Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dangerous dogs

239 replies

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 17:36

My neighbours' cat was killed this week by two dogs outside our local shop. They were on a lead but being held by the owner's partner who wasn't able to control them. Think American Bully XL types. They take part in those training sessions where they are trained to attack the guy in the padded suit. Not a banned breed in the UK though larger and stronger than a pitbull. A few days ago an adult in Rotherham was killed by the same breed and her partner sustained life threatening injuries trying to get the dog off her. That was their family pet. I know it's all to do with the owners more so than the dogs themselves but I cannot get these awful situations out of my head. The death of the cat has shaken the local community as he was a well known and very much loved local character but it could so easily have been a child instead. And the owners will continue to endanger people and pets. No AIBU just venting really. Feeling so sad for my neighbours, they are understandably devastated.

OP posts:
Glencanto · 19/07/2022 20:03

If banning dangerous dogs doesn’t work, then I’d like to see people be strictly liable for the acts of their dog, and the dog treated as an extension of the owner.

I.e., if your dog kills someone, then you’re charged with murder. Your dog killed a cat? You killed a cat.

People might be less inclined to buy powerful breeds if they are truly on the hook for their pets’ actions

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 20:03

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 19:54

A dog that attacks and kills a cat is definitely higher risk to small children than a dog that doesn’t kill cats FFS.

No it isn't. A cat is not a gateway to the dog going on to attack children, or being some sort of predictor that it will eventually attack children.

As has been said several times, greyhounds are especially known to go for small furries, including cats. Are they disproportionally named as the breed that has attacked a person when that person presents to A&E? I thought not. They are not even in the top 10.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 19/07/2022 20:03

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:56

But in both scenarios, the cat is already dead. So both owners had dogs who were, according to posters on here, aggressive and dangerous, and out of control. Why is it different because one is a greyhound and the other is a bull breed?

According to you, the greyhound can be appropriately trained, muzzled and leashed to prevent a re-occurrence - so why can't the same happen with the XL bully?

If it's strength alone you're concerned about, the muzzle would prevent the dog biting the cat, no?

Actually, I didn't suggest the greyhound could be trained - a greyhound that chases and kills a cat may well not be trainable with cats in future. So please be more careful when reading posts, because you're accusing me of something I literally did not say or imply.

I said that these dogs are dangerous in the way that a loose greyhound isn't - there are appropriate mitigations to control a greyhound - a second leashing arrangement, possibly coupled with a muzzle. The bullies would require extensive training, which may or may not be possible, depending on owner and dogs, because their probably isn't solvable with a bit more kit. As I said in a previous post, any out of control dog is dangerous - whether it bites or not. Putting a muzzle on those bullies will not prevent them dragging their owner into traffic, or causing harm in other, similar ways.

If these dogs had slipped their leads, as the theoretical greyhound had, they would be equivalently dangerous, but to be able to kill a cat whilst on a lead and attached to their handler is really worrying.

Wonnle · 19/07/2022 20:01

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:56

But they're not a banned breed.

I didn't state they were , i'd report them as being one though

Silverswirl · 19/07/2022 19:59

Nobody should own any dog that is so large or strong that it couldn’t be easily overpowered by an average strength human. Don’t care how friendly it is or how you have treated it. They shouldn’t be around the public. Even on a lead, if an extremely large or strong dog has its mind made up that it’s going to be attacking / running across a road etc then it will do and there is nothing you can do to stop it. Lead or not. They are animals- people seem to forget that they don’t have human brains- treat them like a child and then wonder why people and children are hurt or killed.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:58

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 19:54

A dog that attacks and kills a cat is definitely higher risk to small children than a dog that doesn’t kill cats FFS.

So, I assume you believe that greyhound, spaniels, beagles, cairn terriers and. Dachshunds are all a high risk to children, then?

Because they are ALL breeds that have been bred to attack and kill small furry animals, many of them considerably larger than cats.

KisstheTeapot14 · 19/07/2022 19:58

Hotdrysunny · 19/07/2022 19:26

What really is unhelpful is people pretending that all dogs are the same. They aren’t.

All dogs can bite, but not all dogs can kill with their bite.

Exactly this.

Dogs which have been bred for their bite and aggression should be only able to be owned by people vetted by police. Just like if someone wants to own a gun. It is as dangerous.

A child died recently at a farm near here due to this type of dog.

Very little chance of restraint if they go for someone.

Unlike a greyhound or similar - yes prey drive but I hear of no deaths by greyhound/whippet as a) they are usually gentle around humans and b) one could haul them off reasonably easily, much less than a bully xl type.

Saying that, stats for dog bite and kids the worst 'offenders' are labs and retrievers as people don't expect them to react badly to a child and so don't watch interactions/police them and sometimes a child/dog interaction can go wrong. Not blaming any dog here. It's their people that's the problem, wanting to look a certain way.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:56

Wonnle · 19/07/2022 19:52

The fact is the woman who had these two dogs on leads had no control over them , that makes them dangerous .

I'd report to the police and RSPCA saying they are a banned breed that should get a response from one of them

But they're not a banned breed.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:56

CaptainThe95thRifles · 19/07/2022 19:50

It's completely different because the greyhound's owner can go out and buy a harness and walk their dog with a double leash strategy and know it can be fairly comfortably contained. They also have the option of using a muzzle to walk the dog in future.

The bull breed's owner cannot safely walk their animal in public without significant retraining, even with muzzles, because their dogs are capable of dragging them around and doing their own thing regardless of their handler's wishes.

But in both scenarios, the cat is already dead. So both owners had dogs who were, according to posters on here, aggressive and dangerous, and out of control. Why is it different because one is a greyhound and the other is a bull breed?

According to you, the greyhound can be appropriately trained, muzzled and leashed to prevent a re-occurrence - so why can't the same happen with the XL bully?

If it's strength alone you're concerned about, the muzzle would prevent the dog biting the cat, no?

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 19:55

Wonnle · 19/07/2022 19:52

The fact is the woman who had these two dogs on leads had no control over them , that makes them dangerous .

I'd report to the police and RSPCA saying they are a banned breed that should get a response from one of them

They aren't a banned breed in the UK.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 19/07/2022 19:54

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 18:24

You can't compare an attack on a cat with an attack on a child. I wish people would stop trying to say that dogs with prey drives are a danger to people.

As sad as it is that this cat was killed, dogs are predatory animals and will chase small furry things - it's their nature. It doesn't mean these dogs are bad or aggressive, or that they're going to go on and kill or hurt a person.

A dog that attacks and kills a cat is definitely higher risk to small children than a dog that doesn’t kill cats FFS.

Wonnle · 19/07/2022 19:52

The fact is the woman who had these two dogs on leads had no control over them , that makes them dangerous .

I'd report to the police and RSPCA saying they are a banned breed that should get a response from one of them

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/07/2022 19:51

These dogs can and do make great companions. However, they do need exercise, we used to have our Dobbies out in the fields all day. Bully xl is the same. We took her out all day in the woods and she was fine.
Some of these dog types aren't meant to be in the home either. You need room for them.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 19/07/2022 19:50

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:44

But OP says that's exactly what happened here. The dogs were on lead and under control, but they pulled the owner over, got to the cat and killed it.

Why is that any different to a greyhound slipping its' lead, getting to a cat and killing it?

It's completely different because the greyhound's owner can go out and buy a harness and walk their dog with a double leash strategy and know it can be fairly comfortably contained. They also have the option of using a muzzle to walk the dog in future.

The bull breed's owner cannot safely walk their animal in public without significant retraining, even with muzzles, because their dogs are capable of dragging them around and doing their own thing regardless of their handler's wishes.

EV117 · 19/07/2022 19:49

Unless your cat is going round and killing gerbils next door then they're not killing someone else's loved pet are they?

