Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this transgender person..

613 replies

ClassSize2022 · 20/07/2022 05:11

Should not have been in the ladies changing room? Especially if naked from the waist down.

I can imagine being very frightened in this situation as a biological woman having to share a changing room with a man.

NHS transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802

transgender worker wins payout after boss asked about underwear www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e15f7c2-0779-11ed-a986-fc91b4ad48f0?shareToken=b22ada0c3a8e04d703e4eb229fb47802 Times article

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/07/2022 12:33

Would you apply your argument to race or sexuality?

Why would you? Being male isn't the same as being gay or a different race. It's a clear biological fact, and it's clear that it's a violation of the privacy and dignity of many nearly all female people, for males to use spaces which are female only for these reasons.

TheUnexpectedPickle · 20/07/2022 12:32

Thing is, this person isn't behaving like any woman that I know. And there is a big difference between accidentally flashing while changing and walking around with your bits out.

In female changing rooms at the gym/pool etc, I usually find that women change discretely in the communal areas. Turn their back on the room when putting on a bra, pop knickers on while sitting and quickly whip them up and so on. This person appears to have just been standing there with their penis out- and apparently then jokingly said that they'd taken their pants off because they were hot. I'd find that weird from anyone to be honest.

I work in an ambulance station, people do sometimes have to get fully changed (including underwear) or even showered after a messy call, so I'd not be surprised to find someone changing, but if I walked in to see a woman- penis or no penis- standing in full view, naked from the waist down who then told me it was because they were hot, I'd very probably be having a word with management.

CharolSmith78 · 20/07/2022 12:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Masterblasterjammin · 20/07/2022 12:32

@Discovereads
’. Nor did she give the impression Mrs Westwood had behaved inappropriately or pressured her to return to full-time hours or that this was the focus of the meeting. Indeed, in the evening on 4 August 2020 she asked for the rest of the week off as compassionate leave. Mrs Westwood did not immediately see the email, but Mr Swallow replied the following morning. In a response to him, the Claimant wrote that she appreciated his and Mrs Westwood’s “support and kindness”’

There we go, I can copy and paste too. The claimant did ask for compassionate leave. Which you have said was not true, and tired to prove this by disingenuously posting a different part of the judgement.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 12:32

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 12:29

Yes it’s true, and why am I the only one quoting the judgement as proof and yet you lot just write a version of events down with no proof?

You are copying down the judgement and still getting it wrong! This is the second time you have got it wrong.

Not this time.
I said the TW was given leave of absence after the incident during the investigation…and she was on 30 July.

You said correctly the investigation was done with on 4th August, but somehow think I was referring to the compassionate leave the TW requested after the 4th of August? I mean how? You missed the 30 July absence that’s how.

At least I have the integrity to admit when I’ve missed a key detail.

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 12:30

You might be surprised to hear that some people like to refer to evidence when they're forming their points of view and considering whether they are reasonable or not. Evidence is important.

Would you apply your argument to race or sexuality?

FOJN · 20/07/2022 12:30

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 12:00

Completely agree. Absolutely vile. Views like this are the reason that suicide rates are so high amongst trans people. Imagine how difficult it must be to be trans and for people to equate your existence with sex offenders.

Are there are any stats on the frequency of attacks on women by transwomen in female changing rooms / women-only spaces? I'm just wondering how often it actually happens? Genuinely interested in what it is that seems to result in such "fear" amongst gender critical mumsnetters.

Do you have any data to support the claim that suicide rates among trans people are high? The Tavistock reports one suicide among their patient group. A patient group which increasingly has co-morbid mental health issues.

Suicide rates among post transitioners have been recorded at 40% and have been for decades, a statistic which pre-dates the current debate. It would be reasonable to ask whether transition actually brings relief for people with gender dysphoria or whether their mental health suffers further when they find they feel no better having exhausted even the most extreme treatment options.

It might be convenient for you to characterise the discussion as equating trans people's existence with sex offenders because it makes you feel morally superior but if you really cared at all you would have done some research into the statistics.

How can you tell the difference between a transwoman and a sexual predator who claims to be trans? We know sexual predators will go to extraordinary lengths to gain access to vulnerable people to abuse so the argument that no sexual predator would go to the trouble of dressing in women's clothing to gain access to female spaces is nonsense; they will train for years to become social workers, members of the clergy, healthcare professionals, teachers etc so a dress, wig and make up is hardly a huge effort.

60% of TW in prison are convicted sex offenders compared to approx 15-20% of the rest of the male prison population. Do you think all those TW struggle with gender dysphoria or do you think it's possible some of them are lying? How do you think it helps people with gender dysphoria to just allow males access to women's spaces based on nothing more than their self identification?

