Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? Cleaner and her child

162 replies

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 19:28

I have a cleaner because I am elderly and physically disabled. Current one is about 30 with a child aged four. She answered my advert for someone to clean for 4 hours once a fortnight. She told me she has a 4 year old but his dad has him all day every Friday, so we agreed she would work for me on that day.

She's only worked for me four times. One day she came in for an additional "one-hour special clean" at my request. She asked if it was OK to bring her four year old. I said yes as I did not want to seem unreasonable and she was doing me a favour.

However, I was not happy on three counts. Firstly found it distracting as I was trying to study something academic and I could hear them talking to each other during most of the hour and kept losing my concentration.

Secondly I did not realise how much time she would spend not cleaning but talking to him, sorting him out, explaining something to him, getting him something to amuse him, picking something up for him, telling him not to touch this or that, introducing him to my cat, etc, etc, during all of which of course she was not doing any cleaning.

She also took him to my loo (for a poo, she said) which took her about 5 minutes. I guess altogether seeing to him took up about 1/4 of the time she was here - say 15 minutes of the hour. However, when her hour was up she got her bag and her son and came to me for the full hour's money. After she left, I noticed she had not done all of the tasks we agreed on. I felt a bit irritated that I had paid her an hour for 45 minutes work but I said nothing.

Now she is asking if she can bring him for the whole 4-hour sessions. I want to say absolutely not as I feel she could easily spend 1 hour of it focussed on him and only 3 hrs cleaning and she won't get it all done and she might miss things because she's distracted by having to keep an eye on him, but she'll expect the whole 4 hours pay.

Am I being unreasonable, being mean to a poor single mum?

or

Am I NOT being unreasonable, as she taking the piss expecting me to pay her to look after her own kid?

OP posts:
Ladyof2022 · 20/07/2022 12:16

For those who joined the thread to help me rather than falsely accuse me of all kinds of nastiness...

Heard from her this morning and she has asked now to bring two children with her on Friday, aged 8 and 4, for the four hour job.

I wrote and re-wrote a friendly message back, which was extremely tactful and diplomatic, and based entirely on the suggested phrasings posted on this thread.

I pointed out that the reason she chose to come on Fridays was that she would always be free of childcare duties on that day, and that this was the arrangement she offered and I accepted.

She's just replied to say that if I can't "be flexible" then I must "find someone else". So that's that.

Thanks again for the helpful replies. Off to find another cleaner!

OP posts:
5128gap · 20/07/2022 06:24

OP, you are under no obligation to enable a lone parent to work. There are clearly ways you could do this, as I and others have pointed out, without paying for more than you've received. But you're not interested in considering them. You've made up your mind and that's fine. We don't have to help others if we don't want to. But if we choose not to, we need to own that choice, not look to others to validate it for us and become aggressive and defensive, if they don't.
Either do a good thing, or don't.

startfresh · 20/07/2022 04:44

I do think, @Ladyof2022 that you need to find a friendly way to say "sorry, our arrangement was Fridays because you didn't need to look after your son, I allowed him to come for the one off and, unfortunately, he was quite distracting to both me and you, and I didn't feel I got the full hour's work as there were still things left. He, understandably, took up a fair bit of your time. He needed your attention and input when he came for one hour and I think he would find 4 hours much more difficult, which will have a knock on effect to the work that I need doing and pay for"
but I couldn't let that hour go unmentioned, especially now she's trying to bring him more.

echt · 20/07/2022 03:41

YANBU, OP.

You are paying for the undivided attention of someone you employ.
You are liable if the child is hurt while in your house.

whumpthereitis · 20/07/2022 01:55

CPL593H · 19/07/2022 23:57

Accusing anyone who disagrees with you/expresses another opinion of being drunk and/or a troll is a very, very bad look, OP.

Not without precedence though. Tbf most just assume a poster’s on glue.

cherish123 · 20/07/2022 00:29

However, I probably wouldn't want the child wondering around my house.

cherish123 · 20/07/2022 00:28

Could you say yes but pay her for the job, rather than per hour? So say you normally pay her £40 for 4 hrs work, just say it's £40 to do.... (give her a list of tasks). Then if she takes longer, it's on her time.

OnaBegonia · 20/07/2022 00:26

@milkyaqua
OP wasn't attacked, she herself has without any basis accused a PP of being a drunk and of being horrible to a disabled pensioner which tends to lose all support.

milkyaqua · 20/07/2022 00:25

OnaBegonia · 20/07/2022 00:22

@Ladyof2022
Twenty wasn't horrible, she had a different opinion, one you didn't like and you then accused her of being a drunk and bullying a disabled pensioner.
You are the horrible one, your attitude towards the cleaner and her child are very unpleasant.

Just stop it.

milkyaqua · 20/07/2022 00:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OnaBegonia · 20/07/2022 00:22

@Ladyof2022
Twenty wasn't horrible, she had a different opinion, one you didn't like and you then accused her of being a drunk and bullying a disabled pensioner.
You are the horrible one, your attitude towards the cleaner and her child are very unpleasant.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 20/07/2022 00:16

It was fair to say yes on the day you asked for an extra session.

It would be fair to say 'no' to regular cleans with the child
-because she wasn't able to complete the tasks agreed last time he was present
-because the additional noise distracts you from work.

It would be lovely if you could find a way to allow her to have her child present - for her sake- but it would have to involve you being satisfied with the work done and finding some way to cope with/disguise the noise.

Ladyof2022 · 20/07/2022 00:05

Kite22 · 20/07/2022 00:00

Have to agree with this.

You have lost all sympathy with your last few posts.

Not looking for sympathy. Was simply wanting to know if Mumsnet thinks it is reasonable or not to refuse to let a cleaner bring a child to work.

That's all.

Also wasn't looking to be abused just for employing a cleaner, or falsely accused of maltreating her, or called "mean" or "selfish". All those things are just people picking randomly on bona fide posters in order to abuse them for fun.

OP posts:
Ladyof2022 · 20/07/2022 00:01

CPL593H · 19/07/2022 23:57

Accusing anyone who disagrees with you/expresses another opinion of being drunk and/or a troll is a very, very bad look, OP.

Accusing me of maltreating a cleaner is a very bad look, P.

It's also a downright lie.

OP posts:
Kite22 · 20/07/2022 00:00

CPL593H · 19/07/2022 23:57

Accusing anyone who disagrees with you/expresses another opinion of being drunk and/or a troll is a very, very bad look, OP.

Have to agree with this.

You have lost all sympathy with your last few posts.

Ladyof2022 · 20/07/2022 00:00

OnaBegonia · 19/07/2022 23:23

Oh dear another thread where OP starts banding about accusations/ name calling to the PP who doesn't agree with her.
No need for the attitude towards @TwentyOneTwentyTwo

Don't be so silly Onabegonia. I have no problem with anyone disagreeing with me, that is why I posted this as an "AIBU", which in itself invites disagreement.

The problem I have is with someone trying to paint me as someone who is being nasty to a cleaner when in fact I have been a model client.

The poster was being horrible to me because they get their kicks doing that on random threads.

OP posts:
CPL593H · 19/07/2022 23:57

Accusing anyone who disagrees with you/expresses another opinion of being drunk and/or a troll is a very, very bad look, OP.

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 23:56

saraclara · 19/07/2022 23:24

"I'm sorry, that won't work for me. I need to focus on my work and while I was happy for you to bring him for that hour, I discovered that even though he was very well behaved, it was really distracting hearing conversations in the background rather than the soothing sound of the Hoover!"

Yep, that is another good way of phrasing it, so thanks for that.

OP posts:
Kite22 · 19/07/2022 23:48

And just add, her travelling all the way and back only for one hours work i.e. £12.50 is not great.

What, all the way from next door ?

saraclara · 19/07/2022 23:24

"I'm sorry, that won't work for me. I need to focus on my work and while I was happy for you to bring him for that hour, I discovered that even though he was very well behaved, it was really distracting hearing conversations in the background rather than the soothing sound of the Hoover!"

OnaBegonia · 19/07/2022 23:23

Oh dear another thread where OP starts banding about accusations/ name calling to the PP who doesn't agree with her.
No need for the attitude towards @TwentyOneTwentyTwo

Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 23:17

@TwentyOneTwentyTwo Bore off. You only came on here looking for someone to pick on and be nasty to.

Pity there is no way to block you from this and my other threads. I shall henceforth be ignoring anything and everything you write on every thread on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
Ladyof2022 · 19/07/2022 23:08

@puddingandsun

"her travelling all the way and back only for one hours work i.e. £12.50 is not great. She was doing you a favour."

  1. She lives almost next door.
  2. She had the right to refuse, but agreed eagerly and when she left said not to hesitate to call her for other short jobs.

"you can do very little in one hour cleaning wise if doing a good job, so she prob wouldn't have been finished child or not."

But you, Pudding, don't even know what I asked her to do in that hour so how can you say an hour wasn't long enough?

I'll tell you what it was: sorting out the kitchen, nothing else: washing up, drying and putting away (15 mins); wiping down the worktops and hob and wiping out the microwave (15 mins), vacuuming and mopping the the kitchen floor (15 mins), and sweeping the leaves up in my small patio (15 mins). One hour's work.

OP posts:
TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 23:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm disabled too, shame on you to call me drunk and abusive. I can't drink with my meds for a start. I've only questioned your attitude towards the 'poor single mum'. You could have left those bits out of your OP, or admitted it's your fault to pay for work you'd not inspected. But you haven't, you've defended your poor decision making and gone on to insult someone who's disabled.

Eunorition · 19/07/2022 23:05

She wants paying to wander around your house for a bit with her child. That's some cheek.

Yes, childcare costs etc etc but that's life, we all get on with it.