Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:38

A communal changing room is very much a public place!!!

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:36

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:34

To answer that I think 'expose themselves' is a phrase that needs contextualisation and clarification of the intent behind the 'exposure'. In my opinion it is not clear in the case discussed in this thread – you don't have to share that opinion, of course.

Contextualisation?

If you see someone's penis without your express permission then they have exposed themselves to you.

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:34

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:31

I don't believe anyone is claiming that here. Though generally used definition of a 'flasher' is to expose in a 'public setting' and not a private one. So perhaps a more appropriate term could be used when an incident such as that does occur.

This was at work.

In a hospital.

It is weird how the dismantling of what we used to think of as 'safeguarding' has been torn down completely by people who just want to be nice.

God help our girls.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:34

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:30

Just to be clear, you believe males who expose themselves to females are just fine? At what age of female do you think it is not fine? Or is ok at any age?

To answer that I think 'expose themselves' is a phrase that needs contextualisation and clarification of the intent behind the 'exposure'. In my opinion it is not clear in the case discussed in this thread – you don't have to share that opinion, of course.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:31

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:26

I do not accept that it's transphobic to say that any male who intentionally exposes their penis to an unwilling woman is a flasher.

I don't believe anyone is claiming that here. Though generally used definition of a 'flasher' is to expose in a 'public setting' and not a private one. So perhaps a more appropriate term could be used when an incident such as that does occur.

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:30

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:22

@donquixotedelamancha

On the specific topic: do you think it was OK for this pre-op, non-passing, transwoman to be showering with women @Didimum?

It is not something I would have objected to on a personal level. I respect other women's right to object to it however.

Just to be clear, you believe males who expose themselves to females are just fine? At what age of female do you think it is not fine? Or is ok at any age?

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:26

I do not accept that it's transphobic to say that any male who intentionally exposes their penis to an unwilling woman is a flasher.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:24

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 12:01

Most often we make these judgements and distinctions in a court of law. But not a perfect system of course

So if I'm getting changed at work, and I get flashed at, I should wait until a court decides whether I was either sexually harrassed or was transphobic because it was a lady dick and therefore I'm the one in the wrong?

It was simply a comment on how society decides whether a criminal act has been committed.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:22

@donquixotedelamancha

On the specific topic: do you think it was OK for this pre-op, non-passing, transwoman to be showering with women @Didimum?

It is not something I would have objected to on a personal level. I respect other women's right to object to it however.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:21

The HR woman will now have to modify her presentation to remove the part about there being no evidence of transwomen causing any issues in the ladies.

Wonder if being exposed to the reality of it will have changed her enthusiasm for such inclusion?

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:16

What all the do gooders up in arms about the women being so mean to this person don't seem to comprehend, is that situations like this will mean that more trans people are unlikely to be offered jobs because from the moment the job was offered the demands and concessions were made.

At no time did the trust actually ever think of their duty of care towards the female people they employed. If the tribunal had actually considered the women subjected to the behaviour of course they wouldn't accept this from a man, but say the magic word 'trans' and everyone loses their rational minds.

In reality if this person had been treated like any other non trans person, he would have been let go months before he left. If he ever made it to the start date.

If a non trans male had insisted on using the female changing rooms, they would have said no. That was the time to put their line in the sand, and they didn't and they are paying for it.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/07/2022 12:10

That was in reference to how we decide if someone is 'a flasher' or not – not the use of changing rooms.

OK. As PPs have said, I don't think that judgement is restricted to courts either but, again, best to report posts that really annoy you rather than making it the focus of the discussion.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:09

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:01

As far as I can make out there are only 2 things that we know happened.

The colleague was naked from the waist down in the female changing rooms, which the management had given him the authority to use.

The manager asked if they usually wore underwear.

The rest of it cannot be proven.

The reason that they lost the case is because the Employment Tribunal used the comparitor of a female rather than male.

Thanks for the summary – this is very explanatory of how I feel about the details of the case and therefore the subsequent conversations about it.

Again, so as not to be accused of 'running away', I don't have time to respond to all the posts to me just now. But I will try to pop back later.

GertrudeKerfuffle · 22/07/2022 12:03

I've been flashed a number of times, thankfully not in a women's changing room, and no court ever found hose men guilty of flashing me, but they were still flashers.

Roll on the day that every instance of flashing could be taken seriously and punished to the point that it becomes completely socially unacceptable.

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 12:01

Most often we make these judgements and distinctions in a court of law. But not a perfect system of course

So if I'm getting changed at work, and I get flashed at, I should wait until a court decides whether I was either sexually harrassed or was transphobic because it was a lady dick and therefore I'm the one in the wrong?

donquixotedelamancha · 22/07/2022 12:01

However, subsequent slurs did persist on this thread, and go unchallenged – always very disappointing to see.

