Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want dd to learn to drive?

213 replies

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:04

Dd is now old enough to learn to drive.

I mentioned getting her a provisional licence and a few lessons, putting her on the family car insurance etc, and she was not keen at all. I agree that learning to drive isn't everyone's idea of fun, but it's just something you do, isn't it?

I got the forms and have been reminding dd that we ought to get going with it. She is now pushing back more than I realised. She absolutely DOES NOT want to learn to drive. Her reasons are: Only old people think cars and driving are important. Her generation won't drive. She intends only ever to live in big cities anyway. Her aunty doesn't drive so not everyone has to drive.

I realise I definitely was unreasonable to push blithely onward with this and not acknowledge her genuine objections. No debate about that. I've apologised and we've had a good chat.

BUT... I still think you just have to learn to drive. Who knows what life has in store - being able to drive is non-negotiable. I do have friends and relatives who can't / won't drive and it's a pain. Genuine question: AIBU? I'm starting to doubt myself.

OP posts:
XelaM · 19/07/2022 23:53

Aquamarine1029 · 19/07/2022 23:26

Both of my children had their license at 17. I consider driving an essential life skill, no matter where you live.

This.

Adults who don't drive have a screw loose in my book (unless it's for medical reasons).

Whatwouldscullydo · 19/07/2022 23:52

But presumably you agreed to that? You could absolutely say no. If you agreed to it then tbh you cant whinge about it can you. You totally could send her on the bus

treesandweeds · 19/07/2022 23:51

Is it not perfectly obvious that of course she doesn't want to learn when she's got her own personal chauffeur! Why has it not occurred to you that the two things are related!

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 23:51

You're all right about not being able to force someone to do something if they're determined not to. But we have a pretty good relationship and I think she'll be open to seeing my point of view that she can't have it both ways (now I've managed to articulate my thoughts in this thread!) She's a good kid and conscientious about doing the right thing / planning ahead usually. It's quite out of character for her to be so set against something which is why it caught me by surprise I think.

OP posts:
XelaM · 19/07/2022 23:50

Whatwouldscullydo · 19/07/2022 22:33

Then don't give them..do they really require lifts or do you just do that thing where people who drive cant fathom we might have a journey plan already worked out , practically force a lift on you saying how its no trouble you are going anyway and I'm not having you get on 2 buses when I'm.right here. Then just whinge about it?

No. Unfortunately, she requires lifts al the time and it's not just her, but her friends as well! We have a pony on a livery yard which is about 30mins drive (without traffic) or 2 bus rides (about an hour) away but she ALWAYS wants a lift there and back. Sometimes I have to go back and forth between our house and the yard several times a day (six times back and forth was a recent low point). She rides every day. And her friends often require drop offs or pick ups that my daughter always agrees I will do (without first asking me!!)

Anyway, I'm counting the days until she is old enough to drive and I will gift her my car, so she can drive herself and her mates wherever she wants.

Whatwouldscullydo · 19/07/2022 23:49

Between being young and being new and of course depending on what the car she will be driving is, insurance cost could make it a costly scenario. Given under 25s get paid less , its worth working out of the costs of lifts and/or public transport is actually cheaper. Even if she gets her own car, depending on the age running it once the car reaches the " work costs more than you'd ever get for it stage" could make working almost pointless.

Plus not being funny but some work places , once they catch wind you drive , we'll you'd be the first on thr list to call when someone's sick or they want someone in at short notice. And unless it's decent length of a shift then frankly between parking, and fuel costs the first 1 hour or so is basically working for free.

My monthly bus ticket for me and a child used to come to 125 pounds. I could get on the bus several times a day fir that. It certainly costs me more than 125 a month in petrol.

justasking111 · 19/07/2022 23:40

DS started driving at 17 did theory test wasn't keen. Went to university didn't need a car, covid hit his theory ran out resat still not keen. He's now realised at 21 university behind him he needs to drive when he's home rural Wales. He can walk bus if he gets a job in a city.

Leave her be it's taken four years for the penny to drop with DS he'll never enjoy driving I suspect

OooErr · 19/07/2022 23:32

Whatwouldscullydo · 19/07/2022 23:18

That's all very well but isn't it the younger drivers more at risk of causing accidents? Driving is dangerous and scary and brains aren't fully developed until our 20s. I think placing the responsibility of driving onto someone still considered a minor as under 18 is a risk factor worth considering.

I'm sure I read over the years about potential plans or possible plans of restricted licenses fir safety reasons. Fir example not taking passengers under a certain age.

@Whatwouldscullydo most new drivers are at higher risk of accidents. Because they are also likely to be young age is a confounding factor.
Countries which have restrictions do so based on experience and not age IIRC

myuterusistryingtokillme · 19/07/2022 23:28

I guess it is fine if she doesn't want to learn to drive, as long as she doesn't expect you to drop everything and give her lifts when she wants one!

She seems to not be keen on anything that requires any effort on her part....

Aquamarine1029 · 19/07/2022 23:26

Both of my children had their license at 17. I consider driving an essential life skill, no matter where you live.

Aquamarine1029 · 19/07/2022 23:19

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:13

Yes, I do a lot of dropping her at work / picking her up / dropping her at friends etc. There are buses but she's not very keen on using them because we're in the suburbs and it's often a 2-bus trip rather than 1. E.g. today she finishes work late morning and I can't pick her up so rather than bus or walk home (40 mins) she's going to wait at a friend's until I finish work and come and get her. Her brother (younger) gets buses or bikes or walks everywhere.

This nonsense needs to stop, clearly. If she refuses to drive, that doesn't mean you become her defacto taxi. She had best become very familiar with public transport. Stop enabling her laziness.

