Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about Rainbows

234 replies

justanotherguider · 20/07/2022 08:57

As a guide leader and as a mother I find this worrying:

girlguiding.foleon.com/guiding-magazine/guiding-summer-2022/rainbow-girl

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ancientgran · 22/07/2022 18:58

tillytoodles1 · 20/07/2022 21:48

My nephew was the only boy in his mums group of friends, they all had girls. He played with pushchairs and Barbies, and all the other "girlie" stuff that their mums thought they loved.

At home he still played with his Barbies and stuff, but also cars and other things. It's what kids do, they don't have to like certain things to be girly or boyish.

It really annoyed me when my granddaughter was born that all girls toys were pink.

I absolutely loathe pink since having two granddaughters. They are so brainwashed, they immediately identify any toy as "That's for boys" or "that's for girls." If you ask them why they have no idea but they can still state very definitely that that is the case. Hair is another one, girls have to have long hair even if they hate having it washed or brushed and it is the bane of their lives because girls have to have long hair. I point out all the women with short hair and still they are emphatic that you must have long hair if you are a girl.

I look back on my childhood in the 50s playing Cowboys and Indians, we were never the womenfolk stuck at home we were always fully armed fighting cowboys/braves. My favourite dressing up outfit was Zorro and I loved my mask and sword even more than the cowboy outfit and guns. I did have a doll and a teddy, one of each, and that it was for girly stuff unless you count skipping ropes as girly, boys firmly put in their places if they suggested that and were informed that boxers all skipped.

After all the years of fighting for equality why have we got to this state with children?

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2022 12:34

^RockandRollsuicide* · Today 11:29
What is stonewall I've noticed dd secondary school has raised money for it.

I had forgotten to use bold RockandRoll’s to quote.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:31

Cutesbabasmummy · 22/07/2022 11:32

The poster who wanted her daughter to have a safe space away from penises! Really?! How about all those poor girls at Beavers ( which used to be just boys - there is now no boys only section away from vaginas) and those at mixed sex schools? We live in a society made up of mixed sex/genders whatever! Get used to it!

Oh FFs. For the hard of thinking. Beavers will not allow mixed sex changing. Boys and girls will have separate facilities.

The difference with guides is that they claim to be single sex but are actually single gender and do allow mixed sex changing. So they will allow someone with a penis to change next to a female.

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2022 12:26

RockandRollsuicide · Today 11:29
What is stonewall I've noticed dd secondary school has raised money for it.

Are you joking, or putting out bait? If not, what it is, is a very bad idea for your DD’s secondary school.

It is a lobby group originally formed to help gay people have rights in society. It did very good work in this regard.

When that was largely achieved, it moved on to transgender rights but using Lesbian, Gay and Bi-sexual ‘orientations chained to Transgender identities^ so that the T gets the sympathy for the LGB. Thus people are supposedly now grouped as being LGBT (Q+)

They are not just lobbying for trans gender people’s well being, but for the promotion of the acceptance of T people by gender to be included where people were previously classified by their sex. This matters say if a woman’s refuge now feels that trans women (male bodied people) must be included.

One of the most contradictory things said by their head last year was the suggestion that lesbian women should examine their prejudices if they are not attracted to trans women (male bodied people). This is conflating sex with gender. Of course there is no reason why a lesbian woman should feel attracted to a man who has become a trans woman. So in that context the T is being set at odds with the LG apparent umbrella of LGBT.

There is also the concern that gender non conforming children, or simply children who feel they don’t fit in, ( or have experienced trauma, or are autistic) most of whom will grow up to be heterosexual, but some of whom may grow up to be gay, are instead being given the impression starting from Stonewall and Mermaids influenced resources at school and on-line, that they have a female brain or soul trapped in a male body, or vice versa. If this leads to them trying to change their body, the effects are more harmful and permanent than simply being gay: ‘transing away the gay’ can be the result.

Every kind of institution was/is paying for it not only to advise them, but also validate them according to their adherence to its principles. If an institution does not do as they say, they will lose points and appear to the public to lacking.

