Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 11:05

I’m confused @Discovereads how can a male be naked from the waist down and the penis not exposed? It’s not like on telly where there’s pixels. Why are you so determined to defend this male and gaslight women into accepting male people onto their spaces?

knittingaddict · 20/07/2022 11:05

Nudity is an essential component of indecent exposure.
And your analogy makes no sense. The management of the Trust had decided and informed staff before her first day at work that the TW could use the womens changing room, so she was not an “intruder”

Discovereads Without consultation with the women using this space I would consider this TW an intruder. Many, many other women would too. Also many decent men.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 11:03

Just counted up and there were 24 complaints made by the TW 23 were not upheld and effectively found in favour of the trust as in the trust did not discriminate or victimise the TW abd acted in accordancewith the law/policy. One was upheld which was that the questions relating to the TW wearing/not wearing underware were asked because they were a TW.

Even then given the comments made by the TW about them taking off their underwear and the comment made that a staff member had seen them naked from the waist down it could be argued that the questions were relevant.

knittingaddict · 20/07/2022 11:01

It’s not “quite a few women”
Mrs Hawkshaw got a statement from ONE woman alleging this and “naked from waist down in the changing room” doesn’t necessarily mean exposed penis in the communal area of the changing room.

What else can it be? If a male body is naked from the waist down ie no pants then their geniltals will be visible. If you can see enough to know that there are no clothes below the waist then the penis will be visible. Give me an alternative explanation please?

Masterblasterjammin · 20/07/2022 10:58

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:48

I’m not excusing indecent exposure, I’m questioning whether it happened. The Tribunal didn’t even address it, so there is no finding of facts as to whether it happened or not.

They didn’t “suddenly decide to be transphobes” they had been bullying her for a year before there was the “naked from waist down in the changing room” allegation. A full year before this allegation, the TW overheard two colleagues plotting to stitch her up. So, it’s just coincidence that allegations start happening?

But the alleged conversation about ‘stitching her up’ happened in the different hospital to the one that alleged she talked about her underwear, and that she was naked from the waist down.

So it couldn’t be the same people, could it. The claimant actually made no allegations of bullying towards colleagues in the second hospital, and was more concerned with raising grievances about the managing absence policy. The woman who raised the comment about taking her underwear off is documented to be a supportive friend and colleague to the claimant.

So yes, it could be a coincidence. Or the claimant is the common denominator here.

WhenWillMyLIfeBegin · 20/07/2022 10:58

Floor to ceiling mixed sex cubicals have been proven to have shockingly high incidents of sexual harassment and rape compared to single sex.

A curtain provides neither safety or privacy.

I also doubt very much whether the NHS, which is financially on it's knees has the money or space to provide adequate third spaces. Not that these would ever be deemed good enough because, as noted in this case a 'compromise' of the tw getting changed in a single cubicle was ignored in favour of them using the shared space.

Get it into your head. Compromises aren't good enough. Whatever you offer isn't enough.

Start prioritising women's safety and dignity and stop prioritising the feels of males, who may or may not have penises. (But they usually do)

Even if no penis is present it is a red herring. A male body and the statistical sex and violence likelyhood of being male stays the same regardless of gender feels. In fact, looking at the ministry of justice information we have, all evide CE suggests it could be higher risk than the average male in the population.

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/07/2022 10:56

The women weren't asked though were they? Consent was not obtained from.those it really.mattered from. That male knew this. They know they are male and have no place in the womens changing room. They are responsible for their own actions.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:56

Did they ask the women if they were comfortable with their changing area becoming mixed sex? Or did their opinion and feelings not count? The trust could have provide a third space. They thought so little of their female staff they did not even think of this option. They would rather indulge the feelings of one male, who it seems had an agenda according to the tribunal records.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:55

They didn’t “suddenly decide to be transphobes” they had been bullying her for a year before there was the “naked from waist down in the changing room” allegation. A full year before this allegation, the TW overheard two colleagues plotting to stitch her up. So, it’s just coincidence that allegations start happening?

Who had being bullying her?
Didn't the conversation incident happen at a different site to the claim that the TW was naked from the waist down?

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:54

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/07/2022 10:51

Why is the nudity the bar?

If you had an inteuder in hour Garden you'd call the police surely ? You wouldn't wait until they broke into your shed or pissed in your pool before you called.

Amd its the same here. They are male. They walked into a female changing room to get undressed. The line has already been crossed.

Nudity is an essential component of indecent exposure.
And your analogy makes no sense. The management of the Trust had decided and informed staff before her first day at work that the TW could use the womens changing room, so she was not an “intruder”

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:52

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:50

It’s not “quite a few women”
Mrs Hawkshaw got a statement from ONE woman alleging this and “naked from waist down in the changing room” doesn’t necessarily mean exposed penis in the communal area of the changing room.