We had guinea pigs and rabbits in our garden - they needed a secure hutch and run with a covered top to keep them safe from cats. Of course a cat could kill someone’s pet.

You train dogs not to attack cats or anything for that matter and if you can't trust your dog then it's on a short lead well under control.

I have to admit I haven’t bothered to train my dog to not be aggressive towards cat - I don’t encourage it but I certainly don’t discourage it - I wouldn’t want him to hurt a cat obviously, but he will scare them out of our garden and they are much faster than him so the danger is minimal. If cats didn’t have the habit of shitting in other people’s gardens I would tell my dog off for it.

What happened in situation the OP described is obviously not ok. But honestly - I’ve been on a walk with my dog, who is a bit more of a wimp in the big wide world than he is in the garden, and a cat was in the middle of the alley way squared up with no intention of moving… I actually turned around because I didn’t know what to do, I didn’t know if my dog would go for it or if the cat would go for the dog! But that’s just me - there are people who would think nothing of kicking a cat or letting their dog snap at it. Not saying that’s ok but that’s how it is. Cats can be a bit big for their boots and not as danger aware as people think. As pp have said, if you choose to let your cat roam it does come with risks.

tillytoodles1 · 19/07/2022 19:47

Angelinflipflops · 19/07/2022 18:41

I would say a dog that kills a cat is aggressive

I have a cat and I lover her to bits. My neighbour has a Patterdale and he's killed a cat, and loads of rats when he's been loose down by the river.
He's a beautiful boy, very friendly with some dogs ,and loving with people, including small children, but he's prey driven towards anything small and furry.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:44

Ludo19 · 19/07/2022 19:34

Too many posts on here with an undercurrent of "the cat was outside and got what was coming to it"
Also a massive feeling of cats kill wildlife so it's the same....it isn't.
This was someone's PET. If you choose to have a massive dog which by the way was on a lead then the least you can do is fuckin have it under control. Different scenario if a whippet or greyhound slipped its lead and unfortunately came upon a cat going about its business sad as that is its sheer bad luck but to stand with them on lead watching them tear a family pet apart is nothing short of neglectful not only for their safety but for the safety of others.

But OP says that's exactly what happened here. The dogs were on lead and under control, but they pulled the owner over, got to the cat and killed it.

Why is that any different to a greyhound slipping its' lead, getting to a cat and killing it?

Thatsenoughnow · 19/07/2022 19:41

There's way too many of these xl bullies being badly bred by people who want a status dog, the bigger and more powerful the better as far as they're concerned. They're not worried about temperament.
X
l bullies should be banned. They weren't bred to be pets. Pretty much every dog attack resulting in serious injury or death recently has involved one or more of them. Dont care about deed not breed - some breeds are just inherently unsuited to being a pet and there's nothing wrong with saying so.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 19/07/2022 19:39

These dogs are dangerous because the owner was unable to control them - any out of control dog is dangerous. Out of control dogs dragging their owners about have the potential to attack anything, drag their owner out into the road causing an accident, or any number of other accidents. It is completely reasonable to suggest that two dogs capable of killing a cat while on a leash are potentially dangerous to humans.

Personally I don't like bull breeds, but any large / strong dog is a danger if it's not controllable and controlled (and it's the latter that a lot of people don't bother with). Small dogs are also dangerous if out of control, but at least can usually be restrained on a leash. Bully XLs are the lethal combination of strong and powerful, and attractive to bloody idiots who can't (or don't) train and control them.

CallOnMe · 19/07/2022 19:37

It’s so sad! And I really think we need much stricter rules on buying ALL animals.

Not only can any idiot buy a dogs but there are puppy farms and too many dogs needing homes when people get fed up with them.

However, animals kill other animals.
I love my dog but there’s no way I’d leave her alone with my rabbit all day.
I also wouldn’t leave my cat with a mouse or bird if I have one.