Public money is being spent on them.

It has been very harmful in spreading false ideology , often based on lack of scientific evidence, and sometimes misinterpreting or manipulating the law, though it even influenced guidance for the judiciary, and NHS. In the NHS information now ‘gender’ free language can mean erasing words like ‘woman’ or ‘breast feeding’.

Last autumn the House of Lords had to fight for the word ‘Mother’ to be included in a bill regarding leave for female MPs who were pregnant. They really wanted to be allowed the word ‘woman’ but ‘mother’ was finally allowed as a compromise. Words like sex ‘assigned at birth’ are wrongly used, and confusion over whether gender is being used as a euphemism for sex, or to mean an identity, are everywhere.

People are now being pressured to specify ‘pronouns’ at work even if they do not share the belief that they have a ‘gender identity’

The Nolan podcasts about Stonewall

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/p09yjmph
explains much better than I can, as could other more knowledgeable and eloquent posters.

Some institutions have now pulled out, famously the BBC.

LillithCraneosaurus · 22/07/2022 12:24

Cutesbabasmummy · 22/07/2022 11:32

The poster who wanted her daughter to have a safe space away from penises! Really?! How about all those poor girls at Beavers ( which used to be just boys - there is now no boys only section away from vaginas) and those at mixed sex schools? We live in a society made up of mixed sex/genders whatever! Get used to it!

What is so hard for people to understand? It's not about mixed sex in girlguiding. They do not view or treat a transgirl as being of a different sex. An anatomically (i.e. penis) intact, possibly sexually active and interested, 14 year old transgirl guide will be treated as a girl along with all the other 10-14 year old biological girls in a unit. Data protection will prevent a leader warning the parents of the biological girls that their daughters may be sharing space, toilet/shower facilities, dorms/tents with a male bodied individual. Data Protection prevents leaders from even letting on to parents that this may be an issue. Therefore, parents of biological girls are letting their girls take part without informed consent.

Co-ed institutions like Scouts and schools can minimise risks because they have safeguarding procedures in place to account for the 2 different sexes and their needs. Now, granted, if you have a transgirl or transboy in those institutions, they will probably (because all institutions have been captured by TRAs) be pressured to allow them to choose the facilities they want to use. However, the point is that there is a choice and available alternative provisions (in schools there is usually a unisex option); and in the event that facilities may be shared between the two different sexes, these institutions can warn parents that this is the case because they have a mix of male and female bodied children anyway, ands parents therefore have informed consent when sending their children along.

The whole point of guides is to give girls a space away from boys. We have discussed this a lot with the girls in our unit, and time away from males is extremely important to them for a plethora of reasons.

Cutesbabasmummy · 22/07/2022 11:32

The poster who wanted her daughter to have a safe space away from penises! Really?! How about all those poor girls at Beavers ( which used to be just boys - there is now no boys only section away from vaginas) and those at mixed sex schools? We live in a society made up of mixed sex/genders whatever! Get used to it!

RockandRollsuicide · 22/07/2022 11:29

What is stonewall I've noticed dd secondary school has raised money for it.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 11:17

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2022 11:03

Didimum
Evidence-based practice is very important to me, so I'll always be interested in the review of that for all industries.

In case you didn’t know, (this is not being sarcastic), the interim Cass Report is available to down load. The final review will be interesting when it is ready.

Thank you! Yes, I'll be interested to read it too.

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2022 11:03

Didimum
Evidence-based practice is very important to me, so I'll always be interested in the review of that for all industries.

In case you didn’t know, (this is not being sarcastic), the interim Cass Report is available to down load. The final review will be interesting when it is ready.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 10:37

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2022 08:49

Didimum · Today 07:46
It does, however, have little to do with a charitable organisation, such as girl guiding/rainbows, choosing to allow admission to a child who identifies as a transgender girl. Some will applaud that, others will not. Fortunately you have the freedom of choice to not have your daughter (if you have one) join the Rainbows.

