Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset about breastfeeding

164 replies

feelingdown7 · 19/07/2022 21:40

My baby was born on Friday and despite every effort, will not latch on. When she does latch on, it's only for a few seconds and then she comes off again. I have been expressing breast milk using a pump and have been giving this to her and using formula as a top up. This has really upset me as I really wanted to exclusively breastfeed and feel that I am depriving my child of all the benefits of breastfeeding. My mum and husband keep telling me not to put pressure on myself and that it's not the end of the world if she has to be formula fed but I can't help but feel down about it.

Can someone convince me I'm not entirely ruining my child's life by not being able to breastfeed?! 😩

OP posts:
Pixilicious1 · 20/07/2022 09:11

For different reasons I expressed for my daughter and kept persevering with putting her to the breast after she’d had a bottle of expressed milk. I couldn’t get the latch right and then someone told me to hold your breast like a hamburger and put it in her mouth. Sounds weird but it worked!
it’s very early days. Don’t be too hard on yourself x

Roselilly36 · 20/07/2022 09:09

Aww your baby will be fine OP, I know it’s disappointing if your plans for feeding change, but it will be ok.

Mally100 · 20/07/2022 09:08

If breastfeeding is what you want, you don’t need people telling you how unimportant it is - it may be to them but it doesn’t seem to be unimportant to you. Seek all of the advice and help you can, infant feeding support workers, la leche league, IBCLC, local peer tan groups.
If once you have sought support and help you decide to move on from breastfeeding then that is absolutely fine! I just hate to think of women swapping to formula because they didn’t get the right support when breastfeeding is what they really wanted to do.

I disagree completely. Do you get that some people just can't. They just can't. Can't And these people need to know it's ok. I had all the support, medication to stimulate my milk supply, I tried 2 of the best recommended lactation consultants, made every potion to increase supply, I was supplied with a hospital grade pump, tried other pumps too and it was just not meant to be. For me persistenting was alot to do with the breast is best that is shoved down our throats. When I sat down with my gynae and my paed who talked me through my reasons as to why I felt so strongly about breastfeeding I realised that I actually wasn't very well informed. I was encouraged to switch to formula and ds has thrived. It's very important for women to know the reasons for wanting to bf and to know the alternative is completely fine.

ChorserSaucer · 20/07/2022 09:07

We had a very similar experience. I saw the local breastfeeding consultant but it was too much for me. I pumped for two months until her vaccinations but also had to use formula too. I was devastated I couldn’t breastfeed and felt like a bad mum but 10months on I don’t regret the decision to stop.

No one looks at a child and can say “oh they were breastfed or they were formula fed”. As long as they’re getting milk and lots of love you are doing everything right!

Follow what feels right for you right now. Best of luck and congratulations!!!

Palmtree9 · 20/07/2022 09:07

Not read the whole thread, so sorry if I've missed something.
I had something similar. I found the following helped:
-i was advised by my MW to use shields for a few weeks, and for me it worked
-there are lots of Facebook support groups, I think ones called breastfeeding and laxtation support UK, which are well worth joining
-look for local support groups and peer support groups

But honestly, at the end of the day, a happy full baby and a happy mum not putting too much pressure on herself is all that is needed!

Also, congratulations!!

AllThatAndMore · 20/07/2022 09:07

@Putonyourshoes I couldn’t agree more . What motivated me to keep going was the encouragement from family and friends who told me their struggles and success stories . I got so much fantastic advice and got the help I needed.

Marvellousmadness · 20/07/2022 09:06

@Goldbar but its women THEMSELVES that put the bar there. I dont understand the hysteria

A baby needs to fed. It doesnt make you a better mum if you bf. It doesnt make you less of a mum when you fórmula feed.

Women do this to themselves
The question of "have i done damage to my kid/ am i a bad mum"etc is just rediculous.

Belephant · 20/07/2022 09:05

To be fair, @Putonyourshoes, op did explicitly ask people to tell her that formula feeding wouldn't ruin her baby's life, so that's the type of support people are trying to give.

I had a really similar experience to @Goldbar. I honestly think I was near a guilt-induced breakdown. I'd been made so scared to give my baby formula that in my sleep deprived state of mind I convinced myself that if I gave my baby formula he wouldn't be a "real" baby anymore Blush

Swapping to combi feeding took all the pressure of me. My baby was losing so much weight (99th percentile for height, 80th for weight at birth. He dropped to 15th I think it was for weight before I decided that the midwives constant "just keep feeding, don't give bottles it will ruin your supply!" was nonsense. We started giving him quite a bit of formula and dropped breast feeding to only once or twice a day. I was able to relax when it came to the breast feeds, as I knew he was well fed the rest of the day. I didn't have to cry with worry for his weight every day anymore. I really believe my baby was picking up on my more relaxed mood. He was also just getting bigger and older which made bf slightly easier. Eventually we increased the amount he breastfed more and more each week. We ended up breastfeeding until 7 months.

If at 7 weeks you'd have asked me if I could imagine still breastfeeding at 7 months, I'd have laughed. I couldn't even imagine still being alive by then at that point!

OP, you are doing amazing ❤️

mydogsteppedonabee · 20/07/2022 09:04

Fed is best.
Please be kinder to yourself. If you're stressed and anxious about bf then she will pick up on it.
I have 3. Eldest wasn't breastfed. She's going to one of the top grammar schools in the country this September.
She is kind and compassionate, incredibly smart and a fantastic big sister.
My middle boy was bf'd for 11 weeks and the baby for 7 months.
Out of all my 3, the baby is the biggest rascal. Absolute terrorist!

I remember seeing a meme once with a picture of a bunch of 5 year olds in the play ground creating havoc. The caption went along the lines 'spot the breast fed child... oh that's right, you can't... because my kid is just as weird as yours'

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 20/07/2022 08:58

Have you contacted your local family centres to see if they're running breastfeeding support in the community?

I volunteer at one as a breastfeeding peer supporter and although the service is being cut in some places it's thriving in others.

Many babies also don't latch immediately, mine included. We breastfed for 3 years! It just took help.

Other posters are right that really breastfeeding is a game of statistics. Statistically it is better, but that's on a population level. Individually, breastfeeding and formula feeding probably make little difference but if you're pumping baby is still getting most of the benefits of breast milk.

You can also call the national breastfeeding helpline and la leche league for support.

Please do not feel guilty about this. It's new to you and to your baby, I've worked with mums where it's taken weeks and in some cases months to go from pumping to breast, but we've made it work.

I won't say fed is best because personally I just don't believe it's helpful. It doesn't quell any. Guilt you feel and it doesn't aid any grief if it does not work out, but you need to know if it doesn't, it's because of a huge gap in community support, and not because you gave up.

The most important thing for your baby is to have healthy, happy parents, who are capable of giving him/her the love and attention she needs.

Reach out if you need to.

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 08:52

There’s some lovely, well-meaning posts of support on this thread. However, I’ve been in the situation where breastfeeding wasn’t going as planned, baby wasn’t gaining enough weight and it made me want to rip my hair out to hear all of the comments: “no-one will ask when they’re older how they were fed”, “happy mum and happy baby is all that matters”, “formula is fine”. That’s not what I needed to hear, and I’m not sure the OP needs this either. If someone expresses how much breastfeeding means to them, it’s dismissive to reel off anecdotes of all of the babies that have thrived on formula, or to persistently tell them swapping to bottles is fine.

If breastfeeding is what you want, you don’t need people telling you how unimportant it is - it may be to them but it doesn’t seem to be unimportant to you. Seek all of the advice and help you can, infant feeding support workers, la leche league, IBCLC, local peer tan groups.
If once you have sought support and help you decide to move on from breastfeeding then that is absolutely fine! I just hate to think of women swapping to formula because they didn’t get the right support when breastfeeding is what they really wanted to do.

