Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? Cleaner and her child

162 replies

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 19:28

I have a cleaner because I am elderly and physically disabled. Current one is about 30 with a child aged four. She answered my advert for someone to clean for 4 hours once a fortnight. She told me she has a 4 year old but his dad has him all day every Friday, so we agreed she would work for me on that day.

She's only worked for me four times. One day she came in for an additional "one-hour special clean" at my request. She asked if it was OK to bring her four year old. I said yes as I did not want to seem unreasonable and she was doing me a favour.

However, I was not happy on three counts. Firstly found it distracting as I was trying to study something academic and I could hear them talking to each other during most of the hour and kept losing my concentration.

Secondly I did not realise how much time she would spend not cleaning but talking to him, sorting him out, explaining something to him, getting him something to amuse him, picking something up for him, telling him not to touch this or that, introducing him to my cat, etc, etc, during all of which of course she was not doing any cleaning.

She also took him to my loo (for a poo, she said) which took her about 5 minutes. I guess altogether seeing to him took up about 1/4 of the time she was here - say 15 minutes of the hour. However, when her hour was up she got her bag and her son and came to me for the full hour's money. After she left, I noticed she had not done all of the tasks we agreed on. I felt a bit irritated that I had paid her an hour for 45 minutes work but I said nothing.

Now she is asking if she can bring him for the whole 4-hour sessions. I want to say absolutely not as I feel she could easily spend 1 hour of it focussed on him and only 3 hrs cleaning and she won't get it all done and she might miss things because she's distracted by having to keep an eye on him, but she'll expect the whole 4 hours pay.

Am I being unreasonable, being mean to a poor single mum?

or

Am I NOT being unreasonable, as she taking the piss expecting me to pay her to look after her own kid?

OP posts:
TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 23:01

Kite22 · 19/07/2022 22:43

@TwentyOneTwentyTwo I think you are obsessing a bit about the £2.50.
The difference of opinion isn't really about that one off - the OP was explaining how, when the cleaner had her child there, there were two issues.


  1. Was the OP found the noise distracting when she was trying to work. I get that - I don't mind 'white noise' and I quite like music when I am working, but can't listen to the radio because voices are distracting.

  2. The Op spent at least 25% of the time not doing the work.

Now, on the one off / hour's clean, yes, that was £3.12 equivalent, or 15mins but the cleaner has now asked if she can bring the child for her 4 hours clean. Even not allowing for the fact the child would be likely to be much more bored and need much more entertaining over a longer period, it means the OP would be paying her 4 hours worth of wages for 3 hours work. Why do you think she should do that ?

I understood the OP, I just thought her being annoyed she'd accidentally let a 'poor single mum' get away with an extra £2.50 sounded scroogey.

FWIW yanbu to not have the son during the regular cleaning but that's already well established.

justasking111 · 19/07/2022 22:57

Totally missing the point but friend of mine share a cleaner who is excellent but she is £18 per hour which made me blink in surprise

puddingandsun · 19/07/2022 22:54

YANBUFOMO · 19/07/2022 20:17

I think you’re confusing two things here.

YANBU to refuse the regular 4hr clean that was agreed when she would have childcare. I had a haircut with toddler in attendance and my usual 5* hairdresser gave me the worst haircut I have ever had in my life. That’s always been the agreement.

YABU to clock watch and count the minutes her child was doing a poo the one time you pre-agreed she should clean for you. That was the agreement and you accepted the compromise prior to the clean.

YANBU to not accept that compromise again. No need for tit for tat, or holding minutes and seconds of her attending to her son as reason not to - just that’s not the agreement and I can’t accommodate a cleaner that brings children along.

Agreed. And just add, her travelling all the way and back only for one hours work i.e. £12.50 is not great. She was doing you a favour. Also, you can do very little in one hour cleaning wise if doing a good job, so she prob wouldn't have been finished child or not.

But if you don't agree for this to carry on definitely tell her.

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 22:45

@Kite22

"The Op spent at least 25% of the time not doing the work."

You mean the cleaner.

:-)

OP posts:
Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 22:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Kite22 · 19/07/2022 22:43

@TwentyOneTwentyTwo I think you are obsessing a bit about the £2.50.
The difference of opinion isn't really about that one off - the OP was explaining how, when the cleaner had her child there, there were two issues.


  1. Was the OP found the noise distracting when she was trying to work. I get that - I don't mind 'white noise' and I quite like music when I am working, but can't listen to the radio because voices are distracting.

  2. The Op spent at least 25% of the time not doing the work.

Now, on the one off / hour's clean, yes, that was £3.12 equivalent, or 15mins but the cleaner has now asked if she can bring the child for her 4 hours clean. Even not allowing for the fact the child would be likely to be much more bored and need much more entertaining over a longer period, it means the OP would be paying her 4 hours worth of wages for 3 hours work. Why do you think she should do that ?

zoeFromCity · 19/07/2022 22:40

Sounds that it wouldn't work to have the child with her for the long regular cleaning session, but it might be acceptable for the addhoc one hours, if it increases her flexibility?

whumpthereitis · 19/07/2022 22:36

tararabumdeay · 19/07/2022 21:02

Mean - £2.50, how can you live with yourself? "I was studying" - selfish. The company of a four year old is a privilege for someone in an ivory tower complaining about how real people have to do menial tasks to thier bidding for their benefit.

In real circumstances, if the cleaner had a real contract (not just an arrangement convenient to you) she could have reported in. As her employer she should have been paid no matter what. If I call in sick for a day I still get paid.

I paid my childminder for the days I didn't need her because it was part of her income even though I was struggling at the time.

It's just the decent thing to do.

😂😂😂😂 fucking hell. If that’s a ‘privilege’ the bar is in hell.

OP has an informal agreement with a local cleaner whom she pays the going rate. She didn’t do the job she was paid to do because she was distracted by her kid (as was OP). Of course OP is annoyed and doesn’t want a repeat. NBU.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 22:31

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 22:24

It's not a "gift" if it's taken by her without my agreement or approval. It's theft, or at the very least dishonesty.

If someone opened your purse and took £2.50 would you say it's fine because to disapprove would be "begrudging her a gift?"

If the teenage boy till operator at your local Tesco pocketed your £2.50 change instead of handing it to you, would you say it's fine because he's on minimum wage?

Funnily enough I gave her a gift last time she was here. Something I was about to sell for £20 but on impulse asked her if she'd like it.

If someone had completed work I hadn't inspected and I'd paid them an extra £2.50 I wouldn't begrudge it, no. I'd take it as a lesson to thoroughly inspect before paying. Unless she opened your purse herself then your analogies are useless. I bet if she'd stayed longer to finish you'd moan she and her son were in your house too long.

"Funnily enough I gave her a gift last time she was here. Something I was about to sell for £20 but on impulse asked her if she'd like it."
Wow, so generous. The best gifts are crap you can't wait to get rid of. You must have saved so much time not having to wait in for pick up/take it out for delivery.

TakeMeToKernow · 19/07/2022 22:27

I totally get how hard it is to say things sometimes!

We’ve had our lovely cleaner for two years. For about 18 months, she was mixing up the recycling bin and the general waste bin (emptying the vacuum onto recyclables). Did we say something? Did we fuck. We just “managed” the bins to make sure general waste was always invitingly empty and the recycling bin was brimmed. It’s the British way.

Hbh17 · 19/07/2022 22:27

You need a new cleaner. If she worked in a shop, office, hospital, factory etc she wouldn't be able to take her child to work with her, so why does she think it's OK when she works for you?

Damnautocorrect · 19/07/2022 22:25

I’m going to go against the grain, and say I would say ok as long as the agreed jobs are done. So pay for that not for time

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 22:24

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 22:14

You begrudge a 'poor single mum' a gift of £2.50?

It's not a "gift" if it's taken by her without my agreement or approval. It's theft, or at the very least dishonesty.

If someone opened your purse and took £2.50 would you say it's fine because to disapprove would be "begrudging her a gift?"

If the teenage boy till operator at your local Tesco pocketed your £2.50 change instead of handing it to you, would you say it's fine because he's on minimum wage?

Funnily enough I gave her a gift last time she was here. Something I was about to sell for £20 but on impulse asked her if she'd like it.

OP posts:
5128gap · 19/07/2022 22:21

I'd say yes on condition we agreed a rate for the tasks I wanted doing not by the hour. Then if it takes longer because she's dealing with the child it wouldnt matter. I'd arrange to study in the remaining hours of the fortnight she wasn't there because I'd find hoovering and cleaning sounds distracting too.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 22:14

You begrudge a 'poor single mum' a gift of £2.50?

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 22:11

Thanks for all the helpful and the chatty replies.

As for the others -- never post drunk! LOL.

@Kite22 "No, you said that your partner looked after him on Fridays and that is why we agreed Fridays. The extra clean was different as it wasn't a Friday. If it doesn't suit you then I will have to get someone else."

