Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:11

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 13:04

Private' is my home. Having said that, if a plumber with a penis dropped pants in my bathroom and exposed said penis it would also be flashing.

@Didimum do you agree that the example given here is an example of flashing?

By the information available I don't think there is enough evidence to make that call one way or another – however, I'm certainly interested to read more on it should more information become available.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/07/2022 13:09

I agree 'public place' can definitely throw up a lot of grey areas.

But the common factor is that the penis is being exposed in an unsolicited way to a non-consenting woman.

Surely this is the essence?

We used to say that if a person with a penis used that penis to penetrate a woman with whom the penis person had signed a marriage certificate that it was not rape. We now agree it is rape (I assume).

So, even if an individual with a penis exposes said penis to a woman in the context of marriage when it is unsolicited and unwanted then surely it is flashing?

And with that as the bar, surely the plumber exposing a penis is flashing?

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:08

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 13:02

For example (and this is very simplistic of course), the objection to sharing a space with a transgender woman because of a belief that a transgender woman is more likely to enjoy indecently and inappropriately exposing themselves (eg, a 'flasher')

Transgender women are males. Males are overwhelmingly more likely to be flashers than women, therefore a "belief" that they are more likely to be a flasher is a FACT and not a belief at all.
How then can it be transphobic?

That's a really interesting point to think on – and I will think on it. I certainly agree that the area of prejudices and biases throw up a lot of grey areas, and I do agree that women unfortunately have to rely on biases more so than men due to the treat, as a group, they are under. And, as I said, it was a simplistic example.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 22/07/2022 13:07

@Didimum the legal definition in the U.K.

The Sexual Offences Act 2003 provides a clear definition of what indecent exposure is in the UK. Indecent exposure is an offence where: A person intentionally exposes their genitals, and. They intend for someone to see them and be caused alarm or distress.

Given that this individual only had permission to use the cubicles in the womens changing room it is reasonable to state that exposing their genitals in the communal area of the womens changing room would be an intentional exposure intended for someone to see them and to cause alarm or distress.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 13:04

Private' is my home. Having said that, if a plumber with a penis dropped pants in my bathroom and exposed said penis it would also be flashing.

@Didimum do you agree that the example given here is an example of flashing?

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:04

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:56

Of course you won't engage with me because the answer should be 'never'. NEVER is it ok for a man to get his penis out in front of a woman or girl without her permission.

In public. In private. In a changing room. In a classroom. In a doctor's surgery. In an operating theatre.

Most men know this and don't get their penises out. If men are getting theirs out in front of you or you are getting yours out in front of females, then your boundaries are completely and utterly fucked.

No, I won't engage with you because I don't find sarcasm useful to a discussion.

As I've said before, I'm not here to change your opinion, simply to express mine. If you want to tell people what they 'should think', go ahead and do that. I have freedom of opinion, just the same as you.

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 13:02

For example (and this is very simplistic of course), the objection to sharing a space with a transgender woman because of a belief that a transgender woman is more likely to enjoy indecently and inappropriately exposing themselves (eg, a 'flasher')

Transgender women are males. Males are overwhelmingly more likely to be flashers than women, therefore a "belief" that they are more likely to be a flasher is a FACT and not a belief at all.
How then can it be transphobic?

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:59

Clymene · 22/07/2022 12:45

Actually the claimant only had permission to use a cubicle within the changing room. They were never given permission to change in the communal area, whether or not they removed their underwear.

This is what I mean my contextualisation. Thanks for posting this. In this instance, I think the individual should have adhered to the policy they were given, unless there was some acceptable reason why that was not possible (for example, doors of the cubicles were broken).

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:56

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:51

I said 'contextualisation' not 'definition'. To your 'minimum age' question, again, I think it needs contextualisation. It's OK for you not to agree with me, I don't welcome sarcasm so won't be engaging with your questions.

Of course you won't engage with me because the answer should be 'never'. NEVER is it ok for a man to get his penis out in front of a woman or girl without her permission.

In public. In private. In a changing room. In a classroom. In a doctor's surgery. In an operating theatre.

Most men know this and don't get their penises out. If men are getting theirs out in front of you or you are getting yours out in front of females, then your boundaries are completely and utterly fucked.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:55

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/07/2022 12:48

I think of a 'public place' as being a space which members of the public have unrestricted access to and right of way. I wouldn't apply that to a workplace changing room. Perhaps you would define it differently, however.

My colleagues are 'members of the public'. If an individual with a penis came into my office which requires swipe card access and dropped pants and exposed said penis it would be flashing.

