Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 22/07/2022 15:45

Didimum · 22/07/2022 11:23

Not in every circumstance, no. And, of course, everyone is entitled to object to something they feel strongly about. Again, some objections can veer into transphobic territory. For example (and this is very simplistic of course), the objection to sharing a space with a transgender woman because of a belief that a transgender woman is more likely to enjoy indecently and inappropriately exposing themselves (eg, a 'flasher').

But that is based on them being male and statistically more likely to be a threat. It’s not because they’re trans.
Female only spaces are “male-phobic” if you’re going to throw around words.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/07/2022 15:40

First of all, there appears to be no clear definition of what transphobic actually is. Trans activists seem to think an awful lot of things are transphobic, including saying things such as "trans women are male". If you take that to its logical conclusion, it seems some of them think the discussion of biological sex is transphobic. That can't be right. So I'm very uncomfortable with people's concerns being dismissed as "transphobic" when no one can agree on what actually is transphobic and what isn't.

Excellent point. Sometimes saying that MTF trans people are male is even framed as "misgendering", and then people say things like "deliberate misgendering is harassment" when they may mean ignoring their preferred pronouns or they may mean being able to articulate that you aren't comfortable sharing spaces with a male person.

babyjellyfish · 22/07/2022 13:47

Didimum · 22/07/2022 12:53

I didn't say they they to give justification.

Right, but you said that "some objections can veer into transphobic territory".

First of all, there appears to be no clear definition of what transphobic actually is. Trans activists seem to think an awful lot of things are transphobic, including saying things such as "trans women are male". If you take that to its logical conclusion, it seems some of them think the discussion of biological sex is transphobic. That can't be right. So I'm very uncomfortable with people's concerns being dismissed as "transphobic" when no one can agree on what actually is transphobic and what isn't.

Secondly, in this case, there is no evidence that any of the transphobic statements were actually made. We only have one person's word for it. One person who is clearly unreliable.

Thirdly, if the alleged transphobic comments were made, and we only have one person's word for it that they were, the situation came about precisely because women's need for single sex changing spaces was ignored in the first place, for the benefit of one male individual, and because we are living in some bizarre universe where women are actually expected to give reasons for why they don't want to share communal changing spaces with penises.

If "no is a complete sentence" were actually accepted in relation to women's rights and their bodily autonomy, the conversation wouldn't need to get as far as anyone saying anything transphobic. It would begin and end with women saying no.

knittingaddict · 22/07/2022 13:35

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:25

I'm just simply saying I don't know. You don't have to agree with me.

You keep saying that we don't have to agree with you. We are disagreeing with you. Haven't you noticed?

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 13:32

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 13:30

They were naked from the waist down but you're not sure if their penis was exposed? Are you using a different definition of naked to the rest of us?

Can you specify your definition of naked so that they know the context of nakedness that you are discussing. Thank you.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:31

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 13:23

Yeah I agree. We should stop engaging. The intention seems to be to fill up the thread so the spotlight on this inconvenient incident goes away. By inconvenient, I mean inconvenient to the "just wants to pee" "too dysphoric to expose their penis in female spaces" narrative.

I'm absolutely not the 'the arbiter of truth' and I'm happy not to be engaged with further. A lot of posters asked me questions and I answered them on the basis of my own opinions. I completely the agree the thread is becoming unnecessarily full now, so on that note, I will get on with the rest of my day and no longer post.

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 13:30

You don't have to agree with me when I say nonsense that facilitates flashers just don't call them flashers you transphobic holes.

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 13:30

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:25

I'm just simply saying I don't know. You don't have to agree with me.

They were naked from the waist down but you're not sure if their penis was exposed? Are you using a different definition of naked to the rest of us?

amicissimma · 22/07/2022 13:29

I have never found it necessary to expose my genitals when leaving a shower cubicle - I wrap in a towel while still in the cubical - and take extra care if steppping into a space where others are present. Therefore I would take any exposure of genitals (even an 'accidental' dropping of towel - it's perfectly possible to secure it safely with enough care) as a deliberate act of aggression. Particularly if the genitals were of the opposite sex to anyone else in the area.

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 13:29

Flashing is a criminal sexual offence in the UK. So let's be clear on this:

This person commmited a sexual offence and not only got away with it, they were/will be rewarded with a large payout for doing so

That's where we are.

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 13:28

I didn't know I was going to get my penis out in front of women, I just made sure I could before I agreed to this job and then did.

Context.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/07/2022 13:28

I do think these discussions are often valuable for lurkers, however.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:25

knittingaddict · 22/07/2022 13:20

Oh please. Let's not start that again. If you can give a reasonable explanation as to how you would know that a man was without his underwear without seeing his "bits" then go for it. I'm all ears.

I'm just simply saying I don't know. You don't have to agree with me.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 13:25

The information I would need is evidence to the person's intent to cause harm and distress. If you don't need that information to make a call, then that's fine. I didn't say 'flashing is only flashing if done in a public area' – I said it was the generally used definition. I also agreed it was a grey area.

No it's not a "generally used definition". I very much disagree that there's any ambiguity about the intention of a person who gets their cock out in front of an unsuspecting female. I doubt a court would find it in any way ambiguous either if a tradesman entering your home got their cock out.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 13:23

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/07/2022 13:19

I'm not really all that interested what DidiMum thinks, they're not the only person on the thread, I don't see any need to treat them like they are the arbiter of truth here.

Yeah I agree. We should stop engaging. The intention seems to be to fill up the thread so the spotlight on this inconvenient incident goes away. By inconvenient, I mean inconvenient to the "just wants to pee" "too dysphoric to expose their penis in female spaces" narrative.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:23

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 13:18

Rainbowshit
Private' is my home. Having said that, if a plumber with a penis dropped pants in my bathroom and exposed said penis it would also be flashing.

@Didimum do you agree that the example given here is an example of flashing?
By the information available I don't think there is enough evidence to make that call one way or another – however, I'm certainly interested to read more on it should more information become available.

What other information do you need? Thankfully the law doesn't agree with you that flashing is only flashing if done in a public area.

The information I would need is evidence to the person's intent to cause harm and distress. If you don't need that information to make a call, then that's fine. I didn't say 'flashing is only flashing if done in a public area' – I said it was the generally used definition. I also agreed it was a grey area.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/07/2022 13:22

The apologism for the sexual assault of these poor women on this thread is utterly disgusting.

Yes it is, but it's not uncommon on this site outside of FWR.

knittingaddict · 22/07/2022 13:20

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:16

The thing I'm not personally clear on from the information I've read (and I think this came up earlier in the thread) is whether the person's penis was actually exposed. Please link me to the relevant source if it's come up and I've missed it.

The recent post that brought up the policy the person was given though (cubicle only changing, and whether they wilfully ignored that with the intent to cause harm or distress – I definitely see that as pertinent.

Oh please. Let's not start that again. If you can give a reasonable explanation as to how you would know that a man was without his underwear without seeing his "bits" then go for it. I'm all ears.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/07/2022 13:19

I'm not really all that interested what DidiMum thinks, they're not the only person on the thread, I don't see any need to treat them like they are the arbiter of truth here.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:19

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 13:12

You called us transphobic holes.

You think it is ok to expose penises to females if the context is right.

You have the freedom to think exposing penises to females is right and to try and find loopholes to be able to do it.

And you don't like it when you request contextualisation and someone contextualises the wrong contextualistion for you and you call it 'sarcasm'.

I have addressed all the above – you can go back and find it if you wish. The 'contexts' you gave were actually definitions, not contexts, hence why I viewed it as sarcasm.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/07/2022 13:18

The thing I'm not personally clear on from the information I've read (and I think this came up earlier in the thread) is whether the person's penis was actually exposed. Please link me to the relevant source if it's come up and I've missed it.

I'm asking about a hypothetical scenario where it was.

Rainbowshit · 22/07/2022 13:18

Rainbowshit
Private' is my home. Having said that, if a plumber with a penis dropped pants in my bathroom and exposed said penis it would also be flashing.

@Didimum do you agree that the example given here is an example of flashing?
By the information available I don't think there is enough evidence to make that call one way or another – however, I'm certainly interested to read more on it should more information become available.

What other information do you need? Thankfully the law doesn't agree with you that flashing is only flashing if done in a public area.

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:16

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/07/2022 13:09

I agree 'public place' can definitely throw up a lot of grey areas.

But the common factor is that the penis is being exposed in an unsolicited way to a non-consenting woman.

Surely this is the essence?

We used to say that if a person with a penis used that penis to penetrate a woman with whom the penis person had signed a marriage certificate that it was not rape. We now agree it is rape (I assume).

So, even if an individual with a penis exposes said penis to a woman in the context of marriage when it is unsolicited and unwanted then surely it is flashing?

And with that as the bar, surely the plumber exposing a penis is flashing?

The thing I'm not personally clear on from the information I've read (and I think this came up earlier in the thread) is whether the person's penis was actually exposed. Please link me to the relevant source if it's come up and I've missed it.

The recent post that brought up the policy the person was given though (cubicle only changing, and whether they wilfully ignored that with the intent to cause harm or distress – I definitely see that as pertinent.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/07/2022 13:14

If men and women were happy with seeing each other naked there wouldn't be separate male and female changing rooms. In general, men and women aren't happy with seeing each other naked, because it is a violation of their privacy and dignity. So we have separate male and female changing rooms.

AlisonDonut · 22/07/2022 13:12

Didimum · 22/07/2022 13:04

No, I won't engage with you because I don't find sarcasm useful to a discussion.

As I've said before, I'm not here to change your opinion, simply to express mine. If you want to tell people what they 'should think', go ahead and do that. I have freedom of opinion, just the same as you.

You called us transphobic holes.

You think it is ok to expose penises to females if the context is right.

You have the freedom to think exposing penises to females is right and to try and find loopholes to be able to do it.

And you don't like it when you request contextualisation and someone contextualises the wrong contextualistion for you and you call it 'sarcasm'.