Whatwouldscullydo · 19/07/2022 23:18

1nsertusername · 19/07/2022 23:07

@daisypond
Because driving gives you independence and huge responsibility,far more than public transport or walking!

It's one of the only true adult responsibility anyone can have beyond having children. You have your life and passages, and those around you in your hands. If you make a mistake people could die. Where else does this level of responsibility exist?

Learning to drive gives a 17 years a new perspective of life,one than non drives will never have.

I would always encourage a 17 years old to do this,same as I would encourage 18 year olds to take a gap year.

In the modern world we dont have coming of age ceremonies,we dont have anything that distinguishes us as we move from childhood to adulthood. I believe that passing your driving test is one of the few things that is comparable.

That's all very well but isn't it the younger drivers more at risk of causing accidents? Driving is dangerous and scary and brains aren't fully developed until our 20s. I think placing the responsibility of driving onto someone still considered a minor as under 18 is a risk factor worth considering.

I'm sure I read over the years about potential plans or possible plans of restricted licenses fir safety reasons. Fir example not taking passengers under a certain age.

bellac11 · 19/07/2022 23:17

We learnt in middle age only because we were leaving London, my mum never drove either, big users of public transport, never even used cabs, night buses home from central London, no tubes in my area in those days

If we had stayed I wouldnt have bothered.

Sparklingbrook · 19/07/2022 23:14

daisypond · 19/07/2022 23:01

No, but it’s not a mark of adulthood either. Being able to drive is not an indication of adulthood. It’s definitely not a rite of passage, as someone said. It’s a marker of wealth perhaps.

It's just something that's very useful to have-IMO. Even if just in your back pocket for future use. It is a rite of passage around here out of necessity. I don't think it is a marker of wealth either. Public transport and taxis are by no means cheap.

ThinWomansBrain · 19/07/2022 23:14

& throw in a tinkly MN laugh for good measure😂

pinkstripeycat · 19/07/2022 23:13

Saying her generation won’t want to drive is definitely not true.
I teach only 17/18 yr olds as I have a manual car and that’s what they prefer and I have a 6 month waiting list!
My DS is almost 17 and he definitely wants me to teach him to drive.
Don’t push her tho. It’s like a anything, some want to do it and some don’t. She’ll manage the same as all those thousands of people who don’t drive.

ThinWomansBrain · 19/07/2022 23:13

If she ever wants/expects a lift anywhers, the answer is "cars are for old people, sorry."

PMAmostofthetime · 19/07/2022 23:09

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:13

Yes, I do a lot of dropping her at work / picking her up / dropping her at friends etc. There are buses but she's not very keen on using them because we're in the suburbs and it's often a 2-bus trip rather than 1. E.g. today she finishes work late morning and I can't pick her up so rather than bus or walk home (40 mins) she's going to wait at a friend's until I finish work and come and get her. Her brother (younger) gets buses or bikes or walks everywhere.

This is why I had no interest I was always taken and picked up. Honestly if my family wasn't so accommodating I would have nee interested in learning earlier.

1nsertusername · 19/07/2022 23:07

@daisypond
Because driving gives you independence and huge responsibility,far more than public transport or walking!

It's one of the only true adult responsibility anyone can have beyond having children. You have your life and passages, and those around you in your hands. If you make a mistake people could die. Where else does this level of responsibility exist?

Learning to drive gives a 17 years a new perspective of life,one than non drives will never have.

I would always encourage a 17 years old to do this,same as I would encourage 18 year olds to take a gap year.

In the modern world we dont have coming of age ceremonies,we dont have anything that distinguishes us as we move from childhood to adulthood. I believe that passing your driving test is one of the few things that is comparable.

PMAmostofthetime · 19/07/2022 23:07

I didn't pass my test until I was in my late 20's and my job depended on it. My parents booked and paid for lessons and bought me at 17 but I had no interest and didn't stick at it. It was a waste of money.

Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 19/07/2022 23:05

I think learning to drive is a life skill and much easier to do when you are 17/18. However, if your DD doesn't want to learn to drive then fine but I wouldn't be ferrying her and her friends around as and when she wants. Perhaps having to use public transport and not having Mum as a taxi service might convince your DD.

My teenager was desperate to drive and gain more independence.

ilovesooty · 19/07/2022 23:04

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:13

Yes, I do a lot of dropping her at work / picking her up / dropping her at friends etc. There are buses but she's not very keen on using them because we're in the suburbs and it's often a 2-bus trip rather than 1. E.g. today she finishes work late morning and I can't pick her up so rather than bus or walk home (40 mins) she's going to wait at a friend's until I finish work and come and get her. Her brother (younger) gets buses or bikes or walks everywhere.

In that case she needs to start getting herself about like her brother does.

Christinatheastonishing · 19/07/2022 23:04

I'm a bit on the fence here.

I think it's a great life skill to have and people don't necessarily see that unless they've lived both ways (as an adult). I'd be rich if I had a pound for every poster on here who's in some shitty situation made worse by 'but I/we don't drive'.

But I voted YABU because she has to come to that realisation herself, and she might not until life without a licence becomes trickier.

CounsellorTroi · 19/07/2022 23:02

That said she didn't ferry me around either before I passed my test, I was happy to use public transport.

daisypond · 19/07/2022 23:01

Sparklingbrook · 19/07/2022 22:46

Unfortunately not everyone lives somewhere that public transport is frequent or reliable. Or they do at the moment but that might not always be the case. It's not childish to need to drive because of your circumstances.

No, but it’s not a mark of adulthood either. Being able to drive is not an indication of adulthood. It’s definitely not a rite of passage, as someone said. It’s a marker of wealth perhaps.