No, you are right, that was not to do with whether or not someone chooses to send their child to Rainbows per se.

It was in response to you seeming to, in my opinion, place too much faith in dedicated medical professionals and therapists when you said the following:

One of the reasons is that the other decisions don’t include the years-long inclusion of dedicated medical professionals and therapists.

Also re the subject of medical professionals in the U.K.

The Interim Cass Report,
Sex-Matters
says:
sex-matters.org/posts/updates/the-cass-reviews-interim-report-is-out/

From the point of entry to GIDS there appears to be predominantly an affirmative, non-exploratory approach, often driven by child and parent expectations and the extent of social transition that has developed due to the delay in service provision.

The evidence base for an affirmation-only model is severely lacking.

Re:
Gender clinics U.K.
Nolan Investigates - Stonewall - listen to
Episode 5
A Gender Clinic Insider Speaks Out

I should have also mentioned that my comment on the guidance of medical professionals and therapists was in the context of equating gender-identity guidance to child starvation, the consumption of animal feed, child marriage and limb amputation. In the interests of staying on topic, and not entering into straw man arguments, I feel it's important to make that distinction in order express my opinion.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 10:26

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2022 08:49

Didimum · Today 07:46
It does, however, have little to do with a charitable organisation, such as girl guiding/rainbows, choosing to allow admission to a child who identifies as a transgender girl. Some will applaud that, others will not. Fortunately you have the freedom of choice to not have your daughter (if you have one) join the Rainbows.

No, you are right, that was not to do with whether or not someone chooses to send their child to Rainbows per se.

It was in response to you seeming to, in my opinion, place too much faith in dedicated medical professionals and therapists when you said the following:

One of the reasons is that the other decisions don’t include the years-long inclusion of dedicated medical professionals and therapists.

Also re the subject of medical professionals in the U.K.

The Interim Cass Report,
Sex-Matters
says:
sex-matters.org/posts/updates/the-cass-reviews-interim-report-is-out/

From the point of entry to GIDS there appears to be predominantly an affirmative, non-exploratory approach, often driven by child and parent expectations and the extent of social transition that has developed due to the delay in service provision.

The evidence base for an affirmation-only model is severely lacking.

Re:
Gender clinics U.K.
Nolan Investigates - Stonewall - listen to
Episode 5
A Gender Clinic Insider Speaks Out

Thank you for linking to that review. It was an interesting read. It's my choice to put my faith in physical and mental health professionals – it's completely OK for you to feel as if that is having too much faith. I'm not here to change your opinion, I'm here to express mine. Evidence-based practice is very important to me, so I'll always be interested in the review of that for all industries.

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2022 08:49

Didimum · Today 07:46
It does, however, have little to do with a charitable organisation, such as girl guiding/rainbows, choosing to allow admission to a child who identifies as a transgender girl. Some will applaud that, others will not. Fortunately you have the freedom of choice to not have your daughter (if you have one) join the Rainbows.

No, you are right, that was not to do with whether or not someone chooses to send their child to Rainbows per se.

It was in response to you seeming to, in my opinion, place too much faith in dedicated medical professionals and therapists when you said the following:

One of the reasons is that the other decisions don’t include the years-long inclusion of dedicated medical professionals and therapists.

Also re the subject of medical professionals in the U.K.

The Interim Cass Report,
Sex-Matters
says:
sex-matters.org/posts/updates/the-cass-reviews-interim-report-is-out/

From the point of entry to GIDS there appears to be predominantly an affirmative, non-exploratory approach, often driven by child and parent expectations and the extent of social transition that has developed due to the delay in service provision.

The evidence base for an affirmation-only model is severely lacking.