Animals also kill humans regularly whether it’s dogs, cats, horses, cows etc and the only way we could stop this was if no one ever had a pet or went horse riding etc which would never happen.

I personally love American bulldogs and would choose them over ‘less aggressive’ breeds as I’ve never met a bad one but I have met other breeds that are aggressive which has put me off even though I know it’s not the breeds fault.

These dogs are obviously very powerful so if they attack there is more chance of sustaining serious injuries compared to other dogs which is why it’s so important that they have proper training.

It sounds like these particular dogs were trained to attack which is of course going to make them much more dangerous.

I am scared of horses.
If I was to be around one or ride one I’d get as small as possible as I know the little Shetland’s (although probably worse tempered) can do less damage than the massive shire horses.
I believe I am less likely to get kicked/ bucked off a shire horse because they’re calmer than a Shetland yet they can do more damage - which is the same argument for these dogs, so I get why people believe there should be stricter rules on powerful dogs but then where would it stop?
(P.s I know I can’t ride a Shetland)

BlueWhat · 19/07/2022 19:36

For the love of god! Is the heat affecting peoples' fucking brains!!

What's the difference between a car killing birds and a dog killing a cat??!??

How many reports have you heard of cats attacking and killing grown adults!

Why are people defending this arsehole owner??

Yea definitely a serious accident waiting to happen. :(

Ludo19 · 19/07/2022 19:34

Too many posts on here with an undercurrent of "the cat was outside and got what was coming to it"
Also a massive feeling of cats kill wildlife so it's the same....it isn't.
This was someone's PET. If you choose to have a massive dog which by the way was on a lead then the least you can do is fuckin have it under control. Different scenario if a whippet or greyhound slipped its lead and unfortunately came upon a cat going about its business sad as that is its sheer bad luck but to stand with them on lead watching them tear a family pet apart is nothing short of neglectful not only for their safety but for the safety of others.

Flaunch · 19/07/2022 19:34

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/07/2022 19:27

We fostered a lurcher who shit herself at the sight of a cat 🤣 she was a very special doggy though, we said she was a hamster stuck inside the body of a lurcher as she just didn’t have the typical qualities of one.

All lurchers are special ❤️

Mine will leave my cats alone but the neighbours cat is fair game. Thankfully we have a large garden with lots of trees for the cats to escape up but if he caught one it wouldn’t be my fault it’s be the fault of the owners who let it roam in the first place.

BMW6 · 19/07/2022 19:31

Well the law is that your dog must be under your control, and although these were on leads the person who was with them was not able to control them.

So I'd report to Police as out of control. Potentially very dangerous.

The Police WILL take action - or should- my leashed dog was attacked by an off lead dog, I reported and Police visited the owners and warned them to always have it on a lead and not being walked by the 12 yo son. This was a big, big dog.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:31

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/07/2022 19:26

@coffeecupsandfairylights thing is, if you take the stance that killing humans = aggressive, that means they werent aggressive dogs prior to the kill.

So how do we tell which ones simply have a prey drive and which ones are aggressive? How many more deaths before we have a grasp of the situation?

And can we please stop pretending the breed has nothing to do with it. Why do people tell themselves these lies?! Ask yourself why a cockapoo or a Lhasa Apso never killed a human

Well, no. Killing humans is the extreme end of aggression. There's a huge range of behaviours that most of these dogs will have displayed at some point before killing a person - from showing "appeasement behaviours", to growling and snapping, to nipping, lunging and biting.

Think of the breeds that have the highest prey drives - greyhounds, terriers, lurchers and scenthounds. These are breeds that rarely, if ever, attack people. I've never heard of a beagle or a greyhound landing someone in hospital. That's because their drive is to kill and hunt prey, not people.

I absolutely agree that the breed has something to do with it, but I still don't think it's helpful to say that any dog that's a danger to cats is automatically a danger to people. Evidence shows us that it's not true (insofar that no fatal dog attacks have been committed by high-prey drive breeds).