Uh huh. You’re very determined to minimise the indecent exposure it seems. Why do you not believe the woman? Is it because the TW is male and therefore thier word carries more weight? Why do you believe this was the only incident?

Masterblasterjammin · 20/07/2022 10:52

@Discovereads Yes, as I’ve said, I read the report. And I repeat - nowhere in the report does it confirm that the handwriting on the note does not match the handwriting of the claimant. Her handwriting sample was collected in anticipation of investigating the handwriting of the entire department, but it was then decided that this was not necessary.

So to say anything else from that is pure speculation. Just like I could speculate that no further handwriting samples were taken because the claimants handwriting matched. We have no idea of knowing, because it is not mentioned in the report, and to make such conclusions is just conjecture.

And I don’t think you adequately addressed the point about her falsely accusing a Filipina colleague - she said she was 85% certain it was her, until the tribunal judge pointed out that it conflicted with her earlier evidence, as which point she accepted that it couldn’t be her. How could she be 85% certain that it was someone she had never met? And please don’t just copy and paste the report again, I have read it.

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/07/2022 10:51

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:48

I’m not excusing indecent exposure, I’m questioning whether it happened. The Tribunal didn’t even address it, so there is no finding of facts as to whether it happened or not.

They didn’t “suddenly decide to be transphobes” they had been bullying her for a year before there was the “naked from waist down in the changing room” allegation. A full year before this allegation, the TW overheard two colleagues plotting to stitch her up. So, it’s just coincidence that allegations start happening?

Why is the nudity the bar?

If you had an inteuder in hour Garden you'd call the police surely ? You wouldn't wait until they broke into your shed or pissed in your pool before you called.

Amd its the same here. They are male. They walked into a female changing room to get undressed. The line has already been crossed.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:50

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:47

But I think @Discovereads must think TW are male. The very fact that they take one males word over quite a few women’s, and is determined to defen said male in the face of evidence that male has done wrong, and the fact that they believe the males feelings take precedence over women’s make me very sure they believe TW are male.

It’s not “quite a few women”
Mrs Hawkshaw got a statement from ONE woman alleging this and “naked from waist down in the changing room” doesn’t necessarily mean exposed penis in the communal area of the changing room.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:50

Why should women compromise over their spaces? Surely compromise involves give and take. What benefit do women get out of sharing their spaces? Why is the discomfort of trans people in the spaces relevant to their sex women’s issue to solve. That is for trans people to solve in a way which will not affect any other group.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:48

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:37

Why is @Discovereads so determined to excuse indecent exposure? How would anyone know the person was naked if they hadn’t been in public? Why do you believe all these women suddenly and at the same time decided to become transphobes rather than a male decided to expose himself?

I’m not excusing indecent exposure, I’m questioning whether it happened. The Tribunal didn’t even address it, so there is no finding of facts as to whether it happened or not.

They didn’t “suddenly decide to be transphobes” they had been bullying her for a year before there was the “naked from waist down in the changing room” allegation. A full year before this allegation, the TW overheard two colleagues plotting to stitch her up. So, it’s just coincidence that allegations start happening?

FOJN · 20/07/2022 10:48

Brefugee · 20/07/2022 10:30

You haven't addressed my point that by allowing some males into female spaces it is women doing ALL of the compromising.

because i have offered several compromises and only one of them involves this. (curtained cubicles) the others involve 3rd spaces based on biological sex or self-contained floor-to-ceiling rooms.

Just stamping your foot and saying "no" isn't helping anyone. Whoever is doing it. What is your solution aside of doing that?

Because otherwise we get status-quo which is, on the part of authorities and companies: TWAW and they can go in women's spaces. Many many people aren't happy with that. What do you suggest?

I have no desire to see anyone's genitals. Ever. I'm in Germany, though, so sometimes i do get to see vulvas all over the gym changing rooms because Germans don't tend to worry about getting naked. Even with members of the opposite sex in the case of saunas and nude bathing areas (which are very common). I put up with it because it is culturally acceptable here (and i don't go to mixed nude areas). I wouldn't be happy about being confronted with a penis when it's not expected but i haven't had that. Yet. If/when it does happen i will suggest compromises.

Again, I am arguing to protect women's rights. We have tried the compromise of some males in female spaces and in 2022 we have women being called bigots for objecting to fully or partially naked, intact males in our spaces. I am campaigning for female spaces to be exclusively single sex, no exceptions.

