Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
FOJN · 20/07/2022 08:58

Brefugee · 20/07/2022 08:36

It's a pretty easy fix which worked incredibly well until we decided the feelings of male people were more important than the safety, privacy and dignity of women.

But we are not going to move forward if there are 2 opposing positions of:
a) biological sex only i don't want a penis in my changing women's changing room
b) TWAW and lady penises (penii?) should be allowed in the women's changing room

with each loudly proclaiming the other wrong. TBH i have a certain amount of sympathy/empathy with both positions for various reasons.

How do you reconcile an immovable object up against an irresistable force? Compromise that people are happy/comfortable with. Often i think the choices here come down to:
i) totally enclosed changing cubicles/toilets with floor to ceiling walls/doors and integrated washing facilities where necessary (toilets)
ii) 3rd space where there are bio-male, bio-female and mixed-sex facilities
iii) modesty cubicles for everyone in the gendered facilities (including mixed gender)

The issue isn't transwomen or transmen who have gender dysphoria. The issue is exhibitionists who are taking the piss. They serve nobody well at all except themselves.

What do you mean when you use the word compromise? If it's allowing some males into female spaces then the compromise is made entirely by women for the benefit of males. If that's not your proposal then why is it incumbent upon women to find the solution. I am defending women's rights, not opposing trans rights.

The government can legislate for all the transrights they want providing it does not come at the expense of women's rights. The Equality Act 2010 gives trans people the same rights as everyone else. In this instance the judge decided the claimant had been discriminated against on the basis of gender reassignment but that is incorrect, the issue arose because of the claimants sex not because of their gender identity. There is already case law on this subject.

Women compromised in 2004 when the GRA was introduced and people incorrectly assumed that a GRC gave a trans person the right to be treated as their acquired gender in all circumstances. It does not, there is provision within legislation to lawfully excluded TW and TM from single sex spaces where there is a "proportionate means to a legitimate aim", changing room would meet that criteria so this problem is entirely of the hospital's own making.

Your final sentence highlights the folly of our current path. When enough piss takers cause enough problems there will be a backlash, if there is violence against TW it will be perpetrated by men, as most violence is, but the people with gender dysphoria can't just walk away from their condition anymore than I can walk away from being female. If people actually cared about this group of people they would recognise the harm the piss takers are doing and stop indulging them.

Clymene · 20/07/2022 08:58

I really recommend that people read the judgement

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/62cff0578fa8f50bfafb091d/VvSheffieldTeachingHospitalsNHSFoundationTrust1806836-2020___Others.pdf

This person was given permission to change in the cubicle but was naked from the waist down in the communal area. For reasons that are not clear.

In any event, this was a discrimination claim brought by this employee so that is not what was judged on. There was a judgment on 61 individual charges made against the Trust and colleagues, all but two of which were rejected. Several of them were rejected with the note 'Did not happen' by the Tribunal. I leave you to draw your own conclusions about the rest of the evidence.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 08:57

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 08:53

How would they know they had a penis if they hadn't seen it? Most people assume trans folk have the surgery.

Exactly. The women complaining said “naked from the waist down in the changing room” there was no mention of seeing a penis at all. As this TW has not had surgery, if they had actually seen a penis, would they not have you know mentioned it? And you can technically be “naked from the waist down in the changing room” but also in the shower or a cubicle where you may be naked from waist down but not actually visible or exposing your nakedness to anyone else in the changing room.

So I think it’s BS really. The women never saw a penis. If they had, they would have said so.

knittingaddict · 20/07/2022 08:57

maiafawnly · 20/07/2022 08:16

It was a shower room, having some element of nakedness in a shower room is understandable. Ive not read the reports fully, but if they worked on an infectious diseases ward having a shower post shift is mandatory. If they were told to use the female communal shower room, it was bound to happen.

However, that female shower room should 100% be a protected space, and if this person was pre surgery, they shouldn't have had it suggested they use the female communal space. I understand they might have felt more comfortable outside of a male shower room, but that doesn't mean the rest of the females using the communal space should be impacted.

Other than creating a 3rd safe space, I'm not sure what the solution is here. The notes are disgusting. People should be allowed to live their lives how they want to - provided its not negatively impacted someone else in a way that doesn't just stem from their own prejudices. But trans rights should also not be at the expense of womens rights.

I just don't know.

Pre surgery?

Very few trans people ever have bottom surgery, so let's not assume that this person was on an kind of "journey" towards becoming a woman. I'm willing to bet that if they were happy shatter the illusion and show their male genitalia to a group of women that they will probably be keeping said penis.

Rainbowbaby13 · 20/07/2022 08:57

Flaunch · 20/07/2022 06:29

Penises have no place in woman’s spaces regardless of how they identify.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Perlunk · 20/07/2022 08:56

The volume of wrong information repeated as fact on this thread is awful.

if you’re going to comment or judge, at least go scan the tribunal report and read what actually was described.

The abuse of the trans person, which the trust accept happened, was repellent and totally inexcusable.

At no point did anyone say a penis was sighted/flashed/flaunted/waved.

The glossing over of actual transphobic behaviours, right along with demonisation of a trans person with invented behaviours, is not OK.

Katjolo · 20/07/2022 08:56

This story and others like it... drives me insane. If you have a child of school age, including Primary, ask to see their policy on this. It is unlikely to be published on their website as it is not statutory but more schools are 'having' to have a policy regardless. I find this of particular interest when in relation to residentials!

Brefugee · 20/07/2022 08:53

can someone link to the decision? i can't find it and the previous link was broken.

From reading this thread it all sounds pretty toxic whichever "side" you're on.

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 08:53

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 08:43

It doesn’t say that the TW ever exposed her penis.
”An employment tribunal in Leeds was told that the transgender woman — who cannot be identified – was quizzed by a manager about her underwear after concerns were raised that she had been naked from the waist down in the women’s changing room.”

But it also says
“And on the same day, the employee said she was subjected to “deeply offensive and unacceptable” abuse while in a changing room cubicle, when she overheard a discussion between two female colleagues. The tribunal noted that one colleague said that she was “sick to death of this bloke with a dick pretending to be a woman, who doesn’t even dress like a girl and has facial hair, that thing may rape me and we can drive it out of the department and maybe find a suitable leper colony for it”. Later, the transgender woman said she again found a note in her locker saying “get out tranny”.

So the TW used changing cubicles to dress and undress. She couldn’t identify the colleague that said the above because of the cubicle walls/no line of sight. The changing room also had a shower so likely the TW had a towel wrapped around her between shower and changing cubicle.

If the concerned women had seen her penis, why didn’t they say so? Surely that’s more to the point and damning than saying vaguely “naked from the waist down” which is also true of anyone simply in a towel as they aren’t dressed.

How would they know they had a penis if they hadn't seen it? Most people assume trans folk have the surgery.

RenegadeMatron · 20/07/2022 08:53

bellinisurge · 20/07/2022 08:39

Predatory lesbians I have encountered in my long life: zero
Predatory men I have encountered in my long life: too many to count

And even if there were (I have never encountered one), I wouldn’t feel as physically threatened by them, because they’d be ~ my size.

Whereas I know I absolutely would be over-powered by any man, even by a man smaller than me (I’m taller than many men).

This ^^ (among many other things) is what so many TRAs and their supporters don’t get. Especially males.

They do not understand what it is like to be a woman, and know that any man out there can over-power you, and - if they want - rape/kill you.

This is why we need our single sex spaces.

Namechangehereandnow · 20/07/2022 08:52

Agree with those saying penises have no place in womens areas. There was a case recently of a TW patient on a female ward who raped another female patient. It was covered up by the hospital and Trust for over a year - hospital stance was “we have no males on this ward, therefore rape could not have happened” ….. Clearly a pp poster was correct - men need to control their penises.

Ffs, start protecting EVERYONE’S rights NOT just transgender rights!