Ditto if the individual did the same in the women's changeroom we have on site.

'Private' is my home. Having said that, if a plumber with a penis dropped pants in my bathroom and exposed said penis it would also be flashing.

I agree 'public place' can definitely throw up a lot of grey areas.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:53

babyjellyfish · 22/07/2022 12:49

But women shouldn't have to give any justification at all for why they don't want to share changing spaces with someone with a penis.

"I don't want to" should be good enough.

I didn't say they they to give justification.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:51

I said 'contextualisation' not 'definition'. To your 'minimum age' question, again, I think it needs contextualisation. It's OK for you not to agree with me, I don't welcome sarcasm so won't be engaging with your questions.

Conflictedunicorn · 22/07/2022 12:50

Exactly. Why do women’s thoughts and feelings always come below those of males. Even one woman saying no or showing concern for whatever reason should be enough.

GertrudeKerfuffle · 22/07/2022 12:50

Yes we're not going to get very far when the definition of every word is open to interpretation.

But then that seems to be the idea.

babyjellyfish · 22/07/2022 12:49

Didimum · 22/07/2022 11:23

Not in every circumstance, no. And, of course, everyone is entitled to object to something they feel strongly about. Again, some objections can veer into transphobic territory. For example (and this is very simplistic of course), the objection to sharing a space with a transgender woman because of a belief that a transgender woman is more likely to enjoy indecently and inappropriately exposing themselves (eg, a 'flasher').

But women shouldn't have to give any justification at all for why they don't want to share changing spaces with someone with a penis.

"I don't want to" should be good enough.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/07/2022 12:48

I think of a 'public place' as being a space which members of the public have unrestricted access to and right of way. I wouldn't apply that to a workplace changing room. Perhaps you would define it differently, however.

My colleagues are 'members of the public'. If an individual with a penis came into my office which requires swipe card access and dropped pants and exposed said penis it would be flashing.

Ditto if the individual did the same in the women's changeroom we have on site.

'Private' is my home. Having said that, if a plumber with a penis dropped pants in my bathroom and exposed said penis it would also be flashing.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:48

The apologism for the sexual assault of these poor women on this thread is utterly disgusting.

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:45

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:39

It's fine if you don't see it as needing contextualisation – you're entitled to your opinion. If I do think something needs contextualisation then that's my own.

What age is the minimum age when men can expose their penises to girls without the girl's express permission?

To put that into context, by age I mean the number of years on the planet starting at the moment of birth and counting a year as 364.25 days and by girl I mean female child that is under 18 years [on the planet starting at birth etc].

By penis i mean the part of the male body that a man uses to ejaculate and pee out of. That is used in an erect state to rape people when they have not expressed permission for sex.

Clymene · 22/07/2022 12:45

Actually the claimant only had permission to use a cubicle within the changing room. They were never given permission to change in the communal area, whether or not they removed their underwear.

GertrudeKerfuffle · 22/07/2022 12:44

If I were asked to comment on a hypothetical case where a transgender person won a tribunal because of proven discrimination due to them being transgender - for example, receiving notes of the type discussed in the case above, verbal bullying and so on - I would say 'Great! Nobody should be treated that way.' I would go so far as to say that the vast majority of posters on this thread would agree - after all, when you're a feminist opposing sexism you can quite easily sympathise with other forms of discrimination.

I highly object to being called transphobic for discussing the ramifications for women of the case this thread is actually about.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:44

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:38

A communal changing room is very much a public place!!!

I think of a 'public place' as being a space which members of the public have unrestricted access to and right of way. I wouldn't apply that to a workplace changing room. Perhaps you would define it differently, however.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:43

Ooh I'm having major deja vu ti earlier in the thread. 🤔

Naked from the waist down doesn't mean anyone saw a penis

Showing Simeon your penis against their will isn't exposing oneself

And communal changing rooms do not count as a public area

I suppose from thiosewho redefine women to include males then they can redefine any commonly understood words or concept to suit their narrative. 🤔

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:41

And to talk about intent, he intended this before he even started the job otherwise he'd not have secured the managment's approval to use the ladies changing rooms.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 12:41

And the transwoman knew fine well that the women didn't want to see their penis. Exposing your penis to someone against their will is very much indecent exposure.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:39

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 12:36

Contextualisation?

If you see someone's penis without your express permission then they have exposed themselves to you.

It's fine if you don't see it as needing contextualisation – you're entitled to your opinion. If I do think something needs contextualisation then that's my own.