Re:
Gender clinics U.K.
Nolan Investigates - Stonewall - listen to
Episode 5
A Gender Clinic Insider Speaks Out

bellinisurge · 22/07/2022 07:53

Neither women nor little girls are care givers to any random male (however nice and sweet) who wants them to shove over and make room in a single sex space.
Rainbows were difficult to get into in my area - spaces limited. Beavers and cubs need to be more accommodating. I have a school mum acquaintance whose daughter went to beavers, cubs and scouts. Let them move over. Girls need to learn that they can have protected spaces

Didimum · 22/07/2022 07:46

ScrollingLeaves · 21/07/2022 23:40

Didimum · Today 22:26

“Conflictedunicorn · Today 22:19
@Didimum why? Why is a child able to make one of those decisions and not the others?”

One of the reasons is that the other decisions don’t include the years-long inclusion of dedicated medical professionals and therapists.

Now, I’ve made it abundantly clear that you are not required to agree with me. You can think what you like.

I’m off now, it’s getting late. Byeeee.

I think ‘medical professionals’ diagnose a child as having an inner gender identity separate from their sex are necessarily particularly worthy of belief and respect.

Look at what has been happening in America where are lot of this current trend is coming from:

An excerpt from
thefederalist.com/2018/02/20/rich-white-men-institutionalizing-transgender-ideology/

Transgenderism: A New Medical and Lifestyle Market

It seems obvious now to look at the money behind transgenderism. Many new markets have opened because of it. The first gender clinic for children opened in Boston in 2007. In the past ten years, more than 30 clinics for children with purported gender dysphoria have arisen in the United States alone, the largest serving 725 patients.

This is entering the realm of the myriad issues with private, profit-making healthcare in the US - the issues stem from everything from plagiocephaly helmets to cosmetic surgery to, as you say, medical interventions for transgender people. Indeed, it’s a complex industry in an already complex and problematic nation.

It does, however, have little to do with a charitable organisation, such as girl guiding/rainbows, choosing to allow admission to a child who identifies as a transgender girl. Some will applaud that, others will not. Fortunately you have the freedom of choice to not have your daughter (if you have one) join the Rainbows.

I understand, to some, that it may be seen as a sort of ‘gateway drug’, and therefore it makes its way onto these threads. You are, of course, entitled to your own opinion, as others are entitled to theirs.

nolongersurprised · 22/07/2022 07:33

Schmz · 21/07/2022 14:57

a family licking an infant school age child into trans shape because the child is not conforming to gender norms is not liberal, it’s a safeguarding issue

“Better a trans daughter than a gay son”.

LillithCraneosaurus · 22/07/2022 02:05

Gender critical beliefs are confirmed as protected beliefs under the Equality Act, following Maya Forsater's High Court ruling. No leader expressing GC concerns should be under any threat of expulsion. As I understand it, what happened with Katie Alcock is she settled her case with GGUK, and is probably bound by confidentiality; which she would have had little choice over without facing costs consequences, but frustrating for those of us wanting to see a clear ruling that GGUK cannot impose their batshit quasi religious beliefs on the rest of us. I

n any event, many of us leaders are outspokenly GC and I have emailed GGUK a number of times, both as a parent and a leader on the matter. They are simply not interested. I think they just think they can just railroad this shit through and hope most of us will just get on with it. I'm happy to stay in for the time being and undermine their stupid agenda from within. There is no way I will accept any boy into my unit however they identify. Nobody under18 enjoys the legal status of the opposite sex because they cannot hold a GRC. Therefore, to accept some boys (those who think they are girls), but not all other boys is a breach of the Equality Act. GGUK cannot compel me to break the law. I'll sue them if they try to make me.

LillithCraneosaurus · 22/07/2022 01:53

therarebear · 22/07/2022 00:56

Who is exposing their penis?! FFS. The girls in my daughter's Brownie Unit don't go around exposing their bits! Why would this child?

Use your brain. We take children to activities where they may need to get changed in communal areas - swimming, overnights where they are sharing dorms/tents.

LillithCraneosaurus · 22/07/2022 01:50

ScrollingLeaves · 21/07/2022 23:40

Didimum · Today 22:26

“Conflictedunicorn · Today 22:19
@Didimum why? Why is a child able to make one of those decisions and not the others?”

