Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dangerous dogs

239 replies

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 17:36

My neighbours' cat was killed this week by two dogs outside our local shop. They were on a lead but being held by the owner's partner who wasn't able to control them. Think American Bully XL types. They take part in those training sessions where they are trained to attack the guy in the padded suit. Not a banned breed in the UK though larger and stronger than a pitbull. A few days ago an adult in Rotherham was killed by the same breed and her partner sustained life threatening injuries trying to get the dog off her. That was their family pet. I know it's all to do with the owners more so than the dogs themselves but I cannot get these awful situations out of my head. The death of the cat has shaken the local community as he was a well known and very much loved local character but it could so easily have been a child instead. And the owners will continue to endanger people and pets. No AIBU just venting really. Feeling so sad for my neighbours, they are understandably devastated.

OP posts:
stillherenow · 19/07/2022 21:59

Except in my garden of course, he's off lead and unmuzzled . And we do get cats, he eats all their sodding shit so I know they come in!

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 21:59

No he doesn't go off lead, so he's always on lead, and always muzzled on residential streets. Not muzzled where cats are less likely .

ScabbersChin · 19/07/2022 21:56

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 21:54

I can only speak for sighthounds but they're unbelievably placid and gentle and many adore children - mine does. But they've been trained to chase prey and also have the genetics and so they will do.

If a cat gets my garden and it kills it, I'd hate it but it's not mine or my dogs fault. I am careful out and about but same applies, if we're walking away from houses and a cat is within range that's also not my fault, it is the risk with letting cats out . I've had cats and I let them out knowing the risks.

I think this attitude is a little irresponsible. A lot of sight hounds are muzzled for this very reason. If you let your dog off a leash where you know there might be cats and you think your dogs recall isn’t good enough to stop when chasing a cat it should be muzzled.

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 21:54

I can only speak for sighthounds but they're unbelievably placid and gentle and many adore children - mine does. But they've been trained to chase prey and also have the genetics and so they will do.

If a cat gets my garden and it kills it, I'd hate it but it's not mine or my dogs fault. I am careful out and about but same applies, if we're walking away from houses and a cat is within range that's also not my fault, it is the risk with letting cats out . I've had cats and I let them out knowing the risks.

ScabbersChin · 19/07/2022 21:50

Unpopular opinion…. But. These breeds have been bred (selectively) to attack without warning for thousands of years. By humans. They’re very capable of it. Just as a collie for herding sheep. Or your retrievers for retrieving.

Only when humans breed them responsibly and breed these traits out of them will there be any change.

Look into the evolution of dogs and theirs predatory motor patterns. And how each section of that pattern is edited.

As long as I have small children I’d never own such a breed (amongst others).

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:50

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 21:46

This thread is nuts ! Lots of dogs would kill a cat given half a chance, they're no more aggressive than a cat killing a mouse. Mine would certainly kill a cat if it caught one. And a squirrel. Children aren't prey .

Honestly, MN in general seems to hate dogs, and thinks that if your dog snapped at a passing fly, then it will be a kid next.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:48

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:32

See
”The dog was eventually homed with a family in Penyrheol but neighbours have revealed it was only believed to have been there a short time and had had attacked a cat, another adult and lunged at child in the last few days alone.

Neighbours described the animal as having "huge muscles" protruding from its shoulders as they saw it moments after Jack's death.”

No one is gathering the data except the Cats.org people. But attacking cats is a well known red flag of a dangerous dog that is a danger to children.

That does sound like a dangerously out of control dog.

My dog has caught a squirrel before. Funnily enough, she do not go on to attack a child afterwards.

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 21:48

If I was standing outside a shop with my dog and a cat sauntered within its range it would grab it . He's not at all aggressive, I've never even heard him bark or growl! As he has a high prey drive I muzzle in residential areas but not in his garden and I wouldn't on a high street either .

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 21:46

This thread is nuts ! Lots of dogs would kill a cat given half a chance, they're no more aggressive than a cat killing a mouse. Mine would certainly kill a cat if it caught one. And a squirrel. Children aren't prey .

Ameliarosethistle · 19/07/2022 21:45

I think a dog's aggression level is a combination of their nature (often partially dictated by their breed), with their training and the behaviour of their owners.

Yes, all dogs can be aggressive in the wrong hands but some breeds are more aggressive as part of their breed-type and I think American bull-dogs are more prone towards aggression.

Overdon · 19/07/2022 21:40

The thing that shocks me is that these dogs were on lead while the owner couldn't control them. Not sure if OP means they broke free from the owner's grasp of the lead or if they killed the cat while still being held on the lead. Horrific in any event, if the owner cant control these beasts they should be removed, if it happened outside the shops they would be CCTV, I would report to the Police and dog warden. While I am sorry about the cat, what really worries me is the complete lack of control of the owner, it could be a child next time.

Round here there was an elderly woman walking through the park who was savaged by one of these Bully breeds. it took 3 men to get the brute off her , she would have been killed if it wasn't for these men who were working nearby and heard her screams.

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:32

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:30

The pit bull that killed 10yr old Jack Lis had attacked a cat days before it killed Jack while at his friends house…

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/breaking-caerphilly-dog-attack-eight-25422902

See
”The dog was eventually homed with a family in Penyrheol but neighbours have revealed it was only believed to have been there a short time and had had attacked a cat, another adult and lunged at child in the last few days alone.

Neighbours described the animal as having "huge muscles" protruding from its shoulders as they saw it moments after Jack's death.”

No one is gathering the data except the Cats.org people. But attacking cats is a well known red flag of a dangerous dog that is a danger to children.

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:30

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:21

So my dog chasing cats in her own garden means she is unsafe around children?
Ridiculous. I mean, my dog can be dumb at times but she knows the difference between a hissy cat and a child who asks to pet her.

The pit bull that killed 10yr old Jack Lis had attacked a cat days before it killed Jack while at his friends house…

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/breaking-caerphilly-dog-attack-eight-25422902

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:25

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 21:21

I don’t think it would apply if such an incident were to occur in an enclosed private garden providing it was purely accidental. That’s way it says control dog PUBLIC.. Clues in the name.

The link you posted says a dog can still be considered out of control in its own home.

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 21:21

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:17

So if my greyhound attacks a cat in her own garden, she is classed as a dangerous dog?
I see countless posts on MN about rats in gardens... and people say t get a terrier, or a cat. Why are they not dangerous, and on the path to eventually attaching a child?

I don’t think it would apply if such an incident were to occur in an enclosed private garden providing it was purely accidental. That’s way it says control dog PUBLIC.. Clues in the name.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:21

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:19

It is true. Cats are not the natural prey of dogs. That is a common misconception fed by childhood cartoons. Attacking and killing a cat means the dog does not have the usual inhibitions and socialisation that make it also safe to be around small children.

So my dog chasing cats in her own garden means she is unsafe around children?
Ridiculous. I mean, my dog can be dumb at times but she knows the difference between a hissy cat and a child who asks to pet her.

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:19

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:13

Because you made the statement that a dog that kills a cat is dangerous to people too, when that is simply not true. Yes, the breed does not matter, but sighthounds, greyhounds in particular, are known for not being safe around cats.
And the no statistic out there supports your view that a dog that is not cat safe is also not child/people safe.

It is true. Cats are not the natural prey of dogs. That is a common misconception fed by childhood cartoons. Attacking and killing a cat means the dog does not have the usual inhibitions and socialisation that make it also safe to be around small children.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:17

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:11

@Feelfreetocallme
Exactly, the Gov webpage states
”Overview

It’s against the law to let a dog be dangerously out of control anywhere, such as:

in a public place
in a private place, for example a neighbour’s house or garden
in the owner’s home

The law applies to all dogs.

You can report a dog that’s out of control.

Some types of dogs are banned.

Out of control
Your dog is considered dangerously out of control if it:

injures someone
makes someone worried that it might injure them

A court could also decide that your dog is dangerously out of control if either of the following apply:

it attacks someone’s animal
the owner of an animal thinks they could be injured if they tried to stop your dog attacking their animal”

www.gov.uk/control-dog-public

Last I looked a pet cat is someone’s animal.

So if my greyhound attacks a cat in her own garden, she is classed as a dangerous dog?
I see countless posts on MN about rats in gardens... and people say t get a terrier, or a cat. Why are they not dangerous, and on the path to eventually attaching a child?

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:13

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:07

Why should I? That’s not the breed of the dog in the OP. It’s completely irrelevant as to whether this specific dog is dangerous or not. Youre just engaging in whataboutery. Might as well be sitting there and asking me how many cats are killed by foxes…not relevant.

Because you made the statement that a dog that kills a cat is dangerous to people too, when that is simply not true. Yes, the breed does not matter, but sighthounds, greyhounds in particular, are known for not being safe around cats.
And the no statistic out there supports your view that a dog that is not cat safe is also not child/people safe.

Dunnoburt · 19/07/2022 21:11

Very sad!...... Lots of 'toy' dogs about that are 'small and furry' wonder what the response would be if the victim wasn't a cat!

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 21:11

Flaunch · 19/07/2022 20:34

I’m sorry for the loss of your cat it must have been really traumatic but sadly if you let a cat roam then it being killed by a local dog is the chance you take and must accept as your own responsibility.

Also would you say that to the owner of the Pomeranian who had their dog killed by an out of control husky? Dogs both out of control in a public place led to the same outcome. Ffs

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:11

@Feelfreetocallme
Exactly, the Gov webpage states
”Overview

It’s against the law to let a dog be dangerously out of control anywhere, such as:

in a public place
in a private place, for example a neighbour’s house or garden
in the owner’s home

The law applies to all dogs.

You can report a dog that’s out of control.

Some types of dogs are banned.

Out of control
Your dog is considered dangerously out of control if it:

injures someone
makes someone worried that it might injure them

A court could also decide that your dog is dangerously out of control if either of the following apply:

it attacks someone’s animal
the owner of an animal thinks they could be injured if they tried to stop your dog attacking their animal”

www.gov.uk/control-dog-public

Last I looked a pet cat is someone’s animal.

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 21:08

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:46

I'm also sorry about your cat, but what if he went into a dogs' home or garden? You can't blame a dog for chasing a cat that's come into its' home and territory, surely?

I don't let my cats out to roam for precisely this reason - I know it's not safe.

Like I said my cat was killed outside my house in the street. If he had of been killed in the dog owner’s garden then no, I wouldn’t think they were at fault as but the fact is their dog was allowed to be dangerously out of control in a public place. There is no black and white, and circumstances are relevant when assessing if a dog is dangerously out of control imo.

I should be able to let my cats out without worrying about a dog attack outside my own house, just as I should be able to let my kids play out without worrying about this! Why? Because it’s the law for dogs to be kept under control and for good reason, and if you’re any kind of decent owner then you wouldn’t want your dog behaving in a dangerous or out of control manner.

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:07

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 21:04

Show me some stats for greyhound/sighthound attacks on people.
I would hazard a guess that whatever figure there is (if it exists) would be outnumbered by the amount of sighthounds used as PaT dogs.

Why should I? That’s not the breed of the dog in the OP. It’s completely irrelevant as to whether this specific dog is dangerous or not. Youre just engaging in whataboutery. Might as well be sitting there and asking me how many cats are killed by foxes…not relevant.

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 21:04

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:47

What proof do you have that it's dangerous? Because it's strong and killed a cat? Any breed over about 10-15kg can easily pull an owner over and cause carnage.

Yes. It has killed a cat despite the owner attempting to restrain it. This is aggression and the dog was dangerously out of control resulting in the death of another persons animal. This is a well known massive red flag that the dog is a dangerous dog.

Swipe left for the next trending thread