Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset about breastfeeding

164 replies

feelingdown7 · 19/07/2022 21:40

My baby was born on Friday and despite every effort, will not latch on. When she does latch on, it's only for a few seconds and then she comes off again. I have been expressing breast milk using a pump and have been giving this to her and using formula as a top up. This has really upset me as I really wanted to exclusively breastfeed and feel that I am depriving my child of all the benefits of breastfeeding. My mum and husband keep telling me not to put pressure on myself and that it's not the end of the world if she has to be formula fed but I can't help but feel down about it.

Can someone convince me I'm not entirely ruining my child's life by not being able to breastfeed?! 😩

OP posts:
Belephant · 20/07/2022 12:34

Again, @Putonyourshoes, I think that's a bit disingenuous given that the last line of the OP is explicitly asking for reassurance that formula is okay. So naturally, that is how people will respond.

LetsPlayShadowlands · 20/07/2022 12:32

It's valid for OP to feel upset about this yes. But it's not ok to infer that bottle fed babies lives were ruined by their feeding method.

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 12:30

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer That’s exactly how it seems. So many posters rushed to tell this Mum that it’s ok to give formula if she doesn’t want to breastfeed when she’s already said she wants to and is upset that it’s not working out. Who’s applying the pressure here?

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 12:26

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 12:18

This is the exact thing that I was previously trying to explain. It’s about what an individual Mum wants. Imagine tirelessly pumping breast milk as you’re having difficulty latching your baby and you really want to breastfeed, reaching out to other mums and basically being told it isn’t worth the effort.
There was even one poster who said “women do this to themselves”. I had comments like that, whilst I was triple feeding, trying to increase my milk supply, working SO hard because it’s what I wanted to do for my baby. People would ask why would you put yourself through that, and tell me that formula is fine. Of course it is, we know as long as baby is fed and thriving and happy then however you feed is fine, but I WANTED to breastfeed.
It’s crazy how if you offer support to a woman who WANTS to breastfeed, as I have, that you are told you’re pressuring them. But telling a woman who WANTS to breastfeed to just give formula is ok.

Totally agree.

I can't help but think it's becuase, like some PPs, its seen as an insult on FF to say you prefer BFing. Almost likea "oh, you think you are better than us then". It's ridiculous.

I would have be gutted at the time if I had been unsuccessful. And I was encouraged by many to stop trying. Luckily it worked out in the end, but it took a hell of a lot of effort. It was super annoying for people to almost mock that effort as though they thought completely unnecessary. It was important to me at the time and I'm really glad I did it.

Of course no one can tell now my children were BF (they are never sick, but I attribute that to my relaxed cleaning habits more than the BFing), but that doesn't mean it wasn't a valid parenting choice that deserved support rather than dismissal.

SuperDoughnut · 20/07/2022 12:22

Maybe try this line:

NCT supports all parents, however they feed their baby. If you have questions, concerns or need support, you can speak to a breastfeeding counsellor by calling our helpline on 0300 330 0700, whether you are exclusively breastfeeding or using formula milk.

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 12:18

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 12:08

And more support for mums to do what they want. Sturggles to BF for a woman who wants to BF shouldn't be met with just telling her FF is just dandy. She should get the support she needs and wants to do what she would like to do.

This is the exact thing that I was previously trying to explain. It’s about what an individual Mum wants. Imagine tirelessly pumping breast milk as you’re having difficulty latching your baby and you really want to breastfeed, reaching out to other mums and basically being told it isn’t worth the effort.
There was even one poster who said “women do this to themselves”. I had comments like that, whilst I was triple feeding, trying to increase my milk supply, working SO hard because it’s what I wanted to do for my baby. People would ask why would you put yourself through that, and tell me that formula is fine. Of course it is, we know as long as baby is fed and thriving and happy then however you feed is fine, but I WANTED to breastfeed.
It’s crazy how if you offer support to a woman who WANTS to breastfeed, as I have, that you are told you’re pressuring them. But telling a woman who WANTS to breastfeed to just give formula is ok.

Rainbowdrops2021 · 20/07/2022 12:18

No matter what happens from here on out do not hold this against yourself! I did that for years and felt like I failed and it’s just not important. Strangely I went on to breast feed my second child for 2 1/2 years and it hasn’t made a dot of difference between my children. I would say my first child slept better and it was nice that my dh got to feed and bond with her and with my second breastfeeding was convenient. Both have perks and drawbacks but you must not beat yourself up for this. If you do decide to not give up I would personally stop topping up with formula, get some advice from Lucas breastfeeding support and although they don’t recommend this nipple shields helped for us maybe as a last resort. What ever you decide don’t let this leave a shadow hanging over such a precious time.

honeybeesknees · 20/07/2022 12:10

Ontomatopea · 20/07/2022 12:02

Yes it is strange, it must depend on who you see/where you live etc. I guess the key thing is there needs to be less pressure either way!

Exactly that!

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 12:08

Ontomatopea · 20/07/2022 12:02

Yes it is strange, it must depend on who you see/where you live etc. I guess the key thing is there needs to be less pressure either way!

And more support for mums to do what they want. Sturggles to BF for a woman who wants to BF shouldn't be met with just telling her FF is just dandy. She should get the support she needs and wants to do what she would like to do.

RegardingMary · 20/07/2022 12:06

If you wanted, you could try and find an IBLCC to help, they're much better than your usual HV or midwife, but usually they're not free. Lots and lots of skin to skin and always offering breast before bottle, paced feeding when using a bottle. Keep hydrated.

But if its not working out, the last thing to do is to beat yourself up. Honestly, you'd never know which children are breast or bottle fed once they're passed a year old, and by the time they're lining up outside school it's the last thing on anyone's mind.
It feels all encompassing now, but it's such a small detail in the bigger picture.

Mally100 · 20/07/2022 12:04

Breastfeeding doesn't give you membership for the Amazing Mother club.

Agree! So doesn't having a NVD over a C-SECTION. No one is giving you a medal for that, women are their own worst enemy. This shit does not matter in the long run. It does NOT matter who was formula fed, born through a CS, or anything else!!

Ontomatopea · 20/07/2022 12:02

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 12:01

It's funny because my, anecdotal, experience was the opposite. Loads of stuff before birth on how amazing BF is, but after birth formula was pushed loads - from medical professionals, society etc. Every little issue with baby was probabyl due to BFing and could be solved by just givign in and formula feeding. It felt almost like some people thought I was being ridiculous for caring about BF.ing It was even suggested once that I was putting my own desires to BF over the welfare of my baby (which was - obviously - not the case).

Yes it is strange, it must depend on who you see/where you live etc. I guess the key thing is there needs to be less pressure either way!

Ontomatopea · 20/07/2022 12:01

honeybeesknees · 20/07/2022 11:58

@Ontomatopea @ReadytoShip I’m sorry to hear you experienced a sneery attitude towards formula feeding. However, as someone who wanted to breastfeed and struggled due to tongue tie, I found all the ‘support’ I got was to tell me just to formula feed and be grateful my baby was being fed, which was not what I wanted to do (nothing to do with society, I had decided that I wanted to do it). If OP wants to breastfeed, she needs support, not just told to stop being so precious about breastfeeding. As I said, research shows that this lack of support and understanding can lead to a higher risk of postnatal depression.
This isn’t about which way of feeding is best, it’s about supporting a woman who would like to feed in a particular way, whatever that may be, and whatever her reasons may be.

I understand what you are saying but I found it the other way around. I wanted to breastfeed but was really struggling. My mental health was declining rapidly and I truly beleve the only thing that saved me from it further declining was the GP saying look, you've tried, it's not working, it is ok to stop. Before that no one had said it was ok to stop all the contact I'd had (albeit limited due to pandemic) was pushing me to keep trying but with no actual advice on what on earth I was meant to do. All the while my baby was losing weight and at risk of dehydration.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 12:01

Ontomatopea · 20/07/2022 11:50

Yes I wholly agree with this. The pressure is immense. At a time when women can be very vulnerable.

It's funny because my, anecdotal, experience was the opposite. Loads of stuff before birth on how amazing BF is, but after birth formula was pushed loads - from medical professionals, society etc. Every little issue with baby was probabyl due to BFing and could be solved by just givign in and formula feeding. It felt almost like some people thought I was being ridiculous for caring about BF.ing It was even suggested once that I was putting my own desires to BF over the welfare of my baby (which was - obviously - not the case).

honeybeesknees · 20/07/2022 11:58

@Ontomatopea @ReadytoShip I’m sorry to hear you experienced a sneery attitude towards formula feeding. However, as someone who wanted to breastfeed and struggled due to tongue tie, I found all the ‘support’ I got was to tell me just to formula feed and be grateful my baby was being fed, which was not what I wanted to do (nothing to do with society, I had decided that I wanted to do it). If OP wants to breastfeed, she needs support, not just told to stop being so precious about breastfeeding. As I said, research shows that this lack of support and understanding can lead to a higher risk of postnatal depression.
This isn’t about which way of feeding is best, it’s about supporting a woman who would like to feed in a particular way, whatever that may be, and whatever her reasons may be.

Ontomatopea · 20/07/2022 11:50

ReadytoShip · 20/07/2022 11:43

I'm not saying it's wrong to breastfeed at all, I'm saying the insurmountable pressure to breastfeed on women nowadays is horrendous and needs to stop. Women should be free to feed their babies whichever way they choose/ can and no one should be shamed for that, unfortunately there is definitely a sneery attitude towards FF which only makes mother's who want to breastfeed and aren't able to feel even more like shit.

Yes I wholly agree with this. The pressure is immense. At a time when women can be very vulnerable.

erikbloodaxe · 20/07/2022 11:48

Breastfeeding doesn't give you membership for the Amazing Mother club.

It isn't the be all and end all that we are led to believe.

Your baby will thrive on formula, absolutely thrive.

All the pushing of breastfeeding can lead to how the Op is feeling when these early days should be a lovely time not a time of being made to feel terrible.

Please listen to your partner and your Mum Op.

Formula is perfect by itself.

ReadytoShip · 20/07/2022 11:43

honeybeesknees · 20/07/2022 10:41

@ReadytoShip there is research to show that for women who want to breastfeed, but can’t, they are at higher risk of postnatal depression. That’s not to say formula is bad, but it’s wrong to just dismiss their feelings and make them feel wrong to want to breastfeed. People should be supportive of feeding choices no matter what they are.

I'm not saying it's wrong to breastfeed at all, I'm saying the insurmountable pressure to breastfeed on women nowadays is horrendous and needs to stop. Women should be free to feed their babies whichever way they choose/ can and no one should be shamed for that, unfortunately there is definitely a sneery attitude towards FF which only makes mother's who want to breastfeed and aren't able to feel even more like shit.

RainbowForest · 20/07/2022 11:27

Try not to be so hard on yourself.
Could your baby have tongue tie?
Do you have any local breastfeeding support groups etc? Since my baby was born just over a week ago, I keep receiving calls from breastfeeding support asking if I need any help. There might be something like this near you?

SpotlessMind88 · 20/07/2022 11:27

You're expressing milk as well as formula feeding so your baby IS getting the benefits of breast milk. I'm still breastfeeding my 22 month old and it's actually really hard to wean her off the milk. She's obsessed and wants it all the time. Honestly at least you won't have to deal with this side of breastfeeding because it is a struggle. I can't see the way out and my body is still not my own and i don't know when it will be again lol
you're doing great!! keep doing what you're doing and don't be so hard on yourself 💐

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 11:27

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 11:23

I do understand some people can’t, I was one of those people that couldn’t exclusively breastfeed. By three months old I’d estimate that my baby was on 50/50 breast feeds and formula feeds.
I have said the alternative is fine also. The point I’m trying to make is that for the OP, they WANT to breastfeed, people telling them formula feeding is fine without any other advice isn’t helpful. She WANTS to breastfeed. If she gets support and then still finds it isn’t working out she can work out a plan to combi feed or move to formula feeding. I just think it’s incredibly important that if women want to breastfeed and can breastfeed that they are supported in doing so and not just told to switch to formula feeding because the baby will be fine. It’s about what Mum wants too.

The states I was told was it was roughly 1-2% physically can't BF. It will obviously be more for non-biological factors (bad support, stress, untreated tongue tie etc). So physcailyl not being able to BF is rare, but it doesn't mean it's otherwise always successful.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 11:25

SpiceRat · 20/07/2022 10:41

Can someone convince me I'm not entirely ruining my child's life by not being able to breastfeed?!
I’ll try to be kind because you’re obviously having a hard time but these kind of statements are so incredibly offensive and upsetting to mums who bottle fed. Our babies, children and even grown adults have in no way been disadvantaged because they were formula fed.

I couldn’t get a decent latch either. My nipples turned to one big scab. She never drank out of a bottle well and I couldn’t afford the extortionate price of a consultant to look at tongue tie, so we made the decision to formula feed. I, with all my
being, wanted to breastfeed, but at no point did I ever think she would be a failure because of that. I felt like a failure, but that was just the start of the Mum Guilt.

Now she’s eating food off the floor with the rest of the bottle / breastfed kids her age, and flying along with development.

Social standing, misogyny etc will all have more of an impact in her life than what she ate for 6 months.

Oh jeeze. OP is clearly being tongue in cheek with that. And is struggling. I'm sorry you had a tough start but as you yourself point out all is fine and it doesn't make any difference to your child. Don't make this about you or some FF vs BF argument.

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 11:23

Mally100 · 20/07/2022 09:08

If breastfeeding is what you want, you don’t need people telling you how unimportant it is - it may be to them but it doesn’t seem to be unimportant to you. Seek all of the advice and help you can, infant feeding support workers, la leche league, IBCLC, local peer tan groups.
If once you have sought support and help you decide to move on from breastfeeding then that is absolutely fine! I just hate to think of women swapping to formula because they didn’t get the right support when breastfeeding is what they really wanted to do.

I disagree completely. Do you get that some people just can't. They just can't. Can't And these people need to know it's ok. I had all the support, medication to stimulate my milk supply, I tried 2 of the best recommended lactation consultants, made every potion to increase supply, I was supplied with a hospital grade pump, tried other pumps too and it was just not meant to be. For me persistenting was alot to do with the breast is best that is shoved down our throats. When I sat down with my gynae and my paed who talked me through my reasons as to why I felt so strongly about breastfeeding I realised that I actually wasn't very well informed. I was encouraged to switch to formula and ds has thrived. It's very important for women to know the reasons for wanting to bf and to know the alternative is completely fine.

I do understand some people can’t, I was one of those people that couldn’t exclusively breastfeed. By three months old I’d estimate that my baby was on 50/50 breast feeds and formula feeds.
I have said the alternative is fine also. The point I’m trying to make is that for the OP, they WANT to breastfeed, people telling them formula feeding is fine without any other advice isn’t helpful. She WANTS to breastfeed. If she gets support and then still finds it isn’t working out she can work out a plan to combi feed or move to formula feeding. I just think it’s incredibly important that if women want to breastfeed and can breastfeed that they are supported in doing so and not just told to switch to formula feeding because the baby will be fine. It’s about what Mum wants too.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/07/2022 11:22

Bf is great, I BF both mine for over 2 years.

But no, it's not the be all and end all. Your baby will be absolutely fine on formula.

That said, if you really want to do it can you find properly help. The help you get of the NHS with BF is in my experience awful. Has your baby been checked for lip and tongue tie? Can you afford a BF consultant? DD was tough to get feeding, and I was encouraged by midwives to give her formula (in fact they told me I couldnt' leave hospital without it). They felt they had helped me try establish BFing after one midwife grabbed my boob without consent or warning and literally stuffed it into my crying baby's mouth. She was tongue tied which they (1) refused to check when I asked, even though I could SEE she couldnt' stick out her tongue to latch and then (2) denied had any impact on bfing. When we finally got it checked anc ut it got SO much better. I went to loads of BF clinics in my local area too (I think hosted by LLL).

Putonyourshoes · 20/07/2022 11:18

@Herejustforthisone
i don’t think it’s adding pressure to recognise that the OP really wants to breastfeed. I think informed decisions are important.
I said, I myself ended up combination feeding, but that was once I’d thoroughly explored every avenue with regards to breastfeeding support. I felt happy and confident in my decision to do this because I knew how well informed I was. It would be terrible for a mother who REALLY wanted to breastfeed, to move to formula and then later find out that there was other options (nipple shields, help with latching, profession advice etc). OP has said she has ordered nipple shields and is going to contact her MW for advice, which is fantastic. If the nipple shields don’t help, and even with professional support it still isn’t happening then the OP will be able to make a fully informed decision to stop and/or combi feed.