Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this a bit of a red flag in people?

88 replies

Irmagerd1 · 20/07/2022 08:09

The other day I met a couple that my partner knows. They seemed friendly, particularly the girl. She talked a lot, I mean really a lot, which is fine, maybe a bit different from me but that's who she is. But she was starting to get quite deep and emotional and I had only just met her. Telling me about dark periods in her life and how X point was the only time she'd felt she had any self esteem in life, this kind of thing. At this point I'd met her for 15 minutes.
I noticed that every time her boyfriend was going to speak she'd cut him off and start speaking.
Maybe she wears her heart on her sleeve, or is just very open but it just really seemed too much for someone I'd known for 10 minutes.
Another person I met a couple of years ago was like that. Within an hour of knowing her I knew her relationship history, the relationships she had with her family, that her ex had been controlling, and so on.
I later tried to make friends with her but she just didn't reply to my messages and then randomly cut my partner (who she'd been mates with for years) out of her life, refusing to meet with him and deleting us both of all social media for no apparent reason. I guess she had had own issues.
I think since her I'm always a bit wary of this super over friendly and over familiar types within minutes of meeting them.
Am I wrong to be? Anyone else?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Faciadipasta · 20/07/2022 22:41

I tend to back away from early over sharers too. In my experience they seem to be drama queens who NEED to be the centre of attention all the time.
The same sort of people who like to post things on Facebook like 'I can't do this any more' with nothing further to explain what they're talking about just so that they get loads of 'you ok hun' messages back.
I'm sure not everyone that acts like this is this type of person but I've met a lot who are.
Personally I'm so the other way that I think it's a bit of a flaw too. I feel anxious sharing anything with anyone bar about 3 people in my life. I think this is also a trauma response and I'm sure some people find me stand offish but I can't, I feel ashamed of some of the stuff that's happened to me and I feel like it's not fair to put it on other people.
I also have a tendancy to get angry when I keep reading how brave it is when people share their experiences so that others can know theyre not alone. I mean sure it can be brave and I'm sure a lot of people do feel better knowing that other people have experienced similar , but personally it feels like pressure. Like if I don't share I'm selfish because what about all the other people???

Moonface123 · 20/07/2022 21:52

Sometimes l think if we allowed our guards to go down and be completely honest and vulnerable with one another there would be less mental health issues. We all go through stuff, but adhere to the stiff upper lip mentality that is conditioned on us early on, not sure how healthy that is.
It doesn't really bother me regarding people off loading, l think the real problem is many of us are embarrased as to what to say/ reply.

Dalaidramailama · 20/07/2022 21:51

It may signal a lack of boundaries but that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a red flag. Some of the most bat shit crazy people I’ve ever met have hearts of gold.

She may just be an open book.

Doona · 20/07/2022 21:49

I don't think it's wrong to open up to strangers. It happens sometimes when travelling and the next day you move on and never see them again. It's good and interesting. I like those open people. There are lots of kinds of people in the world, not just one kind, thank goodness.

bellac11 · 20/07/2022 21:47

Sparklybutold · 20/07/2022 21:37

For me this would signal a history of trauma and problems with boundaries. I hope the person you speak of gets the help they need. I think in terms of your response, although I undertsbad it may be unsettling, I think some compassion and some research on the impact of trauma may help?

It is sometimes about poor boundaries and trauma.

I think its completely misguided (and a bit snotty) to suggest to someone that they research trauma to manage to understand complete strangers who overshare.

Its often also about anxiety, people who are anxious, or think that they're being expected to engage or nervous about silence or if they're self obsessed (which can both contribute to but also be a result of anxiety and trauma) they think they need to make conversation, but perhaps their social skills are poor so they gabble on about themselves with lack of self awareness.

It makes them very vulnerable, its why people like that end up with either similar friends/associates who are all similar and then they proceed to fall in and out having loads of arguments with people like that or they attract abusers because they give out so many signals of vulnerability.

TreePoser · 20/07/2022 21:42

I used to do this sometimes
Not to everybody.
But occasionally I'd bump in to somebody and sense that they weren't a judgemental personal and that they had empathy and before I knew it I'd told them too much.

I did sense it scared people away though because I would always find myself realising afterwards, overshared again.

Then I watched this video which really helped. Below. This explains that oversharing is demonstrating a requirement for a really HIGH level of intimacy, immediately. It's a red flag to other healthy people obviously. This shocked me as although i was oversharing because I sensed they were healthy people emotionally, I was revealing my issues to them.

Sparklybutold · 20/07/2022 21:37

For me this would signal a history of trauma and problems with boundaries. I hope the person you speak of gets the help they need. I think in terms of your response, although I undertsbad it may be unsettling, I think some compassion and some research on the impact of trauma may help?

Cakeandbiscuits23 · 20/07/2022 21:34

Last year I was sitting waiting for 15 minutes after getting my covid vaccine when a woman emerged, sat down next to me and proceeded to tell me her life story. Within those 15 minutes I knew that she'd been abused by her mother, had a child with x, y and z conditions, was bullied at school, suffered domestic abuse in her first marriage and was in therapy.

I actually knew who she was (even with the face mask on), she'd been in the year above me at primary school and I remember her getting bullied a lot, we have friends in common now; she doesn't know me though but she'd said something along the lines of she felt I was one if those people that you could just open up to without fear, or something. I just remember thinking omg be careful, she is clearly a very vulnerable person who'd already through a lot and someone could easily take advantage of that. Not sure what made her share such personal info with a random stranger though.

HappyBinosaur · 20/07/2022 21:23

I have adhd and I do this, especially when I’m nervous. It’s not a lack of self awareness and it’s not for drama or attention, I just can’t seem to help doing it.

I actually hate myself for it and try to avoid meeting new people. My old friends and family seem to love and accept me as I am but once someone actually said something similar to the OP but to my face and it upset me so much that I have been wary of talking to new people since.

I don’t expect everybody to like me but it upsets me to think I’m seen as a ‘red flag’.

Interestingly in my job, which is quite people centred, I don’t do this as much and am a good listener and much more confident in myself. It tends to be socially with new people that I struggle.

bellac11 · 20/07/2022 21:09

You are unreasonable for using such a cliched and over the top phrase like 'red flag'

SheeplessAndCounting · 20/07/2022 21:05

So someone in need of help rather than "attention seeking" or "a red flag".

SheeplessAndCounting · 20/07/2022 21:05

Sometimes it is a symptom of trauma and resulting lack of boundaries.

Shakeitshakeitbaby · 20/07/2022 12:04

Sounds possibly neurodivergent. Recognise my own behaviour here.

RockinHorseShit · 20/07/2022 12:00

This thread has just confirmed that I should just stop trying to socialise and go and live under a rock 😂

Please don't feel like that, I think most of us prefer open honest outwardly friendly people, but we've experienced attention seekers & covert narcissistic behaviour too & know there's no way to initially tell the difference

WellThatsNice · 20/07/2022 11:36

Same here Stroopwaffle5000! I’ve basically become a hermit in the last few years- easier than reliving social interactions and thinking “shit, should I have said this? What does that mean” etc etc 😅

Stroopwaffle5000 · 20/07/2022 11:34

Just to add, I don't overshare to get sympathy or because I want a shoulder to cry on. I'm usually making light of whatever it is I'm talking about and trying to make the other person laugh. I'm terrified of coming across as boring, quiet or shy. All things which I got teased for when I was younger and the
silence freaks me out.

Stroopwaffle5000 · 20/07/2022 11:27

As PP said, over sharing is common in neurodivergents, such as people with ADHD. It can also be down to social anxiety. I often get verbal diarrhea when I'm really nervous, or I go the other way and can't speak. This thread has just confirmed that I should just stop trying to socialise and go and live under a rock 😂

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 20/07/2022 11:24

I treat people like that with caution. It could just be their nature, a nervous twitch maybe, or they are just an open book.

On the other hand, they could be attention seekers, on the lookout for someone new to give them attention, help or money in some cases. I know of people who are a massive over sharers, always drowning in misery, and on the look out for new people to get money from and steal from. They are obviously ones to avoid.

RockinHorseShit · 20/07/2022 11:19

To me it shows clear lack of boundaries & I'd also be very wary. I'd initially step back & observe though, rather than refuse to interact with them further, as I'm aware this can sometimes be due to ND, it can also be the sign of a covert Narc & attention seeker though, something I learnt the hard way

11Hawkins · 20/07/2022 11:18

Characterises for autistic or ADHD people. It's not a red flag.
I can be like this when I'm nervous, that or I'm selectively mute. It depends.

However.... if they drone on about drama "oh Susan down the road she's a bitch," or "this person just looked at me and pissed me off how dare they look at me!" Now that's a red flag.

Dacquoise · 20/07/2022 11:15

BlooDeBloop · 20/07/2022 09:49

With these people I tend to withhold judgement. Ime people overshare because they are a) open hearted and trusting (I like these), b) drama divas (avoid), or c) recovering addicts or people who've come through a lot of trauma and are used to sharing in support groups (can be draining, or not, depends).

Yes, agree with this. It's hard to tell definitively until you have experienced them a bit.

New yoga group, guy turned up and within minutes was telling us about his terminal brain tumour diagnosis. Given three months to live and still around three years later. Felt very uncomfortable with such stark information and discretely moved away. But turns out he's a really nice bloke, very kind with a family he adores, sort of person that grows on you. Perhaps he needed to set out his story in a new group?

Another person latched onto me in another group setting, immediately decided I was her 'best friend' and,although she has some good qualities, plays this toxic push me, pull me dynamic that is very draining. Complete drama queen and hysteric at times. Keep her firmly at arms length.

There's nowt queer as folk!

gnilliwdog · 20/07/2022 11:13

I have wondered about some of the super lively, life of the party types I have met. They seem so charming, but a few times now it seems to me their huge social effort was hiding some pretty dark stuff. I tend to trust less talkative people now, who say what they mean and don't try too hard to be liked!

SoupDragon · 20/07/2022 11:08

Whatalovelydaffodil · 20/07/2022 09:34

A "red flag" for what?

That is exactly what I thought 😂

Gruffling · 20/07/2022 11:06

Oversharing is characteristic of autistic women. Sometimes we don't understand the social nuances of when it is appropriate to share with someone.

onreee · 20/07/2022 10:45

Whatalovelydaffodil · 20/07/2022 09:34

A "red flag" for what?

Exactly! Everything is a red flag these days. If you personally wouldn't want to be friends with someone who overshares, fine, but it's not a red flag. Red flag for what???

And one persons over sharing is another's open and relatable.

Not everything has to be red flag, it's ok to just not want to be mates.