Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want dd to learn to drive?

213 replies

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:04

Dd is now old enough to learn to drive.

I mentioned getting her a provisional licence and a few lessons, putting her on the family car insurance etc, and she was not keen at all. I agree that learning to drive isn't everyone's idea of fun, but it's just something you do, isn't it?

I got the forms and have been reminding dd that we ought to get going with it. She is now pushing back more than I realised. She absolutely DOES NOT want to learn to drive. Her reasons are: Only old people think cars and driving are important. Her generation won't drive. She intends only ever to live in big cities anyway. Her aunty doesn't drive so not everyone has to drive.

I realise I definitely was unreasonable to push blithely onward with this and not acknowledge her genuine objections. No debate about that. I've apologised and we've had a good chat.

BUT... I still think you just have to learn to drive. Who knows what life has in store - being able to drive is non-negotiable. I do have friends and relatives who can't / won't drive and it's a pain. Genuine question: AIBU? I'm starting to doubt myself.

OP posts:
Kite22 · 20/07/2022 17:51

If it takes two buses to get anywhere because she lives in the arse end of nowhere, that's on you. She didn't choose to live in the countryside, you did. I always find it incredible how many parents on here complain about ferrying their kids around when they're the ones who chose to make their kids live in an inaccessible location.

You don't have to live 'in the arse end of nowhere' to need to get 2 buses to get to places. I live in a big City but you can still need to change buses (or trains, or trams) to get to lots of places I, or my dc need to get to. Sometimes more than 2. You do realise everywhere you need to go isn't on one single arterial route through the City, don't you ?
Plus, of course we do need to go to places that aren't in the City - and may indeed be in the arse end of nowhere sometimes. Plus, there aren't that many trains and buses when you need to be somewhere on a Sunday morning, for examples.

@XSnoe - that really is an unhealthy way to go through life. You should try to get some help for your anxiety (I know that is easier to say than to do given the paucity of mental health provision). You really need to learn to look dispassionately at risk assessing situations.

XSnoe · 20/07/2022 17:00

If my daughter dies from cancer caused by microplastics/pollution, I won't be blaming myself in the way I would be if I were in a car-crash either.

XSnoe · 20/07/2022 16:57

With all the pollution and crap in our food/drink like microplastics you’re more like to get cancer and die from that instead of a car crash…

I'd rather die from that than a car-crash. At least I have time to prepare. Also, I'm not going to kill anyone else that way.

toooldtocarewhoknows · 20/07/2022 14:21

My young adult children are the same. It's seems to not be seen as the big milestone that it was in my day.

Jolinar · 20/07/2022 14:16

Don't push, but stop enabling her. It's her choice not to drive, but she can no longer rely on lifts from you. Only give them if they're convenient for you.

girlfriend44 · 20/07/2022 13:45

1nsertusername · 19/07/2022 22:35

I'm going to throw this in but I think all women should be able to drive. The independence and freedom it gives you throughout your life gives you options that you dont know you may need.

I would feel incredibly trapped not being able to drive or have to rely on others or public transport.

I passed my test as soon as I could at 17. It changed my life and signifies and real step into adulthood.

I've lived all over from off grid to inner cities,and have driven everyday or not much for weeks on end.

I do see why a 17 years may think they dont need to learn to drive,most likely driverless cars will be a thing in the future,but before its legal and fully possible who do they expect to be driving them around?

I would always push for a 17 years to learn to drive,just because it opens up doors rather than closes them. What's the harm in learning to drive?

I would stop giving lifts. You have been incredibly generous by offering the support and finances to learn to drive. She has turned it down. Now she has to live with that choice.

I dont understand why so many people dont want to be adults. Driving is a right of passage!

I passed my test as soon as I could at 17. It changed my life and signifies and real step into adulthood.

Just because you dont drive dosent mean you havent stepped in adulthood. Theres more to being an adult that driving.

girlfriend44 · 20/07/2022 13:43

It is a great life skill, she would find it useful if she had a family, and also its easier for work alot require car drivers. I guess you cant make anyone though.

Frazzledmummy123 · 20/07/2022 13:31

I don't think you are unreasonable to suggest to your daughter that she drives as it is an option for her and would give her some freedom.

However, I think you are being unreasonable to be trying to persuade her into it if she is adament she doesn't want to at the moment. If she plans to build her life around not needing a car to get around then I'd leave her be. The 'it is just something you do' belief isn't necessarily true as driving isn't for everyone and why should someone do it solely because it is expected. Perhaps one day she will choose to drive when she is older, but don't force her to do it. That said, I wouldn't be giving her lifts everywhere either as if she chooses to not drive then she has to accept living as a non driver.

My parents pressured me into driving when I was younger (I didn't want to, but did it for the quiet life) and I passed my test only to never drive as I truly hated it. I accepted the limitations l, lived in a city next to transport and never cadge lifts off anyone as it is my choice to not drive.

My parents are now older and living in the middle of nowehere having made no sensible arrangements and are trying to pressure and guilt trip me into driving again. The truth is, I don't feel safe behind the wheel and would be a menace on the road, yet I am being made to feel abnormal because of how I feel about driving because of the beliefs held by many that 'it is something that you do' and a 'basic life skill'. Please don't make your daughter feel like that as while it is an option available to her that will benefit her in some ways, it isn't the be all and end all if she doesn't. Let her experience life without getting lifts everywhere and then let her decide. If she still chooses to not drive, respect her decision

KittyEmK · 20/07/2022 13:24

I totally see where you're coming from, there's nothing more annoying than being burdened with doing all the driving because someone didn't bother to learn. I imagine if you stop giving her lifts she will soon change her mind though. Do you think she might be scared?

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 20/07/2022 13:11

I'm also wondering if she's actually just scared of it? My parents didn't want me to learn to drive (abusive dad who liked to control me) but it's taken me ages to think about learning as am adult anyway, not just because of the climate and lots of nearby buses, but also because I'd been in a car crash as a child and could hardly bear even to be a passenger I was so anxious. I'm guessing you'd have mentioned if she'd been in a big accident but might she actually just be worried about being in control of a vehicle?

Leafsontheline · 20/07/2022 13:00

I reluctantly learnt at 25, because I wouldn’t qualify for car allowance if I didn’t have my license. Passed, and hardly driven since. I live in central London, always worked where there was no parking options anyway so travelled by public transport, and now WFH permanently. But I am lucky, public transport options are great where I live, and I can afford cabs/Ubers whenever needed. I also know i have my license if I ever need it ( after some refresher lessons!)

my friend has never learnt, she now has had to seriously compromise on her ideal job. She was offered her dream role, but then realised there were no public transport options to get there and the location just wasn’t suitable for cycling. She had to turn the job down. She really regrets not learning and is now beginning the process at 40.

I would strongly recommend learning, even if you have no intention of driving straight away as you just don’t know when not having a license will be an issue, and it may take months to pass once you decide you need it.

Cyclemarine · 20/07/2022 13:00

SavoirFlair · 20/07/2022 06:23

What’s fascinating is the vehemence and urgency of the posts from drivers who claim that learning driving is

• A central rite of passage for teenagers
• You’re not a true adult without the skill
• You must have a “screw loose” as an adult if you didn’t learn to drive as a teenager
• It’s an essential life skill
• People will inevitably have to “ferry you around” if you don’t have a car

It’s just utterly depressing in its parochial approach. The kind of level of thinking that means on my friend’s Victorian houses residential street in London we have two households with nine cars, because both DCs (who are in their 20s but “need” cars) are driving. In London.

As I said before, I didn’t drive till much later in life. My parents couldn’t afford driving lessons for me. My summer jobs as a teenager funded university. I then got to experience Singapore, Hong Kong, New York, set up a good career for myself.

should I have stayed in Dorset as a child, forgone uni and spent the money instead on driving lessons aged 18 because without them, I must “have a screw loose” as an adult?!

To the utterly dull folk going on about everyone should help their kids to drive? check your privilege. To those claiming all public transport is shit? Try getting out of the backwater where you live.

We’re not all the same, but you’d be forgiven for thinking otherwise the way half this thread goes on about the existential threat of having to “ferry” (why always ferrying?!) people around

I agree, very strange attitudes being exhibited here. Some people chose to spend the money and time on things that were more important to them, traveling, or a house deposit or just surviving if they had limited means.

However, irrespective of why someone chose not to drive at 17 or 30 or 50 or at all, it does not mean they are unhinged or not a proper adult.

LaJoconde · 20/07/2022 12:57

@Flamingoose have you mentioned that You don’t have to drive everyday and become a slave to traffic just because you know how to drive. FWIW I got rid of my car 20 years ago, and rent one by the hour if I need one.

But whether you own a car or not, knowing how to drive is a life skill, like doing your taxes, or changing a plug.
It can come in very handy, and may save her life one day.

in the meantime, I’d stop the taxi service- if she’s happy with public transport that’s cool, but there may come a time when she’s not, and what then?
It might be a bit of a hurdle to learn as an older person footing her own insurance bill. Maybe you need to reframe how you’re selling the lessons?

I agree with her in principle, increasingly, individual and private cars are part of the climate, NOx pollution problem, and unnecessary in cities, or where people live and work locally/ wfh - in practice, driving a car/ truck / bike is a skill, like swimming that may save someone’s life.

i couldn’t hire a car in the scheme if I didn’t have a full clean drivers license, and some jobs stipulate that too. it’s a little shortsighted to not want lessons and a license. maybe remind her that it doesn’t mean you have to drive in future- it keeps your options open to have a valid license.

gunnersgold · 20/07/2022 12:51

I made dd , she didn't want to either and it took over a year and a few meltdowns .. now she loves it ! So much independence!

Cyclemarine · 20/07/2022 12:51

daisypond · 19/07/2022 22:41

Idont understand why so many people dont want to be adults. Driving is a right of passage!

eh? Why on earth would you relate driving with adulthood? It’s unrelated. If anything, it’s childish - needing a car because you can’t manage public transport or walking or cycling. No one needs to be driven around (except by public transport).

I agree, you can be a mature responsible adult and not drive and you can be an immature adult driver hence the amount of reckless and selfish driving we see. Not understanding those calling it an essential life skill, it's good to have yes but it's definitely not essential.

Sparklingbrook · 20/07/2022 12:49

People are just lazy and refuse to consider life without driving. Their car goes in for MOT and the world ends and they can't possibly do anything on that day.

That’s madness. You just get a courtesy car or someone picks you up from the garage. The place I go to can do while you wait or give you a lift to work. 🤷‍♀️

wibblywobblybits · 20/07/2022 12:48

So she doesn't want to learn to drive, but she doesn't want to get buses? So what she wants then is to be ferried around.

Abso bloody lutely not.

I am in agreement with you, in my very humble personal opinion, driving is an essential life skill - even if you live inner city. Even inner city people drive to the coast, go on holiday etc. Living life unable to drive in incredibly inconvenient and arguably selfish, expecting others to do the donkey work. Not in this house. When the kids turn 17 they learn to drive or they get the bus. Those are the two options.

Confusion101 · 20/07/2022 12:45

LetsPlayShadowlands · 20/07/2022 12:40

I don't drive. I work full time. I take my child to school. I go on holidays. I do the shopping. I go on days out.

People are just lazy and refuse to consider life without driving. Their car goes in for MOT and the world ends and they can't possibly do anything on that day.