The Trans lobby has my full support for any campaigning the might do wrt to provision of safe facilities for themselves as long as they do not demand access to female spaces. What other solutions they may propose is none of my business. My business is women's rights.

I refuse to engage is a discussion about solutions to a problem women did not create because it ALWAYS results in women making sacrifices. Characterising women defending their rights as "stamping their feet" is just more misogynistic bullshit which attempts to shame women into acquiescence under the guise of being the bigger person or the grown up. Women saying NO are not having a temper tantrum, they have found their self respect and are refusing to be crapped on anymore.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:47

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:40

Why is @Discovereads so determined to excuse indecent exposure

Because they don't believe a TW would ever do such a thing or that TW are male.

But I think @Discovereads must think TW are male. The very fact that they take one males word over quite a few women’s, and is determined to defen said male in the face of evidence that male has done wrong, and the fact that they believe the males feelings take precedence over women’s make me very sure they believe TW are male.

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 10:47

*NHS staff

OP posts:
ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 10:46

Also if it’s not usual for NHS to remove their underwear then why is this person naked from the waist down as a biological man in a woman’s changing room?

It’s always Women’s spaces. This is for a minority of people and women are being the most affected.

OP posts:
ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 10:45

It’s incredibly important that such cases are debated. I want to hear from people who think it is ok (and why) for a biological male with a penis to be in a changing room for biological women. Not wearing underwear?

I am not condoning the notes or bullying but there is a huge amount more to this - I hope this pushes hospitals to not allow Men who dress as women into into women’s changing rooms. These have to be safe places for women.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 20/07/2022 10:44

Masterblasterjammin · 20/07/2022 10:28

@Discovereads the claimant only conceded that it wasn’t the Filipino staff member when it was pointed out, during the tribunal, that it was inconsistent with her earlier claim that the person speaking was ‘posh and English’. They were in no way pressured to name anyone, they were just asked if they recognised who it was, which seems a very reasonable thing to ask, given the seriousness of the investigation.

With regards to the notes, the claimant says they destroyed the first note without showing anyone. The HR department decided not to proceed with handwriting analysis for the second note, as it was written in block capitals and it would be too hard/costly to identify who had written it. The claimants handwriting was never actually analysed, and no where in the report does it confirm that the handwriting on the note did not match the handwriting of the defendant.

I addressed the first in an earlier post.

On the second. Yes the TWs handwriting was not analysed by any professional. But the Tribunal determined that Mrs Westwood requested the handwriting sample for the purpose of “elimination” as in it was implied she wouldn’t have accepted the incident as having happened (and thus reportable) without seeing the TWs handwriting for herself.

”Mrs Westwood also asked the Claimant to write the contents of the note on the statement. Her evidence was that she asked her to do so because she anticipated having to investigate what had happened, and thought that she would need to gather handwriting samples from every female member of staff on duty that day, including the Claimant. In the event, she was not asked to investigate it, so she did not ask anybody else for a sample. Mrs Westwood said that she did not ask the Claimant to provide a handwriting sample because she is transgender. She did so because she intended to ask all the female staff members on duty to do the same. She explained that her husband used to be a police officer, and she was particularly aware of the need to gather evidence promptly.”
“The Claimant complains that requesting her to provide a handwriting sample was direct disability and gender reassignment discrimination, and was victimisation because she had complained about the admitted incidents. She says that Mrs Westwood told her it was “for elimination purposes”, and that is what she said in her subsequent appeal of 25 November 2020 (see below).
Mrs Westwood did not recall using that expression, but the Tribunal found it likely that she did. On her own account she thought that it would be necessary to obtain handwriting samples from everybody, so she clearly was asking the Claimant to provide one “for elimination purposes.” However, the Tribunal accepted Mrs Westwood’s evidence that she did not treat the Claimant any differently because she is a transgender woman, nor because she has a mental health disability. She would have asked anybody who complained of finding an equivalent note to provide a handwriting sample. That request may be open to criticism, but that does not mean that the reason why it was made was linked to the Claimant’s gender reassignment or disability.“

Nathleia · 20/07/2022 10:44

Maybe it's time for a toilet facility change:
Men / Women / Disabled / ALL
I find that many abled people use the disabled toilets and treat them like a gender-free option, what if there were a gender-free option that kept the disabled free for the disabled?

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 10:40

Why is @Discovereads so determined to excuse indecent exposure

Because they don't believe a TW would ever do such a thing or that TW are male.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:37

Why is @Discovereads so determined to excuse indecent exposure? How would anyone know the person was naked if they hadn’t been in public? Why do you believe all these women suddenly and at the same time decided to become transphobes rather than a male decided to expose himself?