Saying all of this, I eventually combi fed by little boy. I had supply issues and went through the rigmarole of expressing, topping up by bottle etc. Eventually I came to the conclusion that for us as a family, a mixture of breast and formula was right. However, I was surrounded by people who understood my desire to breastfeed, didn’t belittle this by telling me formula from a bottle was just as good and supported my decision to keep trying.

LooseGoose22 · 20/07/2022 08:50

*formula

LooseGoose22 · 20/07/2022 08:50

Just checked and that is Elvie, and there's one called a Willow, if they're both still going. One has a collection container so no need to buy expensive collection bags, but can't remember which one. They are pricey but ebay etc might have some. The freemie collection cups work with various pumps some of which are portable & small.

The thing is, its not "over"/decided with a few days or even early weeks ... you can take the stress off with formulated keep trying with the breast feeding (if you want to)

lifehappens12 · 20/07/2022 08:46

Hello, genuinely believe there are babies that just don't latch. My first - we stayed in hospital for 3 days and so many nurses tried to get him to latch including the breast feeding whisperer who always got babies to latch.

We had a very lazy baby with no impulse. I was upset and felt a failure but in the end - being fed is the priority. My baby got bad jaundice and was close to needing treatment so that was enough for me to get the bottles out.

Babies can be so different - my second baby was born rooting and fed immediately from birth. I add this as sometimes it's just the way the baby is

Blossom45 · 20/07/2022 08:43

I was adopted from birth so no option to have been breastfed and I can honestly say it has not impacted me, my life or my health. Your baby will be fine and will no doubt grow into a healthy adult. A fed baby is best, whether that’s breast or formula.

Outwiththenorm · 20/07/2022 08:41

Babies are rubbish at breastfeeding to start with! I really struggled to get DS to latch and called a private lactation consultant who just moved his head and my arm a tiny bit and suddenly it all worked. Hope you can get some practical support, I would have never managed alone.

LooseGoose22 · 20/07/2022 08:38

Yeah I'd try some shields.

I'd keep pumping on one side and keep giving her chance to latch on on other side. Having her in your arms while pumping should help re. what you get out.

I'd try to combi feed, you can keep trying with latching/breathing feeding while you do. It is possible to combi feee and reduce the formula as you get more from breast-feeding. You'd have to keep pumping though, if shes not latching/sucking. Have you tried the mobile in bra pumps like the (elvi, if ots still going).... they'd make it a lot easier. There's also a relatively mobile collection cup called a freebie, that works with various pumps.

Veebees26 · 20/07/2022 08:33

I really feel for you, BF is so hard so try to be like to yourself, speak to yourself the way you would a friend if they had the same concerns.

Breastmilk is food, formula is food. They are very much equal. If you really do a deep dive into the evidence and the studies you will see for yourself that the difference is negligible, mainly concerning the gi tract and very much short term. Breastmilk is not the "liquid gold" that some make it out to be, its just food.
Breastfeeding is great, but it is not without its drawbacks, formula feeding is also great. If BF isn't working for either of you at any point then switch without guilt, you both need to be happy.

Ontomatopea · 20/07/2022 08:28

Goldbar · 20/07/2022 08:20

There is a real hysteria around breastfeeding and pressure on mothers. I was made to feel absolutely dreadful for wanting to give formula even when my two week old baby had not slept for hours since they were so hungry.

Of course in the long run this is one of those decisions you simply should not stress over, but try telling that to a vulnerable new mum who has been given the spiel about how breastfeeding offers the best start (and anything else is by definition inferior) in the lead-up to the birth. The benefit of hindsight is a great thing, so please try to be sympathetic.

I agree. It was incredibly traumatic for me. I had very little support due to pandemic. The midwives and HV kept pushing it over the phone. I was isolated. Felt like a complete failure. Even the message on the formula box about breast feeding being best would send me close to the edge. I did have Postnatal depression but I swear the whole messaging surrounding breastfeeding was such a contributing factor to this.

Goldbar · 20/07/2022 08:20

Marvellousmadness · 20/07/2022 08:10

"Can someone convince me I'm not entirely ruining my child's life by not being able to breastfeed?! 😩"

Yes sure op. ...All kids that arent breastfed lives are ruined . 100% ruined. Theyll never get a job. They'll never be able to make friends and be happy. Poor kids....