People get animated on the subject of women's rights. I don't think it's great to tell women it's their responsibility to police each others tone. The mechanism on this site is to report for deletion- if a post is really inappropriate.

It was my opinion on the descent of the majority of most MN threads of similar topics.

I think generalised slurs against the whole site are quite unhelpful to these discussions but I haven't reported that post because we are all pretty thick skinned.

On the specific topic: do you think it was OK for this pre-op, non-passing, transwoman to be showering with women @Didimum?

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:01

GertrudeKerfuffle · 22/07/2022 11:39

Hold on, @Didimum

Your original 'transphobic hole' comment was in response to the OP, which was expressing concern for the women who had potentially been exposed to a naked penis in a women's changing room. Did you read the article and tribunal papers before making your comment? It seems like you were just ready to jump in and slur any discussion of this case as 'transphobic'.

So many posters here have looked very closely at the source material to try and build a picture of what happened in this case, and there have been some detailed discussions of the law as interpreted in this case. All very illuminating. Have you read it all?

As far as I can make out there are only 2 things that we know happened.

The colleague was naked from the waist down in the female changing rooms, which the management had given him the authority to use.

The manager asked if they usually wore underwear.

The rest of it cannot be proven.

The reason that they lost the case is because the Employment Tribunal used the comparitor of a female rather than male.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 11:58

donquixotedelamancha · 22/07/2022 11:51

Most often we make these judgements and distinctions in a court of law.

That's not the case. Who uses changing rooms and showers is self policed on social norms. The number of court cases on this is non-existently small.

Even this case wasn't about that- the trust made the decision to let this male shower with the women because she was trans. That wasn't challenged in court. What was discussed was that, having decided on mixed sex showers, the NHS couldn't then insist the transwoman didn't get her penis out.

That was in reference to how we decide if someone is 'a flasher' or not – not the use of changing rooms.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/07/2022 11:56

Most often we make these judgements and distinctions in a court of law. But not a perfect system of course.

But in the moment ... a woman walks into a women's change room and there is an individual there with a penis exposed - how does she tell the difference between a flasher and a non-flasher?

Didimum · 22/07/2022 11:55

I'm sorry I can't respond to everyone responding to me – busy day! In essence, I fully admit (and apologise to those engaged in open discussion) that my initial post on this thread was also inflammatory and perhaps preemptive (we all get out of the wrong side of the bed some mornings). However, subsequent slurs did persist on this thread, and go unchallenged – always very disappointing to see.

I suppose some of my responses have been vague because it's a very complex issue and I don't have time to write essays, and have to convey my opinion in a few brief sentences. As I've said time and time again, no one here has to agree with me. I am here to express my opinion and not to proactively change the opinions of others.

GertrudeKerfuffle · 22/07/2022 11:52

'Most often we make these judgements and distinctions in a court of law. But not a perfect system of course.'

When you say this, @Didimum are you suggesting that women should take it on trust that any biologically male person in a women's space is acting in good faith, and leave it to the courts to sort it out if the worst happens? That hasn't worked well, for example in the case of rape on a women's only hospital ward.

user1471447863 · 22/07/2022 11:52

I don't see anything that described the layout of the changing facilities. In a workplace, i'd expect any changing, beyond removal of a jacket/outdoor clothing to be in a place that afforded suitable individual privacy so that you wouldn't be subjected you your colleagues underwear/nakedness or required to expose yourself to your colleagues. If trans person was misusing the facility and helicoptering his lady penis in a communal area then that is an issue with him - not the others.
By the sounds of it he is a serial grievance mongerer and would have been looking to be discriminated anywhere they went.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/07/2022 11:52

In the circumstance where opinions are based solely on prejudices and biases.

But in my case, it is because some individuals with penises use them to assault and rape and I can't tell the difference between those who do and those who do not, combined with simply wanting privacy and dignity and not having to see a penis unsolicited and also not wanting an individual with a penis to see me naked. This applies to all individuals with penises.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/07/2022 11:51

Most often we make these judgements and distinctions in a court of law.

That's not the case. Who uses changing rooms and showers is self policed on social norms. The number of court cases on this is non-existently small.

Even this case wasn't about that- the trust made the decision to let this male shower with the women because she was trans. That wasn't challenged in court. What was discussed was that, having decided on mixed sex showers, the NHS couldn't then insist the transwoman didn't get her penis out.

GertrudeKerfuffle · 22/07/2022 11:48

If the definition of transphobia is nebulous and open to interpretation, it's probably best not to throw the term around.