Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dangerous dogs

239 replies

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 17:36

My neighbours' cat was killed this week by two dogs outside our local shop. They were on a lead but being held by the owner's partner who wasn't able to control them. Think American Bully XL types. They take part in those training sessions where they are trained to attack the guy in the padded suit. Not a banned breed in the UK though larger and stronger than a pitbull. A few days ago an adult in Rotherham was killed by the same breed and her partner sustained life threatening injuries trying to get the dog off her. That was their family pet. I know it's all to do with the owners more so than the dogs themselves but I cannot get these awful situations out of my head. The death of the cat has shaken the local community as he was a well known and very much loved local character but it could so easily have been a child instead. And the owners will continue to endanger people and pets. No AIBU just venting really. Feeling so sad for my neighbours, they are understandably devastated.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:04

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 20:53

Yes it is. Killing a cat is unequivocally aggressive behaviour in a dog. And aggressive behaviour in a dog is the #1 sign that dog is a dangerous dog. Dangerous to humans, especially children.

According to Cats.org.U.K.
The vast majority of dog owners are responsible and keep their dogs under control. When a dog does attack a cat, it is usually because the owner fails to control their dog. An attack by a dog on a cat can be an indication of a dog that is dangerous and needs control. There have been reported instances of dogs that attack cats going on to attack children.

Dangerous Dog from CPS:
“A dog shall be regarded as dangerously out of control on any occasion on which there are grounds for reasonable apprehension that it will injure any person or assistance dog, whether or not it actually does so, (section 10(3) Dangerous Dogs Act 1991). This is not an exhaustive definition and the ordinary meaning of the words should still be applied. If a dog is factually deemed to be acting in a way that could be termed ‘dangerously out of control’, for example attacking livestock, a prosecution may still be brought. Prosecutors should note the ruling in Briscoe v Shattock [1998] EWHC Admin 929, in which the meaning of ‘dangerousness’ equates to the dog’s disposition rather than its actions. A dog can be ‘dangerous’ to other animals as well as to humans.“

Show me some stats for greyhound/sighthound attacks on people.
I would hazard a guess that whatever figure there is (if it exists) would be outnumbered by the amount of sighthounds used as PaT dogs.

Flaunch · 19/07/2022 21:00

How many sighthounds have been responsible for killing human beings?

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 20:53

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 20:03

No it isn't. A cat is not a gateway to the dog going on to attack children, or being some sort of predictor that it will eventually attack children.

As has been said several times, greyhounds are especially known to go for small furries, including cats. Are they disproportionally named as the breed that has attacked a person when that person presents to A&E? I thought not. They are not even in the top 10.

Yes it is. Killing a cat is unequivocally aggressive behaviour in a dog. And aggressive behaviour in a dog is the #1 sign that dog is a dangerous dog. Dangerous to humans, especially children.

According to Cats.org.U.K.
The vast majority of dog owners are responsible and keep their dogs under control. When a dog does attack a cat, it is usually because the owner fails to control their dog. An attack by a dog on a cat can be an indication of a dog that is dangerous and needs control. There have been reported instances of dogs that attack cats going on to attack children.

Dangerous Dog from CPS:
“A dog shall be regarded as dangerously out of control on any occasion on which there are grounds for reasonable apprehension that it will injure any person or assistance dog, whether or not it actually does so, (section 10(3) Dangerous Dogs Act 1991). This is not an exhaustive definition and the ordinary meaning of the words should still be applied. If a dog is factually deemed to be acting in a way that could be termed ‘dangerously out of control’, for example attacking livestock, a prosecution may still be brought. Prosecutors should note the ruling in Briscoe v Shattock [1998] EWHC Admin 929, in which the meaning of ‘dangerousness’ equates to the dog’s disposition rather than its actions. A dog can be ‘dangerous’ to other animals as well as to humans.“

Thatsenoughnow · 19/07/2022 20:53

All the people who go to such lengths to deny that overwhelmingly the bully and pitbull breeds can be dangerous are a very large part of the problem.

It's a fact that an xl bully is more likely to attack, and is more likely to kill, than a cockerpoo. That's what they're bred for. But people who fall over themselves to assure us all that they're such kind, gentle dogs really are the issue. Because the evidence suggests they're not. Look how many people have been maimed and killed by them in the last couple of years. The one that killed a little boy recently had been used as a stud dog, even with a known history of aggression. So there's a good chance he will have passed on his bad temperament to all the cute little puppies he sired. So the problem perpetuates. But yeah, they're lovely dogs, deed not breed and all that bollocks.

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:49

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:38

I agree dogs should be under control in public. I've never said they shouldn't be.

As for letting your dog kill something - what would happen if a cat came into your garden and your staffy got there before the cat could escape?

I’ve already answered this with regards to different circumstances and private property. I believe it would cease to be a dog that was dangerously out of control and become a terrible accident. My cat was killed in the street outside my house. Totally different imo.

MiniTheMinx · 19/07/2022 20:49

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/07/2022 19:07

Did you just compare racism to a dangerous dog being classed as dangerous? Seriously?

I can't be bothered with the rest of it......but American bulldogs are not American bullys.

misssunshine4040 · 19/07/2022 20:48

EV117 · 19/07/2022 19:49

Unless your cat is going round and killing gerbils next door then they're not killing someone else's loved pet are they?

We had guinea pigs and rabbits in our garden - they needed a secure hutch and run with a covered top to keep them safe from cats. Of course a cat could kill someone’s pet.

You train dogs not to attack cats or anything for that matter and if you can't trust your dog then it's on a short lead well under control.

I have to admit I haven’t bothered to train my dog to not be aggressive towards cat - I don’t encourage it but I certainly don’t discourage it - I wouldn’t want him to hurt a cat obviously, but he will scare them out of our garden and they are much faster than him so the danger is minimal. If cats didn’t have the habit of shitting in other people’s gardens I would tell my dog off for it.

What happened in situation the OP described is obviously not ok. But honestly - I’ve been on a walk with my dog, who is a bit more of a wimp in the big wide world than he is in the garden, and a cat was in the middle of the alley way squared up with no intention of moving… I actually turned around because I didn’t know what to do, I didn’t know if my dog would go for it or if the cat would go for the dog! But that’s just me - there are people who would think nothing of kicking a cat or letting their dog snap at it. Not saying that’s ok but that’s how it is. Cats can be a bit big for their boots and not as danger aware as people think. As pp have said, if you choose to let your cat roam it does come with risks.

So if your dog decided to attack the cat you would have just stood there? You actually turned around and let your dog decide whether it attacks the cat?
You are in control of your dog.
Why are people acting as if cats are fair game if they are out and about? They are not. Prey drive or not, a cat is a pet not a wild animal.
If you have your dog out and it encounters a cat who's "too big for it's boots" you don't let it attack it!

I actually can't believe some of the responses on here.

Your dog, prey drive or not is 100% your responsibility to manage and control.
It makes no difference the breed or size, you control your dog accordingly.

If you know your dog may chase and kill a cat, keep it on a lead in places it may encounter one. No excuses.

As for the large dogs attacking and killing people, again no excuse. Shit happens but keeping a large breed capable of causing fatal harm to another being is a massive responsibility.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:47

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 20:38

I’m talking about the specific individual dog in the OP that has unprovoked and while being restrained by its owner still attacked and killed a cat. That specific dog is a dangerous dog. It’s not about breeds. It’s about this dog and it’s actual behaviour.

What proof do you have that it's dangerous? Because it's strong and killed a cat? Any breed over about 10-15kg can easily pull an owner over and cause carnage.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:46

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:45

I disagree. When I let my cats out I accept they may be at risk from getting hit by a car or getting accidentally my shut in somewhere but I don’t believe I should have to worry about out of control dogs or malicious people that go out of their way to harm animals. The fact is there should be no out of control dogs. It shouldn’t be something we have to worry about. It’s illegal.

You could apply your logic to a child that got attacked after being allowed to play out in the street. It’s not very logical in my opinion neither be it kind.

I'm also sorry about your cat, but what if he went into a dogs' home or garden? You can't blame a dog for chasing a cat that's come into its' home and territory, surely?

I don't let my cats out to roam for precisely this reason - I know it's not safe.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:45

riesenrad · 19/07/2022 20:41

I wish people would stop trying to say that dogs with prey drives are a danger to people

Why not? They are. Lets never let the facts get in the way of delusion, hey?

Well, because they're not. That's a fact. The list of fatal dog attacks upthread proves as much.

The dogs with the highest prey drives are greyhounds, lurchers, spaniels, beagles and most non-bull terrier breeds. They're not breeds that are ever associated with human aggression or fatal attacks on humans.

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:45

Flaunch · 19/07/2022 20:34

I’m sorry for the loss of your cat it must have been really traumatic but sadly if you let a cat roam then it being killed by a local dog is the chance you take and must accept as your own responsibility.

I disagree. When I let my cats out I accept they may be at risk from getting hit by a car or getting accidentally my shut in somewhere but I don’t believe I should have to worry about out of control dogs or malicious people that go out of their way to harm animals. The fact is there should be no out of control dogs. It shouldn’t be something we have to worry about. It’s illegal.

You could apply your logic to a child that got attacked after being allowed to play out in the street. It’s not very logical in my opinion neither be it kind.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:43

CaptainThe95thRifles · 19/07/2022 20:03

Actually, I didn't suggest the greyhound could be trained - a greyhound that chases and kills a cat may well not be trainable with cats in future. So please be more careful when reading posts, because you're accusing me of something I literally did not say or imply.

I said that these dogs are dangerous in the way that a loose greyhound isn't - there are appropriate mitigations to control a greyhound - a second leashing arrangement, possibly coupled with a muzzle. The bullies would require extensive training, which may or may not be possible, depending on owner and dogs, because their probably isn't solvable with a bit more kit. As I said in a previous post, any out of control dog is dangerous - whether it bites or not. Putting a muzzle on those bullies will not prevent them dragging their owner into traffic, or causing harm in other, similar ways.

If these dogs had slipped their leads, as the theoretical greyhound had, they would be equivalently dangerous, but to be able to kill a cat whilst on a lead and attached to their handler is really worrying.

Actually, I didn't suggest the greyhound could be trained - a greyhound that chases and kills a cat may well not be trainable with cats in future. So please be more careful when reading posts, because you're accusing me of something I literally did not say or imply.

Fair enough, I misunderstood you.

I said that these dogs are dangerous in the way that a loose greyhound isn't - there are appropriate mitigations to control a greyhound - a second leashing arrangement, possibly coupled with a muzzle.

So why can't you use the same mitigations with an XL bully?

The bullies would require extensive training, which may or may not be possible, depending on owner and dogs, because their probably isn't solvable with a bit more kit.

Why not?

As I said in a previous post, any out of control dog is dangerous - whether it bites or not. Putting a muzzle on those bullies will not prevent them dragging their owner into traffic, or causing harm in other, similar ways.

But just because a dog is strong enough to pull their owner into traffic, doesn't mean it's automatically a danger. I mean, any big dog is capable of pulling their owner over or pulling the lead out of their owners hands - greyhounds included. Hell, my beagle has pulled me over chasing a rabbit before and he's only 18kg.

I suppose I just don't understand how XL bully that's muzzled, leashed and wearing appropriate gear is anymore dangerous than a greyhound that's muzzled, leashed and wearing appropriate gear?

riesenrad · 19/07/2022 20:41

I wish people would stop trying to say that dogs with prey drives are a danger to people

Why not? They are. Lets never let the facts get in the way of delusion, hey?

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 20:38

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 19:58

So, I assume you believe that greyhound, spaniels, beagles, cairn terriers and. Dachshunds are all a high risk to children, then?

Because they are ALL breeds that have been bred to attack and kill small furry animals, many of them considerably larger than cats.

I’m talking about the specific individual dog in the OP that has unprovoked and while being restrained by its owner still attacked and killed a cat. That specific dog is a dangerous dog. It’s not about breeds. It’s about this dog and it’s actual behaviour.

wheresmymojo · 19/07/2022 20:38

Angelinflipflops · 19/07/2022 18:41

I would say a dog that kills a cat is aggressive

I don't know if I agree with this.

My dog goes absolutely nuts when she sees a cat on our walks. She's on a lead and I keep her under control but I definitely wouldn't want to say that let of the lead she wouldn't attack a cat.

However....she is as soft as a brush at home. We don't have DC but we do have four cats who she is very gentle with...I have no concerns leaving her in the house with our family cats.

Obviously the issue here is that dogs should always be under control in public spaces and if the owners partner wasn't strong enough to keep them under control she shouldn't have been in charge of them.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:38

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:25

Or maybe folk should control their dogs when out in public? See my earlier post about the small dog that also got mauled. I have cats and a dog. Dog owners have a legal and moral responsibility to control their dogs. We should be able to let our cats out without worrying about them getting mailed by some idiot’s outs of control dog. Obviously different circumstances if it happens on private property. Still horrible in every circumstance. I would never let my dog kill anything. Staffie owner here.

I agree dogs should be under control in public. I've never said they shouldn't be.

As for letting your dog kill something - what would happen if a cat came into your garden and your staffy got there before the cat could escape?

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 20:35

@Feelfreetocallme I bet you do. An illness etc is one thing but the shock of this is something else entirely. I have 2 indoor cats, I'm petrified that something could happen to them if they were out. But in my mind it was always getting hit by a car. This wouldn't even have entered my head. 😔 x

OP posts:
Flaunch · 19/07/2022 20:34

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:17

Had to stop reading this thread as was getting too emotional. All I can say is my lovely cat was killed by a cocker spaniel and it was extremely traumatic for us and the dog owners, but the owners were ultimately at fault for allowing their untrained dog to run around unsupervised and off lead in the street. This dog wasn’t aggressive to people, but still guilty of being dangerously out of control and that was down to the owners. Dog owners (myself included) have a legal and moral responsibility to keep our dogs under control. People forget that dogs are predatory animals. I would never allow my own dog to attack another animal be that a squirrel, sheep, rabbit, cat or another dog.

A few months after my cat was attacked, a Pomeranian was attacked by a husky in the same area. The husky wasn’t aggressive to people, but clearly saw the small dog as prey and did was a predatory animals do… The dog behaved dangerously out of control and that in my opinion was down to the owner. I do wonder if any of the dog apologists on this forum think the Pomeranian’s owner should also have kept their dog on their own property? Take small dogs out at your own risk! No, didn’t think so. Moral of the story is we need tighter legislation on dog ownership. Dangerous dogs act is outdated and doesn’t work. It’s also very cruel on the dogs who end up as collateral damage but that’s another story.

I’m sorry for the loss of your cat it must have been really traumatic but sadly if you let a cat roam then it being killed by a local dog is the chance you take and must accept as your own responsibility.

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:25

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 20:22

I'm so sorry x @Feelfreetocallme

Thank you. Miss him x

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:25

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 18:54

Cats are let out to roam at the owners' risk. I say that as someone who has cats.

If you let your cat out to roam in public, you can't guarantee their safety. If you don't want your cat to be at risk from someone's dog, stop letting your cat off your property.

Or maybe folk should control their dogs when out in public? See my earlier post about the small dog that also got mauled. I have cats and a dog. Dog owners have a legal and moral responsibility to control their dogs. We should be able to let our cats out without worrying about them getting mailed by some idiot’s outs of control dog. Obviously different circumstances if it happens on private property. Still horrible in every circumstance. I would never let my dog kill anything. Staffie owner here.

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 20:22

I'm so sorry x @Feelfreetocallme

OP posts:
Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 20:17

Had to stop reading this thread as was getting too emotional. All I can say is my lovely cat was killed by a cocker spaniel and it was extremely traumatic for us and the dog owners, but the owners were ultimately at fault for allowing their untrained dog to run around unsupervised and off lead in the street. This dog wasn’t aggressive to people, but still guilty of being dangerously out of control and that was down to the owners. Dog owners (myself included) have a legal and moral responsibility to keep our dogs under control. People forget that dogs are predatory animals. I would never allow my own dog to attack another animal be that a squirrel, sheep, rabbit, cat or another dog.

A few months after my cat was attacked, a Pomeranian was attacked by a husky in the same area. The husky wasn’t aggressive to people, but clearly saw the small dog as prey and did was a predatory animals do… The dog behaved dangerously out of control and that in my opinion was down to the owner. I do wonder if any of the dog apologists on this forum think the Pomeranian’s owner should also have kept their dog on their own property? Take small dogs out at your own risk! No, didn’t think so. Moral of the story is we need tighter legislation on dog ownership. Dangerous dogs act is outdated and doesn’t work. It’s also very cruel on the dogs who end up as collateral damage but that’s another story.

Ohtoberoavingagain · 19/07/2022 20:14

Soubriquet · 19/07/2022 18:00

If they are being trained with people using padded suits, theoretically, they should be well trained and will attack on command.

Im guessing it’s not a professional training them, rather a mate in padded clothing.

Unfortunately the police won’t care about a dog attack on a cat.

The trouble is they won’t be. The handlers ( the dog owners in this instance) really have to be well trained to interpret the signals their dog gives off as well as controlling the exercises the dogs have learnt. If you think of police dogs , not only are the dogs thoroughly assessed initially, they are constantly assessed during training and throughout their working lives. The police handlers are also thoroughly trained and constantly assessed. Sadly these dogs will not have any of those benefits, and the owners will have no assessment, no insurance, and only the training with the dogs given by………well, anyone really.

And why, if your dog is a pet, would you need to train it to attack a person in a padded suit? Why not use agility training, or even that cross country running with your dog attached ( can’t think of it’s name) as training tools.

CallOnMe · 19/07/2022 20:10

In the UK the human fatalities are from the following breeds:

2000-2019
6 x American bulldog types
1 x neopoliton mastiff
2 x Bordeaux
7 x pitbulls
1 x jack russel
1 x presa canario
1 x malamute
1 x Lakeland terrier
9 x staffys
2 x German shepherds

Before this most of the fatalities were caused by Rottweilers, Dobermans, German Shepards and Huskies.

I was shocked reading the 2000-2019 list that it didn’t have any Rottweilers or Dobermans on as growing up they were the dangerous dogs.

But that’s proves that although certain breeds can obviously do a lot more damage than others, that it’s not just the breed that’s the issue.

In a few years other digs will be seen as status dogs and they’ll end up being seen as the most aggressive.

If we ban all bull breeds - American bulldogs, staffys, French bull dogs, British bulldogs, bull mastiffs etc.
Then we’re still left with the German shepherds, Rottweilers, Doberman’s etc and then if we ban them we’ll be left with the huskies and collies etc - it would literally never end.

We need to focus more on getting stricter rules for buying and selling dogs and less on what breed should be banned.

Ylvamoon · 19/07/2022 20:09

@Soubriquet · Today 18:44

No not at all. I’m just saying people always seem
to blame the breed of the dog

Often it is the type of dog. You can nuture your dog and train it. But you can't take away their inbreed nature. And American bullies are derived from the American Pittbull.

Swipe left for the next trending thread