There is a real hysteria around breastfeeding and pressure on mothers. I was made to feel absolutely dreadful for wanting to give formula even when my two week old baby had not slept for hours since they were so hungry.

Of course in the long run this is one of those decisions you simply should not stress over, but try telling that to a vulnerable new mum who has been given the spiel about how breastfeeding offers the best start (and anything else is by definition inferior) in the lead-up to the birth. The benefit of hindsight is a great thing, so please try to be sympathetic.

Wotrewelookinat · 20/07/2022 08:20

For me breast feeding was the most traumatic experience. Just couldn’t get DD1 to latch on despite loads of visits to breast feeding clinics etc. After 2 weeks ended up with mastitis and in so much pain. My lovely health visitor said ‘you can just stop trying now you know, bottle feeding isn’t like giving heroin’. I cried with relief and we bottle fed from then on.p and only really then started bonding properly. She is now a very healthy 19year old and has no allergies, rarely gets ill, very sporty.

i know this is my experience, but don’t beat yourself up please. Your baby will be fine if you bottle feed. Keep trying if you want to, stop if it’s adversely affecting your mental and /or physical health.

ps I next had twins and I chose straight away to express and didn’t even try to breastfeed, and that worked really well.

roarfeckingroarr · 20/07/2022 08:19

Ask for help from your midwife and la leche league, and have baby checked for tongue tie.
Please don't be hard on yourself. You're trying your best and stress will hinder your milk production.

GroggyLegs · 20/07/2022 08:17

this is something that seems huge at the time and irrelevant after. You've already pumped which requires super human effort. There comes a point where the stress and effort may not be worth it and that's totally fine. Have you ever heard anyone in your whole life say 'if only my mum had breastfed me a bit longer, then....'? Your baby will be fine.

This is absolutely true. I had a baby who wouldn't latch and was obsessed that he MUST breastfeed. We managed it but I look back and wonder why on earth I didn't just give him formula.

Nipple shields worked for us. I found Medela were by far the best.
I also took him to a chiropractor specialising in babies. Hard to say if it helped but he had a massive sleep after & seemed more settled.

You will get through this OP and one day it'll be your turn to advise a new mum that although it feels horrible right now, everything will be fine x

AllThatAndMore · 20/07/2022 08:16

It’s so early . You can still have a fantastic breastfeeding journey if you want . There is also no shame in formula .

With my first we struggled with latch for the first THREE MONTHS! His first week or two we topped up with formula every feed and again between 8-10 weeks old.

15 weeks later (and two tongue tie snips later ) we were finally exclusively breastfeeding We went on to breastfed until he was 14 months old .

Bellatrix13 · 20/07/2022 08:13

Hi, after lurking for ages I have joined MN just to comment as I noticed no one else mentioned this.
did you have any difficulties during birth and /or have noticed a stiffness in one side of your baby (such as preference to turn head one way or hard to move arms and legs on one side)?

my boy (now 4 months) didn’t BF properly until 7 weeks old. At first I was bottle and expressing due to poor latch. I was told at birth he had slight tongue tie. The HV noticed I was very tired and getting depressed about feeding. I was feeling pressured by my family to BF and by partner’s family to formula bottle feed.

HV recommended nipple shields and they worked.
I then went to see a cranial osteopath (this is what no one has mentioned yet) as my baby was very stiff on one side due to doctor having to reach in and turn him face down as he was going to come out face up and was having trouble during labour to come out. I believe this is what caused the stiffness in my baby.

I then went to see lactation and tongue tie specialist as I wanted to get off the nipple shields as baby was starting to pull them off. TT was barely there so was not the issue. She also suggested it was the stiffness that had been causing issue and recommended a few more sessions with osteopath.

my boy saw osteopath 3 times and now BF like a pro. It is a lot easier for night feeds to BF but like others say, a fed baby is what is essential so don’t feel bad on yourself if you do switch to formula

good luck