One of the reasons is that the other decisions don’t include the years-long inclusion of dedicated medical professionals and therapists.

Now, I’ve made it abundantly clear that you are not required to agree with me. You can think what you like.

I’m off now, it’s getting late. Byeeee.

I think ‘medical professionals’ diagnose a child as having an inner gender identity separate from their sex are necessarily particularly worthy of belief and respect.

Look at what has been happening in America where are lot of this current trend is coming from:

An excerpt from
thefederalist.com/2018/02/20/rich-white-men-institutionalizing-transgender-ideology/

Transgenderism: A New Medical and Lifestyle Market

It seems obvious now to look at the money behind transgenderism. Many new markets have opened because of it. The first gender clinic for children opened in Boston in 2007. In the past ten years, more than 30 clinics for children with purported gender dysphoria have arisen in the United States alone, the largest serving 725 patients.

WPATH, World Professional Association for Transgender Health, is not an organisation I would trust at all. This interview with journalist Genevieve Gluck, who has looked into their murky past and present practices, is shocking:

therarebear · 22/07/2022 00:56

Rainbowshit · 21/07/2022 16:55

What a bizarre thing to say. In what way is it bigoted to not want your daughter exposed to a penis against her will?

Who is exposing their penis?! FFS. The girls in my daughter's Brownie Unit don't go around exposing their bits! Why would this child?

ScrollingLeaves · 21/07/2022 23:53

Trans children money making business.

www.tranzwear.net/store.php/TranZwear/pd9488550/best_boy_bump_for_the_little_guys

ScrollingLeaves · 21/07/2022 23:41

Sorry, I meant “I don’t think..”

ScrollingLeaves · 21/07/2022 23:40

Didimum · Today 22:26

“Conflictedunicorn · Today 22:19
@Didimum why? Why is a child able to make one of those decisions and not the others?”

One of the reasons is that the other decisions don’t include the years-long inclusion of dedicated medical professionals and therapists.

Now, I’ve made it abundantly clear that you are not required to agree with me. You can think what you like.

I’m off now, it’s getting late. Byeeee.

I think ‘medical professionals’ diagnose a child as having an inner gender identity separate from their sex are necessarily particularly worthy of belief and respect.

Look at what has been happening in America where are lot of this current trend is coming from:

An excerpt from
thefederalist.com/2018/02/20/rich-white-men-institutionalizing-transgender-ideology/

Transgenderism: A New Medical and Lifestyle Market

It seems obvious now to look at the money behind transgenderism. Many new markets have opened because of it. The first gender clinic for children opened in Boston in 2007. In the past ten years, more than 30 clinics for children with purported gender dysphoria have arisen in the United States alone, the largest serving 725 patients.

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:38

Yes, it’s been recognised as just another way of trying to shut women up. See the trans tactics thread. Wonder what we’ll get next? Please for be kind or accusations of being mean

Didimum · 21/07/2022 22:37

Conflictedunicorn · 21/07/2022 22:30

So you are suggesting parents subjecting their healthy child to years of medical intervention and therapy for their own benefit/nefarious reasons is not child abuse. Ok. Would you say that if the parents took their child for any other unnecessary medical treatment fit their own satisfaction? What if the child expressed a wish to have a leg cut off as he wanted to be a pirate? Would that be ok for you?

I’m not sure. Let me check the WHO guidelines on pirate amputations and I’ll get back to you.

Anyway, it’s been real entertaining, guys. Have a good night.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/07/2022 22:35

SunnySideDeepDown · 21/07/2022 22:20

There's so much hatred and bigotry in some of these comments.

Trans people do exist. I have a friend who's been a trans man for decades. He's not weird, confused, messed up. He's an intelligent, caring, social, very normal guy.

Stop with the stereotypes and hate

There was a point when throwing around words like hate and bigotry got people expressing concerns to back off. That time is over. That hand had been overplayed. Concern about child safeguarding is not hateful or bigoted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread