Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this a bit of a red flag in people?

88 replies

Irmagerd1 · 20/07/2022 08:09

The other day I met a couple that my partner knows. They seemed friendly, particularly the girl. She talked a lot, I mean really a lot, which is fine, maybe a bit different from me but that's who she is. But she was starting to get quite deep and emotional and I had only just met her. Telling me about dark periods in her life and how X point was the only time she'd felt she had any self esteem in life, this kind of thing. At this point I'd met her for 15 minutes.
I noticed that every time her boyfriend was going to speak she'd cut him off and start speaking.
Maybe she wears her heart on her sleeve, or is just very open but it just really seemed too much for someone I'd known for 10 minutes.
Another person I met a couple of years ago was like that. Within an hour of knowing her I knew her relationship history, the relationships she had with her family, that her ex had been controlling, and so on.
I later tried to make friends with her but she just didn't reply to my messages and then randomly cut my partner (who she'd been mates with for years) out of her life, refusing to meet with him and deleting us both of all social media for no apparent reason. I guess she had had own issues.
I think since her I'm always a bit wary of this super over friendly and over familiar types within minutes of meeting them.
Am I wrong to be? Anyone else?

OP posts:
WellThatsNice · 20/07/2022 10:41

Was coming to say it’s definitely common
with ADHD - I’m pretty sure I’ve overshared in the past and I’d be mortified to think someone thought I was trauma dumping or trying to make everything about me. Since being diagnosed I’m more aware of this and I try really hard not to do it, but a lot of ADHD people find small talk quite hard and get straight into the real stuff as a way of connecting. But you also have to do what’s right for you, and if it makes you uncomfortable or you think that your interactions are unbalanced and that they aren’t interested in you at all then you’re entitled not to bother…

leatherboundbooks · 20/07/2022 10:30

MAybe not all like that are people to be wary of but over the years looking back some of the people I have ended up having problems with have been people who have inappropriately overshared right at the beginning. If it was in a therapy group or session, ok, that's what you're there for, if it's someone on a train and you'll never see them again, that's ok. But apart from that I would hold back, based on my experience. How I wish I'd done that with the ones who have caused me problems in the past

sayanythingelse · 20/07/2022 10:28

Well there's wearing your heart on your sleeve and then there's trauma dumping. She was doing the latter.

I've come across a few people like this and their entire life is woe is me. Every bad thing that can happen, has happened to them. I've learnt from experience that there's over 7 billion people on this planet, just surround yourself with more positive people.

woolwinder · 20/07/2022 10:23

SmellyToilet · 20/07/2022 09:11

I don’t do hugging - they can fuck right off with that shite

if a colleague says 'Shall we hug?', I usually say 'OK but no tongues'

bloodybluemoon · 20/07/2022 10:05

Iswym but sometimes people can open up to people they've only met knowing that they are not going to see each other . My colleagues, acquaintances will only ever know the surface me but the lady who does my laser knows more about me and my plans although I filter out the stuff I want to share and keep the stuff in that is too much info.

cushioncovers · 20/07/2022 10:04

Yes it's a red flag for me when people I've only just met off load their entire life story. It shows a lack of self awareness and social boundaries. It's also boring and tiring being someone else's shoulder to cry on when you've literally just met them in a social situation. I get that sometimes you meet someone who's having a particularly bad day and you caught them at a vulnerable moment and I would have compassion for them. But energy vampires that make a habit of bombarding any new person with all their emotional baggage annoy me.

BlooDeBloop · 20/07/2022 09:49

With these people I tend to withhold judgement. Ime people overshare because they are a) open hearted and trusting (I like these), b) drama divas (avoid), or c) recovering addicts or people who've come through a lot of trauma and are used to sharing in support groups (can be draining, or not, depends).

housepilot · 20/07/2022 09:41

Yabu to judge so quickly.

I have a few friends who over-shared, especially in early days of our friendships. While not always, I do find it leads to a deeper level friendship or conversation, rather than chit chat. Not always though. And I don't mind Some friendships being me being more supportive.

Etinoxaurus · 20/07/2022 09:39

🤷🏻‍♀️
People are different.

You’ve described 2 people with porous boundaries, and it can often be difficult to navigate relationships with pp like that so what you’ve spotted is a red flag for not east going.

ImFuminHun · 20/07/2022 09:39

Sorry should add "in the first half an hour of having met them."

ImFuminHun · 20/07/2022 09:38

YANBU at all.

People who tell me their life story, all their dark traumas and past relationships are people that I don't want to be friends with.

Not because of their past because we all have pasts similar but I just don't trust people who give me that much so quickly.

BogRollBOGOF · 20/07/2022 09:35

Friendship should bring mutual support.
Friendship is not being an untrained, unpaid therapist.

Too often emotional vampire types will suck everything from you, then when you're empty, you'll be the bad guy for putting up boundaries/ distance for your own self preservation. Avoid.
(Been there, done that)

Whatalovelydaffodil · 20/07/2022 09:34

A "red flag" for what?

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 20/07/2022 09:28

As previous posters have mentioned, oversharing can be a sign of neuro divergence. Adhd can make me overshare, especially if I'm nervous - I will then be absolutely mortified about it and ruminate on it for weeks afterwards. I still inwardly cringe at things I can remember saying years ago.

It is one of the reasons why I dread real-life interactions, even more so now I know some people view it as being over dramatic or a red flag!

Mally100 · 20/07/2022 09:27

Shoxfordian · 20/07/2022 08:23

I also don’t like oversharers or over familiar people, seems to demonstrate an early lack of boundaries

I steer clear from oversharers. They also come across untrustworthy to me, they might overshare something about me! I know the type you are referring to.

mycatisannoying · 20/07/2022 09:27

YANBU. Apply it to the opposite sex; if a bloke overshared during a first date, I'd run a mile. It's a massive red flag, not least because oversharers are rarely interested in anyone but themselves.

PintofPlain · 20/07/2022 09:25

MissTrip82 · 20/07/2022 08:56

To me it’s a bit of a red flag when people describe behaviour that’s not familiar to them as ‘fake’ and make it very clear they think their way is right whilst also stressing ‘each to their own’ and ‘not judging’ …….

Some people share more because they’re more open and extroverted, some people do so because of previous trauma, some people share at particular times in their lives or with particular people.

I’m not a sharer and I don’t pretend that’s the right or healthy path tbh.

I think that’s fair enough. There’s an implicit suggestion in the OP that her emotions and experiences are more valuable for being kept to herself, and that her hugs are worth more because she doesn’t ‘waste’ them on strangers, but I think it’s a moral neutral either way — they’re just different self-presentations.

As PPs have said, dominating the conversation is deeply tiresome, though.

ThanksAntsThants · 20/07/2022 09:24

Not the cutting people off though, that’s just rude and that is a red flag all on its own regardless of all the other stuff.

onreee · 20/07/2022 09:23

Depends if it was relevant. If the topic was relevant and she shared it, then YABU.

Eg. Asking what she does for work, and it comes up.

Why would it be a red flag? Maybe poor social skills. But what other red flag? Unnecessarily dramatic.

ThanksAntsThants · 20/07/2022 09:22

When I meet someone like that I tend to think drama, chaotic life, problems with emotional regulation, problems with boundaries. Not necessarily bad person, just in the midst of emotional chaos. The reason I think that is because that was who I was when I was like that.

prettyteapotsplease · 20/07/2022 09:22

Perhaps they needed to offload and yours was the sympathetic listening ear? They may not have been looking for a long term friendship and could subsequently regret being too open.

It's often easier to confide in a stranger than someone you know well.

Irmagerd1 · 20/07/2022 09:21

Perhaps I have been quick to judge re the oversharing. It's also the cutting people off and constant talking that I found hard, I'll maybe give her a wide berth. If she doesn't like my quietness that's fine too. She may be different next time.
Funnily the other person mentioned in my OP told me 'I don't like quiet people."

OP posts:
Newmumatlast · 20/07/2022 09:18

Sometimes oversharing is due to a particular issue. I can overshare due to my ADHD and past DV trauma. I don't always want to it just happens.

Irmagerd1 · 20/07/2022 09:15

Draining is the correct word. She's a good person I'm sure, it's just very different personality types and I couldn't wait to get away.

OP posts:
JoPublique · 20/07/2022 09:15

Was drink involved? It could alcohol lowered her inhibitions. I have done the oversharing thing even though I'm a lot more reserved in normal circumstances. I was through a very traumatic period of my life. When I sobered up I cringed so much at how much I had overshared and then was too ashamed to face them so avoided them.

Years later and both of us sober, a woman overshared with me really intimate traumatic details about her life. I felt really connected to her and glad that she was able to confide in me. I felt a lot of empathy towards her and wanted to support her even though we don't know each other.

It's cheesy but I felt honoured she felt comfortable enough to open up to me. I have been told I'm a good listener and have one of those 'kind faces' where I look like I'm smiling even when it's just my default resting face. I would have happily kept in touch with this woman and wouldn't have minded listening to her again, even though I had a lot of my own grief and problems.

It feels good to give back and have an authentic conversation but I completely get uncomfortable oversharing can make some people and I don't think they're wrong to feel this way I just want them to know that it could be a habit of oversharing or it could be they are going through something and you happened to be the one to have this 'dumped' at and to give the benefit of the doubt because one day you may be the one doing the dumping, however unlikely it may seem now.

So it it a red flag? Potentially that they may be an energy vampire but I would say it's an orange flag for boundaries and a red flag for not being mentally well or really struggling in their own life or with mental health right now. They might be in a crisis or it could be their personality.