Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 20/07/2022 11:29

You don’t have to “see” anything to know someone is naked from the waist down

Please explain how.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 11:28

Why would a TW who is being bullied for a year by transphobic colleagues

But they were not bullied for a year.
There were 3 accepted incidents two on the 28th July 2020 one being the conversation 1 being the destroyed note. The second note was found on the 11th August 2020. Your claim makes it sound as if the TW was bullied daily/ weekly for a year.

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 11:28

No the Tribunal judgement doesn’t indicate the TW is “not the type to stick to an agreement”. But go on making things up.

They agreed to work full time then broke that agreement. There's evidence littered throughout it that they did not have a track record of sticking to an agreement.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 11:27

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:24

Are you saying you can’t tell whether a clothed male body has a penis? Come on. Don’t be ridiculous. You only need to look for a slight bulge between their legs.

Im not painting anyone as transphobic, the comments these women made were transphobic.

why would I be looking at someone’s genitals @Discovereads ? Really? Are you condoning ogling now! You are now accusing these women of staring at the TW genitals? On what proof?

You’re really making a stretch here. Someone complained a male person was naked from the waist down in the female changing area. Males have penises, therefore a penis was seen.

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 11:27

You don’t have to “see” anything to know someone is naked from the waist down

How do they know then? Telepathy? Intuition? Come on!!!

Ramblingnamechanger · 20/07/2022 11:26

Stonewall Champion eh? That explains why this person was allowed to access womens changing rooms, and why women weren’t consulted ,but told this would happen regardless. Why they haven’t been charged with indecent exposure and sexual harassment is the big question. If they had been offered some other facility this would never have happened. Women are angry. Frankly I am appalled to think that unknowingly, a young work experience trainee, for example might have had to put up with this. When I was young and naive I had to, after being redeployed after a breakdown, and expected to be kind, put up and shut up about the man watching me in the changing room.
I don’t understand why they were allowed to be anonymous despite conducting their own case, while other women were dragged into it and had to be identified.

goodmorningcampers · 20/07/2022 11:26

The management of the Trust had decided and informed staff before her first day at work that the TW could use the women's changing room, so she was not an “intruder

Discovereads has a point there. Beggars belief why the management agreed to this at the outset, given that the private cubicle is within the communal women's changing room and without consultation with female staff. Disaster waiting to happen

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:26

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 11:24

It's pretty clear from the judgement that the TW is not the type to stick to an agreement. What are you so convinced that they didn't break the agreement to change in private areas?

No the Tribunal judgement doesn’t indicate the TW is “not the type to stick to an agreement”. But go on making things up.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:25

knittingaddict · 20/07/2022 11:24

So you agree that their penis must have been on display?

On the loo? Why would I see anyone on the loo, male or female?

Shower? Were the showers in full view of everyone? It would have been mentioned if they were naked.

Naked from the waist down before or after a shower? So also fully naked at some point? Well that wasn't mentioned, so unlikely to be the scenario here.

To determine whether someone was naked from the waist down you would have to see the pants area, so also see the genitals. Yes?

No
You don’t have to “see” anything to know someone is naked from the waist down

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 11:24

It's pretty clear from the judgement that the TW is not the type to stick to an agreement. What are you so convinced that they didn't break the agreement to change in private areas?

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:24

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 11:17

So how would the person making the allegation know the TW has a penis? Really, the mental hoops you’re jumping through must be exhausting in this heat. You’re determined to paint the women as transphobic bigots aren’t you? Are women not allowed to complain about males in their changing areas? It was not these women who decided it was ok for their space to become mixed sex, so why are they not allowed to raise concerns.

Are you saying you can’t tell whether a clothed male body has a penis? Come on. Don’t be ridiculous. You only need to look for a slight bulge between their legs.

Im not painting anyone as transphobic, the comments these women made were transphobic.

knittingaddict · 20/07/2022 11:24

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:12

Again, the changing room had a toilet, a shower and at least one private cubicle. So in any of those three spaces in the changing room you can be naked from the waist down and not exposed to anyones view. You don’t have to “see” anything to know someone is naked from the waist down. In the shower? Naked. Sat on the toilet? Naked from waist down. In the changing cubicle? Naked from waist down at some point if dressing after a shower or undressing and putting on a towel to use the shower.

So you agree that their penis must have been on display?

On the loo? Why would I see anyone on the loo, male or female?

Shower? Were the showers in full view of everyone? It would have been mentioned if they were naked.

Naked from the waist down before or after a shower? So also fully naked at some point? Well that wasn't mentioned, so unlikely to be the scenario here.

To determine whether someone was naked from the waist down you would have to see the pants area, so also see the genitals. Yes?

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 11:21

So again, these women had no say in their space becoming mixed sex. The trust did not follow the EA 2010. This TW did not have a GRC. You seem very very sure that everything this TW said is the gospel truth @Discovereads it is only women who have an agenda?

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 11:20

Funny how the perpetrators could not be found

I thought this. You would assume that the two women were colleagues of the TW given their conversation that the TW working with them was negatively impacting on them so you would also assume that as the TW worked with them they would be able to recognise their posh English accents out of the staff they worked alongside.

They were all clearly on the same shift that day so how did the TW get is so wrong when naming the women as to choose one with a strong not English accent?

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 11:18

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 11:17

I think it's pretty clear that the complaint was because the TW was not sticking to the agreement to use the private spaces to be "naked from the waist down" in.

Exactly.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:18

BoredofthisCrap7 · 20/07/2022 11:11

""The management of the Trust had decided and informed staff before her first day at work that the TW could use the women's changing room, so she was not an “intruder”"

AFAIK it was agreed that the TW would change in the private cubicle and not in the common area of the changing room. This agreement was broken.

Or was it? Why would a TW who is being bullied for a year by transphobic colleagues suddenly decide to stop using the private cubicle that they had specifically asked for due to their transitioning status and anxieties ?

“We begin with a general finding about the Claimant’s evidence. As we explain below, there is no dispute that the Claimant was subjected to transphobic abuse by unknown individuals early in her employment by the First Respondent.”

”As part of the Trust’s pre-employment checks, the Claimant was referred for a pre-placement health screening with Occupational Health (“OH”) in March 2020. The OH advisor reported that the Claimant was fit for work, but noted that she was currently transitioning. This had previously caused some anxieties, including people asking her about it. She had not worked for several years and was also experiencing some anxieties about returning to the workforce and her hours of work. The OH advisor recommended meeting the Claimant before she started work to discuss any support that was required.”

”Mr Swallow and Mr Bulman (HR Manager) therefore met the Claimant on 12 May 2020. They agreed with the Claimant that Mr Swallow would send a note to all CPU staff to say that the Claimant would be joining them, that she was transitioning and that she did not want people to ask her questions about it. This was done at the Claimant’s suggestion. Mr Swallow told the Claimant that there were male and female changing rooms, each with toilet cubicles and showering facilities. They agreed that Mr Swallow’s note would say that the Claimant would be using one of the cubicles in the female changing rooms and did not want to be asked questions about this. Mr Swallow sent a draft of the note to the Claimant. She made some suggested changes, mainly offering personal explanations e.g. referring to the fact that she had suffered ill treatment in the past, or saying that she did not want to be seen as offending anybody.”

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 11:17

I think it's pretty clear that the complaint was because the TW was not sticking to the agreement to use the private spaces to be "naked from the waist down" in.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 20/07/2022 11:17

Appalling. Those poor women.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 11:17

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:12

Again, the changing room had a toilet, a shower and at least one private cubicle. So in any of those three spaces in the changing room you can be naked from the waist down and not exposed to anyones view. You don’t have to “see” anything to know someone is naked from the waist down. In the shower? Naked. Sat on the toilet? Naked from waist down. In the changing cubicle? Naked from waist down at some point if dressing after a shower or undressing and putting on a towel to use the shower.

So how would the person making the allegation know the TW has a penis? Really, the mental hoops you’re jumping through must be exhausting in this heat. You’re determined to paint the women as transphobic bigots aren’t you? Are women not allowed to complain about males in their changing areas? It was not these women who decided it was ok for their space to become mixed sex, so why are they not allowed to raise concerns.

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 11:16

Again, the changing room had a toilet, a shower and at least one private cubicle. So in any of those three spaces in the changing room you can be naked from the waist down and not exposed to anyones view. You don’t have to “see” anything to know someone is naked from the waist down. In the shower? Naked. Sat on the toilet? Naked from waist down. In the changing cubicle? Naked from waist down at some point if dressing after a shower or undressing and putting on a towel to use the shower.

Really?!😂😂 Is this really the position that you are taking? That someone complained that the TW was naked from the waist down while they were in the toilet or shower. Come on. It's just embarrassing for you this.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 11:14

So a woman raising concern is not to be believed. Right? But everything this TW said is true? Surely then there would be witnesses to these ‘transphobic’ conversations? Funny how the perpetrators could not be found? Seems like going by the documented behaviour of this TW, more a plot to get out of being pulled up for absence/sickness/performance issues. See also James Wallis pulling the trans card to get out of trouble. Do you believe If the complainant had not been a TW they would have had half the accommodations and support they received?

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:12

knittingaddict · 20/07/2022 11:01

It’s not “quite a few women”
Mrs Hawkshaw got a statement from ONE woman alleging this and “naked from waist down in the changing room” doesn’t necessarily mean exposed penis in the communal area of the changing room.

What else can it be? If a male body is naked from the waist down ie no pants then their geniltals will be visible. If you can see enough to know that there are no clothes below the waist then the penis will be visible. Give me an alternative explanation please?

Again, the changing room had a toilet, a shower and at least one private cubicle. So in any of those three spaces in the changing room you can be naked from the waist down and not exposed to anyones view. You don’t have to “see” anything to know someone is naked from the waist down. In the shower? Naked. Sat on the toilet? Naked from waist down. In the changing cubicle? Naked from waist down at some point if dressing after a shower or undressing and putting on a towel to use the shower.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 11:12

“The Tribunal therefore concluded that Mrs Hawkshaw asked the questions because of a concern that the Claimant as a transgender woman might be in a state of undress in the female changing room.”

Well you would question it wouldn't you as without GRS the TW would still have their penis therefore this is a male in a female changing room exposing their penis.

BoredofthisCrap7 · 20/07/2022 11:11

""The management of the Trust had decided and informed staff before her first day at work that the TW could use the women's changing room, so she was not an “intruder”"

AFAIK it was agreed that the TW would change in the private cubicle and not in the common area of the changing room. This agreement was broken.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 11:08

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 10:52

Uh huh. You’re very determined to minimise the indecent exposure it seems. Why do you not believe the woman? Is it because the TW is male and therefore thier word carries more weight? Why do you believe this was the only incident?

Two reasons
#1 There was evidence of a staff plot to get rid of the TW


  • The Tribunal found as a matter of fact that the transphobic comments that the TW overhead did happen. These comments basically are a stitch up plot- “drive it out of the department and maybe find a suitable leper colony for it.” “we need to do something but what can we do when management are sucking up to that thing.” “We will find a way.”

  • So two unidentified women that use the changing room expressed intent to “find a way” to “drive it out of the department”.


#2 The anonymous allegation as to “naked from the waist down in the changing room” was not mentioned at all (no one knew about it) until the Tribunal interviewed Mrs Hawkshaw as to why she had asked various questions regarding the TW’s underwear in front of Mrs Hulbert.

“The Tribunal considered Ms Hulbert’s account likely to be the most accurate because she was only involved in this matter at the one meeting, and was there as more of an observer than a participant.”

It’s clear the “naked from waist down” allegation wasn’t mentioned at the meeting: “Mrs Hawkshaw had received a report about the Claimant being naked from the waist down in the changing room before asking the questions. She did not mention that specifically, but the questions she asked seemed to be connected with that as much as with the conversation with Mrs Townsend.”

“The Tribunal therefore concluded that Mrs Hawkshaw asked the questions because of a concern that the Claimant as a transgender woman might be in a state of undress in the female changing room.”