Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset about breastfeeding

164 replies

feelingdown7 · 19/07/2022 21:40

My baby was born on Friday and despite every effort, will not latch on. When she does latch on, it's only for a few seconds and then she comes off again. I have been expressing breast milk using a pump and have been giving this to her and using formula as a top up. This has really upset me as I really wanted to exclusively breastfeed and feel that I am depriving my child of all the benefits of breastfeeding. My mum and husband keep telling me not to put pressure on myself and that it's not the end of the world if she has to be formula fed but I can't help but feel down about it.

Can someone convince me I'm not entirely ruining my child's life by not being able to breastfeed?! 😩

OP posts:
LooseGoose22 · 20/07/2022 11:15

If you really want to, of keep pumping to try to stimulate your supply if your baby isn't currently currently staying on longer enough to do so.

A hospital grade double electric pump, hire or buy.

I liked the spectra.

Hold you baby and look af them etc on one side while you pump.

Beseen22 · 20/07/2022 11:14

My second DS would not latch. I had successfully breastfed previously and accessed all support and he was the calmest little thing until the second I put him near my breast and he didn't have a clue, screamed, became a hot sweaty little ball of rage. Tried icblc, craniopath, peer support etc etc etc and then one day when he was about 4 weeeks old said this is ridiculous, why am I putting us through this torture of him losing his shiz every 3 hours just so I can say he breastfed.

I moved to exclusive pumping and thankfully I had an oversupply so I enjoyed it. I loved bagging it all up and making his bottles. I loved how he actually slept from weeks old and took naps and fell in to a lovely routine because I could time when he needed his bottle. I loved when my DH unexpectedly lost his job I was able to get a job and work not worried about him at all because I knew he would settle. I loved seeing him so satisfied and full after a feed and not need more 40 mins later like his brother would have.

Now I have had a bottle fed baby I feel so much different about it and would absolutely pump if I was lucky enough to ever have a third. It was a privilege to bf my first but I feel 2nd DS was a much more satisfied baby and I was a much easier going mum and I enjoyed the whole thing a lot more the second time round even though I was stuck to a milking machine like a cow 4 x a day. Be kind to yourself and evaluate what is important to you and your baby and your family. If that's BF then great, make sure you access all the support that's available to you. If not then great, enjoy finding a solution that works.

LooseGoose22 · 20/07/2022 11:13

*it's not a fait accompli

LooseGoose22 · 20/07/2022 11:13

but I have always been so focused on breastfeeding so the fact it's not going well and I'm having to give her formula is heartbreaking to me.

It's not done and dusted, ots bog a fair accompli. There's nothing wrong with doing it get them fed and take the pressure off while you "investigate" all avenues for breast-feeding (combi or exclusive).

Plus the baby getting bigger/older may help.

Loics · 20/07/2022 11:12

Hi OP, if you want to breastfeed and are struggling, I don't think being told just to use formula as baby will be okay helps. Of course baby will be okay if you formula feed, but it doesn't help if you do want to breastfeed and haven't had support to do it.
I struggled with my first, he would latch but it was painful and I worried I was in for months or years of painful feeds. I had a visit from a lactation consultant who identified tongue tie, it was corrected and feeding was so much easier! She also showed me how to latch properly and observed my latch to make sure I was getting the hang of it. When my second came along, I noticed tongue tie almost straight away and asked the midwife at our home visit for a referral to have it corrected, so feeding was a lot easier second time around, having previously had that advice and support.

Please do contact local breastfeeding support (your midwife will have details if you don't already), and it may be worth having baby checked for tongue tie.
If you decide to formula feed, or top up with formula, you are not harming your baby and you're doing nothing wrong. Just make sure that you have as much support as possible to feed the way you prefer.

Somethingsnappy · 20/07/2022 11:03

Op, often when babies don't/can't latch, it's because when they do try to latch, they are unable to feed effectively, and this is so frustrating for them, to be hungry and smell the milk, but not able to get at it. Does your baby cry if you try to latch him on? As others have said, do get him assessed for tongue tie, both anterior and posterior (harder to spot), as this is often a major cause of refusal to latch.

theremustonlybeone · 20/07/2022 10:53

Speak to your midwife and get your little one checked incase the latch issue isn’t due to a tongue tie. Good luck with it all

CheesyColeslaw · 20/07/2022 10:46

Most babies in the UK are formula fed (though many try to breastfeed initially) and the majority of them are absolutely fine. Ask your health visitor or Google to see what breastfeeding support is available in your area if it's something you really want to do but don't beat yourself up if it doesn't work out and you have to formula feed. Your baby will be fine either way and in a couple of years, you won't even think about how they were fed as a baby.

MoodyTwo · 20/07/2022 10:44

Oh nipple shells help too
When your nipples are cracked you can just put them on to stop your bra rubbing them , and abit of lanolin on the air will help them heal

MoodyTwo · 20/07/2022 10:42

Breast feeding is horrible, I'm feeding my 10 week old... the first two weeks were pure hell
Can you ask someone to come and watch you, we have FAB in our area that do this

honeybeesknees · 20/07/2022 10:41

@ReadytoShip there is research to show that for women who want to breastfeed, but can’t, they are at higher risk of postnatal depression. That’s not to say formula is bad, but it’s wrong to just dismiss their feelings and make them feel wrong to want to breastfeed. People should be supportive of feeding choices no matter what they are.

SpiceRat · 20/07/2022 10:41

Can someone convince me I'm not entirely ruining my child's life by not being able to breastfeed?!
I’ll try to be kind because you’re obviously having a hard time but these kind of statements are so incredibly offensive and upsetting to mums who bottle fed. Our babies, children and even grown adults have in no way been disadvantaged because they were formula fed.

I couldn’t get a decent latch either. My nipples turned to one big scab. She never drank out of a bottle well and I couldn’t afford the extortionate price of a consultant to look at tongue tie, so we made the decision to formula feed. I, with all my
being, wanted to breastfeed, but at no point did I ever think she would be a failure because of that. I felt like a failure, but that was just the start of the Mum Guilt.

Now she’s eating food off the floor with the rest of the bottle / breastfed kids her age, and flying along with development.

Social standing, misogyny etc will all have more of an impact in her life than what she ate for 6 months.

Itdoesntreallymatter · 20/07/2022 10:39

I think there is too much pressure on mothers to breastfeed and I say this as someone who has spent the last 8 years either pregnant or breastfeeding.

I found it easy to start breastfeeding, but breastfeeding itself is not easy and there are many negatives. I have had huge issues stopping both times (I am going down the sudafed weaning route for my three year old soon, as he won't stop). Both never slept well either. I think the benefits are over-exaggerated. My first child has a very strong immune system and is smart, but the second is neither of these and is behind developmentally. Not sure about benefits to me as I will never know if it reduced the chance of cancer, but I would say breastfeeding for so long impacted my mental health a lot as I had to deal with all the sleeplessness and tantrums, and I have struggled to lose the last stone in weight after pregnancies which has ruined my confidence too. Not all women drop weight due to breastfeeding and some retain due to oxytocin.

Sorry this is negative, but I think you get militant breastfeeding mothers who use their bf status for one-upmanship, making people who can't do it, or can but hate the process feel guilty. They make people like me who do bf but have both negative and positive experiences from it feel like an outlier and we certainly aren't. I just want you to not be made to feel guilty by these people who pressure women.

If I had my time again, I think I would actually combi or bottle feed. In hindsight it would have been the best option as a working mother for both of my kids and me. I think breastfeeding for so long has made my life much harder and I think I would have been a better parent having slept better and not feeling so pinned down by bfing. Not for my partner though, as he would have had nightfeeds to do 😂

NightsinBlueSatin · 20/07/2022 10:39

Neither I nor my siblings were breastfed. Between us we have masters degrees, speak 3 languages and work in corporate environments. My Mum didn't fuck us up by giving us formula.

ReadytoShip · 20/07/2022 10:32

Jesus, what is the obsession with breast feeding and mum's beating themselves up if they can't? It's literally reaching ridiculous/ cult like levels now.

OP, your baby will be fine, it's formula milk, not battery acid.

sayanythingelse · 20/07/2022 10:18

You'll both be fine. I just assumed that I would breastfeed my DD, I never had any other plan in place. It just didn't happen though. I think it was a mix of having surgery on one of my breasts, so milk didn't come through great and DD being very small and born at Christmas, so midwife/breastfeeding support was thin on the ground.
I tried all sorts but when she started dropping in weight, I just switched to formula completely. I felt guilty for a long time but she's nearly 4 now and the smartest, healthiest little cookie.

I'm currently pregnant with number 2 and determined to give bf a go again but I'm totally not bothered if it doesn't work out.

easyday · 20/07/2022 10:13

Oh took me and my son about two weeks to really 'get' it. Don't get riled up. Keep trying. But if it doesn't work out bottle feeding is fine and certainly does not ruin a kids life! The baby will look at you adoringly whether he has you or a bottle in his mouth!

Goldbar · 20/07/2022 10:10

@Belephant - I'm sorry to hear that you too had an awful experience in the first few weeks and that your feeding choices weren't supported.

It's something that still makes me feel furious to this day - my baby was so upset with hunger that they had very little chance of latching and feeding successfully. Just constant fussing and screaming, So much judgement and, despite having a healthy 4yo now, I still feel guilty that DC spent the first few weeks of life essentially starving. A few bottles and DC was calmer and able to feed much better. And I continued breastfeeding until 18 months.

If anyone makes any comments about cow milk being for baby cows and human milk for baby humans this time around (and yes, that is the sort of drivel I was being told which is why I don't agree with people saying that it is all the fault of new mothers putting pressure on themselves), I will honestly throw something at them.

WaltzingWaters · 20/07/2022 10:09

It is very early days still and can take time. Definitely seek out all the support available to you. And get baby checked several times for tongue tie, I know several people who had trouble with breastfeeding and it wasn’t until after a few checks they discovered a tongue tie, and fed fine after it was fixed.
it doesn’t matter if baby is breastfed or bottle fed, don’t put lots of pressure on yourself, but also keep trying for longer if it’s important to you, it does take practice and sometimes a lot of assistance. If it doesn’t, that’s okay, and also means others can help with feeding so you get more rest.

honeybeesknees · 20/07/2022 10:08

Have a look at Professor Amy Brown on Facebook. She is brilliant at validating women’s feeling around breastfeeding. Also, as others have suggested, ask for your baby to be checked for tongue tie from somebody properly qualified to assess. You may need to go private if you are able to. Your feelings are real though, and even though you want your baby to be fed, there are maternal instincts and hormones at play which can be very strong in making you want to feed your baby yourself. Don’t feel guilty for that at all!

toastfiend · 20/07/2022 10:05

However you feed your baby is fine, it really is.

It is very early days - does your hospital have any breastfeeding support or are you able to access help from a lactation consultant? I never found midwives very helpful with breastfeeding, my DS was premature and had the same issue that he wouldn't latch. The midwives were useless with breastfeeding support, lacked knowledge, and a few of them were actively unkind and unhelpful, but the NICU nurses, hospital's infant feeding team, and a lactation consultant were all extremely helpful and knowledgeable. If you speak to your Health Visitor you might find that you can access free support from a lactation consultant through a referral from them, I know my area offers this as I was referred.

Have you tried nipple shields at all? My DS had a very high palate and the shields, used temporarily, helped stimulate his latch and suckle reflex. I'm not a trained supporter, but just to say that with exactly the same issue you're facing now, I combi-fed my DS (mostly expressed breastmilk and occasional latching to keep "practising") and then exclusively breastfed him from around 10 weeks when be was stronger and able to latch and suckle more, so the hurdles now don't mean that it's not possible for you if you really want to do it. I won't lie, though, almost exclusively pumping was hard for that time. You also need to make sure that the teat you use on any bottles more closely mimics breastfeeding - I.e. they have to work at it and can't guzzle it - if you do ultimately want to breastfeed.

feelingdown7 · 20/07/2022 09:59

Thank you so much everyone for your sympathy and advice. I realise my post comes across a little bit dramatic, but I have always been so focused on breastfeeding so the fact it's not going well and I'm having to give her formula is heartbreaking to me.

Lots of you have recommended nipple shields so I've ordered them and will see now it goes. I'm also going to contact my midwife for help and advice.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 20/07/2022 09:54

Marvellousmadness · 20/07/2022 09:06

@Goldbar but its women THEMSELVES that put the bar there. I dont understand the hysteria

A baby needs to fed. It doesnt make you a better mum if you bf. It doesnt make you less of a mum when you fórmula feed.

Women do this to themselves
The question of "have i done damage to my kid/ am i a bad mum"etc is just rediculous.

I didn't do it to myself. It's something I'm still cross about actually, but in my case it was definitely done to me. It wasn't me putting the pressure on myself. I was perfectly happy to do mixed feeding until we got the hang of it, but everyone around me was saying don't do that, persevere, just keep going, you'll get there. And my husband had assimilated all the info about how great breastfeeding was for the baby so he was also in the 'you just need to keep trying, it will all be ok' camp. What helped actually was when I decided to stay in bed rather than go to yet another breastfeeding support group and everyone else including him fucked off out of my house so I could do what I liked without feeling that I needed to justify it.

Herejustforthisone · 20/07/2022 09:54

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 08:52

There’s some lovely, well-meaning posts of support on this thread. However, I’ve been in the situation where breastfeeding wasn’t going as planned, baby wasn’t gaining enough weight and it made me want to rip my hair out to hear all of the comments: “no-one will ask when they’re older how they were fed”, “happy mum and happy baby is all that matters”, “formula is fine”. That’s not what I needed to hear, and I’m not sure the OP needs this either. If someone expresses how much breastfeeding means to them, it’s dismissive to reel off anecdotes of all of the babies that have thrived on formula, or to persistently tell them swapping to bottles is fine.

If breastfeeding is what you want, you don’t need people telling you how unimportant it is - it may be to them but it doesn’t seem to be unimportant to you. Seek all of the advice and help you can, infant feeding support workers, la leche league, IBCLC, local peer tan groups.
If once you have sought support and help you decide to move on from breastfeeding then that is absolutely fine! I just hate to think of women swapping to formula because they didn’t get the right support when breastfeeding is what they really wanted to do.

Saying all of this, I eventually combi fed by little boy. I had supply issues and went through the rigmarole of expressing, topping up by bottle etc. Eventually I came to the conclusion that for us as a family, a mixture of breast and formula was right. However, I was surrounded by people who understood my desire to breastfeed, didn’t belittle this by telling me formula from a bottle was just as good and supported my decision to keep trying.

Well, you’ve just added to the pressure.

Herejustforthisone · 20/07/2022 09:52

I formula fed from the get go. Would you tell me I would depriving my baby by doing so? If not, apply that same decency to yourself.

You’re not failing anyone. Sometimes plans change.