People are just lazy..... Or live in an area with poor public transport and don't want to rely on others. As I said previously, if I was to rely solely on myself and public transport, a 40 minute car journey from the town I live in to work would take me 5 and a half hours and 3 different buses. My child would not be able to go to the school I want them to as no transport from where I live to the school and too far to walk / cycle plus roads are dangerous... If I was to up and move to an area with better public transport options, it would be a city, away from any family and friends, and cost of living would be far more. Public transport is not widely available in every area of every country. It is nothing to do with laziness but thanks for that lovely generalisation!

Also if DD wants to travel it is a very useful skill to have. I know for example people who went to Australia without a licence and then applied for it in Oz where the test was a lot harder!

LetsPlayShadowlands · 20/07/2022 12:40

I don't drive. I work full time. I take my child to school. I go on holidays. I do the shopping. I go on days out.

People are just lazy and refuse to consider life without driving. Their car goes in for MOT and the world ends and they can't possibly do anything on that day.

alnawire · 20/07/2022 12:39

I think driving is a useful (not mandatory) life skill.

I have been thinking about this thread a lot and another really useful life skill is being able to say no. Nobody taught me that was ok. As a result I have never been very good at it. If only my parents had respected my decisions and choices (where reasonable) when I was younger. Every situation is a chance to demonstrate behaviour you want your offspring to learn. Saying 'I do not want to do this' should be met with 'ok' and no more.

The secondary issue of how she gets places is another life lesson, but primarily here I think listening is a million times more important.

beadsunlimited · 20/07/2022 12:37

My child wasn't ready at 17 to learn. So no pressure from me, they will do it when they are ready. They moved out many years ago now and I do miss those chats on the late night Mumcab rides!

Finger crossed your DD will do it as soon as she feels ready.

SweatyAndGrumpy · 20/07/2022 12:32

I think driving is a useful (not mandatory) life skill.

But I also think being able to move around and navigate public transport is a useful skill. So, whilst she's not learning to drive, she will be learning how to use different public transport modes - so there's that Smile

I learned to drive at 18 but couldn't afford a car and wasn't allowed to drive the family car (plus moved away to uni). I didn't really start driving until I was about 27. The years inbetween were me just figuring out how to get a bus, train, national express, taxi (often a combination of all 4) to take me from A to B. It means I have been relatively happy to do the same in different countries, when needed and so was a useful foundation skill, imo.

BogRollBOGOF · 20/07/2022 12:29

Society is car dependent, so being a non-driver involves organising your life around that affecting where you live, occupation and social life.

From 17-21 I managed fine. DM's house was just off the town centre on a through route with most things I needed accessible on foot, by the bus stop 30m away, or station 10 mins away. Lifts tended to be from friends naturally passing by rather than DM. At uni, it was all accessible by foot/ bus/ train too. I passed my test at 22 and that opened up a lot more options for my post-graduate placements and career. At 17, that need wasn't immediate and I enjoyed the independence of getting myself around with public transport.

OP's DD can't have it both ways. She can't have noble ideals about not driving on the back of getting the mum-taxi to do double the distance. The mum-taxi needs to be withdrawn so she understands the choice she's making.

CounsellorTroi · 20/07/2022 12:19

I would not have met my DH of 32 years if I hadn't learned to drive. I wanted to join a choir and the rehearsal venue was awkward to get to on public transport and especially so to get home after 9pm which was when rehearsals ended.

Blizzardbeach · 20/07/2022 12:18

Flamingoose · 19/07/2022 21:13

Yes, I do a lot of dropping her at work / picking her up / dropping her at friends etc. There are buses but she's not very keen on using them because we're in the suburbs and it's often a 2-bus trip rather than 1. E.g. today she finishes work late morning and I can't pick her up so rather than bus or walk home (40 mins) she's going to wait at a friend's until I finish work and come and get her. Her brother (younger) gets buses or bikes or walks everywhere.

This alone is why she needs to learn to drive.
She doesn't want to use public transport, and sees that a car is more convenient, however that convenience is coming directly for your efforts and time.
Everyone is facilitating her at the moment.
When you cannot facilitate, and what if she doesn't have the option of waiting for you?
That means taxis or not doing what she wants to do.