Why did you put fear in quotation marks. 98% of sexual offences are committed by males, their gender identity does not alter offending rates. Is it quite rational for women to raise concerns about males in spaces where women may feel vulnerable because they are fully or partially undressed. If you have daughters please don't teach them that their own discomfort is less important than the feelings of male people regardless of how they identify, you will put them in danger if you do so. Women's boundaries are not hateful.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 12:29

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 12:03

Why is the TW claim that a conversation happened that nobody else heard and there is no evidence of be believed but a womans claim that she saw a penis in the female changing room isn't despite the fact that we know its likely there was a penis in the female changing room given the fact that the TW still has theirs and used said female changing room?

I mean the TW claimed to not have recieved an apology for the dummy comment then produced a secret recording of a meeting where the person who made the dummy comment can be heard clearly apologising again.....

There was no claim by a woman that she saw a penis in the womens changing room.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 12:29

Yes it’s true, and why am I the only one quoting the judgement as proof and yet you lot just write a version of events down with no proof?

You are copying down the judgement and still getting it wrong! This is the second time you have got it wrong.

AlisonDonut · 20/07/2022 12:29

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 12:25

Right. And what percentage of transwomen (if they have a penis) engage in that sort of behaviour? Any stats on that or evidence that it constitutes a reasonable threat to other women?

Stats wise, there are more males that identify as trans in jail for murder than there are males that identify as trans that have been murdered.

So quite dangerous actually.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 12:28

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 12:25

Right. And what percentage of transwomen (if they have a penis) engage in that sort of behaviour? Any stats on that or evidence that it constitutes a reasonable threat to other women?

surely the fact women say no to males in their spaces is enough for you? How many transwomen have been assaulted in male spaces? Why should women give up their spaces to males? What benefit is this to women?

Rainbowshit · 20/07/2022 12:28

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 12:25

Right. And what percentage of transwomen (if they have a penis) engage in that sort of behaviour? Any stats on that or evidence that it constitutes a reasonable threat to other women?

They're male. Males commit 98% of sexual offences. There is no evidence that their offending rates drop because of their special gender feels. In fact the evidence from prisons is that TW are incarcerated for sexual offences at a higher rate than other males.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 12:28

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/07/2022 12:16

All the people involved in the Tribunal. I know that the perpetrators were never identified. Why would you even think I was referring to them?

Your statement was false on the face of it. You believe it happened, and so they couldn't have "cross examined everyone involved", could they, as no one was ever identified, but the perpetrators, if they exist, would have been involved. Your comment lends more legitimacy and weight to the finding than hearsay self-reported "overheard" comments deserve.

I'll be scrolling the rest of your posts, so won't be engaging with you on this thread again, as I'm not interested in participating in derailing it with this.

No it wasn’t “false”. The Tribunal interviewed and cross examined everyone who was involved. It’s implicit this means everyone known to have been involved. You can’t interview and cross examine unknown people.

BoredofthisCrap7 · 20/07/2022 12:27

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 12:25

Right. And what percentage of transwomen (if they have a penis) engage in that sort of behaviour? Any stats on that or evidence that it constitutes a reasonable threat to other women?

Why so concerned with stats?
Why is it not enough that women say NO?

Don't they have that right anymore?

ANY PENIS in a female only space constitutes a "reasonable threat" given that 98% of all sexual assaults are committed by males.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 12:26

@Discovereads because we like watching you try to twist things to meet your narrative.

bellinisurge · 20/07/2022 12:26

98% of sex offences are committed by men. No evidence to show that gender identity makes a jot of difference to male pattern behaviour

HackneyMum1 · 20/07/2022 12:25

Right. And what percentage of transwomen (if they have a penis) engage in that sort of behaviour? Any stats on that or evidence that it constitutes a reasonable threat to other women?

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 12:24

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 12:13

By 28 July she’d been the victim of two transphobic incidents and was put on excused absences by management as the investigations were done

Not true. The claiment REQUESTED compassionate leave for the 5th 6th 7th August which was granted and the TW returned to work Monday the 10th. The conclusion of the investigation meeting had already been held on the 4th August. So she was not granted time off while investigations were done.

Yes it’s true, and why am I the only one quoting the judgement as proof and yet you lot just write a version of events down with no proof?

”Mrs Westwood discussed the Claimant’s email with Mr Swallow and Mrs Wilson. She emailed the Claimant saying that she would continue to support her in any way she could and suggesting that she take the following day off as authorised absence.”

”Mrs Westwood emailed the Claimant on 30 July 2020 to confirm that her day’s absence was a personal day to support her, and would not be counted as sickness absence.”

“The Claimant met Mrs Westwood on 4 August 2020. Ms Platts, HR advisor, attended and Ms Barson (supervisor) supported the Claimant. To begin with the Claimant was shaking and emotional. She revealed that she had self-harmed. However, she was able to take part in the meeting….However, with encouragement from Ms Barson too, the Claimant agreed to try four shifts that week. Mrs Westwood was to meet the Claimant at the end of the week to find out how things had gone. They would then consider whether the Claimant wanted to move to a 20 hour per week post temporarily or whether she wanted to continue with the phased approach with a view to reaching full-time hours. Mrs Westwood would refer the Claimant to OH and a further meeting would then be arranged. The Claimant spoke about ending her employment, but Mrs Westwood encouraged her not to, and to take “small steps” to reach her goal of returning to and staying in work.”

BoredofthisCrap7 · 20/07/2022 12:22

"Are there are any stats on the frequency of attacks on women by transwomen in female changing rooms / women-only spaces? I'm just wondering how often it actually happens? Genuinely interested in what it is that seems to result in such "fear" amongst gender critical mumsnetters."

Who gives a fuck what the "stats" are?
Women say NO.
They don't want MEN in the female changing rooms, toilets, any women only space.

Would you be perfectly happy to let your daughter change in a changing room or toilet with a fully intact male?
If it's only happened once or twice, is that acceptable to you? Are those incidents just the collateral damage that we have to accept so that some men can feel validated as women?

Even if there were NO reported attacks, the fact that women say NO and are uncomfortable with it, should be enough.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/07/2022 12:19

I can live without it, having seen it play out on other threads with various posters.

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 12:19

I’m pretty sure that NHS Trusts don’t segregate changing rooms by worker category. There would have been all professions in there- nurses, cleaners, doctors, caterers. The TW was on the catering staff and wouldn’t have met many people outside her immediate colleagues. How would she know who everyone noncatering is well enough to identify by voice alone when she’d worked less than 10 shifts there before she overhead the conversation?

Given these womens comments it would be safe to say they worked with the TW and also the fact that the other staff member provided 4 names of women who were in there and that the TW was 85% sure it was her colleague Mrs M she heard it shows that these women worked alongside the TW.

Frankly I don't believe that convo happened. There are so many holes and inconsistencies in the TW statements I believe they made it and the notes up.

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 12:18

@Ereshkigalangcleg youll miss all the fun stuff though. We’ve already had the racist card, I’m just waiting for the ‘you’re all big meanies so I’m going’ and I’ve got a full bingo card

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/07/2022 12:16

All the people involved in the Tribunal. I know that the perpetrators were never identified. Why would you even think I was referring to them?

Your statement was false on the face of it. You believe it happened, and so they couldn't have "cross examined everyone involved", could they, as no one was ever identified, but the perpetrators, if they exist, would have been involved. Your comment lends more legitimacy and weight to the finding than hearsay self-reported "overheard" comments deserve.

I'll be scrolling the rest of your posts, so won't be engaging with you on this thread again, as I'm not interested in participating in derailing it with this.

Discovereads · 20/07/2022 12:14

CrossStichQueen · 20/07/2022 11:20

Funny how the perpetrators could not be found

I thought this. You would assume that the two women were colleagues of the TW given their conversation that the TW working with them was negatively impacting on them so you would also assume that as the TW worked with them they would be able to recognise their posh English accents out of the staff they worked alongside.

They were all clearly on the same shift that day so how did the TW get is so wrong when naming the women as to choose one with a strong not English accent?

I’m pretty sure that NHS Trusts don’t segregate changing rooms by worker category. There would have been all professions in there- nurses, cleaners, doctors, caterers. The TW was on the catering staff and wouldn’t have met many people outside her immediate colleagues. How would she know who everyone noncatering is well enough to identify by voice alone when she’d worked less than 10 shifts there before she overhead the conversation?

goodmorningcampers · 20/07/2022 12:14

Conflictedunicorn · 20/07/2022 12:05

Oh yes. I’m just waiting for discoverreads, who seems to have er departed. to pop off and the next TRA join in. I think they tag team when they get tired.

I'm interested in their comments though. I really want to understand but its beyond me .

If the bullying took place that is absolutely of order.

But the male exposing his penis in the female changing room, by removing his pants, to wring them out, because he was hot, and they were wet .... seriously who buys this ? 😂