Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 22/07/2022 10:58

@Didimum

transphobic for these slurs and misrepresentations to be given a platform in said discussions.

If you see a slur, report it. MNHQ are very quick on deletions for genuine transphobia.

I don't get the misrepresentation bit. Most of the discussion on this thread is about the details of the ruling- what do you think is being misrepresented?

Didimum · 22/07/2022 10:52

HTH1 · 21/07/2022 21:46

It used to be called a vagina (back in the days when we had “women”).

So much interest on this thread on my use of 'transphobic hole'. Must admit, I did not at first spot the double entendre. To clarify – as it appears some need it – I am referring to the frequent occurrence of trans-identity threads on MN to collapse into slurs and misrepresentations. In my opinion (because let's be very clear that it is my opinion and no one is required to share it), it is not transphobic to open discussions on gender and sex identity, but it is transphobic for these slurs and misrepresentations to be given a platform in said discussions. Hope that clears things up.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/07/2022 10:20

Naked from the waist down is HR speak for had his cock out.

Had her cock out you fucking bigot ;-)

donquixotedelamancha · 22/07/2022 10:15

For me, that fundamentally changes the tenor of the case. A non-trans man should definitely not be in those facilities, a non-trans woman has every right.

Why? I don't think it makes any difference in who gets their cock out. If you have a mixed sex shower area having a penis on show is not unreasonable.

I wonder if the tribunal viewed the appropriate comparator as "someone who is not trans" but eligible to use that changing room i.e. a woman.

I think that's exactly what they did. I think the judgement implies that fairly clearly. The reason that's the case is not the courts fault- the trust made these showers available to all 'women,', including men. Once you have all 'women ' using the showed you can't treat the male ones differently.

Clymene · 22/07/2022 09:26

TheFeistyFeminist · 22/07/2022 08:45

Can anyone clear up a point of confusion for me, with reference to legal precedent perhaps?

Evidencing discrimination relies on comparing the treatment of someone without the protected characteristic.

Who would the comparator be in this case? I always thought it has to be "someone who is not trans" but is otherwise the same i.e. male bodied, but I wonder if the tribunal viewed the appropriate comparator as "someone who is not trans" but eligible to use that changing room i.e. a woman.

For me, that fundamentally changes the tenor of the case. A non-trans man should definitely not be in those facilities, a non-trans woman has every right. That one point clouds the judgment.

I did a bit of a search online yesterday and found comparator examples for other protected characteristics but not for gender reassignment. Is there anything?

Thanks.

I'm not sure if this has been talked about on this thread but it has on my thread in FWR on the same topic. Essentially many lawyers think the EJ applied the comparator wrong in this case - in this case, someone without the protected characteristic is a man who isn't going through gender reassignment.

twitter.com/peter_daly/status/1549735172131651584?s=21&t=CTpulfhYNz-29qKkgPl3Rg

TheFeistyFeminist · 22/07/2022 08:45

Can anyone clear up a point of confusion for me, with reference to legal precedent perhaps?

Evidencing discrimination relies on comparing the treatment of someone without the protected characteristic.

Who would the comparator be in this case? I always thought it has to be "someone who is not trans" but is otherwise the same i.e. male bodied, but I wonder if the tribunal viewed the appropriate comparator as "someone who is not trans" but eligible to use that changing room i.e. a woman.

For me, that fundamentally changes the tenor of the case. A non-trans man should definitely not be in those facilities, a non-trans woman has every right. That one point clouds the judgment.

I did a bit of a search online yesterday and found comparator examples for other protected characteristics but not for gender reassignment. Is there anything?

Thanks.

HTH1 · 21/07/2022 21:46

Soontobe60 · 20/07/2022 06:33

What’s a ‘transphobic hole’?

It used to be called a vagina (back in the days when we had “women”).

SiobhanSharpe · 21/07/2022 20:22

It's not often said directly but reading some reports about these incidents it is clear that the unclothed or partially unclothed male bodied person in female-only changing rooms or spas is obviously sexually aroused.
I'm thinking particularly of the person in the Wi-Spa, where it was actually mentioned by one of the people objecting to his presence. He was later charged with a crime for this (and it seems was a known sex offender.)
Also there were some reports about the U.S. swimmer from their team mates. No one said the actual word but there was a mention of how pleased he was to be wandering around naked.
So IMO that's definitely flashing, not validation.

DoElephantsHaveWrinkles · 21/07/2022 11:17

I don't understand the defenders of this.

If Dave from next door was seen naked from the waist down with your 11-year-old girl in a female changing room, there would be shouting from the rooftops.

Dave is now called Davina, and in the exact same scenario, would be thought of as a poor vulnerable minority that shouldn't be challenged.

When does the magic happen that turns a man into a woman, what materially changes? Absolutely nothing as far as I can see.

And so many people (and a ridiculous amount are women that should know better) will actually argue that those who object are bad people.

Take a look in the mirror and see what you're advocating for. There are no safeguards whatsoever. Any male person can now enter any female space and we have no way to fight back as soon as they utter the words "but I am a woman".

How do people get their heads around the cognitive dissonance to actually argue that it's OK? What am I missing?

BoredofthisCrap7 · 21/07/2022 09:38

It's all so damn nebulous though isn't it, trying to pin down EXACTLY why this is any different from your bog standard case of indecent exposure (I don't think it is).

WHY is it different from a regular bloke swanning into a female space with his dick on display?
WHAT makes this person different?
We surely agree that they are both biological males.
So therefore it must be down to an internal feeling in this persons head that gives them some kind of exemption to the normal rules.
WHY should we care about the feeling in someone's head?
And HOW do you prove that they even HAVE that feeling in their heads?
What does "living as a woman" mean, if that is supposed to be some kind of marker or proof? Wearing a skirt? At what point does he magically change into a woman and therefore have the right to have male genitals on display? When does his penis become female anatomy?
How can we make laws and legislation around something so unproveable and nebulous?

It all comes back to the fact the he SAYS he is a woman. We are expected to acquiesce to some man, saying he is a woman, and because he SAYS that, it somehow changes how the law applies to him.

For those on this thread who think this is all fine and the poor little TW has been hard done by, do you think it is fine for a penis to be in a female space?
Would you be happy with your female child sharing an intimate space with a fully intact male just because they say they are a woman?
I can't see that this has been answered anywhere.

PrincessNutella · 21/07/2022 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CrossStichQueen · 21/07/2022 09:08

I do wonder if the bending over backwards by the trust was because they knew that the TW would take them down the tribunal path?

Reading the judgement it's clear that all but 1 of the TW complaints were dismissed as the tribunal found that the trust had not only followed policies and bent over backwards to support the TW they could also evidence it.
Where as the TW offered little to no evidence and what they did provide which was a secret recording actually favoured the trust.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 21/07/2022 09:01

Personally, in over 40 years of employment, I've never known management to bend over backwards to such extreme extents for anyone, ever. It's incredible.

Yes. I've been horrendously bullied and seniors have admitted it happened and that it was unjust but it has also been made clear they would not address it and the union just shrugged.

AlisonDonut · 21/07/2022 07:40

DrainedHelp · 21/07/2022 06:31

Does anyone know the ratio of trans men to trans women? Are there more trans women and if so by roughly how much?

Is there any reason/research why there are more men that want to be like women if this is the case?

Are there any middle aged women who decide they are men? As in, any at all? Have you seen any evidence of women putting on suits and masturbating in male toilets, and posting pictures of this on line. Or of them taking swords into male toilets and taking pictures of themselves? Or heard of them insisting on using male toilets and changing rooms before they even start the job, and getting naked from the waist down in front of men?

FOJN · 21/07/2022 07:18

Perlunk · 20/07/2022 08:56

The volume of wrong information repeated as fact on this thread is awful.

if you’re going to comment or judge, at least go scan the tribunal report and read what actually was described.

The abuse of the trans person, which the trust accept happened, was repellent and totally inexcusable.

At no point did anyone say a penis was sighted/flashed/flaunted/waved.

The glossing over of actual transphobic behaviours, right along with demonisation of a trans person with invented behaviours, is not OK.

I am part way through reading the tribunal findings and I think you have misunderstood the trust's position and have also glossed over the fact that even the tribunal judges diplomatically referenced the claimants credibility deficit.

If you have read the document, including the legal principles at the beginning then it is apparent that there was no legal benefit to the Trust in trying to prove the claimant a liar. Not disputing the claimants allegations of transphobic abuse (specifically the two notes in the locker and the overheard conversation in the changing room) is not evidence that this actually happened. The Trust simply had to prove that they had done everything possible to prevent other staff discriminating against the claimant which they were easily able to do. Attempting to prove the claimant was lying would not have added to their defence at all.

The claimant stated that they destroyed the first abusive note they received, which seems somewhat implausible given their behaviour both before and after employment, so there was no tangible evidence that an abusive note had even been left. There was no corroborating evidence for the overheard conversation despite other colleagues being in the changing room at the same time and one of them helpfully supplying a list of everyone else who was present at the time the alleged conversation took place. The only tangible evidence provided was an abusive message written on a sanpro disposal bag but as no handwriting analysis was ever undertaken we cannot rule out that the claimant wrote it. A thorough investigation of all incidents was undertaken, the claimants account of events was inconsistent which was acknowledged by the tribunal judge.

The only thing we know for sure is that the claimant made allegations which could not be verified and there was no legal benefit to the Trust disputing the claimants account.

bellinisurge · 21/07/2022 06:57

@DrainedHelp AGP is an exclusively male condition so I imagine that would distort any counting. Also counting is genocide because they just want to pee.

bellinisurge · 21/07/2022 06:56

@Scianel , you've changed my mind. I will now also talk around pronouns to avoid using.

DrainedHelp · 21/07/2022 06:31

Does anyone know the ratio of trans men to trans women? Are there more trans women and if so by roughly how much?

Is there any reason/research why there are more men that want to be like women if this is the case?

NewPotatoSalad · 21/07/2022 00:28

Indeed. Flashing, sexual exhibitionism, is a crime, unless committed by... in which case it didn't happen and anyway, women are being mean and nasty.

Jedsnewstar · 21/07/2022 00:16

They used to take flashing seriously.

NewPotatoSalad · 21/07/2022 00:11

The report is 61 pages, and it's really worth reading (hope this link works):
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/62cff0578fa8f50bfafb091d/V_v_Sheffield_Teaching_Hospitals_NHS_Foundation_Trust_1806836-2020___Others.pdf

Personally, in over 40 years of employment, I've never known management to bend over backwards to such extreme extents for anyone, ever. It's incredible.

And as PP have said - there should be no men in women's single-sex spaces, ever. No males in females' spaces. This has to be law. This needs to be law, not some mere option according to whim or interpretation.

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 21:56

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 15:56

Maybe @HackneyMum1 read the tread and saw the website and is too embarrassed to say she was wrong. And didn’t @Discovereads battery die so conveniently had to log off….

Haha, nah! Just got bored and decided to get on with something worth my time

Scianel · 20/07/2022 21:03

I won't use preferred pronouns for reasons mentioned above. I'll talk round them if necessary but that's as far as I'll go.

TheKeatingFive · 20/07/2022 19:11

Thinking about it, I'm more comfortable with someone avoiding their own sex pronouns than I am with them laying claim to the opposite sexes pronouns. So perhaps they/them would be a better compromise. Or attempting to avoid pronoun use altogether, which is possible.

bellinisurge · 20/07/2022 18:59

Polite pronouns is all I'm prepared to do. Take the piss out of my goodwill in terms that I determine, and I withdraw my concession.
At my work, they were well on the way to getting compelled pronouns in our email signatures. Someone senior stepped in and we had an all staff message saying: do or don't your choice. It all but quoted the Forstater case.