This wording is excellent. I will rehearse saying that, too.

Yes I remember now she said he starts school this year.

OP posts:
Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 22:03

@MayDaze "I always know what a new client will be like by the state of their toilet."

I check to see that my toilet is left pristine literally every single time I use it.

I'm lucky in that I am still sufficiently able-bodied to do this.

OP posts:
Kite22 · 19/07/2022 22:03

Pink993 · 19/07/2022 21:34

This.
I do feel I can sense a little attitude from OP. The child had to use her toilet. Yes. Kids need a wee or poo and can’t wait.
Cleaners need a wee too, especially if, like me you work 9-6. It does seem as though you objected to the use of your toilet full stop. I know some people do object but we are people too and function the same way as you do. I clean it afterwards, honest.

That isn't what the OP has said at all.
Not sure why you are making stuff up, tbh.

The clean is 4 hours, once a fortnight. The hour was a one off which OP asked if she was interested in. The OP pays her £12.50 an hour which is decent money for a flexible job you don't need any qualifications for. Especially when she live virtually next door so has no travel time nor expense.

OP of course you should say "no".
If you really liked the cleaner and / or there were a shortage of cleaners where you live, then you could keep in mind that a 4 year old will start school in September, but it seems that isn't the situation.
You only need to say "No, you said that your partner looked after him on Fridays and that is why we agreed Fridays. The extra clean was different as it wasn't a Friday. If it doesn't suit you then I will have to get someone else."

tararabumdeay · 19/07/2022 22:01

OP you seem verbose, entrenched and intransient. Leave the poor woman alone and do what's best for you.

She's not got a hope against your 10 minute poo attention.

Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 19/07/2022 21:58

Kanaloa · 19/07/2022 19:40

I think on the occasion she did an extra clean she wasn’t unreasonable - you asked her to come in at a time you knew she’d have her son and agreed he could come. But it wouldn’t work for me to have him there every time. I would just say oh sorry that won’t work out.

This
re the first occasion 15 mins distracted YABVU complaining about an hours pay
re it being a regular thing ‘no sorry that won’t work’ should deal with it
use an agency going forward

TabithaTittlemouse · 19/07/2022 21:56

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 21:46

Oh yes, she's like a lovely, cheery, smiley, happy ball of sunshine, and she brightens up my day. She works hard and eagerly even though she does sometimes miss things.

I am rehearsing how to be firm but friendly. It's hard when you aren't all that assertive!

She sounds lovely. Hopefully you can add understanding to the list of attributes!

I don’t think pp was pointing their post to you btw, I think it was more of a general description of what people leave for cleaners and why many now don’t empty bins following your description of the bin not being emptied.

MayDaze · 19/07/2022 21:53

My comment was in reply to @Pink993 and not aimed at you OP, more of a tangent. Cleaners do tend to get the brunt of it on threads like this on here, which is why I can be a bit ranty I suppose.

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 21:50

EntertainingandFactual · 19/07/2022 21:36

‘Gosh, no, I don’t think that will work for me. I’d hate for him to hurt himself or get bored whilst you’re busy. Let me know if you manage to get childcare so that you can keep coming’.

This is wonderful! Thank you! That's the right sort of tone. I am now rehearsing saying it out loud in a breezy way with a big smile on my face, in case I have to say it to her face. Currently I am having to reply to a text but I might have to also say it in person. Thanks!

OP posts:
MayDaze · 19/07/2022 21:49

Well said.

I always know what a new client will be like by the state of their toilet.

Yes I'm there to clean, but leaving skid marks or an unflushed loo is really not acceptable.

Used condom on the floor by the bed - disgusting.

Used sanitary products hanging out of the bin - appalling.

The ultimate was a toilet, bathroom bin and floor splattered with dried-on vomit.

I didn't return to any of those clients . I don't need to work for minimum wage, but I chose to do a job I like to earn money for life's little extras. My regular clients are lovely, courteous and in return I work hard to keep their homes clean to a high standard.

I would never ask to bring my young son with me, it's impossible to clean my own home properly with a child distracting me, let alone a clients home.

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 21:46

TabithaTittlemouse · 19/07/2022 21:43

I think it’s possible to kindly decline her request.
Are you happy with her aside from this?

Oh yes, she's like a lovely, cheery, smiley, happy ball of sunshine, and she brightens up my day. She works hard and eagerly even though she does sometimes miss things.

I am rehearsing how to be firm but friendly. It's hard when you aren't all that assertive!

OP posts: