanted to get married and the parents allowed it, would you condone that? Why would a child that age, who does not reliably know what it wants to be when it grows up, decide with such certainty it is the opposite sex unless the parents influenced the child. If you can’t see this is child abuse I feel very sorry for your children

Didimum · 21/07/2022 22:04

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 22:01

You don't view it as child abuse. I do. These parents have lied to their child. They and other adults in the child's life have told the child that a change of name and clothing choices mean everybody now knows this child is the opposite to the sex he was born. Meanwhile, he continues to have a male body and is on course to have male puberty. Eventually reality will have to intrude. Medical intervention in the form of puberty blockers, cross-hormones and surgery will not make a male body into a female one.

I literally said I understand you view it as child abuse. I don’t have to agree with you, however much you’d like me to. You aren’t providing me with new information. I just don’t agree with you. It’s OK - we can have different opinions.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 22:01

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:54

I am condoning something I don’t view as child abuse. It’s really quite simple. I understand that you do. That’s cool - you do you.

You don't view it as child abuse. I do. These parents have lied to their child. They and other adults in the child's life have told the child that a change of name and clothing choices mean everybody now knows this child is the opposite to the sex he was born. Meanwhile, he continues to have a male body and is on course to have male puberty. Eventually reality will have to intrude. Medical intervention in the form of puberty blockers, cross-hormones and surgery will not make a male body into a female one.

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:58

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 21:54

Didum- I know you said ‘identity’ but there is only sex and personality, gender is just a collection of shifting stereotypes, it’s not something I follow, much as I don’t believe in souls or spirits. Only some people believe that people can ‘identify’ as something that they aren’t. I will always treat people politely if I meet them and address them how they wish, but how they identify themselves is generally irrelevant to me and pretty boring unless it impinges on safeguarding or the rights of another group.

Thanks for your opinion. That is not my opinion. We can not agree with eachother - it’s fine.

RockandRollsuicide · 21/07/2022 21:57

My 9 year old mentioned the word "lesbian" the other day.
I asked her where she heard that term as I have done no sex education with her and as far as I am aware they have not done anything about it in school .

She said school and they had a talk about accepting everyone? It's a Catholic 🏫?

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 21:54

Didum- I know you said ‘identity’ but there is only sex and personality, gender is just a collection of shifting stereotypes, it’s not something I follow, much as I don’t believe in souls or spirits. Only some people believe that people can ‘identify’ as something that they aren’t. I will always treat people politely if I meet them and address them how they wish, but how they identify themselves is generally irrelevant to me and pretty boring unless it impinges on safeguarding or the rights of another group.

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:54

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 21:45

@didimum why are you so adamant that this child abuse is not child abuse? Because it is child abuse. No 18 month old can choose their gender. They don’t even know the difference whether they are a boy or a girl in any meaningful way at that age. This child is in for either a world of pain due to puberty blockers (see jazz Jennings for an example of this), or a world of confusion when he hits puberty. This is solely the parents choice. This is child abuse. Why are you condoning it? .

I am condoning something I don’t view as child abuse. It’s really quite simple. I understand that you do. That’s cool - you do you.

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:53

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 21:49

It's impossible to change sex. Accepting one's sex is as important for mental health as accepting one's sexuality and coming to terms with all the other unalterable things about the body and personality. I have no idea what it means to have an identity founded on a refusal to accept reality.

Once again, I didn’t say sex. Do I have to say it a fourth time for the people in the back?

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:51

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 21:45

Didum - it’s true that the very small number of paid people that ‘run’ guides have been totally captured. I don’t believe that the majority of volunteers have though. What is clear is that the more vehemently people try to force the majority to believe fallacies and the more sunlight is shone on the trans industry the more people are starting to speak out to protect children from sterilisation and womens single sex spaces. In fact the aggressive nature of the trans lobby is harming some of the people they claim to speak for.

Maybe - just maybe - some people are exposed to the same information that you are yet form a different opinion. Shocking, I know.

justanotherguider · 21/07/2022 21:49

Last time there was a major change (to the promise) there was a full consultation with the membership- we discussed it with the guides & rangers- this has just appeared.....

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 21:49

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:41

Once again, I didn’t say autonomy over sex, I said identity.

It's impossible to change sex. Accepting one's sex is as important for mental health as accepting one's sexuality and coming to terms with all the other unalterable things about the body and personality. I have no idea what it means to have an identity founded on a refusal to accept reality.

RunAlongLoser · 21/07/2022 21:46

justanotherguider · 21/07/2022 21:35

I've just checked the gguk website.
It depends which bit you look at, but it does appear the law wording has been changed!

Yep, I'm quite new to Brownies so I thought I'd got it wrong, but it has definitely changed. An announcement would have been nice so I didn't look like an idiot in front of the parents!

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 21:45

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:41

Once again, I didn’t say autonomy over sex, I said identity.

@didimum why are you so adamant that this child abuse is not child abuse? Because it is child abuse. No 18 month old can choose their gender. They don’t even know the difference whether they are a boy or a girl in any meaningful way at that age. This child is in for either a world of pain due to puberty blockers (see jazz Jennings for an example of this), or a world of confusion when he hits puberty. This is solely the parents choice. This is child abuse. Why are you condoning it? .

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 21:45

Didum - it’s true that the very small number of paid people that ‘run’ guides have been totally captured. I don’t believe that the majority of volunteers have though. What is clear is that the more vehemently people try to force the majority to believe fallacies and the more sunlight is shone on the trans industry the more people are starting to speak out to protect children from sterilisation and womens single sex spaces. In fact the aggressive nature of the trans lobby is harming some of the people they claim to speak for.

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:41

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 21:39

There is no autonomy over one's sex and which puberty one will go through, if nature is allowed to take its course.

Once again, I didn’t say autonomy over sex, I said identity.

Didimum · 21/07/2022 21:39

Sittininafield · 21/07/2022 21:36

Didum - but you can’t have ‘autonomy’ over your identity when it comes to sex, it’s not something you can choose or change. You can, of course, have autonomy over your clothing, hair etc. I’d argue that 7 year olds shouldn’t have much ‘autonomy’ though as they are young, inexperienced and need guidance. Eg my children never wanted to wear sunhats, but I made them wear them because it was in their interest, wearing skirts or trousers didn’t matter unless trousers were the practical option for long, cold dog walks.

I didn’t say you can have autonomy over sex, I said you can have autonomy over gender (actually I said identity, but let’s not split hairs). And let’s not equate expression of identity to risk of skin cancer - not comparable.