Sunbun19 · 20/07/2022 08:52

Flaunch · 20/07/2022 06:29

Penises have no place in woman’s spaces regardless of how they identify.

Just envisaged a penis with a little hat and glasses walking into a ladies changing room

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 08:51

If trans activists are thinking this case is a win then they're not thinking far enough ahead. This is not a win for trans acceptance.

The females in that hospital who were exposed to a penis against their will will be full on TERFS now. Decent people reading about it will understand quite well why there was a penis on display when the TW had agreed to get changed in a cubicle.

I think they'll be thinking twice about ever hiring a trans person again. I think many people reading that case will not want to be put in the position those managers were....

Xenia · 20/07/2022 08:51

It is hard to know the fracts here - someone quoted the decision which seems to have said the trans person may not have given very good or accurate evidence. Lots of employment tribunals tend to be sympathetic to the employee even if they do not win their main case some rule or other is broken and they get some cash - it is how that system seems to work with so many potholes for employers to avoid.

In this case if the person had their penis out in the women's changing room that is not acceptable. If they were given the right before the job started to use the women's changing room enclosed cubicle then I am still not sure most women would like that so surely using a disabled toilet or something else or not being obliged to change out of catering uniform until home might have been a solution that was better for most of the workers. Putting nasty notes (if that happened) in the person's locker is not every nice although I do not see why the employer is responsible.

Suddha · 20/07/2022 08:50

The comments and the note are dreadful. What’s more dreadful is that women feel that sort of behaviour is their last resort to remove a penis from their safe space. They had made formal complaints and been ignored, so they started to get angry and took matters into their own hands.

AlisonDonut · 20/07/2022 08:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MenopauseSucks · 20/07/2022 08:50

I'm intrigued why someone would wander around with just their top on & nothing below the waist.
In my experience, in women's open changing rooms (ie no cubicles), the first thing to go on is the knickers!
Again, just my experience, so there maybe women who get dressed like this but I've never seen it & certainly it wouldn't occur to me to do it.
Maybe I'm a dinosaur about these things...

FourTeaFallOut · 20/07/2022 08:49

Sorry, type slow, xpost

FourTeaFallOut · 20/07/2022 08:48

Wait, ignore that, obviously cleaners/maintenance have a uniform and others, thinking non-medical=admin I just got stuck on those in admin roles

maiafawnly · 20/07/2022 08:48

FourTeaFallOut · 20/07/2022 08:46

But if you have a uniform does that not mean that you are in a medical role?

No, clerical staff, porters, cleaners, ward assistants, caterers, and discharge facilitators are all non-clinical, required to wear a uniform, and are not allowed to wear the uniform traveling to or from work. We all have to change

PurpleDaisies · 20/07/2022 08:47

But if you have a uniform does that not mean that you are in a medical role?

Catering and cleaning staff wear uniforms.

FourTeaFallOut · 20/07/2022 08:46

maiafawnly · 20/07/2022 08:42

All staff in our trust, whether clinical or not, have to change in and out of uniforms before leaving the workplace.

But if you have a uniform does that not mean that you are in a medical role?

MerryMarigold · 20/07/2022 08:46

Oh well. It hasn't done the trans cause any good because as an employer I'd think twice about putting my staff in potential situations like this, and my company at risk of being sued. I'm sure the majority of trans women would have been respectful in this scenario but this one has done the cause no favors whatsoever. They've just made it harder to employ other transwomen for fear of these types of incidents happening.

PurpleDaisies · 20/07/2022 08:46

FourTeaFallOut · 20/07/2022 08:40

Are there many non medical roles in the NHS that requires you to get changed at work?

This is a red herring. Plenty of people at my last workplace cycled in and changed.

Its probably worth keeping the main thing the main thing. The person could have chosen to change in a discreet way but instead, they walked around with their penis out. That’s still not the main problem though.The trust made a dreadful decision to allow this person with a penis to change in a female changing room. Single def spaces should be upheld and a different solution found for the person in the law suit.

Supersee · 20/07/2022 08:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread