Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:35

Actually how could the TW claim to be 85% sure it was Mrs M which was based on the TW recognising her voice but then not know Mrs M spoke with a strong not English accent?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 20/07/2022 10:35

Hopefully lessons will be learnt.

It is unacceptable that the female staff have no choice but to put up with a naked penis in the locker room.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:33

Thank you Disc I clearly mixed up the names.

However that does not change the fact that the TW was not pressured in to providing a name as you claim and stated they were 85% sure it was Mrs M.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:31

I dont think this situation was avoidable.

Reading the judgement it is clear that the TW had an agenda from the off and the majority of their complaints were fuelled by their constant absence, refusal to work full time as agreed when the TW accepted the role and the trust correctly following the absence policies.

The only way I can see this could have been avoided was to allow the TW to work reduced hours take as much sickness, leave early as they liked, receive full pay and to have none of it recorded or policies followed. Why does this employee feel they deserved to be treated differently?

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 10:30

You can be “naked from the waist down in the changing room”- a room that includes toilets, shower and private cubicles without exposing yourself because you’re in one of those private walled/screened off areas of the changing room.

If they were in private how would anyone have seen that they were naked from the airway down? Why would someone have complained if it was in private?

The knots you are tying yourself in to excuse the indecent exposure are quite something.

It strikes me that you know it's not acceptable to show a naked penis in a female changing room. But the end point of this gender ideology is that there will be naked penises in female changing rooms. And it seems females are not allowed to be upset, scared or complain about it. Why do you support that?

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:30

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:23

The overheard conversation was in English accents. The TW when pressured repeatedly by management to guess who said those things guessed a colleague that it turned out did not have an English accent. So the TW then confirmed it could not have been the colleague as her accent wasn’t what she heard. This is actually consistency. The TW has always said the voices had English accents and not deviated from that statement.

Actually the TW knew the colleague did not have an English accent as it states in the judgement that the colleague spoke to the TW ( about dropped hairnets) before the TW claimed she was one of the women talking. There was no pressure from management to name people the claimants complaint was investigated as it should be. It was the TW who stated they were 85% sure it was the Filipino staff member.

The judgement shows the inconsistencies and lack of evidence shown by the TW throughout.

No you are mistaken, Mrs F was the hair net colleague, the colleague the TW thought might have said the comments was a Mrs Marshall and she only thought that because Mrs Cooke wrote a note listing who was in/around the changing room at the time of the incident. There’s no indication that the TW had ever previously met Mrs Marshall.

“The Claimant was in one of the toilet cubicles and was breathing heavily. Ms F was not sure if she was crying or struggling to breath. Ms F saw the Claimant later – about 10.30am – in the sandwich room, when she had cause to ask her to pull her face mask above her nose. At about midday Ms F went into the changing room, when the Claimant had just left. The Claimant’s locker was next to hers. She saw 2 hair nets on the floor by her locker, so she went into the rest room and told the Claimant she thought she had dropped her hair nets. The Claimant went to pick them up. Ms F also noted that another colleague had told her that the Claimant had been crying at about 9.30am.”

“When Mrs Cook’s note was provided to her during the initial disclosure process, the Claimant noted that Mrs Cook and Mrs Marshall had had a conversation in the changing room while she was in the cubicle, so she decided that they must have been the perpetrators in respect of the changing room incident. At that stage she presented her third claim, naming them as the perpetrators and as named Respondents. The only basis for identifying them was Mrs Cook’s note.”

”When she gave her oral evidence, Mrs Marshall had a strong accent and it was clear that her English is far from fluent. It was at that stage that the Claimant, fairly, indicated in response to a question from the Employment Judge that she did not believe that Mrs Marshall was one of the people she had overheard.”

Brefugee · 20/07/2022 10:30

You haven't addressed my point that by allowing some males into female spaces it is women doing ALL of the compromising.

because i have offered several compromises and only one of them involves this. (curtained cubicles) the others involve 3rd spaces based on biological sex or self-contained floor-to-ceiling rooms.

Just stamping your foot and saying "no" isn't helping anyone. Whoever is doing it. What is your solution aside of doing that?

Because otherwise we get status-quo which is, on the part of authorities and companies: TWAW and they can go in women's spaces. Many many people aren't happy with that. What do you suggest?

I have no desire to see anyone's genitals. Ever. I'm in Germany, though, so sometimes i do get to see vulvas all over the gym changing rooms because Germans don't tend to worry about getting naked. Even with members of the opposite sex in the case of saunas and nude bathing areas (which are very common). I put up with it because it is culturally acceptable here (and i don't go to mixed nude areas). I wouldn't be happy about being confronted with a penis when it's not expected but i haven't had that. Yet. If/when it does happen i will suggest compromises.

Rainbowbaby13 · 20/07/2022 10:29

@PaddleBoardingMomma I don't have a problem with that each to their own but it does seem odd to want to show it off in a ladies changing room

The boundaries of what is acceptable and what isn't are becoming so blurred in order not to offend anyone it's difficult to know anything

Masterblasterjammin · 20/07/2022 10:28

@Discovereads the claimant only conceded that it wasn’t the Filipino staff member when it was pointed out, during the tribunal, that it was inconsistent with her earlier claim that the person speaking was ‘posh and English’. They were in no way pressured to name anyone, they were just asked if they recognised who it was, which seems a very reasonable thing to ask, given the seriousness of the investigation.

With regards to the notes, the claimant says they destroyed the first note without showing anyone. The HR department decided not to proceed with handwriting analysis for the second note, as it was written in block capitals and it would be too hard/costly to identify who had written it. The claimants handwriting was never actually analysed, and no where in the report does it confirm that the handwriting on the note did not match the handwriting of the defendant.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:28

scorpiogirly · 20/07/2022 10:25

Gaslighting as it's finest. When you have no truth all you can do is lie and minimise.

Is this like when a hospital claimed a female patient was never raped because ‘there are no men on the ward’? The CCTV evidence proved otherwise. The hospital gaslit that poor woman for a year. Turns out there was a TW on the ward who had committed the offence.

scorpiogirly · 20/07/2022 10:25

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 10:21

It's hilarious that someone is actually arguing that no one saw a penis when a complaint was made that a male was naked from the waist down.

Gaslighting as it's finest. When you have no truth all you can do is lie and minimise.

hattie43 · 20/07/2022 10:24

I work in an predominantly working class male environment and whilst some would accept any person there are some who would not tolerate this at all .
If one of us ladies came and said this had happened in our bathroom they'd probably get beaten up . We have recently had a guy convicted of paedophillia and we are doing absolutely everything to make sure no-one finds out , apparently the company has a duty of care Confused

FourTeaFallOut · 20/07/2022 10:24

Whole situation was entirely avoidable if the Trust had complied with the law and provided single sex spaces

Absolutely. This should be the take home message for NHS trusts. An enormous payout should sharpen the mind.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 20/07/2022 10:24

VetIsMe · 20/07/2022 07:35

It's disgusting to use the word transphobic.

To call it phobic wrongly describe systems of oppression as irrational fears. 😡

Also, I hope you know that for some of us, phobias are a very real and distressing part of our lived experience and using this language is incredibly triggering.

If you have any empathy and don't want to perpetuate ableism please refrain from calling people transphobic!!!

Good points, VetisMe. But I doubt if didimum is worried about perpetuating ableism.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:23

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:17

I agree on the without seeing a penis, but again there is no evidence anyone saw the TW’s penis.

Naked from the waist down was the phrase used. How is it possible to be naked from the waist down and not expose your genitals?

You can be “naked from the waist down in the changing room”- a room that includes toilets, shower and private cubicles without exposing yourself because you’re in one of those private walled/screened off areas of the changing room.

If it even happened. The Tribunal made no comment as to whether this happened. The existence of this report was alleged by a NHS manager in defence of her questions about underwear to the TW. No copy of this “report” written or otherwise was presented.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:23

The overheard conversation was in English accents. The TW when pressured repeatedly by management to guess who said those things guessed a colleague that it turned out did not have an English accent. So the TW then confirmed it could not have been the colleague as her accent wasn’t what she heard. This is actually consistency. The TW has always said the voices had English accents and not deviated from that statement.

Actually the TW knew the colleague did not have an English accent as it states in the judgement that the colleague spoke to the TW ( about dropped hairnets) before the TW claimed she was one of the women talking. There was no pressure from management to name people the claimants complaint was investigated as it should be. It was the TW who stated they were 85% sure it was the Filipino staff member.

The judgement shows the inconsistencies and lack of evidence shown by the TW throughout.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:23

Is this like theWiSpa incidence where everyone took the side of the ‘poor oppressed TW’ until it was found he had been exposing his genitals to children in the changing rooms? He had permission to go there as per policy, does that make it ok? I’m sure at least one TRA was saying ‘the children should not have been looking’ rather than blaming the TW, and this seems a similar thing. The safety, comfort and dignity of women means nothing in the face of male entitlement.

drspouse · 20/07/2022 10:23

PurpleDaisies · 20/07/2022 07:12

This is just cruel and unnecessary behaviour. Condoning this sort of bullying is really horrible. It’s not the same at all as women having concerns about biological males in single sex. Transwomen have the right to dress in any way they want but it’s not right that someone with a penis should be able to use a communal single sex space. Another solution should have been found.

It depends what the reaction was. If it was "that horrible transphobic slur" then yes, that's cruel and unnecessary.
If it was a shocked "why is Sir wearing blouse and a makeup and has he got a slang for erection in class? I'm going to talk to my mum and the head teacher" then no, that's not cruel and unnecessary.
And if it was "Sir, can Jason and me wear a skirt to class?" then that seems fairly logical.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 20/07/2022 10:23

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 10:21

It's hilarious that someone is actually arguing that no one saw a penis when a complaint was made that a male was naked from the waist down.

It was their lady penis, you know, like RG pointed out in his latest show. The new cool, exciting, wonderful women have them. Not a uterus and a vagina like us outdated old dinosaurs!

lifeturnsonadime · 20/07/2022 10:22

Whole situation was entirely avoidable if the Trust had complied with the law and provided single sex spaces.

It's a real mess when you can have 2 complaints from each side of a situation, one of discrimination based on gender reassignment and one of discrimination based on sex from women forced to share single sex spaces with males.

And people say there is no conflict of rights, (looking at you the Labour Party). It's just nonsense.

Gender neutral spaces can be provided without compromising single sex ones. That would be equality.

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 10:21

It's hilarious that someone is actually arguing that no one saw a penis when a complaint was made that a male was naked from the waist down.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 20/07/2022 10:21

Rainbowbaby13 · 20/07/2022 10:19

@PaddleBoardingMomma interesting I'd never heard of that it's hard to keep up

It's a rabbit hole! But a quick search of AGP and your eyes will be well and truly opened. So so much of the biggest issues women have with these issues can be found to be rooted in AGP.

Rainbowbaby13 · 20/07/2022 10:20

FOJN · 20/07/2022 10:18

I get it. Nobody wants to compromise. Let's fight about this issue for ever then.

You haven't addressed my point that by allowing some males into female spaces it is women doing ALL of the compromising. You also haven"t answered my question about why women should be responsible for finding a solution?

It is not women objecting the third spaces. If the argument that TW are at risk in male facilities stood up to scrutiny then you might expect them to enthusiastically embrace third spaces so why do TW reject that option and why are you not asking these questions?

And yes I will fight forever to prevent women being treated like second class citizens. My right to safety, privacy, dignity and protection from males is a hill I'm prepared to die on. I refuse to collude in gaslighting younger or more vulnerable women by telling them that a male who claims a feminine gender identity is less of a risk than any other male, the stats do not support such a bullshit claim and it is dangerous to say otherwise.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Rainbowbaby13 · 20/07/2022 10:19

@PaddleBoardingMomma interesting I'd never heard of that it's hard to keep up

FOJN · 20/07/2022 10:18

I get it. Nobody wants to compromise. Let's fight about this issue for ever then.

You haven't addressed my point that by allowing some males into female spaces it is women doing ALL of the compromising. You also haven"t answered my question about why women should be responsible for finding a solution?

It is not women objecting the third spaces. If the argument that TW are at risk in male facilities stood up to scrutiny then you might expect them to enthusiastically embrace third spaces so why do TW reject that option and why are you not asking these questions?

And yes I will fight forever to prevent women being treated like second class citizens. My right to safety, privacy, dignity and protection from males is a hill I'm prepared to die on. I refuse to collude in gaslighting younger or more vulnerable women by telling them that a male who claims a feminine gender identity is less of a risk than any other male, the stats do not support such a bullshit claim and it is dangerous to say otherwise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread