Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want dd to learn to drive?

213 replies

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:04

Dd is now old enough to learn to drive.

I mentioned getting her a provisional licence and a few lessons, putting her on the family car insurance etc, and she was not keen at all. I agree that learning to drive isn't everyone's idea of fun, but it's just something you do, isn't it?

I got the forms and have been reminding dd that we ought to get going with it. She is now pushing back more than I realised. She absolutely DOES NOT want to learn to drive. Her reasons are: Only old people think cars and driving are important. Her generation won't drive. She intends only ever to live in big cities anyway. Her aunty doesn't drive so not everyone has to drive.

I realise I definitely was unreasonable to push blithely onward with this and not acknowledge her genuine objections. No debate about that. I've apologised and we've had a good chat.

BUT... I still think you just have to learn to drive. Who knows what life has in store - being able to drive is non-negotiable. I do have friends and relatives who can't / won't drive and it's a pain. Genuine question: AIBU? I'm starting to doubt myself.

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 19/07/2022 23:01

It IS an essential life skill in some places, especially if you have a child or a health condition. You can’t expect someone else to do something for you that you can easily learn to do yourself.
she needs to learn.my DD wasn’t keen either (although she’s much younger), we’ve done some young driver sessions for her and she’s really confident now. Grandparents bought them for her.

CounsellorTroi · 19/07/2022 23:00

I wasn't in a desperate hurry to learn to drive at 17 and my mum didn't push it - she was a reluctant and nervous driver herself. I eventually passed aged 26.

OooErr · 19/07/2022 22:58

Also ‘public transport’ - if it was that great carers, nurses and similar would just use it instead of having to spend their own money, in their own vehicles driving up and down.

OooErr · 19/07/2022 22:57

daisypond · 19/07/2022 22:41

Idont understand why so many people dont want to be adults. Driving is a right of passage!

eh? Why on earth would you relate driving with adulthood? It’s unrelated. If anything, it’s childish - needing a car because you can’t manage public transport or walking or cycling. No one needs to be driven around (except by public transport).

Haven’t you been watching the news?
Rail strikes, tube strikes, any form
of ‘public transport’ is becoming increasingly unreliable.
You also can’t walk/cycle In all weathers and with heavy loads. Or transport kids!
Obviously people may not be able to afford lessons, or be unable to drive for whatever medical reason. But it’s default to assume that they can, and ‘I don’t want to’ isn’t a good enough reason.

Kite22 · 19/07/2022 22:56

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:13

Yes, I do a lot of dropping her at work / picking her up / dropping her at friends etc. There are buses but she's not very keen on using them because we're in the suburbs and it's often a 2-bus trip rather than 1. E.g. today she finishes work late morning and I can't pick her up so rather than bus or walk home (40 mins) she's going to wait at a friend's until I finish work and come and get her. Her brother (younger) gets buses or bikes or walks everywhere.

I think this is an issue.

If you pander to her like that, then she doesn't have much incentive, does she?

A 40 minute walk is hardly unreasonable for a teenager - it was my dcs' daily walk to school and from school at secondary. (Today's heat excepted - but you give the impression this is regular, the ferrying about).

Eunorition · 19/07/2022 22:55

I live in a big city and figured I'd learn when I wanted to. But I've never wanted to. I never get lifts from anyone. I take trams, trains, taxis, planes, and buses. Or walk, obviously. Saved a fortune in car costs. I've never yet found a place I wanted to go that I needed a car for.

Some rural relatives of mine think it's weird but they live in a place with literally no transport. They don't really understand that I can get on a vehicle to anywhere.

Sparklingbrook · 19/07/2022 22:46

Unfortunately not everyone lives somewhere that public transport is frequent or reliable. Or they do at the moment but that might not always be the case. It's not childish to need to drive because of your circumstances.

QuebecBagnet · 19/07/2022 22:45

I agree stop the lifts. She can use the bus and will soon realise how inconvenient not being able to drive is.

daisypond · 19/07/2022 22:41

Idont understand why so many people dont want to be adults. Driving is a right of passage!

eh? Why on earth would you relate driving with adulthood? It’s unrelated. If anything, it’s childish - needing a car because you can’t manage public transport or walking or cycling. No one needs to be driven around (except by public transport).

pantherpie · 19/07/2022 22:39

Can't she get a bike or a moped?

If it's a 40 minute walk that's like a 15 minute cycle.

1nsertusername · 19/07/2022 22:35

I'm going to throw this in but I think all women should be able to drive. The independence and freedom it gives you throughout your life gives you options that you dont know you may need.

I would feel incredibly trapped not being able to drive or have to rely on others or public transport.

I passed my test as soon as I could at 17. It changed my life and signifies and real step into adulthood.

I've lived all over from off grid to inner cities,and have driven everyday or not much for weeks on end.

I do see why a 17 years may think they dont need to learn to drive,most likely driverless cars will be a thing in the future,but before its legal and fully possible who do they expect to be driving them around?

I would always push for a 17 years to learn to drive,just because it opens up doors rather than closes them. What's the harm in learning to drive?

I would stop giving lifts. You have been incredibly generous by offering the support and finances to learn to drive. She has turned it down. Now she has to live with that choice.

I dont understand why so many people dont want to be adults. Driving is a right of passage!

daisypond · 19/07/2022 22:34

I’m baffled why you’re giving your daughter and your friends lifts if you so resent it, XelaM. I don’t know anyone who has a car in London. Everyone I know just uses public transport - even with DC. No one gives anyone lifts, because no one has a car.

Whatwouldscullydo · 19/07/2022 22:33

XelaM · 19/07/2022 22:27

It's an absolutely essential life skill and I have always lives in big cities. I in London now and I drive A LOT!! People who don't drive and need constant lifts are a total pain. I want my daughter to learn to drive the day she turns of age! I keep telling her, as I'm absolutely sick of giving her and her friends constant lifts.

Then don't give them..do they really require lifts or do you just do that thing where people who drive cant fathom we might have a journey plan already worked out , practically force a lift on you saying how its no trouble you are going anyway and I'm not having you get on 2 buses when I'm.right here. Then just whinge about it?

XelaM · 19/07/2022 22:27

always lived*

XelaM · 19/07/2022 22:27

It's an absolutely essential life skill and I have always lives in big cities. I in London now and I drive A LOT!! People who don't drive and need constant lifts are a total pain. I want my daughter to learn to drive the day she turns of age! I keep telling her, as I'm absolutely sick of giving her and her friends constant lifts.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 22:19

So she doesn't think she needs to drive, but she relies on you driving to get her...everywhere?

Stop the lifts. If she doesn't want to drive, that's fine, she can walk or catch the bus instead can't she 🤷🏻‍♀️

Paprikapommes · 19/07/2022 22:13

I was the same, begrudgingly made to take lessons with a family friend and failed twice. Total waste of my parents money. Moved to London shortly after and didn't try for years. I ended up learning at 25 and purely because it was needed for my CV and helped my job prospects. I regretted not doing it earlier once I had to pay for it! But the driving instructor I got to choose was so much better suited for me.

It's sensible to outline good reasons why, but I honestly wouldn't force it.

Thatswhyimacat · 19/07/2022 22:01

YANBU to give reasons why learning to drive can be a good idea and why she can't have it both ways and expect a mum taxi service.

YABU saying it's non-negotiable. I passed my driving test at 18, I'm now 34 and I haven't driven a car since. Never needed to and no, I don't constantly scab lifts off people. She's also right that fewer people driving is a good thing.

Kite22 · 19/07/2022 21:51

I haven't voted as I think it isn't your decision.
there's no "We" about her not being able to afford it later - that is her choice.
She needs to want it for herself, so I think YWBU to try to demand she learns to drive.

Against that, I totally agree it is a life skill and I can't understand people not being interested. When I look back over the 40+ years since I passed my test, I would have missed out on so much if I couldn't drive - and I live in a big City with plenty of public transport.

She is wrong in saying only old people drive. It is very difficult to get a test or even driving lessons due mainly to 'her generation' getting themselves a qualification, that, once you have it you have it for life (well, almost).

bakewellbride · 19/07/2022 21:45

Just leave the subject alone - it's not like it's a now or never thing. I learned in my mid-twenties (which is still ages away for your daughter as I believe she's 17 from reading your op) and everything has worked out fine.

SweetPetrichor · 19/07/2022 21:42

I didn’t want to learn when I was 17 but my parents basically said ‘this is a life skill, you must learn.’ They paid for my lessons and put me on their car insurance. Once I started driving I never looked back, I’m glad they forced me!

I would stop ferrying her around and let her catch the bus(es) since she’s adamant she can manage on public transport alone. It’s very easy to say “I don’t need to learn” when mum is your taxi!

safetylastday · 19/07/2022 21:42

I wouldn’t push it but no more lifts

if she doesn’t feel she needs to drive to be self sufficient let her crack on

munchbunch12 · 19/07/2022 21:42

InChocolateWeTrust · 19/07/2022 21:15

Stop driving her anywhere. If she really doesnt want to drive that's fine but she's old enough to get where she needs to go under her own steam, whether by learning to drive or by using public transport.

I agree with this. If she doesn't want to drive, that's fine, but she needs to realise that it's unacceptable to spend her life inconveniencing others. She can make her own way.

FlissyPaps · 19/07/2022 21:42

OP, do you want her to learn to drive for her own sake or for your sake?

Her sake being independence, more job opportunities and all the rest of it that comes with driving.

Your sake being: you are fed up of chauffeuring her around when she’s clearly old enough to use and navigate public transport. & I don’t blame you if you feel that way! It puts a lot of pressure on you, takes time up out of your day. Plus, fuel is so expensive nowadays.

However, if she agrees to start using public transport then don’t keep pushing her with the driving lessons. She’ll decide in her own time.

RaininSummer · 19/07/2022 21:36

I see it as a life skill but the usefulness does depend where you live. However even city dwellers like to go places and public transport isn't always the best plan. Also it's a lot easier to ferry children and shopping to different destinations with a car and can massively limit job options. Still she may change her mind when older and sees a reason in her life to drive.